Dori Concept2 png iconPersonal horror begins when you have to confront everything you have successfully denied to yourself until then. I make no secret of the fact that several current issues prompted this subject. One is the still lively debate around Vampire 5, the question of trigger warnings appearing during tabletop roleplaying, and whether you can create character Y in system X. And of course, the opinion a roleplayer might form of the nationwide hysteria surrounding the person named in the title. The trigger warnings appearing around V5 also raise the question of what appears in play, what details we blur or skip, and what the game’s resolution hides. This brings up a particularly extreme form of roleplaying in which we get the most simplified and false picture. There is, after all, a peculiar form of live roleplaying: a celebrity plays the role life has assigned them for business reasons, to create and maintain an image. And it is often damn hard to face the fact that this image, this low-resolution and precisely therefore believable picture, is only a bubble.

Inauthenticity 1.0: What the hell has it got to do with you?

Rockstar brilliantly parodies a similar situation through one of Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas's interesting characters, O.G. Loc. Someone whose very existence depends on the image of a gangster who has done time does not run from responsibility or accountability, but tries to arrange things so that even illegal parking ends in prison. The contrast is sharp between his attempts to become famous and the world of celebrities whose fame lets them get away with all sorts of wrongdoing. Yet somehow, a substantial proportion of Hungary's gangster rappers are less authentic than O.G. Loc. And Rockstar presented him less as a symbol of authenticity than, perhaps, of inauthenticity. This character too is sketched in a few strokes, exaggerating familiar details like a caricature to create a distinctive character deliberately intended to be distinctive. Characters drawn with a few similar strokes work in D&D, World of Darkness games, and so on. His exaggerated struggle for fame resembles, in that respect, contestants making fools of themselves on Megasztár, and that makes him memorable. Perhaps they wanted to exaggerate the inauthenticity too...

The problem is simply that Rockstar's team had never seen icons like Dopeman, and I would venture that even if they had, they would not have wanted to portray this example. Dopeman's most pathetic move was not trying to enter politics, but going after fans and children who pirated his work, starting to investigate kids. That is not compatible with Rockstar, but any GM can portray similar characters. It is not just that the performance in his news show fails to fit a gangster style, which does not deal with either supposed or real theft by targeting children and interpreting—or misinterpreting—the law. Nor is it merely that a celebrity publicly taking a tough line against children makes us think that, if he drank enough, he might even find the courage to kick a two-year-old. Though that too is a characteristic trait of a character drawn in stronger lines. So is failing to understand why Majka spills the beans when it could lead to diversion into treatment—rehab—which could help, rather than after an accident or another scandal when his partner is already down.

One could spend pages listing experiences that deepen the picture, where behind the star's image we glimpse a person much harder to respect. Every roleplaying world is full of darker characters like this. Like it or not, that brings to mind several sources of inauthenticity. And this is precisely the inauthenticity a vampire with a similar past will almost certainly have to face in a personal-horror story. Before the other stories, the first line that belongs here is “What the fuck has it got to do with you? Keep your nose out.” They only harm you indirectly, so do not dare speak against them, because even answering back may be too much for these overgrown little boys. 

I do not listen to Dopeman's music. If music is playing at my place, it is usually from Spotify. I could say it has nothing to do with me, inviting “What the fuck has it got to do with you? Keep your nose out.” But it does have something to do with me. Looking at the Artisjus labels on a few storage media here, for one thing, I too paid through their price for everyone in this country to have the right to make private copies of music and films. Those royalties were welcome when more and more could be collected, since people needed memory cards for photography too, had USB drives for backing up data, and so on. When the other side of the bargain comes due and he has to deliver, it turns out he has neither the strength nor the courage to face the accompanying difficulties. Instead, he skulks, deceives people, and acts tough with children, then tried to enter politics on that basis. If he deceives everyone there, why would we trust him? 

Other people bear the consequences. If we pay for the right to copy and many are then deprived of it, more and more people will copy everything. Software, images, and articles, for example, are not covered by a blanket royalty. In many cases the tools and content needed to create an image cost money. The situation reminds me of cyberpunk: it is not theft itself that is pursued, but even supposed theft when it bothers someone important. Many people do not care about the little guy. Roleplaying creators and many beginning writers are people like you or me. Identifying with them and understanding that they receive no blanket royalties, that even the smallest purchase matters to them, that even $1 or $2 for a book offered on an honor-system basis helps them, is naturally a different situation. But even when large companies stand behind many programs, we have not paid royalties for the right to copy those either. When I no longer wanted to buy from EA, character portraits made in The Sims were replaced by a series of images made in Poser and later DAZ Studio. Neither blank-media levies nor reprographic fees enter into that. 

