RenassaA curse of Hungarian roleplaying is that even when a problem is general, we talk only about the best-known Hungarian RPG and pretend that is fine. I too would happily say that when designing a roleplaying game I would avoid classes, but when designing M.A.G.U.S. I would consider them important. I would immediately point out how almost every roleplaying platform promotes plenty of “new supplements,” with new classes and subclasses proving popular. Yet I would find D&D just as hard to imagine without classes. Indeed, when explaining my opinion of D&D 5, I point to its treatment of races, refining my opinion over time. In reality, an opinion about classes that also arose in the M.A.G.U.S. questionnaires influences me just as much. Why should this be M.A.G.U.S.-specific? All right, Delta Vision's questionnaires made it topical. But “generally this would be best, except for system X” is not entirely credible, since it could be read as saying system X should be bad. 

The opposite is true, however. Classes mattered in AD&D too, but worked entirely differently in AD&D second edition and D&D third edition. Since then, RPGs have introduced approaches radically unlike either example. I am almost certain that classes suit some settings and games poorly, traditional AD&D classes suit others, and a modern treatment suits still others. I would also wager a substantial sum that my negative opinion of D&D cannot be universal, because even something as fundamental as freedom in roleplaying can be approached from many sides. We are tiresomely familiar with the “stock answer” to many criticisms: D&D serves several worlds. Every time, the irritation arises: why does a longsword cost the same everywhere, when available iron and its value can vary even within a world? We have not even discussed available precious metals or possible inflation. The worlds are broadly at the same technological level, because full plate must be available everywhere. What does someone take me for if they think I will miss this contradiction and be persuaded by setting independence? I would instead say that, compared with AD&D, the setting-bound M.A.G.U.S., containing quite a few ideas, took one direction when its developers tried cobbling together a Hungarian AD&D. D&D 3 took another.

A Wizards executive at the time even said D&D was about killing monsters and taking their treasure, during third edition's development. What happened to the DL adventure series letting us play through what we had read in novels and make our characters heroes of their world? The philosophy of “we need two more XP to level up, let's kill something” replaced it. Once story, chronology, and character background recede, how long wizard-school training lasts and whom the school accepts matter much less. With numerous prestige classes and the extreme multiclassing in common builds, class no longer even defined a role. It was merely a larger package of abilities than skills or feats, with advancement accelerating in many respects because a fourth-level spell is worth more than a first-level one.

In the first approach, classes represent a quantity and depth of knowledge that cannot normally be acquired within the timespan covered by play, except in special cases, justifying their separation from skills. Apart from Dual Class, representing rapid learning and exceptional adaptability, AD&D second edition embodied this concept. Of course, some adventure series featured a special case: acquiring a class through special GM permission and relaxed rules. Our wonderful dwarf promised the goddess of magic that if she healed his beloved friend, he would go and learn that entire wizardly nonsense. He would become a dwarf wizard in a system where dwarves normally cannot acquire a new class later, and many special dwarven abilities are justified by incompatibility with wizard magic, making wizard a forbidden class. Our dwarf did not care how many wishes, quests for gods, or other things it took: he had given his word. Thrown out the door, he climbed back through the window. He even built a tunnel when there was no other way into his chosen school. It produced memorable adventures. I never considered objecting that the dwarf broke the rules, and did not begrudge someone else that opportunity. 

For me, AD&D includes possibilities like that. They too make it advanced, more than killing monsters and collecting treasure. I missed AD&D, though I still bring out that fossil occasionally. I even liked the Player's Option series, including Skills & Powers and Spells & Magic. No, Combat & Tactics is not a neglected stepchild; it is simply less important when starting with character creation. I look at the DM and suggest: “Planescape? Shall we use the cleric trick?” The DM only wants to know whether it will involve dual-classing or multiclassing. If Planewalker's Handbook suggested playing particularly unusual races, we must somehow turn monsters into playable races. We found a reliable trick: the cleric in Spells & Magic can buy spell-like abilities with character points, simulating many races nicely; even the d8 Hit Die is not far off. I loved it because treating the race as a class also models promotions within that race very well. It is no secret that this required greatly loosening the class system and using a trick D&D 4 later called reflavoring. Nor is it a secret that there would be little game balance. But we play well, and our characters even work mechanically roughly as imagined. 

