Article Index

Above, I have listed various problems, tricks, and possible solutions, without attempting completeness, chiefly as food for thought. They show how the decision about which dice to use and how to roll them affects everything from character creation to many elements of the world concept. There are many ways to fix the flaws of particular rolling methods with a few optional rules, so a d100-based system can also be improved to some degree. The questions are how difficult those fixes are to implement for the designer, how complicated the improved system becomes, and how many flaws remain afterward. The second of those three questions is particularly worrying because we want to use relatively few rules. 

A possible multi-die d6 solution would provide an excellent foundation with few additions, and many new possibilities. We know the d100-based system. People who play M.A.G.U.S. have long compensated for its flaws and like the resulting form of the game. Potential new players, however, have no tried-and-tested recipes for compensating for d100's flaws, and would be happier with a system built on a better foundation. But many existing players flatly reject that, leaving new players with a smaller player base and fewer opportunities to play. 

Let us look at a non-exhaustive list of ways to mitigate d100's many disadvantages:

  1. Roll less often, making extreme results less frequent too.
  2. Use larger modifiers so the die plays a smaller role.
  3. Explain the oddities within the world.
  4. If even insects are kept out of an inn by runes, magical items can influence the dice, such as a lucky amulet.
  5. Reserve critical successes for adventurers and critical failures for their opponents.
  6. Use a “card-based solution and deck building.”
  7. Use an electronic die with a nonuniform distribution—a physical device.
  8. Use an app whose distribution, memory, and so on can be adjusted.
  9. Make a d10 from a die with more sides, with a nonuniform distribution, perhaps optionally or tied to an ability or magic.
  10. Require many unusual results to be confirmed by another roll.
  11. Introduce open-ended rolls.
  12. Create a system based on rerolls that can be “bought” with points.
  13. Use tables to determine the result associated with a roll and thereby fix the problems.
  14. Allow many different unusual events for extreme results.
  15. Reinterpret the moral rule to change the form of the game.
  16. Alongside outright failure, allow “partial success at a cost,” and several degrees of success. 
  17. Apply some form of “roll and choose.”

Clearly, we can try many methods to reduce d100's disadvantages. But while manufacturing a cheap electronic die might make sense for a boxed board game, it is not good for a fantasy roleplaying game—often playable from free introductory material—to rely on either that or, say, an app. We do not want to lug tables around either. Open-ended d100 rolls have already appeared elsewhere. An in-world explanation and fewer rolls are not enough. So, little by little, we rule out most of the possibilities we identified.

Solutions 3, 5, 6, 14, 15, 16, and 17, however, can be combined to a degree. Special cards and deck building are optional, but could supply variety in extreme cases. Explanations involving adrenaline, the will of the gods, and the written chronicle, along with a moral rule brought closer to them, also help. In fact, option five can be added to the picture too. If we make high rolls worthwhile for skill checks as well—say, skill + roll + modifier > 100 means success, with several kinds of “better success” above that and a few kinds of partial success below—we can say that we rarely roll in situations without stress. In a live situation, however, the adventurer rolls several d100 and takes the highest, the non-adventurer rolls only 1d100, and some of the more accursed creatures must use the worst of several d100 rolls. 

That lets adventurers readily defeat creatures and opponents who would normally be stronger than them. The quality of success and many other things provide “something to get excited about”; the d100 feel is there, and you can roll lots of dice. Even low skills can have a chance, especially when we roll many such dice. Some may come from “adventurer status,” while others are bonuses “purchasable for particular occasions.” Yet higher values continue to improve the odds for a long time and let the character perform even better. Even lower skills can now have value.

The result: a system that can be summarized in a few sentences, supports heroic achievements, longer life-spanning campaigns, and adventurers victorious against superior forces. Yet there is still something to get excited about, and we have made low skill values useful too. Multiple dice used this way can easily be incorporated as an optional rule into the traditional system, and indeed something similar is possible for almost any other d100-based system. In Call of Cthulhu, for example, we would simply choose the lower roll, except on advancement checks. 

The beauty of it is that the system is easier to calculate at the beginning, when there are few dice. But we can arrange for players to develop skills freely while “an adventure bringing a major turning point”—achieving an important goal—grants a level, and an extra die usable either all the time or occasionally, with only the best counting. Character development can thereby become multidimensional: alongside improving skills, the “wealth, power, and influence” gained through achieving goals, and possible magical items, we have gained a new kind of level. Multiple forms of advancement support both frequent small rewards, which are useful, and rarer large rewards, which are memorable and get talked about.