Article Index

We are used to demographic questions asking our age, where we live, about family, children, and other details. Many know these allow responses to be filtered. I would add that they can filter the questions too. Sorry to return to the topical M.A.G.U.S. questionnaire, but perhaps unfortunately everyone has encountered it. Several kinds of people could speak on the subject: current M.A.G.U.S. players; people playing on Ynev with another system; former players who might return for a better system; readers and fans who would try playing; other roleplayers who hear about the questionnaire; and even people tired of the M.A.G.U.S. wars overwhelming every roleplaying group, who do not want to see it but could be won over by a good system and service. All six groups could complete a good questionnaire. The real one did not consider that. Yet you want to separate their answers, because the larger group is heterogeneous and divisible along many dimensions. When, as a GM, you have PCs complete a questionnaire intending to use their answers later in adventures, asking them to write their names may not occur to you. You can instead ask about traits uniquely identifying the characters.

Suppose the party has two female and three male characters. Your first demographic question asks the character's sex. Lo and behold, among five anonymous forms, one marked male can belong to only three characters. Asking about education eliminates at least one of those three and separates the two women too. Perhaps skin color distinguishes the remaining two men. You retain those five forms separately, while during an investigation they receive about 250 additional generated responses and must work out which belong to the killer and victims. Demographic questions initially help filter by profile. 

Once they know the killer's political leaning, a consistency-check question examining that no longer measures something; it becomes a filter, like a demographic question. In an American setting, for example, they might seek a white, not particularly educated Republican man who, asked what discrimination affects him, probably mentioned the higher price and difficulty of finding large clothes and shoes, since clues suggest a large man. For our bald friend, a shampoo opinion saying only that he does not use shampoo becomes another demographic question.

Questions about regular haunts, organizing activities, and daily routines tell you where you are most likely to find the perpetrator, perhaps to recognize them from a photograph or composite sketch.

You can find common ground in the victims' lives too. Finding it brings you closer to the hunting ground where your suspect operates, making the questionnaire a genuinely useful adventure tool. The party will first smile when their own completed forms also appear in the adventure's database, and again when some answers return two or three, or even four or five adventures later. Perhaps six months later. An answer may enter an adventure's story, or an NPC may produce their questionnaire and approach them because “several questionnaires say you often visit where this happened.” Another investigator finds them just as they once found someone through questionnaires.

If “roleplaying questionnaire” means an in-character questionnaire assembled by an NPC and completed by PCs, an important consideration immediately arises: what you present must be believable. Or sometimes precisely its implausibility matters, since this is Call of Cthulhu. Remember what I wrote on the previous page?

Sol is a scientist and sociologist. Someone suggested his professional analysis “missed” the consistency-check questions, despite their being basic. They warrant attention in two cases: when very bad or very good. “Clever Magnus, smart Magnus, lovely Magnus, he found the A key on the keyboard” is not professional analysis. Leave that fine work to people around the author. Finding the A key is basic too, just like a consistency-check question; praising it is a grossly personal jab.

You are running Call of Cthulhu, perhaps in present-day Hungary, where those M.A.G.U.S. questionnaires exist in the game world. Suppose the party investigates cultists operating among roleplayers, perhaps largely LARPers: first having people act things out, then exploiting what they learned for the game and their opened minds. During the investigation through roleplaying circles, numerous questionnaires first appear and characters complete them. Then one appears where the noteworthy thing is not clever Magnus finding B and C too, but questions allowing means, medians, and standard deviations; demographics; and a few clever interactive questions distinguishing current, former, and potential players. You would immediately ask what replaced this person and look for a suitable monster.

When running horror or writing a comparable story, players must be able to notice changes and unusual things. That includes the questionnaire maker's behavior, but also responses. For people whose answers have recently shifted suspiciously, suggesting possible cultist danger, ask how they answered the basic demographic questions. Where do they live, how old are they, what sex, what income, what education? It becomes easy to identify which factory has something dangerous spreading through it. You filter by answers usually measured, then measure and build statistics and geographical profiles from questions ordinarily used merely as demographic data.

A few skill checks, Know and Idea rolls, and similar things make this approach work too.