There was a pretty fierce argument in one of Facebook’s roleplaying groups, which I fortunately missed at the time. The admin wrote about it, pointing out that going off topic was bad, and the unacceptable tone even worse. Then one commenter, discussing that tone, mentioned the harsh remarks directed at people who disagree on HVG’s website. I did not see that debate either, but the stories certainly inspired this article. The first question is what falls outside the subject of tabletop roleplaying games. If I argue about Puzsér’s latest program, that is outside it. If a Call of Cthulhu or Vampire character argues about it, it belongs. And if I offer tips on how a Hungarian gender-studies scholar who is a Brujah could argue against Puzsér’s reasoning, that is an RPG article full of useful advice. What follows is a longer, perhaps graphomaniacal piece running to several pages on the relationship between roleplaying and politics.
Perhaps what I love most about roleplaying is that you can be a gender-studies scholar who is a Brujah, or an antifeminist investigator who considers gender ideology Nyarlathotep's latest and greatest con. If you GM many systems, you have to step into both sets of shoes and understand both sets of arguments. I have said a hell of a lot of times that I prefer AD&D second edition to D&D 5. In some of those debates I used arguments that drew a rather unfair response: that was still the public playtest, it is now bad to a slightly lesser extent and in a slightly different way, so mentioning it makes you an idiot who knows nothing, and we will attack you personally. Without being able to acknowledge that it really is difficult, almost impossible, to make an attribute stand out as dramatically as it once could.
These outstanding attributes are iconic in many respects because they set the character so far apart from the crowd that even similar characters will be rare within the group. Something that truly stands out, making a character memorable and iconic, is rare. Just as I discussed ratios in relation to personal horror and Vampire, focusing on the difference between 1:200 and 1:2,000,000 and pointing out that a vampire seeking the best possible person to Embrace also pushes toward extreme, memorable qualities, I can say that two things often matter to me in a character. They should be multidimensional, with a more complex, interesting background. And they should be outstanding in something, making them memorable and unique.
An outstanding quality need not appear only in numbers. It can appear in opinions or ways of thinking, things that give no bonus and do not go onto the character sheet, but that you may remember. As you can probably guess, seeing this in play matters more to me than optimal tactics. So mechanics built around challenge—balancing encounters by challenge rating, a tactical combat system—will not appeal to me. Naturally, for someone to whom roleplaying is simply another game, just like tabletop strategy or a board game, that is excellent. For me it is dreadful. And when D&D 5 promised a middle ground between “it used to be good despite its faults, and I still love it for the settings, many iconic things, and fond memories” and “dreadful,” even a perfectly achieved middle ground would still be what I call mediocre crap.
But when a game's designer calculates that two kinds of rolls have the same average, yet ignores the distribution, the frequency of extreme events, and what will be memorable, and does not understand the mathematical difference, there was never any chance of discussing distributions as well as expected values in relation to rare and memorable things. Yet the characters and handful of scenes you remember two or even nearly three decades later are far more defining for a game than the “Magic Missile is an iconic spell” approach. And here I want to note something. Alongside exceptional scores, backgrounds, ways of thinking, personalities, and much else, an exceptional and memorable event is just as defining.
If events intended to be special and rare—critical successes and fumbles—have a high probability and rolls are frequent, we get everyday events instead of memorable ones. Instead of iconic stories, we get the short-term excitement and addictions also found in slot machines and video poker. Something intended to season a story as a rare, special event should not be commonplace. A roll's distribution matters as well as its expected value. Someone who modifies a heavily rules-based system such as D&D without considering the latter does not persuade me. On the contrary, they show me that they do not understand why rare and exceptional things become iconic, so I must pay attention to problems involving outliers and their frequency when assessing the system.
That is how the racial modifiers described as final in the last playtest became decisive in whether I would buy D&D 5 at release. When what had been called final did not turn out to be final, but the final version still failed to answer the underlying problem and some community members were rude, I said I would not be buying D&D 5 for quite a while. If we try it at someone else's place using their books, it may appeal to me or it may not... But it has a lot to prove. Those distinctive characters included, incidentally, a drow worshipper of Eilistraee, or even a surface elf of the same faith.
