It is not my job to defend M.A.G.U.S.'s Első Törvénykönyv. It is full of flaws I cannot accept either. One example is the three-Sphere priest of Arel. Not because other priests have two Spheres, but because four can be justified: Arel dislikes hard limits and written laws, so would not rigidly restrict her priests. M.A.G.U.S.'s Spheres do not represent a god's spheres of influence, merely restrictions on the priest. Originally, a priest of Arel had four. Or take the spell whose description says astral and mental Magic Resistance prevent stealing a human body. That would make a shielded pet animal's body, one that can approach someone closely, difficult to steal. A peasant girl's or maid's body, with Magic Resistance near zero, would pose no such difficulty even to a spell at basic strength.
For the four-legged forms mentioned in the spell description, it is particularly charming to consider what replaces a kiss in a spell. The question is whether speaking magical words and drawing runes in the air can be replaced in a body incapable of doing so. In experiential magic, supposedly not. But learning a spell—and a witch knows her spells—presupposes trying it. If you do not want to keep trying it regularly, every detail of successful use can be written into memory instead. From there, the witch would exist in two bodies. Need scholarly skills? She rests in her favorite librarian's lap, so whenever she needs information, she need only look into his eyes and ask him to bring over some important books on the subject.
Making this situation almost mandatory adds color to play. The witch may not remain silent while sneaking: she is in two places at once, shares FP, and some playful activity could make her gasp at exactly the wrong moment. Does the body sent on the adventure die? She may acquire another. There are interesting methods for that. The problem is not that the spell exists; I welcome it. The problem is how little thought went into it. Anyone demanding game balance will already object to that library solution. But there are facts to account for.
Most adventures and life-path campaigns are not designed to be solved with the Sexual Culture skill, largely because while one character uses it to influence someone with pleasing words and suitable movements, everyone else merely watches, often uncomfortably. Yet it belongs to many characters. I do not dispute that some games can place it at their center, but most do not. This skill, or similarly seldom-used Sailing, Driving a Cart, and many others, will probably not arise in most adventures. They still cost skill points. Their price in KP, and through that in KAP in ÚTK, is proportional to learning time rather than usefulness, advantages gained, or frequency of use.
The many forms of Profession rarely come up. They provide character background rather than useful adventuring skills.
A skill does not automatically become more useful in the world because it is harder to learn. It becomes rarer, which can often earn money, but not necessarily more useful in adventures. Creating everyone from the same number of points, with everyone having had the opportunity to use the same build, does not create balance. Someone's Shadonian womanizer will indeed understand Sexual Culture even if the women in the adventures' intended region do not excite his imagination.
Some system developer will surely say they ran a game where Profession: Farmer was useful. Or built an adventure around ornamental cabinetmaking, requiring everyone in the party to buy expensive rank 4. Most games are not like that, however, because a hell of a lot of skills are hard to handle well. Imagine a story centered on Sailing and its portrayal, with a detailed role throughout. Unlikely. Many scholarly skills are similar: great, you know something off the top of your head that others must look up.
I do assert, based on Új Törvénykönyv's text, that a skill costs exactly the same whether it never appears in play or the game master builds half a life-path campaign around it. Its usefulness differs completely between those cases. Different usefulness, identical price. We cannot speak of balance. Yet everyone starts with equal points in the name of balance, right?
What did this wonderful change rule out?
- Giving characters with probably seldom-used skills more of them on some basis, such as class, so they are useful and receive the spotlight roughly as often. Story balance disappears.
- The system handles some important character traits in detail, including characters weaker in that area, while others are harder to handle well. Not every character's concerns receive equal time, eliminating the possibility of time balance.
- Putting characters at roughly similar life stages, who would naturally adventure together, into one party. A kind of social balance disappears. We can complain about its absence.
- Properly creating many characters who need more or fewer points to be plausible. One player gets enough freedom for their imagined character; another does not. Players lack equal chances to create and balance the characters they imagine. The balance of fair, equal treatment disappears.
We threw four kinds of balance away to pursue one: game balance. And we did not get that either, because we do not and cannot know how often or how much each skill will help. That depends on adventures the system cannot foresee, and the GM cannot necessarily incorporate every skill into the imagined story in a way interesting to everyone else.
I have heard an honest explanation, of course: System X is balanced because it drives away anyone needing any of those four considerations. Those wanting to roll dice through standardized adventures with builds selected on similar principles suffer the problems equally: both the problems preventing general game balance and those arising from other kinds of balance being lost. Unsuitability for other considerations, and the fact that sensible players seeking those avoid the system, become the guarantee of balance.
An excellent explanation! I have received it for D&D 5 and M.A.G.U.S. ÚTK alike. It is entirely true, demonstrating that under certain conditions these systems really are balanced. It simply means that recommending them on that basis to people seeking something else remains a bad recommendation.
The truth, however, is that no roleplaying system or edition deserves more than two or three rolls. We sit down, and you suggest ÚTK. My character will have interests. Their background will also include things that grant no advantages but constrain them through expected behavior and mentality.
The points will run out. Little Steve will accuse me of powergaming because the equipment list is long. Admittedly, it starts with everyday objects rather than power boosts bought here and there, and ends with produced or producible goods. But balance does not end with the five considerations above. It can differ along other dimensions too.
One is whether characters should be equally powerful, or have power proportional to the player's work, achievements, or another consideration, under equal treatment. Clearly, that work can include backstory, optimization, and many other things the system, GM, or group wants to reward or penalize.
Wanting game balance regardless of merit produces a very different game from wanting story balance that rewards work on backstory and personality while penalizing energy spent powergaming.
A disadvantage has a negative effect on game balance, but from a story-balance perspective it draws more attention to the character. A personality influencing many actions likewise lets the player receive more time and attention, while weakening the character much as mechanical disadvantages do.
As we suspect, attempts at game balance riddled with major mathematical errors are no good. Many systems, including ÚTK, also neglect proportionality, provide no support for other concepts of balance, and substantially undermine them. Someone who understands that many kinds of balance exist and can exclude one another rarely calls a system balanced or unbalanced. What kind of balance the system intends to offer matters more.