Few creators in M.A.G.U.S.'s history have welcomed constructive criticism. Among the ÚTK team, Tuan's publisher does; Nyúl did back then, as did Mátyás Massár around the M.A.G.U.S. card game. I do not know what the other ÚTK developers are like, but even this makes ÚTK friendlier than similar initiatives. It is a pity that doing much with this is difficult: a possible new, revised edition of Új Törvénykönyv has little chance of truly convincing me. It would require abandoning precisely the values I prize most in ÚTK, immediately counting against it in my eyes too. What is this important value?
The game's strength is the life-path campaign, which needs continuity and consistency. Anyone reading our comparison of M.A.G.U.S. editions may quickly have noticed: One of Új Törvénykönyv's greatest sins is having turned out well. A substantial community therefore uses it. Otherwise it would not truly divide the community either, but as it stands, a sizeable fan base plays by Új Törvénykönyv. Naturally, they interpret its rules and world quite differently, and most would prefer continuing according to their own ideas. Just like those who cling to other conceptions of the world and therefore never switched to Új Törvénykönyv. » Click for details
The differences naturally begin with Summarium's innovations, many adopted by Új Törvénykönyv. Some accept certain creators' or writers' every work uncritically, sacrificing even their own world's consistency. According to malicious tongues and the Delta Vision forum, András Gáspár is contemplating further partly retroactive changes. Consequently, we must reckon with at least five different conceptions of the world.
- One Ynev is human- and adventurer-centered. Here, a Kránian aquir race rose above the others through modern magic, so ancient magic cannot be decisive. Many famous and less famous adventurers have fought aquir, even in Ediomad. This fundamentally requires strongly restraining words of power and the freely formulated aquir language. In return, an adventurer is somewhat more than human. Their collected stories often define Ynev's history for a reason: adventurers shape history. That requires strong characters from the outset and easily overcome ancient magic. A head-hunter team with someone using words of power is easy to imagine, but it still needs several other spellcasters. Such units' composition then makes sense. Unwritten details, however, are filled in many different ways...
- The second direction is Summarium, seeking a darker world with powers and monsters that justify fear, and weaker adventurers. Yet adventurers never became mere “people forced to wander,” creating a contradiction with the adventurer concept. The system contradicts itself about od, affecting not only aquir power relationships but head-hunter unit composition. This conception is not very consistent, but in a sufficiently dark or horror-oriented game, characters neither live long enough nor become developed enough for that to matter much. It simply never became a well-functioning world...
- The third conception arises mainly from mixing the first two. Accepting many sources merely for the M.A.G.U.S. label while rejecting the original creators' explanations produces alternative Ynevs where a “gnome king” may possess substantial territory in Erion, strange adventures have introduced many creatures alien to the world, and stories and their continuations require them. The central concept is “anything goes, and so does its opposite,” allowing many adventures and characters, even a website's most overpowered amateur supplement. This too supports a popular play style. The world's role changes again. Words of power, once representing ancient terrifying might, gradually become possessions of “passing adventurers.”
- Új Törvénykönyv arose from an honest creative intention to produce a somewhat more unified, consistent world after all this, but compromises were made to bring the groups together. Many see this compromise as falling between two stools rather than a happy medium. Lovers of human- and adventurer-centered Ynev still find ancient magic too powerful and reject it for that reason. Others miss their disreputable heroes with plentiful OP who would overturn the world while drunk.
- András Gáspár now wants to describe what each country is like, creating a new situation. The concept here is authorial freedom and many personal ideas. It need not necessarily be logical, but must present the Ynev he imagines. As long as he stays faithful to that world, the concept is an image close to the novels.
And no, we cannot say “few take the first conception seriously anymore”: that can mobilize many vocal people against a new one. Nor should the last be dismissed by saying literary Ynev was always separate and will be inconsistent... András Gáspár holds the rights and wants to become involved now for a reason. The third could be mocked as a “munchkin kindergarten,” but plenty of people like that style, and they too constitute paying demand. Despite many problems, Summarium influences many. And an ÚTK reform begins with ÚTK.
The relationship between ancient and modern magic is an important difference. For martial artists, the traditional conception accommodates internal time that also accelerates the body as an iconic ability, perhaps only as a weapon of a chosen few. Új Törvénykönyv went against this precisely because it is much less adventurer-centered. Many skill and spell descriptions also reflect differing power relations, worlds, and play styles. These conceptual differences are difficult to bridge. The fact is, while sites publish pieces where city-states from nowhere suddenly know more magic than Toron, Doran, Krán, and Pyarron combined, introducing yet another more powerful wizard subclass, and demand exists for them, saying “we need a more consistent world” is pointless. A site living off the newest overpowered subclasses has no interest in a consistent, solid, well-described Ynev that lets everyone recognize within two minutes when a supplement does not fit.