Nor is it surprising that when a found image or other content that could be used privately, or even on a blog, is suddenly picked up by Index, and the rights holder then prohibits republication, that piracy is not covered by a blanket royalty either. But when even uses for which we have paid royalties are pursued, many people will stop distinguishing between them and will also overlook harming poorer beginning authors, commercial use, and piracy of content types not covered by the levy. Dopeman does not feel sorry for those people, however, only for his own circle of friends with himself at its center. A potential Embrace would immediately force him to confront all of this, because this kind of playing king would not work among vampires.

Personal horror begins when you have to confront everything you have successfully denied to yourself until then. After the Embrace, you cannot simply declare yourself a tough guy in front of a thousand-year-old vampire. Frankly, World of Darkness has never been my favorite. This kind of situation seemed both important and natural: something so fundamental that its presence did not need to be listed as a special merit of a game. It seemed natural that, however roughly drawn and low-resolution our picture of many characters might be, this dimension was present. Then came Vampire fifth edition, which recognized that this is a sensitive point and potential trigger for self-deluding, conceited pricks. Either flag it as risky and ask for consent, or better yet skip it and lose this detail from the picture too. Cover a narrow strip of the image in red, because it is out of bounds.

Inauthenticity 2.0: Wealth and want

The other consideration is more interesting and more topical. A star established in the music industry rarely goes hungry during their active years, and rarely needs to let their child go hungry. It is not my place to rummage through other people's pockets, but someone who flaunts their wealth as a rapper or producer and then invokes the things their child needs is not only using that child in the dispute while acting tough toward another child like a truly pathetic worm. They are also sending a message: if income falls, it is not their luxury that will be endangered, but the child's food. Yet the expectation is interesting: a child should save their lunch money and go hungry rather than exercise the right to private copying that we have purchased. Because when the child involved cannot hit back, Dopeman is strong and brave. Such a tough guy needs no separate commentary; his decisions speak for him. 

There is just one problem with this picture. A hell of a lot of children go hungry and end up on the streets with their families because alcohol, cigarettes, and drugs take priority over their safety. And this kind of neglect is child abuse too. At present, for example, this man is speaking out in the Curtis affair and demanding to know why the celebrity in question is not getting another chance, then two more, then many more, perhaps over years. The trouble is that the victim here is not Curtis, and probably not Majka, Dopeman, or Puzsér either. “Don't be a snitch, don't inform, cover for him” is undoubtedly a fine-sounding moral lesson in certain circles, but what it actually says is that the victim should get no help and should not dare speak either, because we identify with the big shot who enjoys a life without consequences.

Majka could be a victim too, if at the umpteenth deception he did not cover for Curtis, take his side, and become complicit in deceiving others. As it is, the victims are the deceived fans, many event-organizing companies, and plenty of others for whom nobody stood up. But we can identify with the celebrity, making it easy to take his side, and that is dangerous. It is the same basis on which people defended pedophile priests, directors caught in sexual-harassment scandals, and talented American athletes who got away with gang rape in the USA because of their sporting performance: those covering for them even tried to silence the victims.

Personal horror begins when you have to confront everything you have successfully denied to yourself until then. After the Embrace, smoking, taking cocaine, drinking, and so on are harder, and the forints spent on them become easy to see. Many players squeezed financially by such spending may face this problem too. So here come trigger warnings again, and the metacommunication recommended after Vampire fifth edition. Or, better still, the recommendation is to ignore all this, so there is no need to suffer with a triggered SJW. Great suggestion: let's just cover a few more details in our low-resolution picture. Not many, and if they are at the edge, we have only cropped it a little and still have just one distracting red stripe to ignore. A few possibilities ignored because of trigger warnings in the wrong places do not yet ruin a world or a system. 

