AmundThe obvious answer is that a substantial part of the community rejects it. The less obvious answer largely lies in a conceptual flaw that cannot be corrected without replacing the whole system. That flaw is in the concept of Skill Points. KP, or Skill Points, is a fundamental system concept that has been wrong and flawed since M.A.G.U.S.'s first edition. Just as abilities and the definition of Beauty are inconsistently applied when it comes to an amund's beauty, the definition of a skill is not always applied consistently either. Imagine this: you have no unspent KP, but several people teach you knot-tying during a boring sea voyage. Your knowledge of knots earns experience points as experience acquired through learning, so it becomes part of what you know. But you will have no skill in knot-tying. This problem can be resolved in three ways.

  • A skill represents completion of a particular formal course of training, rather than knowledge itself. 
  • KP per level represents free time during the schooling associated with levelling up. Things learned during an adventure and skills acquired at other times are independent of it.
  • Alongside experience acquired through learning, allow TP → KP conversion, then spend those skill points.

The first case is legal within the traditional system's definitions of KP and skills. Together with other knowledge, such as what kills a troll, it is part of the system's concept. Practising it to skill level can wait until levelling up, but the character is somewhere between complete ignorance, or being untrained, and the intended skill rank. They receive no bonus, but the game master reduces the untrained penalties with a situational modifier. Recording the source of the experience points and the time invested also avoids arguments, and you can do this during character creation too.

You may have no Literacy skill. You say the system is shit because you lacked the KP for it. In fact, Literacy is cheap: if you lacked the KP, you chose something else as more important, and even in the ÚTK that can leave no points for something fundamental. But in the present system, you can say you have experience of learning to read and write. The experience-point value is covered by experience acquired through learning, in proportion to the time invested; it simply has not yet become a skill. You have not been examined on it, nor consolidated the knowledge through formal schooling. You say learning ahead would shorten the time needed to acquire the skill and free up KP? I say a maths lesson does not get shorter just because you already know the material.

The second option leads to the same place, and together these two approaches substantially reduce the flaw. The serious bug arises if a character completes actual training during play, resulting in a genuinely complete, practised skill. Rúna's options for advancing KP on credit are good in such cases. What happens in the world is that the character's experience acquired through learning qualifies them for further instruction within their order, but they must be examined on it. Outside training is not recognised, so the time required for the relevant instruction appears again. This is where the character demonstrates to their teacher that they possess the experience acquired through learning—the TP. If we also adopt the KP-credit option proposed in Rúna, the system is stable. The character cannot keep deferring the KP debt because the examination on that learning experience takes place at the current level-up. 

The third option is Új Tekercsek's solution. House systems for tournament character creation based on spending TP generally point in this direction too. 

But there is another interpretation. It says that the acquired KP represents not the maximum amount of skills a character may choose when spending it, but the minimum amount the character must possess to attain the next level through initiation, learning secret combat moves and so on. The game master can award skills beyond this, whether for a good backstory or through something resembling Rúna's advantages-and-disadvantages system. Membership in a school, examinations and the other things justifying classes and advancement clearly point in this direction. This is an agreed house-rule approach, but it is not alien to the system's logic.

What single consideration legitimised these options? The system openly did not aim for game balance. It never believed for a moment that a newly qualified, inexperienced wizard could simply join adventurers of equivalent power as if by magic. Adventurers at similar stages of their careers were roughly the same level. Differences between characters created the game master's opportunity to establish narrative balance without mechanical balance. That intention means that, in this system, the absence of game balance is not a flaw but a feature, a design concept. 

The traditional system chose a suitable tool for a defensible, indeed justified objective, and it works when interpreted appropriately. 

Then came Új Tekercsek and Új Törvénykönyv. By severing the connection between skills and training, they reclassified this sort of experience, which does not constitute meaningful training, as a first-rank skill. This invalidated the first solution, while the second creates a bigger problem: this experience was not acquired by an adventurer returning to study for a level-up. Does the skill now come free? Or do we seek the third approach? Whichever route we take, every rule introduced for balance becomes meaningless, because points are also available for free. 

