Some players swear they are no powergamers. They merely want a system allowing effective, powerful builds. If only values above 14 grant modifiers, then although the system calls 10 average, they describe average as perhaps 8–13 and expect standard point allocation to yield an average of 13 for them. Yet they also want to argue that “even 8 is average; surely a basic task must succeed with it.” We know the problem well. We can argue which came first, chicken or egg: did the system first give them poor reference points, or did they first seek an overpowered character? It varies. But a somewhat firmer foundation would help.
“A giant's disadvantages are not fitting into many places and people often refusing to speak to them.” But if one is in the party, the GM runs things so the first problem never appears. And if a player cannot contribute to social situations, let us get to what works as soon as possible: combat, where strength, plentiful hit points, and so forth immediately come into play. The theoretical disadvantages and balance disappear in practice.
What? Wizard school requires passing a history exam before learning spells? Then give us an unrestricted point system where we need not take it. In roleplaying, a wizard is balanced only if they also portray the school's constraints in behavior and character, and take every skill expected there but useless in play. They evade both by invoking twists in their character's life, immediately gaining substantial advantages. How nice that deviating from these things carries no numerical penalty. Even assuming they do not really intend to exploit these demanded advantages and are no munchkin, allowing this attitude undermines the game at five or six points. If you do not allow it, however, whining that the system lacks freedom is almost certain.
But character creation fundamentally offers several solutions, not merely the two people discuss. Let us examine known methods of defining characters' abilities:
Rolling
A familiar method. It grants players little freedom and is often paired with classes and so forth. Traditional, but not universally liked for good reason; most of its advantages can be reproduced otherwise without difficulty. It matters, however, that rolling itself takes several forms. In M.A.G.U.S., class-dependent rolls ensure the character can be a viable representative of the envisioned profession. AD&D also allowed rolled values to be assigned to attributes afterward. The myth of “a character completely ruined by one roll” is often false when values are interpreted correctly. But this is not ideal for a life-path campaign with the character we envision.Even that flaw is easily bridged: roll many characters and pair the envisioned background with suitable rolled values. Play that one. If a character does not appear first time, they may appear second time. A character who emerges rarely and with difficulty, whose equivalent would be hard to replace, is more precious to us, encouraging more realistic portrayal of their sense of danger. The solution also simulates chance and guides players short on ideas. It is quick and requires little calculation.
Fixed Point Buy
Another familiar method with familiar limitations. If something cannot be made today, it will not fit the same points tomorrow either. This genuinely destroys many plausible, good character concepts permanently, making it worse in that respect even than basic rolling. In exchange, there are powerful builds. What worked once works again, so players value the character less. It offers beginners little guidance or inspiration. Meanwhile, it takes more time and calculation. Many uninteresting concepts, however, always fit; unexpected obstacles never need to be overcome, and no randomly poor attributes enrich play.Someone wanting a powerful character appreciates such a system for advice-based, endlessly reproducible builds and the many characters based on them. They do not feel excessive rules or randomness have obstructed their plans. This is a benefit to them, and they can complain at length about rolling or other solutions if their builds disappear. Point buy is therefore a good, diplomatic decision when dealing with them. The solution usually extends beyond attributes.
Variable Point Buy
Many designers have observed that a point total suitable for one party concept may be unsuitable for another. Miraculously, different totals and tables can suit different situations. Yet many characters fall “between two categories”: too few points in one, too many in another. Powerful builds and other difficulties remain. Fortunately, in Shadowrun third edition these are merely recommended values, requiring no absolute precision. There are also many relatively simple advantages and disadvantages that affect the character less, such as individual contacts.Many limitations of point-buy systems have been more or less repaired. In exchange, creating characters in advance is not straightforward, since you do not know the available points. Character creation can therefore consume play time. With strangers, of course, many choose a standard “average value.” Many other point-buy disadvantages—builds, less-valued characters—remain.
Multiple Point Pools
Simple point-buy solutions quickly emerged: “Buy at character creation what you cannot acquire later, or what costs more later. Do not buy things that improve quickly. Explain the character's few skills with descriptions like inexperienced or trained somewhere isolated. Initially, play so adventures concern relatively safe discovery of new things. There is your powerful character.” Developers decided this would not do. Let there be separate points for attributes, professional skills, hobbies... Attributes themselves can have categories too. Many things are divided up.Point buy's advantages and disadvantages apparently remain, except that often even fewer kinds of character fit. If they do not fit, they never will. Again, some systems allow tricks, such as languages and a few details in Shadowrun. Others forbid them in the name of balance. The promised balance then fails anyway because designers could not know how often each skill or ability would prove extremely useful in our adventure. They did not know its contents when creating the system either.
