In a conversation, someone said they found it missing all too often. Several M.A.G.U.S. core rulebooks consider the concept unethical. Someone else points out that, whether in forum RPGs, MMORPGs or tabletop roleplaying, protection for other players is unrealistic in their view. Others argue precisely that PvP kills roleplaying and realism, and that it should fundamentally be banned for the sake of the quality of play, rather than because of vague ethical rules protecting whoever is attacked. But where the hell does the truth lie? And is it even in the same place across the different forms of roleplaying?

As a roleplayer, András argued that "protection is unrealistic", which is why he plays on a PvP server and enjoys PvP in EVE Online: in a realistic world there is no boundary marked "player character". Fine. I asked him when he had last charged into a few settlements where attacking NPC guards would have got him slaughtered. When he had gone somewhere in EVE Online with lots of tough NPC ships. I also asked about attacking plenty of random NPCs. His arguments about whom his character would attack on sight suddenly did not hold true for NPCs, especially when the reward was not worth it.

"Dear Bandi, you are such a great roleplayer that, in your world, people's levels and whether they are player characters float above their heads in two-metre letters. Maybe even their loot tables." That inevitably became my opinion. If someone cites varied combat and challenge rather than roleplaying considerations, I understand PvP. Provided challenge and enjoyment really are the aim, rather than merely harassing the smaller and weaker without any challenge.

Someone wanted PvP in forum roleplaying, mostly on sites without character sheets or a proper system, where he thought his backstory made him stronger and therefore entitled him to screw up someone else's game. He was no more enthusiastic about the administrator's suggestion that he could be a butcher against NPCs in an adventure than about the site's team opening a thread for the scene where he would be hunted down for his murders. From that perspective, what seemed to matter was not credibility or an opportunity to roleplay, but being able to act like an arsehole with impunity.

And less work had gone into the little powergamer junior he had invented than into the characters he wanted to slaughter. Even those, I would say, were one-dimensional characters without a story, geared only towards romance and sex scenes. Nor was it a case of his character being a bastard and him roleplaying that, consequences included. He simply wanted to wreck things without consequences. Challenge, combat and plenty of other story elements would work against NPCs too, but for some reason signing up for an adventure offering more possibilities never appeals to those who miss PvP but not adventures. And of course the death of their own character, throwing away the work invested in a backstory, is immediately a different matter from the death of a weaker character they can beat in PvP. You can also be sure that PvP only happens when they can be certain of winning.

Someone explained, in the context of tabletop roleplaying, why these boundaries supposedly damage roleplaying. In his view. But it is also true that, if the character concept was clearly agreed during character creation, including that he should bring a character for whom PvP would not arise, yet he wants PvP without any substantial change, there are two possibilities... Either he has not brought the agreed character, or he is not roleplaying the character he brought. Neither situation is about freedom to roleplay. If you accept a party as a game master, a basic consideration is that PvP should not arise after a few hours of play. Otherwise all the work invested is simply thrown away.

If PvP would become part of portraying the character early on, or someone would give cause for it early, that is a problem. Yes, sometimes it comes from "out-of-character" motivation, because the player knows that another PC is a witch, for example. Bringing in out-of-character information is hardly the pinnacle of roleplaying either, is it? But he appeals to what his character would do... And when he starts explaining what he would do to whom, the only thing wrong is that he cites nothing but things his character would not know. 

If a character starts changing in a direction that would make PvP realistic, banning PvP is not the first step I take as game master. I merely point out that the character will now also have enemies outside the party who are not enemies of the party as a whole. If the character would initiate PvP, those opponents can eliminate them too; they need not encounter rigid, unrealistic boundaries. Yes: if four people in a party of five change, making the fifth a PvP target, all four characters can be slaughtered.

If, on the other hand, the changing character would be the victim lynched by the others, I have a chance to write them out through play. Compatibility with the party thus remains a condition of taking part in the game.

Why? Because in most cases people who would be willing to kill each other would presumably not seek one another's company for teamwork and adventuring together. Those two things do not necessarily fit within the same character, and anyone who ignores that is not roleplaying their character. At the same time, another important roleplaying consideration is that characters who could realistically adventure together should be able to share a game, regardless of game balance. Many are pleased that this means balance is not a requirement; some would head towards PvP against the weaker characters, naturally discarding the concept while invoking roleplaying.

And you can count on this too: when it turns out that he was the weaker one after all, and that becomes clear without any GM intervention, the player pushing PvP and hoping to exploit the lack of balance will be the first to cry that the GM let him get beaten, that there was no balance, ugh, powergaming... A party of characters at different levels, sometimes even a master–apprentice relationship, is an important part of roleplaying. Given the considerations above, I would not necessarily sacrifice that so that "we can have balance and PvP". 

Of course, in a Cyberpunk- or Shadowrun-style world, potential betrayal and PvP can be part of the party concept. But there the situation is agreed in advance and forms part of that concept. The people who sign up for such games are not the ones who think the ideal situation is that they get to kill a player and the other person gets to endure it. Want to fight another player? Tabletop strategy games are there too. You just have to reckon with being hit back. When the first roleplaying games still had "Roleplaying wargame" on the box, the essential innovation was precisely that, instead of PvP, here was PvE: the adventure.

If there is no conflict with a particular character that your character could walk away from, and you simply "want to PvP", then, since your character does not know the difference between a PC and an NPC, pursuing PvP is not part of roleplaying either.