Or, still with AD&D, one of my favorite settings is Gothic Earth, described in the Ravenloft: Masque of the Red Death boxed set. Strangely, it occupies two places in my top three. In second place is the setting as presented in the box. In first place, though, I say the nineteenth century is home to countless adventures; there is no need to make so many horror elements mandatory at the system level. It works well as a potential continuation of the vision of Earth in the green books, such as Glory of Rome, but with AD&D magic, AD&D races, and even the possibility of playing them. That slightly modified version of the setting takes first place.
Distinctive characters are often rare and special because of their political or religious views, or perhaps their plans. It is also understandable that a system will not appeal to me if it cannot accommodate a character whose thinking is modeled on an actual living person, because that would mean they were not clanless. The clan supposedly is not a class, because unlike already rigid classes it wants to determine personality, behavior, and more as well—yet many players call this freedom compared with a rigid class system. Again, this raises the question of whether the designers understood frequencies and the question of who and what was exceptional in a person's life.
I am fed up with worm-people and other things invented on a “let's be fucking special snowflakes” basis that do not fit the setting, because ideally distinctiveness can come from existing races and classes too. As I said, through personality, for example. When even a Sith could lean toward the light side in an MMORPG, I celebrated several things. The first was that this could be derived from the Sith Code. The setting itself often provides opportunities for distinctive characters; SJWs and websites offering new overpowered races need not force them into it.
Star Gender Wars
The other consideration was a little more interesting. Here I have to enter the ugly Star Wars arguments about whether another Asian, Black, or gay character is needed. Of course I might have an NPC arguing for one side and another for the other. The first question I would ask is obviously when the story takes place. A sudden drastic change in a group's social role should not happen overnight with no groundwork. But if thirty years pass between episodes, consider women's roles in 1955 and 1985. Meanwhile, Star Wars began with George Lucas's childhood experiences and misunderstood stories. The Poles' light sabers became lightsabers.
In that context it is a tale of prejudice, genocide, inhumanity, and the hope confronting them. It concerns why prejudice and exclusion directed at Jews, people of color, Jedi, gay people, white people, heterosexuals, men, Sith, or even conservatives are bad, and how joining forces and building on the light side, which symbolizes balance, rather than on wonder weapons can defeat horror. How the hell would an unattractive Asian woman not fit that story? It also needs room for the fact that the Sith Code was originally light in many respects. That earlier persecution often shaped them and may also explain your own problems. Star Wars is about rejecting prejudice and hatred born of fear. That is precisely why a light-side Sith with views extreme in many respects, even played on an MMORPG's RP server, captures the story's essence. And precisely why it bothers me so much that many tabletop roleplaying games convey not Star Wars's opposition to prejudice, but our prejudices about its world.
Exclusion is no better, however, when people demand it and harass others on the basis of “nasty oppressive white men; make X a different kind of character.” That is just as disgusting as attacking an actress or someone else because they symbolize something deeply hurtful or disturbing to us. The reverse holds too: attacking the actress is no better or more acceptable than the SJW hysterics that assign her the role. And yes, I know perfectly well that an actor is often not gay enough, Jewish enough, and so on for the SJW community to play a gay, Jewish, or other such character, so the driving-people-away game goes both ways.
“It started when the other person hit back” was not an argument even in kindergarten. The kindergarten teacher cannot do anything with it either. A form of activism having made a pattern acceptable and therefore normal may explain the phenomenon, but legitimizes nothing. Especially when someone has had enough of precisely this aggression, of characters pushed in through harassment, because they consider it unjust. If harassment is your problem, do not become a harasser. Point out the double standard of people cheering one side's harassment and denouncing the other's, but do not apply one yourself by saying we are allowed because we are only copying them. No, we are not.
It is equally prejudiced to agree with one side unconditionally and ignore glaring signs that this or that will not turn out well. They are the saint, the other side is evil, even if its supposed sins must be exaggerated to maintain that picture. Unconditional faith in the elite and rejection of the stigmatized side made Palpatine emperor. We know who he was, who recommended him, and that he matched the basic values displayed in the shop window, except... If you regard one side as unconditionally good, as a victim to protect, you will be prejudiced against the opposing side in a conflict.