Inauthenticity 3.0: Emptiness, self-delusion, and compensation

And forgive me for asking, but can weak-willed little stars who cannot tell themselves no when it comes to drinking or drugs say no when the forbidden fruit is sex with a fan or perhaps a member of staff, and inhibitions erased by mind-altering substances also make stopping themselves impossible? How does a sketchy, inauthentic image work? Why do we believe it? Because our minds fill in the missing and poorly visible details. Our minds believe themselves and tend to discard conflicting information that seems wrong to them. The visibly pixelated picture above, completed by our minds, will seem more authentic to many people than a high-resolution one, precisely because their own minds fill it in and they have no sufficiently accurate reference. That is why the images of athletes and many other people work, making people see them as good guys and identify with them. One of the central traits in this picture will be the message that he is one of us and our hero, which makes loyalty to him seem more important than the right course proposed from outside. 

The same thing happens when politicians posing as responsible, serious people get away with all sorts of things behind a wall of silence, while we complain about the many countries where actions have no consequences. If impunity is natural, or even an accepted value, in a country, it affects the whole of society. The politician too will know that they are important, that others will cover for them, and that identification and herd mentality will matter more to their own voters than decency. What a pro-Brexit politician earns from Brexit-related stock-market movements and other people's losses can easily be invested elsewhere, insulating them from the worst consequences. But someone speaking up about that politician's trading would not be seen as protecting voters, but as betraying the secrets of a leader belonging to their group. If their loyalty to one circle is not unconditional, perhaps they will not be unconditionally loyal to us either.

Personal horror begins when you have to confront everything you have successfully denied to yourself until then. The subject above concerns not only drug use, but also so-called power rape, and points to its causes. And, of course, to a million other subjects, including politics and a long line of other perceived or real injustices. So here come trigger warnings again, and the metacommunication recommended after Vampire fifth edition. Or, better still, the recommendation is to ignore all this, so there is no need to suffer with a triggered SJW. Great suggestion: let's just cover a few more details in our low-resolution picture. Our minds can still fill in two or three covered strips without difficulty; perhaps the picture is even more believable this way, since we have hidden the worst details. 

Inauthenticity 4.0: An enemy image instead of understanding

Trigger warning! The proportion of positions held by Jews is often cited as a cause of the worldwide antisemitism preceding the Second World War. Why? Because most leaders, investors, bankers, and so on primarily trusted people with whom they shared membership of a group that also helped define their identity. A church is such a group. But so were a particular golf club, a gentlemen's club for smoking cigars, a shared favorite restaurant, a shared school, and many other little things. Even today, promotions to leadership positions are often decided not by racism or sexism, but by the connections linking the decision-maker and the person hoping for promotion. One candidate is chosen not because he is a man, disadvantaging the female candidates, but much more because he shared the boss's opinion of many unsporting incidents during the football World Cup. The boss therefore thinks they can see that one candidate's values are broadly sound, while they cannot tell with the other. 

Just as many then called Jews privileged and made unfair, sweeping accusations, a few other groups today—white people and men, for example—receive the same label, even when the law actually discriminates against them, and today's new numerus clausus goes by the name of various quotas. Naturally, one could also discuss measurable differences in performance in sport and other fields, even if that is not politically correct. Or differences in average overtime, and how retirement age affects pay scales that also reward length of service. All considerations different from the discrimination assumed by advocates of gender theory. And the claim called rape culture is countered by the claim that social norms rewarding loyalty often require covering up and becoming complicit. Meanwhile, society pursues sexual offenses and intimate-partner violence committed by women less vigorously; the existing discrimination runs against men, not women. These experiences contradict the very politically correct worldview behind V5.

Personal horror begins when you have to confront everything you have successfully denied to yourself until then. Mentioning social capital and points of social connection is sensitive for the excluded too; racism and sexism arise as subjects, while many problems have better explanations than such accusations. That makes the subject particularly sensitive for minorities pointing to similar phenomena as well. So here come trigger warnings again, and the metacommunication recommended after Vampire fifth edition. Or, better still, the recommendation is to ignore all this, so there is no need to suffer with a triggered SJW. Great suggestion: let's just cover a few more details in our low-resolution picture.

