You were young once too... The eternal argument when someone explains why dungeon crawling is cool. The trouble is, many did not start with dungeon crawls, especially not in munchkin fashion. Another problem is that Diablo III offers what munchkin play offers, only better. Why the hell would that player start tabletop roleplaying? Meanwhile, there is a broader group nobody can accuse of being unable to read, failing to use their imagination, or lacking creativity. They play on forums, and most are girls. Calling a girl “Munchkin Steve”—Vérpisti—would be unfortunate. Even if she behaved like one. But on the surface, at least, she behaves entirely differently.

And there is a group that does not even reach forums, playing on Facebook instead. Nobody labels the topic 18+ there, and even at fourteen she can... Let us say that from Roman times, you would run not gladiatorial combat for them, but the Saturnalia festival. She is neither perverse nor some extraordinary new species. Munchkin Clara does exactly what Munchkin Steve does: enjoys herself because she feels good and cool, imagining herself in the situation. This virtual sense of achievement is the kind of play many learned minds would call self-rewarding behavior. Only while Munchkin Steve wanted to be macho like the action heroes of Vico films, Munchkin Clara wants to be cool and attractive like certain contemporary celebrities. She immerses herself and plays, then returns to real life and lives normally. A normal schoolgirl who will become a normal adult woman.

Female knight and her victimWell, dear friends, a dungeon will not attract them by offering random monsters to defeat and great treasure to gather. Neither a monster whose presence has no explanation nor a magic sword they cannot imagine the monster possessing will interest them. But if that particular dungeon is even more interesting than Fifty Shades of Grey... There is a reason the Order of Eternal Change description also winks somewhat in their direction. I know, that was a little below the belt. 

She wants to excel at something different and will seek a game providing that experience. I would not guarantee most games do. But do you know what we can offer? The role of a woman whose deeds, adventures, sharp tongue, and cunning make her attractive and dangerous, a kind of femme fatale. The knightly order mentioned above concerns this too. You can say our piece “The Wanderer” is not a short story, is incomplete without the adventure behind it, and surely has other faults. But they will certainly identify more easily with Alyssa, the sharp-tongued, cunning yet attractive witch, than with an emotionless killing-machine head-hunter. 

Obviously, you can say I am much more lenient toward Munchkin Clara than toward most Munchkin Steves. Partly because I have seen few Claras insisting everyone should play that way. Partly because while Steve would charge Daisy the cow crying “seven XP!”, Clara would not stage a sex scene there, perhaps making her more compatible. Her character would head toward the inn, of course, but... Third, many characters could fit beautifully alongside theirs.

Partly, too, because the character type embodied by Munchkin Steves is difficult to fit into many worlds. Even if Clara always has only one thing on her mind, fitting her into Shadowrun is easy. A university adventure fits the world, and for their young female mage, the hormonal first-year student partying every night and having numerous one-night stands is a stereotype that exists in Shadowrun too.

Likewise, M.A.G.U.S. allows a witch with the appropriate attitude who also favors quantity. We can even give them a suitable character in Star Wars without particular sacrilege: more than one Sith could have realized sexual desire is also an emotion to build upon. 

Complaining about constant erotic content, however, makes just as much sense as complaining about munchkins. It is equally true that, in time, these girls may discover and appreciate other things in roleplaying alongside somewhat one-dimensional scenes. They too start somewhere. It cannot be forced. They can be introduced to possibilities, but that primarily requires content interesting to them, whether in forums or other forms of play. They enjoy reading and need novels they may like, inspiring many kinds of characters. Eventually those characters may be not only attractive, but cunning, dexterous, or possess many other positive traits. Later, even that will cease to matter as much as the “pleasure of good roleplaying” and the recognition it earns. 

Tabletop roleplaying would work in many cases. Or chat- or voice-call-based play using a tabletop system. Why? Because the latter also requires only being online and playing... But their character does not get stuck in an adventure, and a finite amount of time suffices. The adventure happens that way, while evening flirting and so forth happen on the forum. This hybrid can work. Before you notice, those who come to love the tabletop game you run will eventually want to play around a table too. After all, “we can do it at a forum meetup,” and they may already own a rulebook.