Priorities
From Shadowrun to Storyteller. Say where the character is strong, and receive different point pools accordingly. Designers tried to eliminate many earlier point-buy flaws. But the system becomes more complicated, and fitting every point and priority allocation to the envisioned character becomes harder. The idea initially seemed good, but many things soon proved impossible. Then they changed it, or did not. Yes: Shadowrun acquired a different point-buy method. Vampire acquired Age: something bought for a few points that granted several times as many.Many good characters still cannot be made. Point to familiar people and the relevant scale, and the answer is that World of Darkness is not Earth. An atmospheric background built on many ideas from that world? It does not fit, but remember the system began from earthly reality, so discuss anything different with the GM. Very few GMs say they can implement and handle such characters. Fewer succeed. Yet many fanboys insist, whichever edition you choose, that the limitation exists only there and another works. Encounter that one's limitation, and the same happens again. You can go through them all. Someone who distributes points approximately and does not mind a somewhat one-dimensional character functions without difficulty. If they also believe this represents quality roleplaying and receive a few source works, they defend that approach everywhere.
Customization
I could cite Shadowrun archetypes, but more importantly most free introductory packages contain sample characters. Give these a few selectable attributes, items, and so forth, and we obtain a system supporting barely a few character types... But it is quick, provides good guidance, and makes balance easier. A worthwhile new system benefits from kits allowing quick trials of the game, where this character-creation method can be selected. If the system supports it, having some options alter attributes helps too.Browsing the tabs above shows many widespread methods. Most have well-known advantages and disadvantages. None is ideal or guarantees balance or enough creation freedom to accommodate every character faithful to the world. If most primarily create obstacles, why choose the system over freeform? I venture to note that most beginners today start roleplaying on forums without a game system. Others begin with MMOs or CRPGs. Claiming we are better than system X means nothing to them. We must be better than the games they already play. These disadvantages and obstacles may even deter beginners. But let us consider what else occurs to me among less familiar or widespread methods:
Point-Buy Ranges
If we do not specify how many points to distribute, but allow free allocation and then rate the character's strength by the total spent, perhaps even giving their “level,” the result immediately changes. Most characters can be legal regardless of point total, provided they are consistent. Naturally, the game master will not necessarily admit every level and will often require a background. Initially the solution seems good. Former freeform players lose less freedom and gain some guidance. Since there is no need to test multiple ways of fitting things into a point budget, time is less problematic than with earlier point-buy methods. And without a need to optimize, recurring builds will not be the natural outcome.But this still offers little guidance and extra work. And the game master will decide by reviewing the character anyway, not by the resulting score...
Discussion
In most systemless freeform play, character creation consists of discussing the character. Adopting this directly while using a system to describe abilities precisely, making everyone's work easier, with optional dice rolls for many situations, is good. Dice can even add excitement, and the result offers several extras over a wholly systemless game. All right... Forum players may prefer a forum service installed together with the setting and rules over a PDF, unless we want to seat them around a table at “meetups” and demonstrate how efficiently adventures work this way...But our system then lacks one advantage of shared rules, the theoretical possibility of portability. That can be changed, though.
