The hangman gets hanged. Criticising and tinkering with someone else's game system is always easier than creating your own. But how do we begin? With a few basic premises and goals, say. Some are self-evident, such as higher values being better—in AD&D, lower was better for AC, THAC0 and saving throws. Others are less obvious, such as a human attribute maximum of 20 rather than AD&D's 18, with an average of 10. And some are a little surprising: we specify the standard deviation too. Let it be 2, for example. We roll ability checks with two ten-sided dice. But this is precisely where the first twist comes in.

Most people would ask: "Do you have to roll under the attribute, or does it add a modifier to the roll and you roll over a target number?" Anyone somewhat familiar with the history of Hungarian RPGs may remember systems where you had to roll either below your own value—a skill, for instance—or above the difficulty. Both were good; only the middling rolls were bad. Neither approach applies here. Quite the opposite: middling rolls will be "relatively good". The roll tells you how well you would perform...

If that is not enough to overcome the difficulty—you rolled below it—the check fails. Straightforward. After all, the difficulty, or target number if you prefer, tells you how well you need to perform. Your ability, however, tells you your personal maximum. Roll higher than that and "it started well, but you could not see it through", leading to the inevitable failure. But you rarely roll an ability check. Even with an illness, you try to treat yourself and so on, immediately bringing in a skill that helps with the check. You might even drink a medicinal tea that helps your immune system, allowing you to resist the illness better than your normal limits permit: you receive a modifier to your ability. This is already a skill check with some modifiers. 

And if, for some reason, a healer tells you exactly what to do, following their instructions means you use their skill too, indirectly. So this is not even a simple skill check. You might have one skill of your own covering many simple remedies, but there is another skill you use together to help you recover. We do not yet have an ability list, and there need not necessarily be only one kind... But let us assume a typical Health ability for a moment. Make it 10 and the illness's difficulty 2. You have one skill covering a good routine for treating yourself and basic remedies to aid recovery, and the doctor can "lend" you another. Your assorted herbal concoctions raise your Health by two points in this situation. "Healing purrs" are only a placebo for you, but that lovely big cat helps by one point too. 

You start with two dice. You have one die from each ability. You roll four ten-sided dice: 3, 5, 8, 9, and choose the two dice that count. A skill thus means not just a better chance, but some control over your fate. 8 + 5 = 13... Lo and behold, you recover so quickly that people marvel at it. This time, the illness was caused by something that does not want to make you ill; you simply have to adapt to its presence. If the pathogen itself wanted to make you ill, you would roll an opposed check. The disease's Infectiousness attribute would come into play. 

And how do we handle superhuman attributes? A minotaur with Strength 22, for example? It rolls its Strength check with three dice, and can choose whether to keep two or three. A not particularly large dragon with Strength 48 would roll five dice, choosing two, three, four or five of them. A minor skill has less control over strength on that scale. But there are other situations too, such as a footrace. We can specify its difficulty as well. Not that running is generally difficult... But you have to pace yourself, pay attention to optimal breathing and many other little things that matter in elite sport. Including when the adrenaline rush should arrive and how to make the "final sprint". 

The point is that the results of successful rolls tell us how far the character ran in that "round". These results can simply be added together. Whoever would complete the race distance first wins. Failure, if the roll exceeded the attribute, also brings a small fatigue deduction to the character's attribute, but in this case they achieve their own maximum. The game master decides whether this "overperformance" merely causes fatigue, or means "you lifted the weight but dropped it", "you cleared the obstacle but landed badly", "you overcame the illness, but now your overactive immune system causes allergic symptoms", and so on. If the character failed to reach the check's difficulty, they might have stumbled, for example.

Within the core system, difficulties can of course be "embellished further". A check can simultaneously have a conventional difficulty, with appropriate consequences for rolling below it, and the difficulty of an opposed check. In the footrace, we saw a new concept appear alongside the task's difficulty. Let us call it a requirement, which can be fulfilled over several rolls. Spellcasting has both a difficulty and a requirement too. Casting a spell consists of several rolls, and situations may often arise where it must be abandoned before completion. Sometimes each of several casting phases has a separate requirement. 

Many more complex sporting events, combat and so on are sequences of checks in which the requirement also depends on the other side, and the rolls are opposed. The aim is to "wear down the other side's resistance". Once that happens, an opponent can be captured or killed; there is a chance of clean hits. We do not examine minor wounds. If a character is attacked directly and their own resistance is broken, that character can be defeated. If several people protect one another, their collective resistance must be broken. Members of organised groups can also help each other, lending skills or working together to provide modifiers to one another's abilities, or take separate actions. In battles, individual formations support each other according to learned tactics, battle order and so on, so even a larger group can be "treated as a single unit". 

The precise action need not be described. Only which tools and skills the character is prepared to use during it. But if they have already tried to attack with the sword in their right hand, they cannot use that same sword in the same round to defend against someone else or make an additional attack against someone else. The weapons used modify the relevant abilities: the character can reach farther, their hits are more dangerous, and armour helps them withstand blows better. And the equipment determines which skills can be used with the item. The combat situation in turn determines the list of usable skills.

As the above shows, we count the number of skills used. But Basic Mathematical Knowledge can readily be supplemented by Mathematics, then Linear Algebra, Discrete Mathematics,  Probability, or Analysis. Higher-level knowledge is generally specialised, and learning it may often have prerequisites too. The game master decides which skills are usable for which task. There may be cases where a character can attempt a task only if they possess a particular skill. In such cases, that skill does not always also add an extra die to the roll.

If two skills would contribute the same knowledge to a check, with neither adding anything beyond the other, only one can be used. It is advisable, however, to allow skills that represent substantial additional routine and experience: a primary-school mathematics problem rarely challenges a mathematician. 

We have a core system for combat, spellcasting and all kinds of checks. We have not yet dealt with abilities, and there is no skill list, no schools, spells or equipment. Nor character creation, methods of setting difficulties and requirements, minor advantages obtainable in combat, the precise method of spellcasting and so on. Much of this can go into the setting description. Why? Because in one world we want very fast combat, just one round each, and in another longer fights. Different abilities may matter in different worlds.