Many people know Roll20, and many say one of its greatest advantages is that it runs entirely in a browser, saving you a few minutes of installation, for example. The trouble is that there is no free lunch here either. Meanwhile, Roll20 has earned the mocking nickname (t)Roll20, putting even its principal advantage in a different perspective. The news about it over the last few days has not been about some cool new feature, but about whom the company treated like an asshole and how, and who left it and why. Whether the company is being an asshole to you personally or you merely run into a bug or awkward feature that would have been fixed long ago if they had treated the person reporting it properly, you lose that saved time with interest.
I do not deny it. People who happily pay Apple's higher prices and see that the iPad has fewer alternatives than other devices will probably stay. Not only because there is nothing else for the iPad or switching platforms would be expensive, but because they may have grown used to this: even if the antenna is bad, the Apple product just works, and you are simply holding it wrong. A sufficiently narcissistic developer believes in their product very strongly, and can make you believe it is good as it is, even when every objective measurement says it is weak. And it is hard to say which blog's or website's arguments deserve to be taken seriously when they call solution X or Y smoke and mirrors.
As for virtual tabletop play, there were probably already people playing correspondence chess in the nineteenth century. If that approach will not work, and you choose a game from the outset and GM in a style from the outsetthat makes you dependent on a tactical map, Roll20 is certainly useful. If combat is not chaotic or dynamic, you may get the slight feeling that the characters have sat down to play chess. There is nothing wrong with that; it is simply your choice. These considerations stand against all the reasons that make you feel you would avoid this platform if there were an alternative.
And people rightly say of the Roll20 news that users can only leave a product in droves if they were using it in droves beforehand. In many respects Roll20 is not bad. It has a dice roller and chat, you can run a voice call alongside it, and of course you can share a tactical map and manage character sheets. It even understands much of many game systems. The trouble is that Roll20 is not good either.
Choosing Roll20 means creating many things there specifically for that tool. If you eventually decided, like those leaving after several years, to move on, you would have difficulty exporting all the information accumulated there. Alongside its price, you pay for it with that dependency. That is precisely why the quality of the service matters. And I really am glad that their problematic leader is no longer a moderator of their subreddit, nor are the rest of their staff, but I have two problems: there was no apology, and the same circle still provides official support.
Just as the #metoo tag brought forward victims of sexual harassment, news of people leaving prompted some to join the departures and others to bring out their own stories. And the story probably began much earlier.
The blog of the Cybersmile Foundation, supported by Intel among others, carries an interview with Nolan T. Jones, the Roll20 founder also involved in the current incident. Discussing his relationship with online abuse and harassment, he acknowledged having been a perpetrator in the past. It is unlikely that the company did not know this. The number of people coming forward with grievances could therefore be relatively high. The current conflict erupted on Reddit. The company's leader accused someone of being a previously banned user's second account. That immediately raised issues of the current false accusation, arrogance, and disregard for evidence.
But it also soon emerged that the earlier user's ban had not been justified either, and that this sort of arbitrary moderation may not look good on a forum discussing a product. Reddit, as a neutral community platform, works well when criticism of the subject is allowed too. Several people objected, which led to bans, and naturally earlier grievances and reasons for previous departures surfaced as well.
This immediately raises the point that almost everyone able to ban people from groups or websites has exercised that right and fulfilled that duty. There is a significant difference between banning a paying customer for criticism of a product or service provider, where the criticism has a basis and the accusation is, say, passive aggression, and a website run by volunteers with an explicit rule that you should behave in a way that makes it worthwhile for the admins to work on the site or group for free even with you present. In many arguments about bans, that is an important dividing line. And Nolan ended up on the condemnable side of it.
People say EA has reacted this way a few times too and cannot repair the damage because its team is too inept. Among the major figures in Hungary's roleplaying market, András Gáspár has also been accused of similar behavior. Declaring someone a banned user's second account despite all the evidence to the contrary, making accusations with zero evidence, clearly raises questions, however.
When it also emerges that he saw fit to tell others they did not need five white guys, thus judging by skin color and gender rather than, for example, the relevant subject matter, he also faces accusations of racism and sexism. This is a person whose past blemish is certainly known and whose practices the company's employees certainly see. At the company, this kind of abuse operated as normal policy.
But what conflicts led to bans?
One of the most interesting incidents described on Reddit also shows how problematic Roll20—or now (t)Roll20—is. A small mistake was made when adapting the map of an older, classic adventure module. Originally, the printed map was mostly for the GM, so it included every secret door and trap. On Roll20, all of those also appeared on the players' map, visible from the start.
Among the older incidents that surfaced was, naturally, one where starting a game only for women was considered acceptable, while excluding women arriving without their partners was not. Here the issue was a ban from the entire paid service. With a little research, it was possible to find people from a group banned on this basis. And of course, it also emerged that the subscriber in question did not see the story quite as the ban's justification presented it.
A fair question is why, if the problem were a player being a woman, they would treat women who did not arrive alone differently. Even two lesbian women could come together. The reason was simple: if the partner of the woman in the group could also be present, none of the group members would face a girlfriend's jealous argument at home. The condition "you can enjoy your hobby with your friends, provided you are not spending time with single women, or women who appear single there" is not unique.
If a condition like this cannot appear in recruitment, then under the conditions imposed by his partner—a woman—a guy could not enjoy his hobby at all. Other groups, perhaps even the unaffected members of this one, welcome with open arms the woman who had to be turned away here. Supposedly this situation is patriarchy, oppression of women, and a host of disgusting prejudices that must be fought. Ugh. Yet "we don't play with men because we know what they're like and they're all potential sex offenders" is the pinnacle of fair, prejudice-free behavior.
A company deciding on this basis may also face accusations of prohibited discrimination and sexism. But a much more serious point is that, when you choose this platform, everything you buy or create within it ties you to it. In the cases above, Nolan T. showed that his decisions are driven by arbitrariness, not decency, the law, or economic reason. And all the value tying you there can be lost. Whether it concerns quality, understanding people's circumstances, or anything else, you can easily run into their unfair practices.
The truth is that I would have reason to tell you to give Roll20 a wide berth. But arbitrariness also appears when the creators of M.A.G.U.S., one of Hungary's most popular fantasies, decide that if they fall out with a former colleague, the world changes retroactively. All the work and money countless people invested in playing on that foundation becomes irrelevant and worthless; only their personal concerns matter. When I initially tried to accommodate many of their requests, and then waited in vain at the agreed time but stayed on the following week too, I did not walk away either. I cannot expect you to say to hell with Roll20. I cannot expect it, but I can ask you to think through what you lose if you leave, and what you might lose if you stay with Roll20!