Let us return briefly to the issue of attacking actors. I consider it pathetic for another reason too. SJWs did not actually ruin Star Wars; a little ordinary everyday sexism had already ruined it. It is easy to say that even the first film had a princess as a protagonist, so there is nothing wrong with female heroes. But that kind of princess is a classic heroine, a traditional female role. Another traditional female role replaced it, containing the sexist discrimination that says a Disney princess can be the lead in a Disney fairy tale, while the prince on a white horse is merely the objectified reward. It has worked that way for decades, but this sexism generally does not trouble those making the loudest SJW noises against sexism.
A hell of a lot of things belonged to Star Wars and gave it its essence. Fans could think things through themselves, and the story gained increasing depth. The creative decision came not from a director or producer, but from the rights holder, when they decided to throw the Expanded Universe's many ideas and values out of canon and give us something else. That something was not a further development of Star Wars. Not even to the extent of the prequel trilogy, which drew heavily on recreating the original films yet still offered new things in several areas. Here, they shamelessly took familiar outward trappings from the Star Wars universe and pasted them onto a sufficiently formulaic Disney production.
With Disney princesses, every kind of diversity matters and all sorts of things are needed, because all sorts of people can become such heroes. Even the role model showing that acceptance is good—Beauty and the Beast—can be a woman, because we must demonstrate that women generally do not fall for the cool football player but for the despised geek... So Disney princesses presented as statues of female perfection, and that sexist, objectifying style, were going strong well before online SJW hordes and Starbucks revolutionaries appeared. When Disney discarded the Expanded Universe, which pointed toward a nuanced worldview opposed to such simplification, and we could see the first Disney princess coming—because mothers will take their children to a story where you can be an Imperial or a serial killer but are a perfect, good person if you have a cunt—it already no longer mattered what supporting character they inserted into the series to please SJWs.
While Puzsér identifies the IT world as the source of this direction spreading, California is also a center of something else: the film industry. The trend above predates Internet companies' rise. Village People, who performed Go West as well as YMCA and In the Navy, marked an important early stage of LGBT activist art. Go West was about members of the gay community migrating west, mostly to California. And the story of the AIDS epidemic exploding in the bathhouses there is not about Internet companies either. These companies do not shape society; local society, the available workforce, and the available managers shape the companies. Mandatory quotas for women are being imported from Europe. Pinning this situation on today's SJWs active in the USA is foolish.
The Internet-active companies Mythic, BioWare, and EA represented real diversity on this issue in Star Wars: The Old Republic, where a Sith leaning toward the light was an important possibility. That belonged to the essence of Star Wars. If we play and this interpretation appears in tabletop roleplaying, even a light-side Sith can be a princess. For all I care, she can belong to any sexual minority and even be an unattractive Asian woman. That is not about double standards or aggressive politics; it would add to the game rather than spoil it.
Trigger Warning
The left-liberal elite and the populist anti-elitism spreading internationally can provide adventure ideas in a hell of a lot of games. Games set in the modern era—World of Darkness and Call of Cthulhu, to name just two very familiar ones—are as suitable for exploring this as games placing present conflicts in the near future, renaming many participants so we discuss the subjects by forming new opinions rather than relying on existing prejudices. Shadowrun, speaking of trolls instead of African Americans, orks instead of Latinos, dwarfs instead of Asians, and elves instead of Jews, can explore all of this too. It still works there.
There were things about Vampire fifth edition that I said fit the picture and were good to that extent. But it also occurs to me that the system is one-sided. It is one-sided because this is not about trolls, but about African Americans, and a substantial part of the target audience consists of SJWs around universities. Supernatural struggles, conflicts between clans, and the balance of power among many other groups could be modeled on social problems. That would, of course, require a neutral, realistic assessment of the relationships, and attention to frequencies too. In a game where many people do not understand that the difference in frequency between 1:200 and 1:200,000 is a thousandfold, while between 1:2 and 1:200 it is only a hundredfold, many things would be hard to build.