The solutions proposed above are therefore alien to this system. 

The KAP system admits two interpretations: one says balance is the objective, the other says it is not. If balance is not the objective, tying the experience described above to a first-rank skill is a conceptual flaw undermining one pillar of the five-rank system. Moreover, there are too few points for many realistically constructed starting adventurers. If we want freedom irrespective of balance, that is an unforgivable flaw. Editing out the first rank is harder, but we can move from "create a character with exactly X points" towards "create a character with at least X points, because below that they are one-dimensional and too weak to be a believable adventurer". With only a minimum specified, and the maximum limited solely by what the game master permits and what fits the party and adventure, there is no question of lacking points for something or the system being unfree. Then we need only reform another five or six parts of the system, remove the third rank, turn the multiple specialisations at fifth rank into independent skills, and...

If game balance is the objective, however, the cost of every ability and skill must be proportional to its usefulness. A general problem I have often pointed out is that, since you do not even know what will come up in the adventure, you do not know which skills will be useful, powerful and so on. In a combat-free investigative campaign, high-rank weapon proficiency with an unavailable weapon offers zero benefit. Yet it cost points. A skill you can actually use during the campaign is an infinitely better deal: imbalance cannot get greater than that.

Beyond that, there is another problem. A bad system ties you up. A hell of a lot of skills should be taken with a specialisation. History does not always cover everything; you must specify what it applies to. Area Knowledge works similarly. Some such skills are expensive, provide no numerical benefit even when used successfully, and easily tie characters in knots. Characters with these skills, who are ultimately weaker anyway, run out of points sooner than stronger characters. The problem is not merely that creating them is harder and requires more calculations. Often, the character cannot be created at all. It is no secret that we have ongoing campaigns in which all six player characters are witches, or have been six assassins or six thieves.

To prevent wildly overpowered munchkin characters, the points allow relatively little freedom for extreme combinations. But they also allow little freedom to make a character's knowledge distinctive. Every witch will have enough points to be a witch. A fine sexual object in the game. Probably not much more, and not much less. But a witch with scholarly interests, a bookworm who would research magic, hits a wall. One merely seeking more power hits it less readily. To give your character something they are truly good at in a system striving for balance, you are often forced to develop in one direction. That is harmful. Apparent freedom is soon restricted both by points and by the question of what makes a viable build. 

4Shu2avgaThere are bonds, and they tie the character up. In the campaign built around six witches, most of their differences would quickly disappear on switching to the ÚTK. Yet its promise of balance would come to nothing. 

The ÚTK system chose a tool especially unsuitable, because of fundamental internal contradictions, for an objective that cannot be achieved for several reasons and is therefore unjustified. Its stated objective, balance, depends on GM decisions and can be achieved differently through those decisions, but the poor choices here obstruct that. 

As a counterpoint, I repeat: the traditional system chose a suitable tool for a defensible, indeed justified objective, and it works when interpreted appropriately. 

The only problem is that it will be twenty-five years old by the time the next edition appears. Time has passed it by. We need a system doing at least as much, at least as well, while learning something from the past twenty-five years. One that accounts for the fact that, twenty-five years ago, even multiplication was unacceptable during character creation because someone might dislike maths. Today many people create characters with character-generation programs. An app can calculate standard deviation, the frequency of a given attribute score, and many kinds of relationship. It can even account for the kind of adventure the GM mentioned, what might be useful, and calculate how well the character fits accordingly. But this is not the ÚTK approach. Very much not.

And many of a character's advantages and disadvantages are hard to quantify. A system alone will never produce balance. 

What I have considered a good direction since roughly the spread of laptops is evaluating characters from several perspectives based on the values chosen during creation. We receive numbers as results, but colours too. Green: the character will probably work safely in most stories. Yellow: the character is beginning to depart markedly from the usual. Red: the character is far outside normal bounds. Choose too few things and you get red for being too sketchy.