Witch1One of the most typical complaints you hear from quite a few game masters is that whenever a female NPC enters the game, the party immediately suspects she is a witch, which is hardly realistic. There are plenty of arguments for why it is not. If nobody in a society even dared speak to a woman because she might be a witch, that society would promptly die out. Fortunately, Ynev has not been completely depopulated yet, and the character's father dared speak to at least one woman too. And then some. But even so, you could still say: yes, but an adventurer is, after all, an adventurer. While nobles marry for political reasons and a peasant has known the peasant girl in question since childhood, an adventurer would mostly have to get acquainted with unfamiliar women. Most adventurers also have money, and their abilities really do make them better targets in a witch's eyes. So the player does have arguments to offer.

Nine out of ten players like this are less suspicious of witches when the game master is a woman too. Partly because they would feel less uncomfortable roleplaying a seduction that way, and partly because a female GM will have plenty of female NPCs: they become a natural part of things, rather than an event that attracts the player's attention. And if a female NPC is already a noteworthy event, and that is another reason the party suspects every one of them, little good will come of introducing such NPCs even less often as a result. That makes it even more conspicuous when you do, your players never learn to handle this special event, and they remain suspicious. Because what the hell reason could the GM have for introducing a female NPC? She is bound to be a witch, and the GM is bound to have some evil plan.

At that point you can argue about how their character would know this and so on, but they are already convinced you are merely defending your plan. What can you do in this situation? For instance, you can deliberately introduce a witch, and deliberately have an evil plan. Only the plan should not be for the characters to sleep with the witch: quite the opposite. Your goal should be to make them suspicious. Feel free to point out that those who always suspect a witch are convinced the pendant around her neck is some sort of witch's amulet too, but how clever they are to have spotted the danger. Aren't you being nice to them? What they fail to notice, however, is that there are witches who would basically be on their side if all that suspicion, all those rejections and so on did not offend them. And a sufficiently offended witch can easily take revenge if the party is certain to need her, and to keep needing her.

Whenever they need a favor, let them hear that they were the ones who did not want a friendly relationship, so from now on it is strictly business. Their jobs will take them places the witch would not even send servants, let alone her lover. And the NPC lover should not have a particularly bad life, even if the party assumes the lover is being exploited a little along the way. Once they have had enough of that side of the torment, move on to the next: word can easily spread that they got into trouble because they are afraid of women. Have someone offer them the city's best male prostitute a few times; at other times let a bard who certainly is not afraid of pretty girls make fools of them in an inn. Shall I keep listing the possibilities? And make the characters work for that loss of reputation.

Feel free to begin an adventure with someone looking for brave adventurers, then have them laugh when the party volunteers: they are looking for genuinely brave adventurers, not people who are afraid even of a young girl. Let the party get a commission elsewhere for a difficult but humiliating adventure. If putting an end to the screwing-over requires the characters to be seen with women, perhaps even known witches, so that the new gossip can defeat the old, sooner or later they will go out with witches too. And if, on precisely that occasion, you do not screw them over because of the witch's alignment, religion and so on, perhaps next time they will approach female NPCs differently—especially if you make a point of emphasizing that roughly half of all NPCs are women. After all, they too are part of life, and therefore of your world and your adventure.

Of course, alongside tormenting them, it is also useful to get them into a debate about witches, ask their opinions, and let people discuss what they have heard and the experiences of those who have been with one. If envy settles the issue, that is fine too. If they learn a thousand and one ways to protect themselves, that is perfect as well. From there, the number of tools is limitless, and it will not be so difficult to break the characters of a habit that does them no favors whatsoever and encourage a little roleplaying.

You can also try inviting someone into the party who will not be afraid of the witch, someone who is in on the plan. Well, if that player gets more XP at the end of the adventure, and the employer rewards them more generously too because they discovered a great deal of important information thanks to not being afraid of the witch, that can certainly help. Sooner or later the players will understand that better roleplaying means more XP. And if they now “always” receive less because they fail to learn even from this example, that can once again be an excellent source of motivation.

If the first tool, on the first occasion, is not enough to stop them playing out their own out-of-character fears instead of their character's fears, you still have plenty of tools up your sleeve. The torment can recur, perhaps with different witches from the same sect. And if there really is no other option, keeping their distance from a witch may even cost a character or two their life. Preferably kill the most suspicious one, and tell the player that in this situation they can rejoin the party with a 1st-level character. Will they call that a shitty thing to do? Perhaps. But when hours invested in numerous NPCs and adventures go to waste because they suspect witches instead of playing their characters, that is no better either.