Inauthenticity 5.0: The question of social capital

Yet the apparent immunity of celebrities—even celebrities at this low level—to consequences would be an important subject for the personal horror that defines World of Darkness. So would the fact that many people reached high positions not through membership of a privileged group, but through good old social capital, belonging to a group, and helping its members. Their image, their simplified role, may say nothing about it, but what decided things could have been which team they supported and whether they understood what they saw on television. Or the fact that, as a young teenager, the character shared a hobby with a decision-maker and still has a half-forgotten skill that can be called on when needed. 

Only accompanied by a colored circle, a hand signal, and trigger_warning.mp3 blasting from Bluetooth speakers loudly enough to be heard five kilometers away could we raise the possibility that Rose, an ordinary mortal character, got her career going because, before a football World Cup, she once paid attention not to women's magazines and brands loudly promoting ways to avoid it, but to a widely reported study saying half the supporters at major matches were women. Football can be presented in a way women find interesting. Since then she has had a shared subject and more shared activities with an important boss, and the glass ceiling she previously felt over her head has disappeared. That one point of theoretical knowledge about football, and the wealth and career arising from it, are more than enough to turn SJWs clinging to their own prejudices into a triggered, hysterical problem that destroys the game. 

Few things are more hateful to an SJW than a situation confronting them with the possibility that they or people like them can also harm others, and that not all their suffering is the fault of their chosen scapegoat: perhaps they could even have done something about it. That they also lack social capital because they were the asshole.

There is another small problem here: the situation above shows why so many waves of immigration were followed by a complete failure of integration. It was not only initial social capital that was missing, nor merely that the decision-maker attended a Christian church while the immigrant attended a mosque. The sports bar was also out because of a religious ban on alcohol. Exchanging recipes was out too, since pulled pork will never be halal. The musical tastes brought from home were different, as were reading experiences and national identity. There were few points of connection and many opportunities for an us-versus-them conflict to emerge, if only over what food to serve at a company team-building event, what music can be played in a shared space, and similar questions.

This shows that society does not have to solve every problem; integration and catching up are often also the responsibility of immigrants, disadvantaged people, and so on. Demanding a new numerus clausus—a quota—like a new Nazi is not the only possible approach. One can start a business, build a company, and make shared hobbies, interests, and points of connection with oneself matter in promotions to leadership positions, allowing people to break the glass ceiling through those rather than football or Formula 1. Their own responsibility in a matter they consider disproportionately serious can badly undermine their self-esteem. That is why the SJW direction is the enemy of every real solution. Political correctness, safe spaces, and many other concepts are also bad and dangerous directions because they rule out the solution first. 

Personal horror begins when you have to confront everything you have successfully denied to yourself until then. Several things occur to me here and now. I am not popular in many places, but even I have more contacts I could ask for help than mortal characters you can put together in the Storyteller system. I also think of how one of the chief elements of the intrigue that traditionally defines Vampire is building social capital, because the Embrace erased many old relationships and many new ones will be needed. But this raises the fact that the character is losing something they could have done earlier, and through which the player themselves could open up to the world and create opportunities. That latter point is painful for many people: a trigger. So here come trigger warnings again, and the metacommunication recommended after Vampire fifth edition. Or, better still, the recommendation is to ignore all this, so there is no need to suffer with a triggered SJW. The image editor is still open in our minds, and another red rectangle goes onto our low-resolution picture, covering an important element of personal horror.

Inauthenticity 6.0: Two sides of adaptation and integration

When discussing celebrities' immunity from consequences, we often speak of a country without consequences. We see Curtis getting away with it again, held accountable neither for drug use nor for deceiving others; he will not become Curtákis in Szeged's Csillag Prison. The trouble is that every such celebrity's victims, and indeed society as a whole, bear the consequences. We bear the harshest ones when a politician does something stupid, trusting that there will be no consequences. Short-term legal and political consequences may fail to materialize, but mistakes in integration policy lead to ISIS, anti-elitism, and, among other things, Brexit, which will again have serious consequences. It is time, for example, to put aside the official optimism about Brexit. Fine, politicians loudly proclaim their hope of securing a good agreement. If little negotiation is needed, they might even meet some technical deadline. They face no legal compulsion.

The problem is that the world does not work by relocating in a day. Most companies and migrant workers assess how long moving elsewhere will take them. Migrant workers also calculate when airfares will be expensive, when many migrant workers will be sharing a reduced supply of seats, and so on. If the situation is uncertain, there is no point returning to England after a Christmas family visit and then relocating on a potentially much more expensive ticket. If they have to leave the United Kingdom, it is wiser to move home a little before the Christmas peak, when tickets are cheaper. They start watching prices for November trips in September, looking for a cheap fare and suspecting that bad news could send the price soaring.