These beings are tied to an Outer Plane and often closely connected to a religion. Handling spell-like abilities this way was logical. We can say that combining all available points into one pool and everything purchasable into one list produces a point system apparently capable of creating the same characters. But we immediately notice that different races and classes receive different point totals. A single common list would not change that. Seeking to make characters fitting the world, story, and party possible, instead of pursuing balance at system level, is not a bug—poor balance—but a feature: more possibilities, freedom, and roleplaying. Many of us value that feature, especially when the system handles imagined characters reasonably well. 

I played AD&D for many such characters and stories. Later D&D editions made some things difficult to realize, but they promised fifth edition would change that. This one would be for me, for us too. Playtests arrived, and I eagerly awaited fifth-edition D&D. They said they would consider those who never really liked third or fourth edition after AD&D second edition. Many of us moved to other games, yet often miss AD&D. If later editions do not provide what we miss, out come the second-edition PHB and DMG. We were in the declared target audience. The final playtest packet's racial modifiers were described as final, but were not. So some D&D fanboys can declare how ignorant I am for criticizing D&D over them, failing to grasp why their eventual partial correction in the final version is irrelevant. 

Not every supplement or new feature gets a playtest. Those supposedly final modifiers showed that whoever called them final did not understand why they provoked outrage or needed changing. Later, many similar things will be published before we can respond. This was not the only reason I said I did not want the new edition, only the last straw. I considered illustrating the problem by caricaturing the Dunaújváros champion of “D&D is about killing monsters” with similar poetic exaggeration, in repayment for many often dishonest personal attacks, but decided against it. Given his behavior, I am not surprised he needs the sense of achievement that powergaming-brat gameplay offers, which he defends by saying I was young once and young people still exist. He conveniently forgets that Vérpisti is out of fashion; Vérklári is the fashionable one now, playing a sunlight-sparkling vampire in romantic roleplay on a forum. You will not turn them into tabletop roleplayers by shoving down their throats that story and many moral dilemmas are unnecessary because D&D is about slaughtering monsters.

That gave me the pleasant opportunity to point out that everything from sparkling vampires to angels and demons is normal in that environment. To seat those people at a game, we cannot say, “The succubus is a party member in Planescape: Torment, recommended by old gamers, and could be played on a forum; it fits the world and concept, but the system does not support it.” Especially when the justification is the supposed balance between a D&D character made weak for roleplaying reasons and the legendary CoDzilla or Pun-Pun builds. We can say nobody plays those builds, the DM handles balance, and so forth, but balance still does not exist. A character fitting the world and story would cause fewer problems. Yet D&D 3.x rejects it for two reasons often invoked together: ability X requires at least a certain ECL, so it exceeds the party's allowed ECL, while simultaneously being too weak for the party, unviable, and game-ruining. To win back people lost for this reason and work in many directions, D&D 5 fundamentally needed to avoid characters simultaneously unplayable because the system considers them too strong and the party and GM consider them too weak. 

Of course, perhaps that is not the goal, and there is nothing wrong with “D&D is about killing monsters,” or even powergaming-brat behavior. I merely note that in the late 1980s and early 1990s, earning a circle's admiration for monster slaughter really did mean playing D&D with the geek community and powergaming there. The trouble is that the calendar says 2017. The internet is widespread; Diablo and even World of Warcraft have appeared. I know reaching the tops of leaderboards, streaming, and building a presence there is hard, while tabletop play optimized for killing monsters and familiar dungeons hands out achievement almost for free, supplemented by conditioned reflexes, laughter, and pizza. But analyzing Dunaújváros's ace or other examples to explain what they failed to learn and why they need that achievement would miss the point just as they do. The point is that D&D 5 always promised compromise because it wanted to serve many styles of play. That promise is familiar: the publisher promises it for the new M.A.G.U.S. too. Here is an important shared point.

Compromise means not getting everything important and giving up many things. In return, we might receive a newer system with available core books and easier recruitment of new players. They are not asking us to give things up for nothing. But the sacrifices remain, the glass gradually fills, and the straw after the last can arrive. Obviously, if the thing that destroyed trust did not become final, it is a smaller drop. Its size matters little once trust is gone. I point to that last extra drop. A million times, the small point is made: invoking setting independence for races is unconvincing when even inns charge identical prices in the system's worlds. Blunting racial traits removes many large and small iconic elements. All this is true and supported by many arguments. This was indeed where D&D 5 lost me, along with many other forum participants. 

