Many arguments raise the question of whether this or that forum roleplaying game is good because its players are basically satisfied with it, or whether it is not good after all because... This gives rise to the feeling that certain people find fault with lots of games as soon as they see an advert. Many also suspect these attacks are among the reasons so many games subsequently fail. In groups used almost exclusively as advertising spaces, there is a perennial dispute over who is the "idiot": the person pointing out the problems, or the person making the mistakes they have noticed. For many, one decisive argument is that "they enjoy themselves on the site", followed by "it is just that lots of people leave without a word; inactivity is the source of the problem". Then comes the observation that many people must be inactive because the attacks on the site have put them off.

The problem is that this interpretation approaches the issue from fundamentally the wrong direction. Quite simply, our dear player overlooks one little thing: enjoying themselves while playing with a few people on the site is usually not thanks to the site. The success comes from the concept devised together with the other player and the game they share. The question is: if the site is not, for now, an obstacle to that success, and the player is therefore happy, why do so many of us think the site is doomed? Well, partly because of mathematics. The death of these sites is practically inevitable. Players who become inactive generally do not even read the criticism and the same trend affects sites that receive no such criticism. That makes it unlikely that criticism is causing the problem.

A dilemma immediately arises, though: once someone leaves, they have two options. They can leave without a word, or say they are leaving and explain why. In the latter case, criticism of the site or its players instantly makes them the nitpicking, malicious, evil "Brainy Smurf" who must be hounded. I think it is understandable that most people do not enter into that kind of confrontation. But the other reason most leave without a word is that they do not decide they are going to disappear. It is simply... They have many characters, they have no time to write replies everywhere, and on that particular site they are a little less motivated. By the time they notice how much they have missed, they no longer have a reason to return, and they do not go back afterwards to tell people not to wait. I think that is understandable. 

And however much we might like to believe otherwise, the motivation goes first; only afterwards do they leave the site. People leaving are not the source of the problem, but merely a step in the process. That is not good news, because it makes the cause of the process a little harder to find. Where does the motivation disappear? Fundamentally, we need to recognise two possible scenarios. In one, we are looking for a satisfied player who leaves because they have achieved what they wanted on the site, and there is little new it can offer. The main way to counter this is with something new... But that does not mean a new design: it means new content, and I do not mean only new games provided by players. That leaves the site itself, its staff, needing to renew itself and provide content that renews motivation. 

The other problem is the hungry player who wants to achieve something but cannot do so on the site. Someone who was not looking for adventures, lots of GM-run content and so on in the first place is obviously not going to start complaining about their absence. What remains is that they cannot play out what they want with the characters that appeal to them, because they lack suitable partners. Nobody takes up their wanted-character requests; they struggle to find people on the site interested in the game ideas they come up with. They have participated in games important to other people's stories and may even have taken a wanted character, but existing players have no time for their ideas, and no new players arrive.

The problem is that, in this situation, the opportunity to play through things important to your character—the value on offer— depends chiefly on new arrivals. If everyone interested in the theme is already there, there will be no new arrivals. So the person whose important wanted characters have not been taken, who needs additional players for many concepts, does not get them; the site therefore fails to provide what they came for. The motivation to leave without a word is now in place. Once they leave, other players' games stall, and those players no longer get the things that matter to them on the site. They face the fact that they will remain hungry here, while elsewhere they might still have a chance of getting everything. With many stalled games and few ongoing ones, they can take that chance and become more active elsewhere... Others may close their games, but that does not lead to a much better result. 

The problem is that the site's community looks primarily to new arrivals for the value essential to the site's survival, without providing equivalent value in return. When the value a system needs to operate is supplied chiefly by new entrants, rather than generated at the top, that system functions as a pyramid scheme. People say that, apart from being illegal, a pyramid scheme is the deal of the century for those who join early. What a shame that, if they know it is a pyramid scheme and recruit for it, they can be prosecuted for fraud. But someone who simply believes that what they are involved in works, and happily recruits, may do very well out of a real pyramid scheme. Similarly, in a forum RPG operating like a pyramid scheme, early players get everything they want for a relatively long time, and then the site they find wonderful sooner or later becomes mysteriously more and more inactive, effectively ceasing to exist through inactivity. But that is just how games are. The same happened to lots of other sites; this one was good, certainly no worse than the others.

Or, put another way: those other sites were no better than this one, and would have received the same criticism. For the same reason: on the site, the value received by every player would be created by the players, rather than by the site's team. Such is life. There is another trick here: when two players play together, a reply from one advances the story only for the other. In an adventure, however, a GM's reply adds something to the story of every party member involved. When imagining the shared world requires learning many things and gathering information from many places, an hour spent on this by the staff does not "save" that same research effort for just one player, but for most of them. In other words, it produces a gain in time.

Often, when a forum game refers to a tabletop RPG or another precise setting description—wikis describing particular worlds, for instance—the information gathered by the game's developer or the setting description assembled on the wiki supplies organised content for many players and helps everyone save time. The system is that simple. Obviously, where there is a GM there can also be non-player characters; people important to the characters can enter the story without recruitment. Value introduced into the system from the top is valuable to everyone, and as long as the site's administrators and GMs are willing to put that value into the site, a substantial proportion of players have a chance to get what they want. 

Naturally, a player can also become inactive because they do not like the site after all. However, if this happens in a GM-run game, and their character can continue as an NPC, it does not drag down the other players' games with it. From that point, both renewal and sustained quality matter to the site's survival, but there are sites that work well over the long term. Of course I am not claiming that a game built on the players' shared activities cannot succeed if player numbers reach a critical mass. Then, when many old storylines end, "there will always be someone to take the new wanted characters" from within the site's own community. Or, even without wanted-character requests, someone can readily find time to adapt and fill a gap in the life of a new player's character.

Of course every site says it is welcoming. But it also says it should not have to adapt to the newcomer, and that people already have enough characters. And while there is someone to play with, the established player mostly focuses, in their limited time, on things important to them: yes, they are welcoming, but they want time left for those things too. Or, even without such an expectation, the situation will be neutral; they will neither prepare much nor adapt much. And in truth they are right, because their character cannot be this, that and the other on demand, constantly changing, learning and preparing, since then "it would no longer be the same character". They would lose what they themselves can play through and experience with that character. Always having a "roughly suitable" character available requires a roughly suitable number of players with the right interests. That requires a stable site. Which requires one of the other solutions described above.

Of course everyone knows a site that was once large enough, where they happily played with friends without so much as looking at the adventures or GMs, and they want the same thing... But the size the site needs in order to work would not come about without those adventures and GMs. We do understand what that means, don't we? Where playing with a GM and taking part in adventures is the aim throughout, however, you need rules and information about the character so that it is easy to decide what they would succeed at and what they would merely attempt. We soon arrive at tabletop roleplaying using some widespread system, but on a forum. 

Why is a forum good for this? Why is it better than chat? In what respect can it even beat playing around a table? The answer is simple: on a forum, it is easy to handle characters going in different directions and players being available at different times, while everyone has little time to spare. And before writing a reply, you may even have time to think through what your character thinks about the matter, if it is not immediately obvious.