Whether Krán, Gorvik and so on are evil can make for interesting arguments. With Krán, of course, the question arises: whose vision of Krán are we looking at, and from when? The differences have far-reaching implications, and not only the visible differences matter, but their causes too. Alignment is a perennial subject in the history of roleplaying games. Or, to put it another way, alignment and what lies behind it. Behind alignment is a set of values against which alignment itself is judged. Those values are based on experience and knowledge—knowledge that differs in a fantasy world from that on Earth. At the same time, a value system is not necessarily sincere. Many political systems have established values to serve their own purposes. Judging things against a yardstick distorted in this way is difficult.
Is it a universal value that killing is wrong? And when someone today argues, on the basis of the right to human dignity, for the right to euthanasia and for those who would choose active euthanasia, is that wrong too? How evil of them not to throw away human dignity for the sake of a life that no longer offers anything good to the person concerned, those around them or the world, when we say human life is a universal value! Put that way, whether a universal value system exists is no longer obvious, is it? Fundamentally, two positions are possible here.
- Many M.A.G.U.S. creators, the majority of its writers, have declared that because Ynev is fantasy, divine laws and a universal value system can exist.
- Several other M.A.G.U.S. creators, however, would start from the position that known reincarnation, contradictory divine laws and the fundamentally different ways of thinking of multiple races make a universal value system even less possible in that fantasy world. This is also why M.A.G.U.S. uses "Life and Death" rather than "good and evil" in its alignment system.
Hang on! These approaches differ so much that it is impossible to reach the same result from both. Under the first, we designate a universal value system; Krán deviates from it and is evil. Under the second, the position that "Krán is not evil, but alien" works—a position associated primarily, and not without reason, with Nyul's work.
In this view, the basic feature of Krán's values is that its people think over a bloody long timescale. They never look at the body's immediate happiness, but at the long-term development of the soul and the world, approaching this on the principle that the end justifies the means. In the long run, they want good. If, however, they think your soul would now benefit from a quick rebirth, and that your long life would obstruct both the world and all your own future lives, then they would consider it a very great sin to be selfish and fail to give you the gift of another life.
Even when a Kránian kills in Ranagol's name, they offer the life and its extinguishing to Ranagol, never the soul. They would not interfere with the eternal cycle. If you do, there is a good chance you are making such a grave mistake and transgressing so badly against the will of those more exalted than you that a few well-meaning Kránians will do everything possible to ensure you get your new life as soon as possible—one in which you will not make such a great mistake... Before it gets you into worse trouble. Few things matter more to Ranagol than the eternal cycle and the development and renewal it brings.
If a country's continued flourishing is bad for the souls of its inhabitants and for Ynev, while renewal after its destruction would be beneficial, Krán is not selfish. Because of that good aim and its neutrality in many other respects, Krán could accept anyone, and can envisage many other faiths subordinated to Ranagol's. Indeed: "Ranagol rules over a god less exalted than himself, but that god still usually stands above you. Very few gods are so unexalted that they do not."
In this approach, when Mogorva Chei defeated one of the Thirteen, he proved not only his own exalted status, but Arel's exalted status and equality too. It is no accident that Yllinor is treated very differently from the outside world. Krán's secrets turning up there? Natural. Something reaching Toron? They stop it, and not peacefully. This is another reason the Law of Change matters.
And yes, Arel and her followers were singled out because written law is unimportant to them too: things are judged by their actual effects. A brave priest of Arel would also sacrifice their life for a longer-term good. They get involved in plenty of trouble and focus on development. A good follower of Arel wants to overcome obstacles, including their own limitations. Renewal applies here too. Indeed, so does the idea that destruction precedes renewal: sometimes something in a forest must perish so that the forest itself can renew and survive. The cycle exists here too. Only the timescales differ, as do the importance of empathy and the guidance given.
Of course, some Kránians argue that, for an individual, various forms of education can offer alternatives to a new life, and this can lead to arguments. The Life alignment is rare, but not unheard of. In Messen it is possible even for an assassin.
The picture is further complicated by the fact that most Kránians have no need in their lives to understand the lofty principles. If told to kill someone, they kill them. Amoral but dutiful. The country's aim is constant change, evolution and development... In this they are close to Chaos. Yet absolute, unconditional loyalty is also expected: Order. What is a mortel with the Death and Order alignments, fighting for good aims they know nothing about? Good or evil? It is not clear. But most of the world considers Krán evil because of people like these.
