Striking distanceEarly in the Második Esély, or Second Chance, project, I wrote an article examining whether a d100-based system was technically and commercially feasible if we wanted to avoid bringing out smartphone dice rollers during play. Many celebrated: wonderful, I was voting for d100. No luck. The next article came: d6, d100, distributions and the feel of the game. Fix d100's many flaws and a d100-based system can follow. Some took that as certain. Recently, though, I wrote that it is nowhere near certain. The system must be built, and that may not succeed. Many people do not know how many steps remain. But I included examples of why and how I made decisions on many issues. There are two things I cannot do. One is leave these out of what I write about the Second Chance project. The third is publish the article immediately after "save as copy", forgetting that this one, for example, is not about the questionnaire or the AD&D examples. 

When I asked whether we wanted substantial revision of the old system or a genuinely new one, the question meant something different to me: revision can happen step by step. Even with the system unfinished, a twenty-fifth-anniversary edition correcting many small errors could include little changes as optional rules, reflecting "what we have learned in twenty-five years". Carefully editing minimal optional rules into the original text is an alternative available from the very first optional rule. But a handful of changes would not bring people currently using other editions back to the original. A differently rolled skill check, skills rewritten as percentages, improved attribute checks, fixes for d100's flaws: a few sentences of optional rules. Let us admit, though, that this would not convert someone attached to the ÚTK's Favour Points. It is not plan B but plan Z. And I cannot promise its flaws are smaller than those of the d6 solution. 

An acquaintance working at ELTE gave me hosting for my first roleplaying website. Naturally, there was no domain, subdomain or anything else: everything lived in a /~theelf/ directory on that Linux server. It was nice, it was good, it was static HTML. Then the menu became unmanageable from an editor's perspective. A PHP-Nuke installation followed. That site eventually disappeared. Then came Enerla.Net, currently unavailable but being worked on. That is not a one-person project either, nor is kalandmester.com. Even on that first host, there was an article I was damn proud of because Nyul praised my work. But that was the nineties. Let us say at least twenty years have passed. Twenty years is a long time.

What is all this?

There has not been a successful new M.A.G.U.S. system for a long time. Many of us play from twenty-year-old books that are almost falling apart. We wait for new solutions, then complain about why the new system rolls attacks that way.

But we have often heard that the rights holder would welcome homebrew and other attempts. It has even been said that more than one might get a chance. They waited in vain. We did not trust that there really would be a chance. Delta Vision's developers are currently working on a new system. Fans are working on complaining about d6. 

Let us admit there are currently four alternatives:

  • The d6-based system happens.
  • It fails, and nothing happens.
  • We deliver a finished system that gets a chance either instead of or alongside the d6 system.
  • A series of articles presents a method by which a new core rulebook can be completed.

No homebrew system's developers have been sued, although we have heard of at least four or five. But there is official* permission for supplements and articles, not homebrew systems. 

Even if permission comes, the articles cannot assemble into complete "core rulebooks", only an SRD. Let us call it the Second Chance system.

* This does not make the finished supplement official or officially approved. Only the permission for fan material and house rules is official in the legal sense. 

Many articles from those sites never made it here. Really many. Others were republished first on one M.A.G.U.S. site, then another, then taken by kalandozok.hu from the third location. Fact: Gergely Magyar edited it nicely. Another fact: several tables were damaged during all that copying. You can find it here. I still would not fundamentally call it a bad article. I choose it, though, because I am free to slag off my own old work. One of M.A.G.U.S.'s most ignored rules concerns objects' resistance and the STP introduced there. It appears after poisons and before magic items, on page 279 of my third-edition book, for example. The book explains how much STP an object has and how various attacks damage it. If armour's SFÉ, or damage reduction, is related to its STP, then STP loss and damage to the armour necessarily reduce SFÉ. 

Great: we can track a weapon's STP too, and that of other objects, giving everything realistic maintenance requirements. There is just one small problem. The resistance of objects is a M.A.G.U.S. chapter, a subsystem with separate points and differing vulnerability rules, that absolutely nobody uses. I wrote an analysis of it. Great, wonderful. It was updated too, raising how a smith could increase STP and modify these things. Reading the rules raises questions worth thinking through. There is only one problem: nobody used STP afterwards either. Wherever my old article is linked, I must immediately point out that it is outdated. If you came to play with me, it would not serve as a reference. Not because it is not good in itself, or a good option if you want extremely detailed combat bookkeeping, but because my advice would be: do not want that sort of bookkeeping in combat. 