But it is that tiny final extra drop, whose size can be disputed. Decisive as every last straw is, it has a problem: it says nothing about the already full glass. Without that, it would merely be a drop, not the final extra one. Once the glass is full, any small drop can serve that role. It also says nothing about why I know others lost at the same time: we discussed it on countless forums and waited for the final playtest packet on the basis that if others remained hopeful, I would stay too. The final packet was everyone's last, so “wait for the next packet, wait until the playtest ends” fell silent for everyone at once. People who already considered many D&D editions not to be RPGs needed little persuasion that “prices are universal everywhere, but many racial traits are omitted because they are not universal enough” lacks credibility. They too remembered worlds with different currencies, prices, and equipment: Dark Sun, Dragonlance, and Ravenloft: Masque of the Red Death. 

Many racial traits, alongside shared racial pantheons, suggest common origins while leaving room for iconic elements, whereas many worlds have different economies. These are almost commonplace, extremely simple arguments, with only one excuse for ignoring them: the developers did not even consider them. For someone whose glass was full, whose patience was already strained while awaiting the last straw, it was easy to agree that D&D 5's creators did not know even this. They are right: that was when many of us left together. But fixing that last drop of a flaw requires one short paragraph of house rules. I could have put it on kalandmester.com's front page, immediately removing the declared reason D&D 5 failed to win me over. I said nothing about why I did not. A fanboy merely sees me attacking their favorite system over a detail when I silently fix more serious flaws elsewhere. 

The true, precise answer to why I do not take that step is loss of trust. Its cause is naturally the event that changed hope into disappointment. We have gone in a circle, apparently returning to the tiny, easily fixed flaw. Massive circular reasoning leaves the average-intelligence fanboy feeling their favorite system is treated very unfairly. A slightly more intelligent person immediately separates my claim into five important parts. That quickly reveals it is not about the easily fixed mechanical flaw: the same event raises another problem.

  1. I mentioned that this was the final playtest packet.
  2. That something was declared final.
  3. And the rule itself. 
  4. Every time, I contrasted it with the promise of several play styles and compromises to win back those who had drifted away.
  5. Every time, I explained why invoking game balance was problematic for me.

Little research is needed to see I said something similar about Mass Effect 3's ending: many of us would respond and act differently and are dissatisfied. As at other points where precisely our choice is unavailable, despite it supposedly being our character and decision. Elsewhere, the continuing story repairs that momentary bad feeling, but at the ending the disappointment stays. A bad rule that can later be corrected says little by itself. Every playtest is full of them. I could have named many other disliked rules, and they certainly helped fill the glass. Yet this mattered: “To win back people lost for this reason and work in many directions, D&D 5 fundamentally needed to avoid characters simultaneously unplayable because the system considers them too strong and the party and GM consider them too weak.” But what makes someone weak? Perhaps strength comes from their heritage and is used in crafts such as sculpture or smithing, while as an artistic spellcaster they rarely use its attack and damage bonuses. One point of Strength is worth noticeably less to them than to a fighter. This was true even when perhaps only one elven subrace in AD&D received +1 Strength. 

The system's own logic concludes that exceptional attributes are overpowered, especially Strength, and high Dexterity too would be truly dangerous. In reality, a high attribute with few opportunities to help in play mainly means fewer points for genuinely important attributes. If skills likewise prioritize cooking edible food over anything yielding direct numerical benefits in play, that creates another disadvantage. Creating a character along these lines spends points in several areas whose only benefit is a more colorful, living character. Points disappear fairly quickly. As we suspect, while everyone at the table plays that way, the DM provides appropriately strong opponents; D&D 5 is less rigid about CR than D&D 3 was. Expanding rules to accommodate exceptional traits that do not affect play is easy too. If the whole group agrees, if there is no dispute...

But when several systems support this play style to varying degrees, and D&D 5's rules virtually do not support it at all, even optionally, encountering such a D&D 5 group is unlikely. One of the first design questions for any game is what it is about. D&D apparently remains largely about killing monsters. That is fine in one respect: many people like it and need a game too, and they make up much of the previous editions' core audience. Turning your back on them would be a deadly sin. Yet the announced goal offered an alternative precisely to that, and optional rules should have represented other directions too. Their absence is a more serious problem. 