Rating
Rating is simple: we state what each attribute value means, allowing players to describe their envisioned characters. Since it means the same in every group, and numbers make deciding whether a character fits easier, we have a sufficiently free system with some guidance. It is quick and portable. It promises no balance, but other systems cannot deliver that either. This could be called “completely free character creation,” except that as long as players choose among listed special abilities and skills, and the attribute divisions reflect a prescribed concept, even generously speaking this freedom is incomplete. Yet it is much greater than point buy offers.Roll or Choose
Rating is all very well, but what if a player has no ideas? “Ask someone,” “borrow ideas,” and so forth are not system-level solutions. Dice rolls designed to balance “realism”—lower standard deviation—against interesting characters—higher standard deviation—would be useful guidance. But we already know what rolling takes away. Enter roll or choose. A good game master will hardly permit “copy a build,” making the same thing twice, but freedom remains and the dice provide a useful crutch.Choose or Roll
The difference between “roll or choose” and “choose or roll” is mainly psychological. Most GMs who view choosing as an alternative to rolling tend to restrict it. Where choosing is primary and rolling merely an option for uncertainty, choosing is more readily accepted as the default. This matters. The GM can avoid resorting to rolling by offering suitable advice and supporting the player's decision. In my view, choose or roll, using the scale and considered selection process described under Rating, is sufficiently free and relatively strong in many other respects.1:n
We would not recommend it to players, but it is interesting for NPCs. Why unsuitable for PCs? Because it requires calculation, multiplication, and small conditions. Describe how common each attribute is, consider how many people there are per baker or guard, what abilities they need, and in which others they will be relatively good... You can immediately create a more realistic NPC. This requires the system to describe frequencies and provide many reference points.Many systems have flirted with these directions, without necessarily following them through, leaving them relatively rare and interesting. But so far we have still been thinking within the triangle of “dice, free choice, or mathematics.” Many other tools now exist: not only tablets and phones, but more traditional solutions too. And somewhat trickier ones:
Fortune-Telling
Imagine a simple card reading. Alongside a prediction read aloud by the GM, you receive attribute modifiers relative to basic character templates. Fortune-telling is more interactive, where a set of cards appears matters, and it is atmospheric too. An interesting alternative to sample characters and customization, especially one of the best alternatives to customization or simplified creation in free introductory packages.Cards
There is no real character sheet. Instead, many cards specify how well the character would perform in particular respects at this moment. Replace a few cards in the deck, and your wizard now displays brilliance less often and strength more often... Skills follow an old-school approach: rather than appearing on a sheet, anything is possible if the player can explain how the character does it while respecting the world's reality. Another alternative immediately emerges...Collectible...
Cards can be collectible, or we can have ability dice selected according to different rules. Different strength dice alter not only Strength's value but the variation in performance. The publisher makes a fortune while players spend every last penny on special dice. And little Stevie is so excited opening boosters...Questionnaire
Answer a series of questions, perhaps with branches. Your answers, and therefore your background, determine where and how far you differ from the average person who studied alongside you and received the same training. If much of the world's education is fairly standardized and a few dozen questions can account for every difference, you immediately have a good core system.Interactive
Smartphones, tablets, and computers exist. Who cares if character creation requires calculations? Players can express their ideas in many ways while the app handles rules and plausibility. Many methods and algorithms are possible, but computational demands, complexity, and plentiful data are no obstacle. Even a small random element prevents many identical builds while preserving considerable freedom. The precise conditions and algorithms are difficult to evaluate collectively.Fate Line
The turning points defining the character's life are established: how talented they are at birth, what school they enter, and so on. Positive turns cost points; many negative ones may grant a few. How much you spend on background and how much on influencing events during the life-path campaign is up to you. You can earn such points during play too. There are not too many points or unrealistically purchased outcomes; the scale described under Rating can underpin it...Blank Sheet
The character sheet has one kind of point, unspent in advance. You spend it whenever you want to use an ability, declaring, “My character has this.” Pay the points and you can use it from then on. You can begin immediately, with considerable freedom. Since you can earn identical points during play, “the sky is the limit.” You do not waste points on unnecessary things, and can declare later that “I already had these,” briefly explaining and justifying their origin. If, however, you lack points for something that arises during play, record that your character did not know it at that time. To buy it later, you must explain when after that moment the character had time and opportunity to learn the ability or skill, or improve that attribute. Spending adapts to the adventure while building on background and personality. Nothing is forgotten. Too many points, too few, or “I forgot something” create no obstacle. The GM should nevertheless explain beforehand what kinds of characters to envisage.As you see, there are many solutions. Whether classes, schools, skill packages, or skill prerequisites exist depends partly on the world and partly on the core system selected above. Rolling benefits from classes and class-dependent rolls. Such things would be pointless with the blank-sheet method, which instead needs more skills, sometimes with prerequisites and training times. The fate-line method builds more on schools. A creation system modifying sample characters works best with archetypes, allowing the GM to define new ones easily; creating those can use another “character creation” system. The possibilities are endless. “Classes and rolling” versus point allocation are not the only two choices.