Even if we see the noble and good purpose behind Krán's aims, what would we say about a Kránian who does not see it, but enjoys killing and cruelty and can hardly wait for permission to indulge those pleasures? By the time they get to kill, the order has passed through numerous people who do not grasp its real purpose. And how many Kránian provinces are trying this? Surely it is no surprise that Krán is in conflict with some of its own provinces at the end of the Manifestation War? Nor that it is primarily the more exalted, who understand the aims, who have a chance of victory with Ranagol's support.
Although Shadon appears good on the surface and talks of good morals, its people themselves know that Domvik cannot be the one true god. When the internal Inquisition was first mentioned, it was also stated that they knew this perfectly well there. If much of their faith is false, true faith cannot be the measure of a priest's vocation either. And if those priests persecute supposed or actual heretics—including followers of genuinely good gods—for political interests too, and offer the SOULS of victims sent to the stake to a not entirely real god, a soul-sacrifice behind a false faith, tearing them out of the eternal cycle...
Many see Shadon through the teachings of peaceful priests who preach the sanctity of life while following the principle of "drinking wine and preaching water", and many of the people who take those teachings seriously may indeed be good. They do not know that Shadon's apple is rotten beneath the skin... I do not believe Nyul, who wrote Southern Ynev back then, would call that good. Especially given the links between Shadon and the Grey Hoods: although they are milder than the Cobras, they too have committed robbery-murders and kidnappings.
On this basis, however bad Shadon may be, you need not fear an average Shadonian. Because the principles they have learned would make them peaceful and unwilling to kill. That those principles rest on a lie does not affect their character or behaviour. A Kránian, on the other hand, is worth fearing. Even an exalted Kránian, because good intentions will not make them any less ruthless. They do not want to kill you; they even like you. But they see that, if you keep making mistakes, you will suffer in every subsequent life. In that situation, they must help. They can set aside their feelings—that is what they were trained to do—so liking or even loving you counts for nothing. Neither does astral magic. You can beg for mercy all you like: precisely because they want what is good for you, no empathy will divert them from their aim. And turning your back on an assassin living in Yllinor and praying to Arel is not healthy either.
The positions of Krán, Yllinor and Shadon now become interesting, without invoking a good–evil axis or even the bad–worse axis sometimes offered as its alternative. Instead, the choice is between a ruthless truth based on long-term considerations and a merciful lie looking to your short-term interests. At least if we leave out the possibility of being burned at the stake: include that, and things become much worse, as they do with certain leaders. But that is not the defining feature.
Gorvik's Shadonian roots matter. The original ideas that "Domvik created humanity in his own image", that the foreigner is a monster and may be a heretic, and so on are still there. That distrust can matter later, as can the importance of the church, on which their religiosity rests. Add to that a rather temperamental people who are a law unto themselves. But the Blood Brotherhood's Niarei martial art, acquired "through Enosuke", came from the Cobras' people who were present at Gorvik's birth: something had to be done against the Grey Hoods. Their relationship with Shadon therefore matters.
Krán was there. So were many others. And Gorvik wants to adopt many things from here and there. That is why it was interesting that the original system placed the first assassin clan here. Orders older than this became assassin clans, rather than other kinds of orders, only by adopting the new doctrine developed here. Gorvik, however, mostly copies without understanding, because it does not truly take things in. The local Ranagol faith therefore fits within Ranagol's amorality, but is not based on a thorough understanding of the religion's principles. Gorvikians vary greatly too. They vary, but have some common features.
They too follow Ranagol and can understand everything a Kránian can. Among them are people who, hearing what was said here about Yllinor, would immediately declare: "I like the new Goddess too, and if Ranagol encourages us to surpass him, then precisely such a goddess is a good ally for the task; she is the one to pray to"... You would not call that person evil, strange though this dual faith is. But you would do well not to turn your back on them—and to grow another pair of eyes in the back of your head... Because they may have conspired with a few Yllinorian friends, assassin-looking types. Such people, though, are as rare as white ravens.
Yes, Gorvikians are a temperamental, stubborn, proud people, so that sympathy could exist. But the church is an important centre of power in Gorvik, and most Gorvikians are too proud to listen to news of foreign gods' faiths and exalted status. We might say that reaching this point is extraordinarily rare: perhaps 0.01% or 0.005%. But Gorvik is large enough that you can still meet such characters. And they too will possess Gorvikian fire and audacity, and their tongues will certainly be sharp. They often use those sharp tongues to strike up a conversation with the target, though; afterwards they will be on good terms.