A serious problem with M.A.G.U.S.'s current system is that it is full of unnecessary rules, subsystems and who knows what else. When I said that, despite a good idea for carrying a d100 approach forward, pitfalls might remain, this was among the things I meant. Also penetration. Mandatory ÉP loss. Or Summarium presenting pages of a subsystem for aquir ancient magic whose purpose was to prevent players confronting aquirs. Its internal contradictions emerge with the first idea. After saying an aquir can articulate anything and it happens, it immediately explains that one can describe only breaking little-finger bones, while another can break your leg too. Such things undermined the world's logic and its existing, somewhat coherent foundations.

Then came the new skill system. Let there be five ranks. Not because five has any mechanical advantage, but because little Pisti wrote a letter saying Vampire has five ranks too, and how awesome that is, how much more grown-up a game. And what horror it is to rule, intrigue, romance and feel oh-so-cool. Fans of that system do not understand why I measure the frequency of attributes against the population from which a vampire selects a new vampire to Embrace. Or the difference between 0.5% and 0.0001%, because the curve is flat there. By the time this became the five-rank skill system of Summarium, Új Tekercsek and Új Törvénykönyv, it required far more memorisation than either percentage skills or the points in most d6 systems. Because every rank has a meaning.

The problem is that Új Tekercsek, for example, returned to requiring the full price of every skill rank, whereas Rúna's Magisztérium column had previously overridden this, allowing Master level's price to include Basic level. This means Master level, renamed fourth rank, costs far more KP. You must receive far more additional power-ups to obtain the skills important to your character and plausible for their training. What percentage of GMs knows the difference between the third and fourth ranks of a rarely used skill? Yet it takes up book space, can provoke arguments, and creates unnecessary memorisation. 

Discussing damage to weapons and armour can be great. Even someone with whom I am not on speaking terms republished and recommended it! But it merely added to the dung heap of unused, unnecessary rules making the system unmanageably complicated. Whatever work went into the analysis, even into the relevant section, the dung heap's smell sticks, and the whole piece stinks of shit. A M.A.G.U.S. with a future cannot be like this. Some call removing so much manure from the stables a Herculean task; others observe that it would require at least a flood. 

The guideline briefly mentioned in the previous article is this change's most important foundation. It is perfectly simple: Stealth remains Stealth whether you use a physical method, ancient magic or a racial ability. We often use the principle that the mechanics remain while the description changes. It is one of Second Chance's most important foundations. 

It is not nice to take an example from an existing edition, but regarding the Favour Points introduced by Új Törvénykönyv, someone asked what happens if a favoured character changes religion, knowing the rules do not allow it. Many answers appeared. Mine stood out somewhat. The gods can probably tell where you belong. If that is with Arel, she may well support you even while you still think you will follow her rival Ellana. What you learned and what you tried to cast is beside the point, because the goddesses knew your path all along. You see a change where no real change exists. Someone who was one kind of priest both mechanically and in their portrayal was another kind in the world's reality. Applying the principle that mechanics remain while description changes makes this a good character concept too: more interesting, multidimensional. And why did the deity reward a decision wrong by its own teachings? Because it rewarded commitment. 

But Favour Points certainly do not fit the aim of eliminating unnecessary and often parallel systems. Something else will replace them. We will return to that, but I would begin the problem elsewhere. 

With a short list: attacks per round, ÉP, FP, STP, KÉ, VÉ, CÉ, TÉ, Damage, SFÉ, MGT, Penetration, the vulnerabilities described under STP, Strength, Dexterity, Speed... We have not even used magic, yet all these values and countless modifiers can appear in combat. There are many modifiers to calculate, and division and multiplication for STP or penetration too. A hell of a lot of skills modify rules; more modifiers follow. Then come arguments about what is realistic, how and why, which skill description introduced a penalty for lacking that skill, and whether that optional source applies. The combat system is the biggest problem.

So is the way my old article ignored how combat builds the dung heap we now want to remove. One player invokes realism, another balance, and each tantrum produces another pointless rule, perhaps with tables or something else. Excuse me, but combat does not work by one person waiting while the other strikes. The whole underlying system and idea are unrealistic. And sorry, but when a thief cheats at cards, we do not have eight modifiers for fifteen different tricks. Because the player is not planning tactics: the character is acting. Recognising that simple point shows that most details can be folded into how good characters generally are at fighting, letting us use simple checks. 

Checks emphasising combat's chaos and sacrifices made as circumstances change, rather than chess divorced from the world and story. For this I must point to another article, somewhat newer than the one examining STP. 

