Article Index

Renassa

It is difficult to deal with a player who refuses to understand that a seven-year-old child does not cast spells, especially not through random experimentation, and of course has no mana, even if admitted to a wizard school. It is particularly difficult when they insist this is a huge system bug: if magic is not innate, and mana points require, for example, initiation received at school, how did the first wizard come about when there was nobody to initiate them? I could say look a little to the right at the picture for the answer, but really, the question is best divided into three parts straight away.

It is difficult to deal with a player who refuses to understand that a seven-year-old child does not cast spells, especially not through random experimentation, and of course has no mana, even if admitted to a wizard school. It is particularly difficult when they insist this is a huge system bug: if magic is not innate, and mana points require, for example, initiation received at school, how did the first wizard come about when there was nobody to initiate them? I could say look a little farther down at the picture for the answer, but really, the question is best divided into three parts straight away.

Renassa

Obviously, “I do not understand the world; I think it is flawed” can be expressed civilly, without trying to rewrite the world over the GM's head. The second point is simply that in a life-path campaign including wizard school, the game master is there to tell you when you can start casting spells, and meanwhile you will receive answers to numerous questions about the world. These are obvious considerations most players understand on their own. The third question, however, is interesting: if the issue arises in your game, how do you answer it as GM?

Obviously, crude answers range from because I say so, and I am the GM to the first magic-user was not a wizard; wizards developed from another kind of magic-user who already had mana. The latter answers the question literally and tells us how we get to the first wizard, but not how someone first acquired mana points. Obviously, we cannot answer questions on the level of who created the first creator, and Ynev's creation story has changed more than once too. But a little exploration of magic's history does no harm.

And of course, this raises which creators' ideas and which sources we consider authoritative. 

Let us begin with the most obvious answer: although humans and most races alive today do not possess magic from birth, other races do. They can even teach. I think of Seyrine the Tormentor in the Bestiárium, and the teaching spell described there, which immediately answers the question. According to an official source, an inherently magical being from the outer planes can enable another to use magic and provide the mana points too. The newly trained witch can then make further developments. 

It matters that many witch orders are tied to religions and trace their knowledge to their deity and its emissaries. The gods' power and knowledge allow any of them to have emissaries capable of the same. From here, we see numerous orders of magic-users tied to religions. Some to gods, others to demons, but all possess teachable magic with which to train further spellcasters.

Opening the rulebooks at the chapters on priestly magic, we find the observation that the Lesser Arcana's Litanies do not necessarily require real gods: faith and the appropriate formula suffice. In that case, magic manipulating creative forces could easily pass from devout clergy into the hands of heretics pursuing worldly interests. They could then readily begin independent research. This can also occur among creatures of the outer planes. Although the creators have tinkered with Ynev's creation story, I still consider this an easy foundation to build upon.

This is precisely the point in magical history where I find ÚTK's separation of Grace Points and Mana Points problematic: from heretical magic, it is easy to arrive at constructed faiths and the question of what those behind them can create. In comparing divine and mortal powers, I would like to point out that the Kyr defeated Orwella, and divine power is not unstoppable in Amhe-Ramun's manifestation either.

Naturally, numerous other sources of magic arise. Ancient magic based on the gift of tongues may offer a solution depending on how we treat it within our conception of the world. Likewise, any procedure by which non-spellcasters created objects with magical properties, using magical materials, for example. The list could continue for pages. But the question of the first wizard has another aspect, and this is no longer neutral regarding one's conception of the world. Fortunately, it is a softer question.