Alignments and classes are the issues that generate the most arguments about game systems. Many people reject both concepts because they have seen bad and worse examples of them. But what happens if we try to offer a good example? Let us forget the various versions of the "good–bad" axis and the old solutions of "regaining a Willpower point by roleplaying the character's Nature". When discussing adventurer's sickness, we talked about the idea of linking people's personalities to the primal elements. If our world has primal elements and their emotional counterparts, and the structure of the soul is built on them too, we can arrive at a simple alignment. Say, ten points divided among the four primal elements, with certain behaviours and perhaps a few restrictions tied to the individual alignment levels. Lo and behold, we see a new picture. And quite a few different alignments.
Alongside a hermetic view of the world like this, there is another, more mystical approach to alignment: the horoscope. In a fantasy world, of course, different constellations and planets, a different number of moons and many other little things make it fundamentally different from its earthly equivalent. Also because, in a fantasy world, it operates on a completely different basis. No, I do not believe in horoscopes. I do believe, however, that they were not invented entirely without foundation, even if all sorts of nonsense were put behind them. The month in which a child was born or conceived could fundamentally affect many of their characteristics even on Earth, depending on a few other factors.
Suppose there were two children. One was born at the time of year when almost every other child in the village was born. They grew up together. Their parents were decent, hardworking people, like everyone else. The other child was conceived at a different time, when decent, hardworking people would have had little energy left to try. So this child could have grown up among children a few months older or a few months younger. They were more likely to be allowed among the older ones. Even then, though, only cautiously, partly because of superstitions and partly because of rumours about their parents. Among children, already ruthlessly honest, this could easily lead to teasing; the vulnerable child became a victim of bullying too. On top of that came what their environment gave them and what they inherited from their parents.
The child heard plenty of rumours too; placebo and nocebo effects were at work. Predictions also influenced other people's behaviour, so many self-fulfilling prophecies led to ever more mutually reinforcing observations. It was not hard to associate these with constellations. The horoscope promptly appeared. If the connection was often observed in general but there were subtler situations, then it was logical to think in terms of a more nuanced picture. Astrology could thus provide a nuanced, multidimensional description of personality. Now imagine it in a world where the issue is not misinterpreting characteristics observed in connection with someone's time of birth, but where astronomical conjunctions really do have effects, determining a character's personality, talents, magical abilities or anything else.
The idea immediately suggests itself that characters can be divided into complementary classes not only by training, but also by horoscope. And what if the resulting talents determine skill costs, granting smaller or larger discounts, while a school may grant similar discounts too? That is another interesting possibility. Lo and behold, something new has taken over the roles of alignment and the class system. Naturally, we can also say that if the horoscope affects behaviour and talents, talent and the daily routine arising from behaviour together determine the character's abilities, and the horoscope can also describe how those abilities are maintained.
For instance, a connection to a particular zodiac sign and the divine will behind it describes physical attributes because a planet was in that sign, while another describes mental attributes, and so on. We can even play with the idea that, when stars and planets are suitably aligned, a "superhuman" attribute—a stronger-than-usual connection—can mean a different race. Lo and behold, a detailed horoscope describes most of the character sheet, and the character may be motivated to maintain or strengthen some of the connections that give them power. But what if they take up something new? Then they bring another connection to the fore, strengthening one and weakening another. We can even decide how much, how and how quickly a character can change such connections during play. This system can be sufficiently open while still fulfilling certain aims of class and alignment systems.
We might also say that the character is not doing things associated with their alignment for the first or second time; they have more practice at them, and so receive some modifier based on their alignment or horoscope. In the system proposed earlier, for example, both this alignment-related routine and the general knowledge belonging to a culture could function as skills. Even a player motivated by powergaming would think about how to connect their actions to their alignment, cultural ties and so on, philosophising if necessary or making the connection directly. Not because roleplaying comes naturally to them, but because they hope for two extra dice.
Alignment can thus be multidimensional, and nuanced alignments and the cultures built on them can provide the foundations of a colourful world. This is hardly unprecedented, even among roleplaying settings, and the worlds of many literary and cinematic works are diverse too. We could say that M.A.G.U.S. fans in the Hungarian market also love a colourful vision of the world, but the fact remains that most of its creators do not share that vision, while those who endorse it have only hinted at it, so few people know that playing on this basis is possible. In the history of AD&D and D&D, Planescape was special in terms of alignment. The Harmonium pointed in one direction through most of its actions, many of its proclaimed principles and its planar allegiance, but its intolerance and other actions sent it slipping in another direction, taking its home territory on the Outer Planes with it.
In each case, moving away from the good/evil axis was the key moment. Many different alignment concepts can also be combined. Horoscope-based and primal-element-based alignments can define different aspects of a character's behaviour and determine talent or lack of talent in different things. If you describe this well and put astrological and alchemical diagrams and illustrations alongside the numbers, expressing the same things, the distinctive character sheet already conveys some atmosphere about the character. When building a game, thinking about how to fit familiar templates together is not necessarily enough. It is worth considering what else can be used, and how.