And there is a bigger problem. Without renaming them, mentioning these subjects is almost certain to provoke resentment. If the system rests on an SJW position, a hell of a lot of people will become terribly upset because, as usual, aggressive, hysterical SJW politics has reached after them even into their imagined world, the story created with friends, and those intimate inner circles of freedom. There is a reason I am unhappy to see even a rainbow-colored avatar in many places: it brings this problem with it, and the conflict begins out of character, not in character. It is difficult to object to that in, say, a Shadowrun or Call of Cthulhu group, but possible in a M.A.G.U.S. group.
If the game does not work from the SJW side, that side will boycott it. My opinion is that, for a smaller game, this can even be advertising: they spread its name to many places, and someone swearing because they are meddling with yet another game and even independent creations are no longer sacred immediately hears of it. They also hear that this is a game in which SJW demands invading play hopefully do not yet ruin their game. Even if the game contains SJW characters, and characters belonging to sexual minorities.
The very same character will then be less annoying and irritating to that person. The problem is not the presence of an unattractive Asian woman, a gay Latina, or a drug-addicted African American, but a political ideology that flattens freedom of thought too. This politics already has victims in the world, and given how often it considers one side's perceived grievance grounds to disregard the other side's real human rights, there will probably be more. It is no better than any murderous twentieth-century ideology; it merely reaches still further into people's freedom.
And the game can contain not only such characters but even the most militant SJWs, even if we consider them distinctly bad. There was no problem when many people saw such characters in Vampire before. Aggressively forcing this direction, however, means many people will feel a dangerous extremism has reached after them here too, even if the character never appears in play, and that explains the uproar against Vampire fifth edition. In many other cases, though, our games can have SJW characters as PCs or NPCs alike. Is that a trigger too? No, because however bad we consider this politics, we are used to many player characters, even protagonists, having darker personalities in roleplaying games.
In many games, it is almost natural. In others, mad people or people manipulated by Nyarlathotep do things we consider condemnable. That is precisely why the antecedents of the SJW need to appear in the game.
SJW antecedents
It would be easy to approach the SJW through gender. An easy target, just waiting to be hit. The problem is that this was not the only route to the SJW. One cause is the person who, in pursuing their own freedom, rebellion, and pushing of boundaries, treated other people as invisible and ignored them, thereby showing a substantial lack of social sensitivity. In the absence of upbringing, it offers the (Disney) princesses and spoiled princes created by pop culture a chance to compensate through causes that do not affect them—for instance, addressing conflicts arising from rural minorities' behavior from central Budapest—and partly to gain advantages for themselves by invoking the basic values of social sensitivity. Among people overcompensating for their disregard of others, there will be plenty of charismatic psychopaths addressing the “masses they represent.” Qualitatively this is no different from Adolf Hitler's social sensitivity toward “Aryan Germans,” alongside his insensitivity toward his victims.
I would like to reach a point where we can sit down somewhere with the founders of the gender-studies program, have a proper debate without accusations of mansplaining, and look up data. But that requires daring to depart from Puzsér's path and say gender studies is not at the heart of the problem, even if Robi Puzsér blames it for the weather. Or blames the troll regime. And although I often say a field of research cannot occupy an ideology or political camp, while an ideological camp can occupy research, feminism will not be the bogeyman. The problem under discussion is much older.
Even the division of power between the tribal chief as political leader and the shaman as spiritual leader reminds us that blurring the two roles is bad. Politics should not interfere in the affairs of sages, philosophers, and scholars. That expectation remains rational as long as the spiritual or intellectual leader does not start practicing politics either. Respect for boundaries and each other's territory works as long as it is mutual. When sages, priests, and scholars become activists and political or public figures, presenting not only objective facts but their own opinions too, the boundaries between politics and scholarship collapse. Where scholarship strays into political territory and practices politics through opinions and ideologies, politics has every reason and right to throw the intruder out of its own territory.