At the playtest's declared end, supposedly settled points showed that they did not understand what mattered long-term to me and many others. Even if the flaw were corrected, there was no time left for developers to explore the issue or seek consensus and compromise. A deadline arrived and development stopped before declared goals and promises could be fulfilled. Which rule exposed it is less important than the problem persisting at development's end. Without specifying which proposal's approach created this impression, however, the claim would be no more than belching “it is shit because it is shit.” However tiny that detail about racial modifiers and abilities, its importance comes from timing and context. The focus is no longer the modifier, but a product hurried to market before important promises were fulfilled and before many needs were even understood. When I grumble, “So much for Wizards' fine promises,” the depth of the problem should be apparent.

They may have partly corrected the specific flaw, while invoking balance, but do not know why it mattered: the playtest closed before they could ask. They still work from that knowledge, and deadlines still matter more than fulfilling D&D 5's great promise. We have more than enough releases like this in both tabletop and computer games, and tolerance for them has largely run out. Anyone following this far can quickly observe: this is also why wasting the available time on weak questionnaires seems a deadly sin, and every D&D fan can now criticize the new M.A.G.U.S. But those poor questionnaires contained one badly written yet enormously important question. 

8 - Which do you consider more important?
316 Votes A balanced rules system
50.56%
309 Votes Classes receive the disproportionately greater number of skills needed for their flavor (headhunter, bard)
49.44%

The proportions change very little. Voting is fairly even; in a nonrepresentative survey, the two answers' popularity lies within the margin of error. But both answers are problematic. A balanced system and game balance are not necessarily the same. Game balance is a goal not truly attainable; a balanced system balances different needs. Plausible characters, with skills and abilities credible in light of training and background, matter more than class flavor. Both errors push the result toward the first answer. “Balance” is a powerful buzzword and promise. When the last shred of credibility is slaughtered in its name, the response comes easily: balance is not the problem. The examples I mentioned cost many points yet were weak, so there was no balance. Balance is good because it is fair. Naturally, respondents included not only active M.A.G.U.S. players, but people for whom M.A.G.U.S. is out of the question, unlike some “balanced” foreign system. Preferably with Pun-Pun.

Game balance was central for a while. But in Vampire: The Masquerade, for example, Age certainly and automatically overturns it, showing that balance is not the goal. It improves point allocation, while clans replacing classes guide character creation. Behind this was recognition that story balance, based on time in the spotlight, matters similarly. So can keeping characters' positions in the world roughly level. Or balancing invested effort and reward, risk and reward, or different player needs. These many balances can exclude one another. Designing a system without recognizing this is not ideal, though D&D's sufficiently large audience has mostly allowed it to withstand that too.

That is only the surface. A more important problem with invoking game balance is that it would require knowing exactly how often each ability will be used and what combinations will build on it, and how often. Unless your spellcasting is Charisma-based, Charisma in D&D is a damned rarely used attribute, unlike Dexterity. Yet the system charges the same for both. Different usage frequencies can make a point in one ten or twenty times more useful than a point in the other. There are too many unknowns and too many large differences depending on them for talking about game balance to be worthwhile.

The D&D community attempts a simple compensation: it expects roughly optimal choices. That can constrain freedom more than classes do. Optimization also appears in combat during play. Your character sees a chaotic battle; you see a gridded “chessboard.” The game is optimized around that battle being central, requiring choices based on metagame considerations unknown to the character. The result? Most play becomes metagaming, leaving little reason to forbid metagaming or “reading spoilers about the module,” since that is largely what the game rewards.

If we reject point allocation aimed at game balance and look at character creation following the world, we must recognize that much knowledge can be learned only in schools admitting people in early childhood, where organizational membership may last a lifetime and advancement requires returning there. A good class system imposes limits, but no more than the world and roleplaying do. If the limits come from the world and roleplaying rather than artificial rules, the system is free—freer than fixed-point systems pursuing game balance and steering players toward optimization. That freedom is hard to surrender. Until a better solution provides it, the thousand-times-cursed class system remains, however old and shabby. 

And it remains to improve the game by pursuing important values, rather than being torn down on the basis that other things are good and this is a bad, shabby fossil that merely happens to belong to this game.