But some are just as guilty of simony as many Shadonian priests, just as full of underworld connections, knowing their faith is crooked but that soul-sacrifice is the way to retain power. Gorvik is thus heterogeneous, but more human than Krán. Yet the greater prevalence of human frailty also makes it more evil. And I would venture to suggest that precisely this situation produces influential Gorvikians who defy the church's power and form a counterweight. This duality matters too.
So does the fact that these Gorvikians, often considered xenophobic, trade for a variety of luxury goods. Although most Gorvikians think little of foreigners arriving in their trading ports, perhaps of other races, they know exactly whose interests are served by trading with them. They know whom to leave alone and why. And they know what happens to those who do not. That gives us a slightly more colourful picture here too, even without going into many other details. But trade is only one of the peculiarities.
Gorvik's relationships with family, love and war are just as peculiar. Serious internal and external conflicts kill many people, and only substantial population growth compensates for that. Since a significant proportion of the men are destined to die, many Gorvikian men keep mistresses too. Thus every woman can bear children. Loyalty to the family means unconditional devotion, but not strict monogamy. And if Ranagol himself enjoys causing pain, and so many Gorvikian men know that "this distracts a witch from her dangerous practices", then some pain occasionally enters Gorvikian lovemaking, yet they are legendarily good lovers. Another duality contributing to a nuanced character.
But family does not always mean blood relations, and almost never means only the immediate family. Gorvik too has "honour children", whom a family's conquerors, or others who gain ascendancy over them, take into their own family. Such an adopted family member is loyal to the new family too. It is extremely rare, but not unheard of, for foreigners who have proved their exalted status to acquire a few Gorvikian family members by knowing this custom. They say Gorvikian servants are relatively cheap in Erion's slave market because they would readily slit their new master's throat. After all, slavery would deprive them of the chance to develop, rise and become exalted. That would cause problems in every future life; it is worse even than death.
But what if they come into the hands of someone who gives them a "new, free life", is exalted themselves and takes them in as an honour child? The Gorvikian is at once audacious, temperamental and loyal... And as unreliable as they may be to others, as readily as they would stab anyone else in the back, they would just as readily walk through fire for their new family. This attitude to loyalty is so deeply ingrained in Gorvikians' characters that it remains even in those who convert to another faith during their lives. The attachment can sometimes be a burden. Show a Gorvikian the door and you had better close the window, because they will already be climbing back in. This remains true even if they are the entirely positive hero of your story. And it can even override their racism.
Gorvikians are also exceptionally good at dissembling. If one has a foreign family in this way—even of another race—they will play the classic racist Gorvikian perfectly to infiltrate the enemy's ranks. "Then somehow they will stab a few people" who would hurt their family.
So far I have mentioned four countries: Krán, Yllinor, Shadon and Gorvik... This fine pentagon would be incomplete without Pyarron. But detailing Pyarron's position here would be unnecessary. It is enough to say that two of the five countries advocate consciously adopting many values: Krán and Pyarron. Gorvik and Yllinor adopt things beneath the surface; Shadon rejects them as heresy. Two are defined by audacity and stubbornness: Gorvik and Yllinor. Pyarron and Shadon have courage too, but Kránians are too cold and calculating for this. Two are exclusionary, for example because foreigners are heretics too: Gorvik and Shadon. Yet Yllinor's pure Arel faith and Krán's Ranagol faith are not all that open either; Pyarron is. Two would look evil at first glance: Gorvik and Krán. But you could also object to the Shadon-centred underworld and Arel's priests' underworld connections; Pyarron stands against them. Two are defined by written laws resting on moral foundations that can be considered good: Shadon and Pyarron. Gorvik's and Krán's internal laws have alien morals behind them, but morals nonetheless. Yllinor, however, does not merely talk about changing laws: the "Word in the book" in the Ballad of Things Not to Be Tolerated also refers to written law of this kind.
The two visions of the world work completely differently in play. If we think in terms of universal good and universal evil, use this to guide characters, and dislike overly deep philosophical debate undermining the system's foundations, then arguing about magical theory, cosmology or the structure of matter is completely and utterly pointless. These things do not matter in simple little adventures. If we are talking about the latter vision, however, characters can be curious about the world, its magical and natural laws and its deeper connections. All of this becomes part of play, and many small errors can become irritating bloody quickly.
It was precisely this latter direction that made M.A.G.U.S. more than the average fantasy game. And although Planescape for AD&D originally looked in this direction too, D&D 3 and later editions simplified things again. Many other games simplify too. We will discuss that simplification in another article.