When increasing numbers returning home are almost certain, and the loss of their remittances will hurt several Eastern European countries, British politicians hope the consequences will not arrive and those countries will be accommodating, so the EU as a whole will not be forced to take a hard line. Every affected country's leader will have a say. Do we know Viktor Orbán as someone who would be accommodating in such a situation? Everyone said it: establishing the foundations of a good agreement is easier at the start, because it is a shared interest. Every passing week and month makes it harder. And of course an agreement, or its absence, has consequences. Without a deal, there will be fewer flights on routes such as London–Budapest too. Fact: that will hurt the party district.

On the other hand, Hungary's labor shortage in that sector will ease. Some people who spoke English but not German or Spanish, for example, will take jobs at home. There will still be enough capacity for the party district to thrive. London will struggle more with far fewer incoming flights and the necessarily drastic collapse in tourism. If parts of it become run-down, it will become less attractive. Those who can still afford a cheaper European trip, however, can continue buying tickets that an Eastern European tourist might otherwise have bought. The United Kingdom's need for imports will remain. If English cheeses become more expensive than Irish or French cheeses, Europe can readily adapt.

Europe's, and many European countries', main reason for seeking an agreement was to avoid this wave of relocation affecting businesses and people, and its many costs. Once that interest is no longer on the table, the British negotiating position has deteriorated considerably. An important person's postponement of a decision has consequences just as an ordinary person's delay in paying bills does. Those consequences simply hurt voters more than politicians. As long as a celebrity associated with a particular side, team, sport, or musical style can do anything they like, they readily feel that nothing has consequences. Here, though, delay does.

We have heard a hell of a lot of Brexit scenarios. Anyone paying attention to the details will notice that they focus on which companies will be able to operate, where and how, and whether there will be labor shortages. The problem is that, although the British banking system recovered from the previous crisis, it is unlikely that every bank is prepared for substantial capital withdrawals. Yet the threat of a no-deal Brexit is more than enough for migrant workers to withdraw their money from British banks, and relocating businesses may also withdraw significant capital: from the country, but also from individual banks. If one or two of the weakest banks come under threat and begin to buckle, that could even trigger a spreading bank panic. In that situation, it is easy to think the smart person is the one who does not listen when the captain says the ship is not sinking that fast and everything is sure to be fine. 

Personal horror begins when you have to confront everything you have successfully denied to yourself until then. I imagine you have noticed the repetition by now, and the subject of integration and fitting in. But there is a problem. Fitting into vampire society is also a question of integration, as is how a static vampire adapts to a changing world. Many supernatural groups—vampires, technocrats, and so on—also raise the question of their role in steering world events, and a thousand-year-old static being will not be progressive. What it takes for granted would be banished even from literary works at universities establishing safe spaces. Integration is a risky subject in itself. So here come trigger warnings again, and the metacommunication recommended after Vampire fifth edition. Or, better still, the recommendation is to ignore all this, so there is no need to suffer with a triggered SJW. This time a red rectangle covers a fundamentally important element of Vampire, hiding the subject to be avoided.

Inauthenticity 7.0: One-dimensional nobodies

Róbert Puzsér says public shaming does not cure drug addiction. Let the illusion remain that the drugs harmed nobody. Not even the people the addict deceived because of the addiction. Nor does shaming or punishment after, say, a rape cure boys whose sporting stardom has left them without boundaries. Facing consequences for their actions does not cure a politician drunk on power. It does not cure them, only makes them paranoid, makes them concentrate even harder and take still more compulsive, bad decisions. It does not cure them because most of them cannot be cured. Someone who does not recognize they are ill and is not looking for a way out certainly cannot be cured. 

It may only protect the addict's further potential victims. It may force the addict to recognize that what they have been doing is not all right and that things cannot simply carry on as before. It cuts them off from some of the feedback saying, “This is so cool, keep it up, kill yourself with drugs.” It will not cure them. Where these effects are unnecessary, it may even be harmful to that particular addict. But someone who sees Curtis as an example, considers this life cool, and would become addicted by following it gets another opportunity to seek and follow a different path and example. For them, this is still a lifeline. Plenty of people are more respected and celebrated than Curtis, for example, and can bear it while sober. But they are usually somebodies. And when we explain who they are, the emphasis is not on the negative ending of a sentence beginning “I achieved something, but...” 