Blade Dance 1: The Arena's Sand

Alina circled cautiously in the arena. She knew perfectly well that this time she faced a dangerous opponent. Drisqar the orc was not only bigger and stronger than the slender girl, but an experienced gladiator, champion of many contests. The crowd roared. They liked Alina's style, but the champion had plenty of admirers too, so the slow opening only heightened the excitement. Then Drisqar's eyes narrowed, and with a tremendous shout he hurled his battle-axe at his slight opponent. She dodged out of its path with lightning speed, and the weapon buried itself in the arena wall. Many angry spectators cursed the champion for throwing away his battle-axe so recklessly... And Alina cursed him too, for the skill of the throw. She would not have admitted it for all the riches in the world, but she knew perfectly well that her opponent had not thrown his weapon in vain.

Continue reading

STP was indeed important in many respects, at least according to the system's logic. But one question remained unanswered: why does armour covering more area have greater SFÉ? Is it not enough that striking an unarmoured body part is harder? Naturally, at least with an "overhit", or túlütés, a rolled hit location further complicated things. STP lets us model damage to weapons and armour, reduced SFÉ and much else. A better weapon can even receive an advantage through its STP. But we fail to ask several questions: what counts as an attack? One movement? What is a hit? A weapon reaching someone? A realistic attack often involves more than one movement, and a successful attack can hurt someone simply by forcing a painful movement. 

The article just quoted begins with a story showing how damage can arise this way and through other indirect means. A hit need not be a clean hit. Such damage depends on many things. How threatening is the weapon, and how much can your armour let you escape with a less painful movement? Across how wide an area might sharp fragments from a broken object strike you during an indirect hit? If we invent separate rules for everything, we get a huge pile of impossible-to-remember, unusable and therefore unused rules. Introduce them only for some situations? That is arbitrary and unfair, and justified complaints will eventually force a solution. Introduce none, though, and simply "grinding down FP" is hardly exciting. The combat system is fundamentally wrong. 

If, instead of grinding down FP, we examine who currently controls the fight, gaining and losing advantages and experiencing many dangerous situations through that, we can handle things more generally without creating so many rules. The principle that the mechanics remain while the description changes is easy to apply.

Imagine another small detail. Where Új Törvénykönyv uses Favour Points, we could introduce a score I find more interesting: how strong the character's "Essence" is. A better-played character has stronger Essence; a poorly played one, weaker. The game master uses this mechanic as a reward. A priest's Essence lies in their relationship with their deity. A wizard's often lies in a depth of focus and concentration far beyond other magic users'. Essence signifies something else too. As long as you have Essence, your story in the monastery is simply written onward with you having survived. Thus it, rather than Health, can be the guarantee of survival. A simpler approach can replace the existing ÉP/FP concept: 

When your combat reserves run out, you are defeated; after that, your pain tolerance can continue to decline. When pain tolerance also runs out, you are broken, and your Essence can be damaged. A continuing campaign character has greater Essence through many rewards and divine favours, so is not only stronger in certain situations, at the cost of reducing Essence, but also far more likely to survive than a newly created tournament character of the "same level". The latter can face greater mortality and risk, making play more exciting. This supports different play styles. Spending Essence may produce a stronger effect than an iconic ability. If the result temporarily or permanently reduces Essence because the ability is so powerful? Stronger still. Instead of tactics based on combat positioning and many other details, using iconic abilities and Essence can provide tactical choices while making combat more cinematic.

An "overhit" can be rewarded with increased damage. Or simply by reducing not only combat reserves but pain tolerance, and, with an even greater overhit, Essence too. Most fights would still end with combat reserves exhausted. And we can add another twist. 

In most cases, "combat reserves" can be shared. Each side's checks, whose difficulty depends on the opponents' values, reduce enemy combat reserves in proportion to their success when attacking. A defending side can reduce the damage inflicted by its enemy. Healing and spending a character's Essence can even increase combat reserves. The result? You can describe how your character fights more freely and with more roleplaying, without seeking "the mechanically optimal tactic". Another advantage? Once character and party creation establish how combat reserves are calculated, we have turned combat into a sequence of simple checks, a group contest. Far fewer values are needed. It is faster and more lively. Since combat is not chess, I find it more realistic too. 

Arguments over realism versus balance, and the accumulation of unnecessary micro-rules they force, become less likely. The system is abstract enough to let you change the situation. Does armour absorb part of a blow, deflect strikes, let you parry with a vambrace, or make an opponent commit more errors while trying to circumvent armour they consider impenetrable? Any of these fits the description. That is why the mechanics remain while the description changes is such a powerful principle. If I say armour adds X points to combat reserves, and that is its mechanical property, it could represent full armour or magical mail. Providing examples is enough. We can add that, even if you disagree with an example, you still receive armour according to its point value; you simply describe it differently. Or, when freely choosing armour, choose a higher category. Family armour can be better for many reasons. 

