Article Index

Some issues find their way onto every roleplaying site, whether or not they belong there. In a game set in the present day, many may of course be on topic. But they crop up around fantasy games too, mostly adding noise rather than meaningful, substantive content. When somebody makes a Ynevian version of the current political poster in the M.A.G.U.S. group, it chiefly promises to ignite a political argument and needlessly divide the group. The Flag War also produces many refugees, and the refugee question is relevant there too. The posters and their parodies are not. If I run Call of Cthulhu in present-day Hungary, however, the characters would have opinions about Sunday shop closures, the refugee issue, Mr. Habony, perhaps even the Greek crisis. I will go further: real events appearing in an adventure set in a real environment are not necessarily a problem. Quite the opposite...

Some people use roleplaying to escape everyday problems and seek a simpler, perhaps—in a good sense—superficial game. Others value depth and would like to examine numerous problems through several characters' eyes and from different angles. Leaving out many events in that case is a sin. But many games lie somewhere in between, and placing stories in the real world is useful because we certainly know some of it well, while learning many other details is easy. Provided we are not obstructed by a subject on which one player finds many facts and consequences difficult to face. The sensitivity of the subject and political correctness immediately become issues. Of course, it is also true that players' laziness and tendency toward powergaming can detach some characters from the world. 

We know the case of someone described as small but given a high Size characteristic in Call of Cthulhu for the mechanical advantages, and very good at shooting in an era when that was rare. A superficial background and a position appear, but the player has not wanted to read up on what those entailed at the time. The adventure took place at a rural pig slaughter, with a peasant family whose relationship with the regime was not necessarily ideal, and a connection to them was a requirement. Firearms made no sense, and a character possessing them did not fit... But who cares that everyone else knows this? Somebody wanted those advantages, and if their unbelievable character wiped out everyone else's game, so be it. Others have encountered the same thing. The only thing worse than powergaming here was that the character's description, the results that would be plausible on that basis, and the game statistics bore no relation to one another.

Part of the story is that, confronted with such a privileged person from before the change of regime, I soon thought that the principles behind those privileges were as much Nyarlathotep's jokes as the illusions of those preparing for the transition. Cultists are on many sides, then, and you do not shoot that sort of joke with a hunting rifle. But the story had a much more important lesson. Most players would rather throw numbers around, think about mechanical solutions to situations, and use a movie cliché or two than create a truly lifelike character and try to place them within the world. 

That is true not only of Call of Cthulhu and World of Darkness, but of forum roleplaying games set in real environments too. Do not misunderstand: I am not thinking only of present-day Hungary. In games set in the USA, Switzerland, and so on, people ought to know at least a few widely known details. If someone running a US-set game welcomes lawyer, prosecutor, and similar characters, those characters should at least vaguely resemble people in their professions. In conversation, for instance, they should understand the difference between federal and local cases and what precedent means. But you know what? It also helps to know what kind of political group the Tea Party is and how its voters and sympathizers relate to the Republican Party. Someone running a game in Switzerland should not be surprised by certain characters' attitudes to guns. This is the responsibility of players and game masters, or administrators on FRPG sites, alike. But many unavoidable topics are divisive. 

One of the worst kinds of player you can encounter carries their fight for perceived social justice—which often would not be justice after all—into games too. In computer RPGs, we know the Pillars of Eternity story where a gravestone inscription written by a backer, perfectly fitting the world, had to be replaced because of the controversy. Forgive me, but a world contains not only characters of different sexual orientations, but homophobic characters too. Their presence can justify even particularly harsh language in a game. Someone unable to tolerate that, who therefore damages the group's game, is not welcome. If a player who is not gay themselves demonstrates on game-related platforms with a rainbow avatar or profile picture, because although it has nothing to do with the game they cannot stop fighting for their cause there too, I assume they may likewise not know, when faced with such a remark or scene, where and when demonstrations belong and where the world needs both sides. And world events include more serious subjects than this. 

One major current issue in world politics is handling refugees. It is often a cliché that all sorts of people can be among them. Lovecraft called himself a racist and may have been somewhat xenophobic too; if he were writing today, there would certainly be dangerous cultists among refugees, perhaps even monsters appearing human. When I suggested where cultists might be found in present-day Hungary, somebody considered politicians an extreme—though I could have written Fidesz politicians instead—and even the ordinariness of an “average person undeservedly turned into a celebrity” an extreme. Yet they thought the barely tolerated refugee at society's very bottom, truly at its edge, was too typical. It did not fit among the other, less unexpected examples, because Lovecraft's work makes cultists expected there. I would dispute that...