Anyone can deceive the world with an image, with the role played throughout their life, with this peculiar live roleplaying. But not themselves. That provides the reason for drug use. It also provides the reason for #metoo. People who feel they are celebrated and respected beyond their merits, and whose future is uncertain, compensate for that insecurity by proving their masculinity to themselves through violence. A politician who is a nobody behind the role will compulsively prove themselves by doing worse and worse things. A gold digger too will play games, testing the other person's loyalty and proving their own value to themselves; yet these very games, deliberately harming and exploiting the other person, begin an abusive relationship. Society is healed by not turning such people into stars, role models, and examples.

When I discussed the Storyteller system and World of Darkness with a player who otherwise liked the system, an interesting question soon arose: resolution. An article about game systems and resolution is in preparation, and I do not want to give away its point in advance. But it is a fact that an average group never raises the question that the character spent ten years fishing as a youngster, or what skill that corresponds to. Nor their electronics kit, or the tiny skills left over from many forgotten hobbies. Yet this past, these many forgotten possibilities, makes characters more alive. Each mention of one is another thing the character has lost and that can form part of personal horror. And when we see how rare vampires are, and that often one of the best really would be chosen to become a vampire, we see that these characters would have more strengths in skills and attributes too. As beginners in supernatural matters, they could have less of those, as far as I am concerned.

Personal horror begins when you have to confront everything you have successfully denied to yourself until then. This is a hot topic for two reasons. One perspective concerns the constant flame war between people who prefer higher-resolution systems and fans of systems using a sketchier picture. This kind of trigger, however, comes with no colored circle, hand signal, or blaring trigger_warning.mp3 as a warning effect. Problems belonging at the gaming table need not be addressed. Problems caused by SJW hysterics that do not belong at the table, however, must be solved by accommodating the SJWs. The possibility that another person is multifaceted and perhaps more exceptional is another trigger for some on the SJW side, as are mind games, insecurity, compensating gold diggers, a lack of variety, and other subjects. So here come trigger warnings again, and the metacommunication recommended after Vampire fifth edition. Or, better still, the recommendation is to ignore all this, so there is no need to suffer with a triggered SJW. We feel the loss again.

Perhaps seven repetitions were enough for many people to notice one small thing. A feature of personal horror is that you must encounter all kinds of things repellent and frightening both to you and to your character. Things where a trigger warning is timely. Sensitive subjects where an aspect of the historical perspective you dislike also appears. Without this there is no personal horror. We could go through more than seven examples into which I copy and paste the conclusion, and the fact that breaking down safe-space-style denial is itself one of the most important foundations of personal horror. Understanding that addresses such SJW problems. I have doubts about the design abilities of anyone who, when modernizing a system previously built on personal horror, invents signals and metacommunication tricks for these matters. 

It was never my favorite anyway...

If details offering glimpses of the past and the appropriate resolution were missing, I should note that they would have had difficulty appearing in play. For many activities, the obstacle would be not only supernatural risk but also, in many cases, an unrealistically high number of failures and botches; that makes many more passive chronicles understandable. But the “being a vampire is cool” situation arising in them still does not seem like personal horror, and in many respects the GM's invented drama and narrative still do not make the game a favorite. Losing the countless small details belonging to our lives, suddenly turning from an outstanding talent into a mediocre novice vampire, would be a form of personal horror. Losing that is why the deliberately lower resolution bothered me. But another form of personal horror is precisely when self-delusion can no longer continue, and instead of a world without consequences the Beast is at the character's heels. 

A multifaceted, living character losing everything through the Embrace, including a childhood hobby so hard to remember when writing down its single point, would undoubtedly make a valuable, deep story. But it is often preceded by the temptation to spend that one point, in desperation, on some power boost instead. If that is the aim, points can readily run short in a system with lower resolution for characters. Someone Embraced because they really were good does not always fit within it, because both resolution and talent require points. Points that many designers and GMs consider unwise to give everyone, because those who do not need the resolution would spend them only on power. Fewer points and lower resolution are a compromise in many respects. The problem is not that it is a bad compromise but simply that this small detail defeats the fanboy's claim that the freedom here accommodates everything. A realistic, attractive but complex picture with many details really cannot be put together without many house rules. 