Where a spiritual or intellectual leader becomes a political factor by going beyond independent, impartial inquiry, many seek to buy that leader's worldly power; simony arose from this too. Others fight over the disputed territory through appointments and the question of what and whom we accept, leading to investiture struggles and countless other things. Where spiritual authority interferes in secular power, secular power answers back, and this has been a constant throughout history. The political and social activism of a substantial portion of the intellectual elite occupied political territory, inevitably bringing battles over that disputed ground and political interference in its affairs.
But the real problem does not begin there. Scholarship's perspective is neutral, while activism and political involvement never are. When scholarship and activism meet, it is very easy for preconceptions to emerge in particular fields and distort research's objectivity. This convergence appears from two directions. One is the distortion of the scholar's objectivity. The other is the “search for truth” of someone seeking self-justification becoming part of the intellectual elite because shared activism, thought about similar subjects, and a system of reciprocal citations make it accepted.
From prehistory through the present to hard science fiction, from medieval fantasy through Victorian horror and steampunk to Star Wars, this phenomenon can appear anywhere and at any time. The rise and fall of dystopian systems detached from reality is a recurring historical process, as is the emergence of an intellectual elite seeking to build such systems and its loss of credibility after the events. For Vampire's Brujah clan, necessarily in a state of permanent rebellion and compensation, the racial theory serving Nazism and the message of supposed oppression by Jews are just like gender today. The clan's small measure of internal diversity based on background comes from the variety of recurring problems.
When thought abandons scientific objectivity and works on the foundations of political activism, we speak of ideology. Its apparently scientific research base often becomes pseudoscience. If that involves violations of human rights, it can no longer rely on academic freedom: it ceases to belong to freedom of thought, one of freedom's innermost and most important circles, and becomes an instrument of hatred that must be opposed.
How pseudoscience is made
Just as homeopathy was taught, recommended, and widely accepted within the scientific community for a long time, even in medical training where other people's lives were at stake, Gender Studies also achieved acceptance as an academic field. But I consider Gender Studies a pseudoscience not only for the reason my friend Sol does, pointing to its lack of scientific foundations, but because it meets five criteria, any one of which would be enough to recognize a classic pseudoscience.
1. We can decide whether a question belongs to physics or mathematics without assuming the truth of any particular physical or mathematical law or proposition. If we discover that what we previously saw was a surface appearance approximating the real process well, while the actual physical law is different, the subject remains physics, because physics is defined by objectivity rather than preconception. To decide whether a question belongs to gender studies, we must decide whether the explanation or presupposition applies that differing social perceptions of genders cause the phenomenon.
2. Meanwhile, these very same problems are examined by fields meeting the criterion of scientific objectivity and not defined by preconceptions. Gender studies can establish nothing objectively ascertainable, and achieve no real scientific result, that these objective fields could not. It was therefore not created by a need for scientifically rigorous investigation of things otherwise impossible to understand, while it does serve activism and ideology.
3. If a problem also examined by gender studies—say, a company's wage gap—has a better explanation than the gender-based preconception, such as an actual correlation with length of service, that research falls outside gender's preconception. It is not part of research within gender studies, undermining the testability central to science. Any gender-studies research can dismiss these counterarguments by saying they do not belong to the field or the question it examines, allowing the preconception to operate unchecked. Even if the first argument were untrue and this merely avoided counterarguments, it would still be enough to require considering gender studies a pseudoscience.
4. A false statement can lead to a false conclusion even through correct logic and a chain of reasoning whose validity has been checked. If a field allows its representatives the luxury of creating and using terms such as mansplaining so that basic assertions are often settled through personal attacks rather than debate and competing arguments, that undermines not only the particular claim and researcher's credibility, but also every other study building on it, even indirectly through many other studies. Instead of science's solid stone walls, we see a house of cards built on a shake table, inevitably collapsing when the table is switched on—that is, when counterarguments are genuinely examined. Anyone seeking truly objective research must avoid such contaminated foundations and work from a different basis.
