The first reason to celebrate is that Solo promised an article on the subject if I did not criticize something he thinks they seriously botched. I have plenty planned on this topic, but criticizing that particular part, in that particular place, is not among my plans. Besides, this subject is at least as much flamebait as D&D 5, the eternally forthcoming new M.A.G.U.S., and Nyarlathotep's relationship to contemporary Hungarian party politics put together. Not because this is another fifth edition, another system notorious in many people's eyes for internal illogic, with gender an equally hot topic for the Brujah and in everyday politics because of the closure of the corresponding degree program. But also because, while half the community rolls on the floor laughing at what utter nonsense this is, that is precisely what makes me ask: are we sure it is nonsense?
I have to say there are at least two ways to read that question. One is that the process of wrecking worlds with continual retcons for SJWs and in the name of political correctness is neatly reflected here, along with certain people's belief that harassment by the Starbucks revolutionary subculture is heroic while dissent is villainous. After all, what kind of thing would it be if the rebel in the game were a cisgender white man and the real, dyed-in-the-wool SJW conflict were left out? But many of the works behind Vampire began as homoerotic for various reasons, so within a work that fits LGBTQ+ propaganda, the rise of the SJW no longer represents such a rupture. All right, I and A follow Q, and a few “activists of pedosexual orientation” speaking at more recent Pride events already tack P onto the abbreviation, but the picture would not be complete without adding N for necrophilia after all those erotic vampire stories. You know, involving the living dead and other sorts. Being an SJW in the name of intersectional feminism fits this context far better than PC retcons affecting Star Wars, Mage, and so forth fit their respective settings.
Is that a virtue, or part of the many problems for which I and plenty of people around me have criticized more than one White Wolf game? Everyone can decide for themselves. Facts are sacred; comment is free. And here, this sort of SJW straining fits the context too.
The Brujah clan's history could be seen in many ways: first sages, then noisy rebels, and now a gender studies crowd. Anyone reacting incredulously, since some of them would have lived through several of these changes, finds it hard to imagine them changing that way. But when scholarship and activism begin to intertwine, as they do for many sociologists, anthropologists, or philosophers, a process begins. Yes, that is also why V5 could throw in the reference to sociologists: the process is quite old. Through activism, however, the person becomes involved; their own opinions and preconceptions emerge, and at that point scholarly objectivity starts to disappear.
That process eventually makes the more militant rebel valuable instead of the sage. But as the struggle increasingly reveals that they are not actually right, initially they only need to ignore the facts, while compensating more and more and becoming more militant. Eventually that stops helping too, and satisfying the resulting addiction no longer provides even occasional relief from stress and frustration. Better self-justification is needed, a new source to feed self-esteem. Pseudoscience appears, along with speculation about it. A circle emerges for whom researching gender through various scholarly disciplines is insufficient, because objectivity refutes them too often. They need something where a preconception can be passed off as knowledge, counterarguments can be met with accusations, and everything that makes ideologically driven pseudoscience ideologically driven pseudoscience can flourish.
The professional rebel, who does not care what the revolution is about so long as there is one, readily rides this trend. Whether they used to be a revolutionary thinker or a thug. And the new form of rebellion, shaking one's tits, is a fairly workable alternative too. Provided there is a Tzimisce nearby to help surgically alter whoever needs altering.
But we often say of gender too that bias and militant statements are about someone compensating for something. The rainbow-colored gender studies Brujah is in much the same position as PRIDE marchers. Not merely because of vampire stories' homoerotic overtones, but because they must compensate ever more loudly and militantly to convince themselves their life is complete, even while knowing their own choice has put some things beyond reach. When you have to shout down your own doubts, the result is loud overcompensation.
When gay men, lesbians, and heterosexuals together say there is the normal homosexual, who does not compensate or shock but lives as we do and goes unnoticed, and then there is the aggressive, constantly compensating faggot with something wrong, who is the one marching rather than Józsi and his Béla, we understand that overcompensation lies behind gender and many other small things. And compensation is precisely the answer to the problem of someone highly talented in many respects becoming a vampire at the bottom of society, with nowhere to go but further down and more to lose every year.
The Brujah compensates specifically by joining whatever struggle is current, alongside mortals who overcompensate just as they do. Just as it was natural for the rebellious crowd to follow the current rebellion before, they have done so again. Now they are happy. Because the rebellion's subject now concerns sexuality, roles in society, and many other things that mirror their own problems and rebellion. This is much more their own. But there is something else. A vampire has no way forward. Explaining that lack of advancement through issues of sexuality is a much more pleasant prospect than admitting that their pointed teeth and many decisions are the reason.
This is an important aspect of the personal horror of vampirism, present every minute yet denied by the vampire. Every clan seeks a different way to deny it, teaching a different method by which a vampire can try to deceive themselves. No, John, you are not failing to advance professionally or realize your dreams because you are a vampire. It is because you too contain the natural female role, and that fucking patriarchy stands in your way. If pay scales are fixed and depend on position and length of service, let the source of your problem be that the lower average wages caused by a lower retirement age are not compensated with some humiliating pussy allowance. That is the problem, not that as a vampire you do not publish, do not attend conferences, and have no chance after your own decision and the celebrated Embrace. The pussy allowance will solve everything: off you go to shake your tits naked outside your favorite Starbucks. And if not, tomorrow there will be a new, even more comfortable and softer rebellion, bringing yet another promise and scapegoat for the entire clan to ride.
This is precisely where it connects well with the source material, the homoerotic content of many vampire stories, and the fact that vampires have already lost most of what can make heterosexuality important in life. V5 may have many faults, but they got this one thing right, perhaps against their own intentions.
And how splendid it will look when the gender-Brujah character protesting naked appears at a Vampire LARP. The neighborhood's residents will be wonderfully entertained...