But a nobody hyped into stardom, empty behind the image, whose image sells one good skill as an exceptional one? That can be built. When the self-delusion, mortal status, and impunity collapse, that is personal horror and can make a sufficiently dark story. And if the constructed illusions and self-delusion collapse earlier, the character's mind struggles to endure it, but the appearance of genius remains behind the madness and is amplified by the supernatural background? Malkav...

The swaggering rapper who previously hid behind a tough “gangster” role, breaks on his first day in prison, and leaves it as a Malkavian with psychological problems is an excellent basis for this. But a politician turned Ventrue or Brujah falling flat on their face is just as interesting. Or an insecure business leader whose sins would push them into the Beast's claws, while they can plainly see that their earlier successes at the company's helm were their employees' achievements and can happen without them. In this way, the fault of a player bringing an empty, one-dimensional character with no meaningful personality or background can be forged into a strength and virtue. And similar hastily assembled, stereotyped, simple characters really do lead to deeper roleplaying than the quickly assembled first-level character of a game about killing monsters and pocketing their treasure. 

It is easy to understand why someone comparing this with the worse model considers it good. But we can also see that political correctness has neatly covered up many of these possibilities. And as written, that is bad. Bad, but something you can depart from. 

The question is more about which system, and when, puts an obstacle in your path as you try to increase the resolution and find the few points needed for childhood experiences: an obstacle you can jump through GM judgment and house rules. It is about how the existence of such surmountable obstacles shapes that system's community and its expectations of the game and other players, and what stories and adventures—chronicles—are created as a result. Many say this is Hungary, where Sol's Western experiences are irrelevant. Here the book is not holy writ, and does not shape perceptions of the game so badly.

Yet I have heard countless times that the solution is to work around this by ignoring the troublesome parts, pushing them into the background or leaving them out, and how good that will be, and that every player and GM worth anything understands it. I must publicly call the fanboys arguing this way idiots, here and now. In that case, by ignoring those player needs, we would fail to satisfy at all the very needs the system currently satisfies poorly or incorrectly. The solution is house rules, optional rules, and the many other ways to depart from the rules. If a system's simplicity is meant to spare us unnecessary work fiddling with mechanics, yet a package of house rules recalculating much of the system creates that work anyway, and GURPS: Vampire, using the same setting, would provide a better foundation than VtM, then the system is not an ideal choice for those players and that purpose. Storyteller will not be a system good for everything. It has a niche in which it works. 

There are many kinds of horror

And of course it matters what kind of horror we are discussing. Horror stories really have three main directions. 

  • Stories where the protagonists are doomed. 
  • Stories where, at the end, the protagonists can say they escaped. They are survivors, but the experience will continue to haunt them. 
  • Stories where the protagonists grow and succeed by facing the horrors, rather than merely escaping.

A battle too is often a horrific scene, especially when the defenseless women of a besieged city know what horrors await them and the other side intends to demonstrate them. Medieval sieges like this forced women to defend their cities, and the titles awarded for their courage led to an order of warrior knights composed of women. Where an estate passes down the female line as a privilege, that favor was often earned by a woman surpassing her own limits in the shadow of horrors. The terrible adventure behind it is often a horror story. 

Likewise, a story built on a serial killer's horrific acts, straddling horror, thriller, and crime fiction, can create a famous detective whose reputation and career rest on the particularly horrific case they solved. Horror moving toward a positive outcome is a possibility. 

In many cases, a character facing the monster, danger, or something else within themselves and emerging stronger and perhaps at peace with themselves is also a heroic variety of horror story. In Vampire, Golconda is like this. One step on the path toward self-reconciliation for a character coming from the emptiness described above may be discovering hobbies and values they previously never noticed, whose neglect left them empty, and whose discovery can make them a fuller person. Perhaps in first edition, too, the miracles possible with a sufficiently high level of True Faith included becoming mortal again, reversing the Embrace.

Many consider this direction more adult than adventuring fantasy not because horror contains unbeatable monsters—low-generation vampires, the Technocracy—but much more because characters do not merely hack monsters down. They also face their fears, make more decisions, and have other decisions called into question. They often have to see consequences they do not want to see, make more serious sacrifices, and so forth. But even the most positive direction and story in horror contains many fears that must be faced: the trigger is there. The entire game ought to carry a trigger warning!