One of the most important changes would be thinking through what belongs in the book and what in an accompanying electronic publication. They are different. Printing is an expensive luxury, whether conventional or print on demand, even though I know relatively inexpensive examples of the latter. But many dislike extensive reading on a computer or monitor, and even if they have an e-reader, most devices struggle with beautiful RPG core books. A book's purpose is to be read. Its electronic companion is searchable and unrestricted in length, and with a suitable format can even be partly interactive. Separating the functions would also keep the book coherent. The printed book's PDF would be optimized for e-readers too. (E-readers and Rulebooks: E-readers are designed for prolonged reading, but usually display grayscale and are not very large. Color content and large pages therefore work poorly.) I would therefore ensure pages remain comfortable to read on their screens. The interactive publication could export to PDF too.
I would therefore envisage a “book + PDF + interactive electronic publication” combination. The book would not use the customary rulebook size, but one easy to carry, reread, and “learn from.” Format matters for that reason. Traditional printing or print on demand? Both have advantages, and many publishers favor print on demand for good reason. Even the version where a bookstore orders X copies, produced for that order: physical distribution without warehousing stock. The latter could be particularly effective with an Espresso Book Machine or similar device in the shop. Yes, a machine delivering a paper book “while you drink a coffee in the bookstore” would permit many more publications, and hopefully customers interested in other rare books would help recoup its cost. I know: such investment is expensive. But then even a personalized export from the interactive publication could become a book, right in the shop.
Separating reading material from everyday reference would improve matters considerably. Electronic editions could contain much more material, perhaps attracting a wider customer base. A possible next ÚTK edition could become a truly twenty-first-century book. With this distribution model, I should add, new paper copies would already be correct after errata appeared. But what would I use the additional space for?
Many restrictions introduced for game balance work better as optional rules, (Optional Rule: Optional rules are choices, so players know a suitable group can depart from them without overturning the entire world or system. Tournament rules could also be specified, mandatory at official competitions.) explicitly targeting balance rather than the world. This matters not merely because a group might sometimes break them, perhaps in a life-path campaign, but because the game master then knows such rules are less reliable guides to how the world works.
Personally, I would thoroughly rewrite ancient magic as another optional rule, leaving the existing version for those who like it. The concept would simply ensure that even a head-hunter possessing ancient magic remains magically insignificant beside the spellcaster accompanying them. Two things are needed. Distinguish a few copied words from instinctive formulation through the gift of tongues, a distinction missing even from Új Bestiárium. Second, even a head-hunter genuinely capable of a word of power should not become a substantial magic-user. Let this power add flavor, its unexpected use and variety confuse opponents, and make it frightening because any word of power is possible and many are legendary. But it must never become strong enough to “overshadow” spellcasters.
This would benefit both world and balance. The difficulty is that many use the creature creator to make prospective player characters, and it would make a major change over their heads. As an optional rule, however, it could fit.
The creature creator is a more important question. I have mixed feelings. If rules exist, they cannot be only for the GM, who is not really bound by rules anyway... At least that is roughly every player's position when they want to use it themselves. Nothing wrong with that, except the creature creator is unprepared for it in many respects. It could become more detailed and part of ÚTK, strictly as an optional rule. But if Wier are a separate race because of a karmic curse, chosen adventurers are too. Including one or two similar “chosen” versions of every race as examples would, through slower advancement and stronger beginnings, sneak many adventurer-centered elements back into the system.
Equally important, attribute checks should be replaced with 2d10 rolls under the full attribute, allowing many simpler illnesses to be “shaken off on one's feet.” That would greatly help play remain faithful to the world. It is not particularly complicated. Repeating the mathematical background seems unnecessary. I would quickly add that the “chosen adventurer” concept could be reflected in slightly more starting KAP points, while cleverly rethinking the KAP-based system could also support life-path campaigns beginning in childhood.
It would also matter where maintaining an attribute requires regular exercise or plentiful food, such as Strength, or where it has substantial disadvantages—a highly beautiful thief would have more difficulty stealing unnoticed because too many people watch them...
These hardly seem drastic changes, except perhaps the format and electronic publication. Many details obviously have not occurred to me. But the point is precisely that these rules do not seem major. While I am basically satisfied with a system, the new one offers little more or better, and I object to five-level skills and much else, I have little reason to switch. I will not say, “rewriting these and thinking through the consequences in a few days is trivial.” I will say, “That is extra work; the old one works well, so why switch?” But if I see even these details serving me better and requiring less discussion of modified rules, the result would be excellent.
The publication's format would make my life more convenient. “Almost as good in its world conception, but requiring plenty of work and offering no extra convenience” is insufficient reason to switch. Whatever improvements others see, “do not fix what is already good” would leave me unconvinced, and many details would even bother me. Why spend money on it? Why invest considerable work if it promises nothing more or better? With optional rules, a better format, and so forth, however, there would be systems offering greater convenience and easier agreement on numerous optional rules, with many things making me say, “this could make switching worthwhile.”
But I am unsure Tuan would want the trouble of handling two concepts of ancient magic. Unsure they would embrace the unusual format. I do not believe many would invest in letting me walk into their shop, choose from a substantial catalog of roleplaying PDFs, say “I would like this as a book,” and hold a fresh copy minutes later. I do not believe it, though publishing suitable works through such print on demand would give many people a chance. But may I be wrong.