5. Where questions of gender arise, the fields to be examined include biology, medicine, psychology, neurology, genetics, biochemistry, economics, mathematical statistics, probability, sociology, anthropology and its various branches, criminology, sports science and questions of women's sport, politics, political science, law, literature, history, military science, and so on. When, say, a sociologist turned gender scholar seeks to investigate workplace-safety rules grounded in medicine, biology, biomechanics, and engineering—and the resulting “discrimination”—without understanding those foundations or properly interpreting the relevant research, that lacks any scientific basis. Unfortunately, this is an accepted norm in gender studies, and again other research in the field builds on the resulting incorrect claims.
Every dangerous ideology, however, has created similar pseudosciences for itself, and much of the scientific community regarded them as real science while the dangerous ideology spread globally. The collapse of totalitarian ideologies detached from reality, offering no real solutions and compensating for their own failures with ever more violence, also destroyed the credibility of the pseudosciences serving them. Teaching the pseudosciences that served Stalinism, Nazism, and so on would be an anachronism. But anyone who fails to learn from history and does not speak out in time against pseudosciences displaying the same signs—the five criteria above—condemns themselves to complicity in the next similar totalitarian system.
At the same time, we say the preconception behind gender can be studied like any philosophical school, without requiring gender studies to be right about anything. A fair, scientifically rigorous examination from a neutral perspective of the phenomena gender studies examines would often be particularly important, since the presupposition affects more than the people who enrolled in gender studies for that reason. If someone says of a workplace that seven of its sixteen department heads are women and nine are men, and that the men earn on average 4.72% more in the same position, there really will be wage tensions and social tensions there.
Overtime may explain part of the difference. Length of service and the department heads' average age may explain another part, with retirement age affecting the latter. Injustice may quite possibly have appeared precisely when firm measures reduced a difference of more than 7% to below 5%. Wages could not be cut to compensate for that injustice, while there is no money to raise them. Something may also need to be done about aggressive behavior demanding further discrimination to reduce the gap further.
This story can appear in an adventure because an investigative-journalist character in Call of Cthulhu encounters not only cultists and the supernatural but feminazis deceived by Nyarlathotep. Or the wage tensions above may affect a ghoul's company in Vampire, or the assessment of gender studies may form the basis of a Brujah–Ventrue conflict. Many other modern or future-set games can feature similar issues, whether the real problem, its effects on PR and revenue, or obtaining related research and data. Confronting a company with its own financial data contradicting its claims has also worked in Shadowrun, for example.
The role of the press
The question is why mudslinging feels natural instead of reasoning and constructive discussion. The elite that already called the MDF Nazis saw its lies backfire as those accusations wore thin and lost credibility. On one hand, today's criticism of the government, comprising justified and unjustified accusations, lacks credibility; on another, the labels have worn out; and on a third, it is easy to say this established a form of politics built on personal attacks, exclusion, and lies. Surely when Gyurcsány spoke about political lies reaching back to the change of regime, he could also have meant lies like these and their consequences. A pity he did not break with similar lies after the speech.
But online harassment that drives others away brings something else to mind: the lowest point in the history of Hungarian journalism. The incident in which many militant feminists did not give a damn that a woman was facing verbal violence and aggression from men, because HVG was on their side after all. A flight attendant's profile was included in an article, exposing her to continual harassment. There were three problems. First, that flight attendant had not even been there. Second, independent witnesses said the HVG executive taking revenge and his family were very much in the wrong. Third, an independent press should inform readers, not pursue personal revenge. But when the lie was exposed, many of us asked in vain for a notice on HVG's Facebook page, giving the correction equal prominence as required by law, so the harassers would be notified that they should stop and why. Nobody there cared at the time.
At that point, harassing and driving away an innocent person for personal revenge was perfectly cool according to the very people who condemn everything like it when fans complain. Such behavior violates human dignity and human rights, except when someone politically on our side does it, in which case this spinelessness is a heroic deed even against an innocent, defenseless person. I have bad news. The often rude fans complaining about the roles of Asians, Black people, gay people, women, and so on in Star Wars do not have a problem with Asians, Black people, gay people, and women. Most of them even like women.
