When we asked how useful it is to accept the notion of adventurer's disease, we were essentially in a difficult position. We had three choices. One approach, which many people would have chosen, would be to go down the “what do the official people say?” route. I know perfectly well that the rules gurus on many sites describe precisely that. There is just one problem: it never tells you how well the official position works in play. And here we specifically needed to test whether an official statement was workable. The second option would be the “can we construct an explanation?” method, starting from magic and Ynev's many other ideas. That is hardly alien to me, but you can easily say: of course you can explain it after the fact... That still does not make it realistic. That is how the realistic idea of adrenaline addiction came up.
Then a fine, lengthy analysis by my fellow editor appeared in the comments, drawing on things written elsewhere about the relationship between personality types and the primal elements. It is something worth examining, because if primal fire involves not only matter but also temperament (personality type), emotions and so on, it is easy to say that in mosaic magic the mosaics of elemental magic and astral magic can be combined in interesting ways. Primal fire that does not burn (concealment? cold?) could symbolize particular emotions or an emotional state. Would a performance like this affect those who see it—as a kind of living, moving astral symbol—or those it hits? Questions like these can arise from the mosaic principle too. And the reason for my “official optimism” about Lunír's system reform is that they are more concerned with this than with the rules needed to manage munchkins at tournaments.
This leads in a different direction from the “who can affect what, and how do we stop it being overpowered?” approach. Like it or not, combat is part of roleplaying, so combat situations often need describing. One small example of such descriptions can be found in our piece Blade Dance: The Arena's Sand. It soon becomes clear that the description goes beyond “you swing, it hits, 6 FP,” while also showing why I handle certain rules the way I do. But let us go a little further. When describing combat, it helps to begin with what the characters feel. Someone who has a little tunnel vision from too much adrenaline, struggles to think things through, does not use tactics, and has lost their usual accuracy but is strong is one very particular case.
The situation is quite different when someone can remain calm. This composure, this “cold-blooded slaughter,” can be the foundation of certain people's fearsome reputation. And yes, in the case of many assassins on Earth, people tried to maintain composure through hashish or cannabis use. This idea found its way into Ynev too: the desert origins of the Path of the Herb and similar traditions make an interesting connection. That is, if we do not immediately point out the reasons. Among groups playing from dreadful pirated translations and the occasional English-language supplement, real mythology, history and so on often served as sources. And here too, appetite came with eating.
You can say that victory in a game also brings a sense of achievement and triggers addiction. But it is equally certain that someone who regularly serves as game master and is forced to do a little research will eventually stop finding their joy in defeated monsters. Instead, the pleasure of discovery will take over, along with the joy and pride of successfully applying a good idea. Thus even the notorious groups at the Petőfi Csarnok produced the creator of CODEX. And of course, once success has for some time meant discovering the world and piecing together its details—something the character can do too—rather than defeating another monster from the Bestiárium, both player and GM change. Just as they do when recognition from their companions for good roleplaying provides that sense of achievement.
In that situation, the whole question of adventurer's disease is no longer about the current rights holder bandying about a slightly odd expression they may only have heard from their GM. It is much more about what the GM and player can do with adrenaline addiction and tolerance affecting how a character experiences combat, and what explanation they find for adventurer's disease. We have already described the things needed to portray combat as an objective part of a logical explanation. But what else can we add? Where can we give the overall picture a little more color?
For a long time, diseases were attributed to a sort of “possession by harmful spirits.” Later came the idea of a disturbance in the proper balance within the body or soul. It is easy to associate the “buildup” of individual elements in the soul or body with separable phenomena or spirits. This also points to a connection between warlock curses, diseases and necromancy—which on Ynev is based on summoning, remember. Some alien phenomenon or presence entering a person and their soul can upset the balance, but a karmic curse or a genetic or psychological illness can also be explained as a dangerous disturbance of that balance without outside forces. And if we explain diseases this way on Ynev, adventurer's disease becomes easy to explain too.
Hippocrates distinguished four temperaments based on the four primal elements: sanguine, melancholic, phlegmatic and choleric temperaments. According to this, the choleric temperament associated with fire is hotheaded and combative. The point is that, regarding the “fiery-souled” adventurer, my fellow editor assessed “adventurer's disease” quite simply:
Why do I mention fire? Let us look at adrenaline addiction from the outside.
Adrenaline is a stress hormone, part of fight or flight. When needed, it provides extra energy so we can react faster and with greater strength in an emergency. It drives us to much greater performance, and its use often goes unnoticed. Since we solve something, dopamine provides a rewarding effect, establishing a link between a situation, adrenaline and a positive outcome. From then on, we try to create similar situations just to get the chemical kick.
Advantages:
-everything feels urgent to the user; they cannot sit still and act quickly
-a temporary surge of energy, the so-called adrenaline rush or high [the euphoria accompanying the effect]
-the user can temporarily concentrate very well and feels effective and confident
-life seems much more exciting
-negative emotions temporarily have no effect on the userDisadvantages:
-the user needs stress and crisis to be able to accomplish anything
-the addict may wait until the very last moment, until something becomes truly dangerous or urgent, just so they can be the heroic rescuer [adrenaline and reinforcement (dopamine)]
-their expectations are unrealistically high
-they promise far more than they deliver [a stressful situation]
-they are reactive rather than proactive: they respond to an emergency instead of planning and preventing itThe price of addiction:
-it puts an incredible burden on the body
-it weakens the immune system
-the ability to concentrate deteriorates
-quality is sacrificed for immediate results
-they feel guilty if they do not perform at their best, which can also lead to depression
-a negative effect on social relationships
-the addict lives in the future, always rushing, and does not savor the benefits of things even when they have the opportunity
-constant guilt, because the addict feels that neither they nor their performance are good enoughLooking at the advantages and disadvantages, this is a typical choleric temperament, and therefore fire. In a world founded on hermetic principles, where this is also an advantage and is valued and glorified, it gains an even greater advantage. No wonder the disease spreads. Since the civilization is not technological, battles are fought with late-medieval weapons, which also creates plenty of dangerous situations; someone like this is perfect for them. The pure elemental version of this is Mogorva Chei, whose sword acts first, after which he looks around and asks questions, if there is anyone left to ask.
The dominance of fire matters. Paying attention to the many other traits of similar choleric personalities would soon enrich the roleplaying. So would the fact that an addict needs ever larger doses. Addiction is often accompanied by tolerance. Where an ordinary person could no longer make use of their knowledge because adrenaline controls them, tolerance helps. But the effects listed above can also appear in how an adventurer's personality is played, as can the many other traits of a choleric temperament. And a similar fire-associated temperament can be easy to describe and roleplay.
With aura perception, astral sight and similar methods, you can also describe what the observer sees on this basis. Thus adventurer's disease, which simplifies motivations, adds an interesting detail to the game. But we can supplement it with little touches such as the many different things that might cause this disease. Does the adventurers' red banner affect an adventurer through some sympathetic connection? Or, through the bond between an adventurer and the writings about them on a particular page, could a little “fiery” ink—containing carbon?—exert an influence?
Of course, many more things could be added, but I think this little connection is interesting in several respects, and could even be of decisive importance in a story. We will return to it.