A new M.A.G.U.S. system is in development. For the umpteenth time. This always reminds me of the Második Törvénykönyv and the fact that instead of a system reform, we ended up with an Amund with Beauty 23. But whom is it for? Obviously not the people constantly criticizing M.A.G.U.S. on various roleplaying sites. There may be at least two major target groups: new players and M.A.G.U.S. players. Both groups need a little explanation. Anyone who thinks that covers everyone leaves out at least two groups: former M.A.G.U.S. players, and veterans who have good reasons for playing something other than M.A.G.U.S.
By new players, I mean people who have never played any roleplaying game, for whom more than just M.A.G.U.S. will be new. Somehow we must explain to them why M.A.G.U.S. is worth choosing. Among M.A.G.U.S. players are people for whom M.A.G.U.S. is the roleplaying game, or at least their primary choice. They are easy to persuade: buy it, at least try it. A few possible fixes and additions make a fairly good selling point. The other group consists of those for whom M.A.G.U.S. is one roleplaying game, played because of some particular quality. It is no great revelation to say that different things matter to these three groups.
Wait until it comes out, give it a chance... Buy it first, read it, then judge it. There is one problem with all this. One of the new book's greatest flaws is visible not only after publication but well in advance, right now: it does not start with a clean slate. The team behind the brand stopped deserving another chance and a clean slate long ago. For a considerable proportion of players, then, the new M.A.G.U.S. will not merely lack a clean slate: their opinion will be determined not by the new system's qualities, but entirely by factors already known today.
Suppose the new M.A.G.U.S. appears, I take a selfie with it, and alongside it write the entirely unsurprising opinion that we have already seen a system's release followed by arguments and then a split, leaving the reform without official support and with a fragmented community. Perhaps also noting that this is why I cannot recommend it to new players, who need solid foundations and stable support... None of this requires reading anything in the new book; such criticism is independent of its contents.
Over the past twenty-three and a half years, we have been conned more than once or twice. The Második Törvénykönyv, assembled from material cut and pasted from here and there after internal arguments, is an obvious example. So are the incompleteness and contradictions of the Summarium project, also advertised as a new core book. Or how Új Tekercsek's supposedly playable system turned out. The issue is not merely “where is the circular dependency?” or some more complicated flaw, but the obvious: it tells us not to mix it with earlier systems because it is incompatible. Indeed, skills and special abilities imported from elsewhere can upset the system. Only the basic races were left out. There is no way this could not have been noticed before publication.
Then came the con called “the M.A.G.U.S. logo can bear anything.” Yes, in literature too. Then came the promise of Yardain and company's system. Then d20, which lacked just one thing, the d20 system's greatest promise: compatibility with the d20 system, to ensure a supply of supplements. ÚTK brought litigation, then the twentieth anniversary brought no M 2*0. Legal wrangling and everything else over how to make money from the brand. While players and fans were consistently shat on and stabbed in the back.
Someone tell me what either a playtest or publication changes about many M.A.G.U.S. fans saying I no longer trust you, I have my own customized solution, leave me alone with your promises and lawsuits! I will tell you: nothing. Nor does it matter whether I write this before or after the new system's release. As long as this position is justified, plenty of people will refuse to switch to the new system out of sheer defiance and protest. That makes uniting the community harder.
2018, the twenty-fifth anniversary, is coming. They could plan a twenty-fifth-anniversary edition. Correcting only printing errors, with physically durable, handsome books worthy of a collection. A small print run could even accommodate leather bindings, a presentation box, and many other extras. An art book, atlas, and numerous other treasures for collectors could accompany it. It could sit under the Christmas tree. And yes, the intervening time could be spent organizing the community and winning back alienated fans. We could have a splendid quarter-century anniversary. Even someone fond of another edition would not be disappointed by the anniversary and a collector's edition.
And numerous other things could follow soon afterward. A companion-style volume, for example. Perhaps with point-buy character creation, or a host of house rules. Some could even be gathered online and voted in. With many optional steps, previous reforms could become a concept that wins over even ÚTK lovers. A new system accompanied by mistrust, however, is more likely to provoke angry arguments among many of us.
Some people are pleased by almost anything. But they would also welcome a twenty-fifth-anniversary reprint and reform through supplements and optional rules.
And yes, it is possible that it will be good. But what mattered to me was precisely that literary Ynev and roleplaying Ynev were separate, as, in fact, were the literary Ynevs of many works. They provided examples of the games we could build with optional rules. For the litigants to become influential, however, canon had to acquire greater importance. Yet this great bundle of lore includes numerous awful works one would need to know to conform to it. And many people do not want to wrestle with unreadable works.
For others, if much of canon once again becomes optional and many reject it—with good reason—the value of the knowledge they acquired and the hours they suffered through disappears. Both groups cannot be satisfied. And many occasionally play M.A.G.U.S. alongside other games either because their accumulated knowledge makes Ynev feel their own, or because of the world they built themselves among the earlier independent versions. There will be arguments and complaints. And that is hardly a fitting way to celebrate the twenty-fifth anniversary.
And the possibility will remain that it could have been done differently. That is precisely why this must be written now, because if we write it then, the only answer will be: everyone is wise after the event. Then we will discuss the system's subtleties or flaws. If it gets finished.