A short digression for my colleague Sol, and a conclusion

You can probably guess that I will also discuss the picture above, in its unobscured version, and a planned character named Angelica. When I first explain what the character is like, several things are easy to notice. For example, I have not decided many questions that usually define a character in this system. It is easy to dismiss this as not a character, at most a wishlist, because it lacks what matters most for others. Someone paying closer attention will say the personality is there, along with many events and background details that shaped the character's personality and situation into what they are. This is immediately playable in a systemless roleplaying game, and a chronicle could even be written around it. It is very much a character, not a wishlist.

Once I say not only that a character is like this or that, but also how and why they became that way, many constraints become stronger. What they know about themselves and their past becomes firmly established, while the things they themselves do not know for some reason are things I deliberately do not want to decide, even if they define many WoD characters. At most, I check whether a solution exists. If, alongside my first solution, a storyteller offers a second, third, or fourth, I note them and tell the next interested person those too. The list becomes quite long. For the details that have solutions. But many details will have no solution found for them, simply because the system itself makes little distinction between one kind of faith and another. True Faith •••○○, and we are done. It will not pay attention to hobbies over all those years, because the system and chronicles offer a resolution in which such things are mostly invisible. But when these things define a character, they are what matters. Low resolution and the system's generalizations are what make many characters hard to create. 

But let's step into SJWs' shoes for a moment. Vampire is anything but politically correct: if faith cannot heal, help, motivate, advance someone and thereby help them learn, but can only wound and harm, that is a hurtful, sweeping negative stereotype. A prejudice against which someone ought to speak. It would be easy to demand why the SJW says nothing and why the SJW author does not rewrite the system, but the answer is not hard to know. The SJW, like the drug-addicted star, is compensating. They throw tantrums so they can believe themselves to possess an openness they show no trace of, not a speck of, when encountering disagreement. And the method is not proposed for resolving many other conflicts precisely because there is no need even to pretend openness there. Being an SJW is inauthenticity, self-delusion, and pretense. 

Some characters—or initially—may respond to a more lifelike, multifaceted character with envy and rivalry, but that can readily lead to learning from a useful example and forming an alliance. A character finding their own path eventually has to fear not only the Beast, but also the unknown road ahead, the risks to be taken there, and how it makes them vulnerable. Meanwhile, things in their surroundings try to pull the characters back. They still have to hold their own in intrigue and existing conflicts, involving their new allies. Stronger opponents and raw brutality can also appear in many areas.  

I too see at least the theoretical possibility of many such stories. But there was a reason I said that numerous elements of the system influence players' expectations, chronicles, and, among other things, the situations that GMs and players become more experienced in handling. House rules can be written for any system, and new merits and flaws invented. Where there is a precedent for a cheap merit or background granting many free points, a GM can grant free points elsewhere too. The system's resolution can be improved with countless house rules, and every good GM has a homegrown solution for routinely unrealistic results. But after a point, you say it is no longer worth making this many repairs, because another system gives better results with fewer fixes. And there is a point where player preferences, themselves shaped by the system, lead people to say that changing the system to meet these needs would make it cease to be the game they are used to and like playing, and they have neither the time nor the inclination to change.

They have neither the time nor the inclination to provide a more detailed picture of their own character for the higher resolution. Nor may they have the energy for a chronicle requiring more activity and thought when they happen to have time to play. If they had the desire, energy, opportunity, and talent for it, finding a game where it works with little difficulty would not be hard. Roleplaying is not free of its own SJWs either. If someone does nothing throughout a session and receives less XP, they will find a point on which someone else can become the scapegoat: perhaps that other player has more equipment listed on their character sheet, even if it is only an old photograph. The SJW mentality ought to be curbed rather than catered to, among other reasons because it kills personal horror, the essence of the game. 

Personal horror was never taken all that seriously before either. In many respects, the image the game presented of itself was no more authentic than O.G. Loc, Curtis, or Dopeman. But the openness and fairness of the SJWs behind V5 are not authentic either. Pointing that out, however, is a serious trigger for the developer, the many SJWs, and a substantial proportion of the fans.