Essence can replace not only ÉP, but Favour Points too, and may influence how powerfully we cast spells or how we fight. Under the principle that the mechanics remain while the description changes, we can explain the effect in many ways: divine origin, deep focus, magic or something else. Many things influence the player's position. One is that, since at least the enemy's combat reserves are hidden, the player knows how their character is doing only through the description and cannot calculate everything to the last point. Another is that this makes the choices faced each combat round interesting. I will try listing them from weaker to stronger.

  1. Fight normally: attack, defend or heal.
  2. Use an option available once every specified number of rounds, which therefore requires pacing. This too often depends on Essence.
  3. Also use an iconic ability or item available a limited number of times per scene. The risk is that reinforcements may arrive, or another reason may make a different use preferable.
  4. Use something available less frequently, including consumable but easily replaced items. 
  5. Use an option temporarily reducing Essence.
  6. Use a limited resource, such as a charge from an item, that is difficult to replace.
  7. Use an option reducing Essence permanently, until advancement: make a serious sacrifice.

Suppose the skill associated with an iconic ability gains +10 whenever it goes unused in an important scene. The GM decides what counts as important; a scene of the character going for a piss does not. Perhaps deliberately charging it gives a somewhat larger modifier—a wizard through meditation, a priest through prayer, a witch through lovemaking, for example—worth as much as +25%. But using it "spends" that modifier. Deciding when to use it and when to stick to the basics immediately becomes a serious dilemma. Sometimes you might accept a small wound, temporarily reducing Essence, rather than lose the modifier before a major battle. These are interesting tactical choices. Moreover, taking a serious wound no longer merely means cursing a bad roll. In a fight going too well for the enemy, looking too evenly matched, it can result from a heroic manoeuvre through which you knowingly accept the wound. A dramatically important moment in which your character matters right then. Such moments make both good and bad rolls memorable. 

Clearly, changing the values of Essence and iconic abilities makes it easy to shift between a more traditional worldview, where many not especially famous adventurers have defeated aquirs, and a darker, somewhat horror-oriented world, where the aquirs win. But we must switch to skill-based magic, so the skills corresponding to spells need to be produced as content. The fiddly work most agonising to a creative mind arrives. Essence belongs to the character, with its uses and methods established, at least for an adventure. But it has individual and class-dependent features. Iconic abilities can likewise be personal, class-based or race-based. A few magic items can also grant bonuses or new abilities of this kind, but rarely.

Remember one foundation of our system? The mechanics remain while the description changes. For a given effect, we do not count how many blows produced it. We do not know "how many times you attack", but it probably depends less on weapon weight or Speed than on how many opportunities you create. I divided the options above into seven tiers. If I say you may use one thing from each tier per round because each creates extra opportunities, less frequently used abilities need not be powerful on their own. If aiming and the "iconic ability: arrow machine gun" occur in the same round, the GM can narrate them as one manoeuvre. A player may thus do up to seven times as much in a round as normal. But there is a serious price. 

That price, often appearing as a heroic charge, is not necessarily cheap when it includes accepting a wound, permanent Essence loss, expending rarely available abilities, iconic abilities and so on. But it can produce many interesting victories. Suppose the combined result determines the size of the "overhit". The risk is that the benefit is capped because "you cannot kill someone twice", limiting the reduction in combat reserves. The advantage is that an enemy defeated by the heroic charge no longer strikes back, while the sacrificed Essence leaves you weaker in combat too... 

The basic system is in place, but some questions remain open: 

  • How do we calculate combat reserves? — We address that in character and party creation.
  • How much damage is inflicted, meaning how much combat reserves change after a check? — It could be the full roll, or perhaps "the amount above the difficulty". To calculate faster with smaller numbers, it could be one tenth of such a value, rounded down.
  • How much Essence does someone lose, and why? — That belongs to the Essence system, a general rule. Like iconic skills, it will have its own chapter. 

An explanation of the class system is coming soon. After that it will be easier to explain Essence, the skill system and character creation. Once we understand Essence and combat reserves, we can return to "How much damage?", which will also handle overhits and variations in combat according to the world's tone. Something is beginning to take shape. If magic's combat role is built into combat resolution, the magic system will only need to cover magical rituals outside combat.