Not interested in M.A.G.U.S., and would rather read about any other roleplaying game? Never mind. Delta Vision managed to make the forthcoming new M.A.G.U.S. a topic even in many D&D groups. And the fact that everyone is making a new M.A.G.U.S. Or rather, nobody is. We are, and have been, involved in that a little. To this day I do not know whether the official project's questionnaires are deliberately bad and we are witnessing brilliant trolling, or whether they simply turned out that way. They did achieve one thing, though. We discussed their flaws and our experiences in far more places than if the news had merely been that there was yet another M.A.G.U.S. project. Number n+1.

It is no secret: I said perhaps a thousand times about D&D Next that the last straw, or the straw after the last, was the final playtest's approach to racial modifiers, described as final at the time but ultimately not final. We can have a perfectly good debate about why that problem bothers me or does not bother someone else. Those saying the system is setting-independent and magic is not alien to dwarves everywhere probably hold part of the truth. The other part is my point: if it is setting-independent, these races and spells do not exist everywhere. The equipment in the PHB is not typical everywhere, especially at similar prices. A race does not see exactly as far in darkness everywhere or have the same typical height. We could list countless other examples. 

If there is anything familiar from Hungarian politics and public life, it is the Double Standard. In one case we judge by setting independence; in another, we do not. We forgive something in one system but not another. We tend to argue forever and beyond about exactly how large that straw after the last was, forgetting the many larger and more important things that had already filled the glass. Arguments around the new M.A.G.U.S. were not really about the new M.A.G.U.S. at all. Most people do not even believe it will ever be finished. 

These arguments concerned things never properly discussed. The d20 has been there since D&D's first edition. More precisely, 1d20: a discrete uniform distribution. M.A.G.U.S.'s k100 is the same with finer resolution and slightly rarer extremes, perhaps making it less prone to turning a story into farce through “five extreme results in thirty seconds.” But we cannot criticize D&D for this, because it is the world's best-known system. The country's best-known system, however, can be called every name under the sun for a less severe version of the same flaw. Yet criticism of the discrete uniform distribution is also criticism of D&D. 

It leads necessarily and directly to my first and greatest disappointment with D&D Next. Discussing modifiers and clever rolls, the lead designer talked extensively about equal expected values, treating many things as equivalent regardless of how they changed that value. Distribution, frequency of extreme situations, how predictable combat was for the DM in each case, and many other considerations were omitted. Mathematics was omitted.

Game balance is a recurring concern in system design. It means two characters can influence the outcome of play equally overall. That depends on two things: how useful their abilities are, and how often they can use them. Nobody can accuse me of supporting D&D uncritically against M.A.G.U.S. But I have never seen a worse solution than M.A.G.U.S.'s Új Törvénykönyv, and I know it results from designers' shortsightedness. D&D 5 does not make even a tenth as large a mistake in the same area. That does not mean either that D&D's mistake is acceptable or that no better solution than D&D 5 exists. If one does, and there is a group for it, we have no reason to play D&D 5.

The forthcoming new M.A.G.U.S., almost any D&D edition, CODEX, Shadowrun, and many other systems put unified checks and mathematics behind skills. Skill costs are proportional to expected or perceived usefulness. Új Törvénykönyv talks about balance while including relatively expensive skills with zero usefulness in likely adventures because they take a long time to learn. That unfortunate design team could not decide whether KP was a concept in a system seeking balance, intended to balance characters, or simulated learning time as in the traditional system, and therefore must not be used in the system responsible for balancing, because doing so causes gross imbalance. 

But this record-breaking mathematical error becomes irrelevant once the frequency of using individual abilities cannot be predicted, so genuine game balance cannot operate at system level. The myth of a balanced system also persisted in the days of D&D 3.5's unkillable builds. Giving up story balance, balance in player characters' positions in the world and therefore their goals, players' equal chances to create characters they like, and so forth, while pointing toward an unattainable balance and demonstrating that the lead designer lacks even primary-school probability knowledge, is a serious problem either way. 

The developers of the forthcoming new M.A.G.U.S. do talk about distributions, however. 

The ÚTK dispute certainly also involved workload, money, and business. There is no money in this field; revenue was needed, compromises had to be made, and neither side agreed with the other. But if András Gáspár's circle had considered ÚTK good and workable and expected it to earn money, there would have been no reason for the dispute. Delta Vision's claim about problems with the vision of the world is therefore true. The recurring accusation that this relates to which setting-appropriate characters can or cannot be created is precisely the kind of criticism I also make of D&D 5, Új Törvénykönyv, and several Vampire editions. It concerns play spoiled for the sake of a nonexistent balance deliberately abandoned in many places. 

Alongside Új Törvénykönyv came Új Bestiárium and its creature creator. We learned how creatures made with it could become player characters and advance. Balance was abandoned, but restrictions introduced for its sake, often damaging play, were not. I think M.A.G.U.S.'s niche was defined precisely by its willingness to ignore game balance. Arel dislikes hard limits and written laws; the gods themselves have access to every Sphere, and the question is how many they grant their priests. Fine: a four-Sphere priest of Arel. 

There is no game balance, but there can be story balance and social balance among characters. Not a bug, but a feature. A decisive feature. Ignoring game balance is already present in Vampire's Age advantage. Shadowrun's third edition offers several character creation methods for different situations, and separating Knowledge Skills opens many possibilities too. Such options must be opened at the expense of balance because roleplaying is about freedom and freely portraying an imagined character, not balance and chess. This conflicts with the tactical direction pushed by several D&D editions and with the current search for balance between approaches too. 

The M.A.G.U.S. questionnaire controversy got us talking about M.A.G.U.S. and about subjects independent of system or setting like these. Yet they could not keep to the schedule even with the questionnaire, and their tools were amateurish. Shall I go on? Everyone is making a new M.A.G.U.S. Except that in most places, those who said there should be a new community project and they would help do not write even a single-sentence comment. 

We are talking about groups with thousands of members, while publishers talk about print runs of a few hundred. The new M.A.G.U.S. project highlighted that reality too, as well as the even smaller interest in projects that are not M.A.G.U.S. What defined Hungary's roleplaying market in 2017? 

Content appears, someone else steals it, a third party republishes it from there with attribution, and eventually it circulates in groups alongside pirated scans of books. 

A hell of a lot of sites publish a mixture of good and bad articles. One person likes an article; another thinks it dreadful. One thing is certain: every site has costs. At none are fans lining up to contribute or buy amateur writer X or creator Y a beer. If everyone were not pirating even free material, as well as professional books, many sites could create more and better work. They could advertise, promoting the hobby too and bringing in new players. D&D, M.A.G.U.S., and plenty else could flourish. But that is not how things are.

Nor is the new M.A.G.U.S. being made by a professional team with varied skills, assessing demand and working hard to find compromises. This market will never provide the money for that approach. Instead, someone has a system and an idea, which may or may not become something usable. At present, it is not only purchases that are missing: proper, considered constructive criticism and participation in community projects are as rare as white ravens too. Anyone believing this will not show in every game is a fool. 

If you are considering a New Year's resolution, resolve that 2018 will be different. Spend at least 2,000 forints over the year supporting various projects: a few one-euro PayPal transfers. Plenty of people will appreciate them. Offer constructive criticism and useful comments. Perhaps then something will change. 

The kalandmester.com team wishes every reader a happy New Year, better for roleplaying and rich in opportunities to play!