Their problem is that when they escape this two-faced, lying, dishonorable politics into a fantasy world, yet another character reminds them that the politics has reached after them here too, pushed these characters here, and shoved in their faces the fact that their last refuge, the world of imagination, the most intimate place, offers no shelter from its aggression. The unfortunate Asian, Black, gay, or female character, or the actor behind them, comes under fire because of the stomachs knotting and hands clenching into fists over this. They are simply in the wrong place at the wrong time, made a tool of a bad aggression at the wrong moment. Star Wars and roleplaying worlds need many things, and more of many kinds of characters would be good, if only for the world's diversity and original message. But when people flee this aggressive politics into imagination, films, video games, and tabletop roleplaying, they do not need this problem to follow them and confront them there too.
Their problem is an elite equally represented by many gender-studies professors and HVG journalists, which tramples anyone and flattens anyone's innermost freedom out of self-interest, revenge, or compensation. Objectivity is not only for scholarship. Facts are sacred and opinion is free, says the basic principle of journalistic ethics. We should also expect the press to present every side and its arguments fairly. Criticism of feminism, for example, received no such opportunity on Index. Yet it is entitled to that even if it is wrong.
Politicians lie, gender “scholars” can be prejudiced, and many things can be described as bad. But we pay journalists—even if only by viewing advertising—for truthful, impartial information. With foreign-currency-linked lending, it is fashionable to criticize banks and act as though the loan structure itself was bad or unfair. Even if that were true, an economics journalist ought to recognize it. The truth is that, despite all their faults, foreign-currency-linked loans remained far cheaper even in trouble than fixed-interest forint loans. Anyone choosing a risk with a similar expected value instead of a fixed cost should also have accepted the possibility that the difference would not merely narrow but reverse, at least for a time. And of course, if part of the family worked abroad—washing dishes in Austria, for example—it was a forint loan that was risky.
The problem involved three things.
Banks were competing in the market. If borrowers could grow out of their debt burdens, issuing more loans was worthwhile: discounted repayments worked in the short term, wages would rise in the longer term, and hopefully even the increased installment would remain affordable. Alongside promises of growth through employment abroad and EU membership, the over-lending seen in other countries and the search for places to put capital withdrawn from abroad also helped people borrow more than they could repay.
The idea spread that banks only lent enough to people who did not need it. People therefore joined forces to create circumstances that manipulated banks within the system into lending still more, bringing in extra collateral if necessary or working out how to present income as though they were better able to pay.
Years passed during which intellectual journalists belonging to the elite had every reason not to believe in the “Pannonian Puma,” to know the crisis would spill over, to write about the loan structures' limitations, and to publish articles helping calculate how much repayments were certain to rise and how much they were likely to rise. In a word, to write impartially and fairly about what mattered to readers and put their livelihoods at stake. Yet however much readers trusted them, and however much this was their job, they did not cross the political and economic elite belonging to the same elite and, in many respects, the same political camp. They even helped generate the optimistic vision of the future that sold dangerous loans.
They did not write what mattered, letting the lying pseudo-problems of gender studies take its place and thereby laying the foundations of an aggressive politics that intrudes brutally even into other people's imaginations. The international crisis was underrepresented in the press. So was the possibility that installments automatically jumping after an initial repayment discount could cause trouble. Or what an interest-rate rise, and a higher APR resulting from risk premiums, does to an annuity loan early in its term. These were newsworthy matters then, but demanding quotas and discriminatory, often unfair supplements was more important.
Every family that took out a loan but would never have done so with knowledge of the facts, that trusted such publications and the scholars and “scholars” speaking for this elite then and now, and that now stands on the brink of eviction as a result but continues to trust this elite and this press, plays the part of a badly deceived sucker. Those who do not miss the press offering advice instead of drama, helping them find genuinely effective objections to enforcement proceedings, but simply join in the shouting... Those for whom fair pay and work under fair conditions for everyone matter less than serving this elite by fighting along the lines of gender's prejudices... They are the victims of one of Nyarlathotep's ugly jokes.
The journalists helping lead them into the trap are the best salespeople for Nyarlathotep's bank and other banks' risky products.