Back in AD&D, magic items had XP values and generally required higher levels to create, which meant they should in theory have been rare. Had there not been so much random treasure that still let you roll up various things. M.A.G.U.S. works differently. Creating an item requires not an adventure or research, but magical formulae taught to the character, practised and checked by their teacher for reliability. For many reasons, the products are not made for sale. They are either disposed of or strengthen the membership. The others already have theirs, having gone through the same process, with spares too. That leaves the maker. A witch had to learn not only what she could do alone, but what she needed to accomplish within a witches' circle.

We see a world where more than one novel mentions an innkeeper replacing a protective rune or another item. Commoners far less wealthy than adventurers also possess minor, unremarkable magic items. It happens. If an innkeeper can afford runes protecting against insects with nasty bites, player characters can buy similar trinkets from the same source. If a modest inn can afford them, so can PCs. Permit me an unpleasant aside: collection sites are full of new, even more overpowered PC classes. But they lack NPC magic users competent in such things and far weaker than PCs. Attempts to weaken PCs retrospectively through magical fatigue overlook how such practitioners, including a level-zero priest knowing only one or two spells, sometimes use their modest power repeatedly without exhaustion.

The world contains more than PCs, and what we consider overpowered or not cannot be the main criterion for imagining it. 

The party started at fifth level. My character held a staff. It did not function as a wizard's staff, merely indicated that she was no apprentice but a respected magic user researching at the wizard school. It was listed under ordinary equipment, not magic items. There was a magic-item section too, however. She belonged to the department researching different methods of magic-item creation, analysing many items through varied magical experience. I admit the roleplaying opportunities of research, and magical-theory questions arising in character, interested me more than which items she obtained and what they did. I assumed they would have little meaningful effect on the adventure.

A better character takes harder jobs, making roughly every check harder accordingly, so the story changes little. This is naïve in several respects, of course. Every such situation invites a problem before the adventure even begins: the familiar a dozen somethings problem. A long equipment list makes every player ask where it all fits and how you carry it. Because it is a lot. But we are not playing World of Warcraft or another MMORPG where a needle and plate armour occupy equal space and weigh the same. A needle, thread, a few pens, chalk and a small whetstone already fill five equipment lines. If clothing has buttons or similar things that can tear off, add three or four spares. Perhaps a spoon and small eating knife too. Surely a comb. Finding a few little bits like these is easy.

We have not even mentioned that throwing them into a large backpack is unwise: a small "supplies box" helps, ideally no larger than a pencil case. It hardly weighs a ton, nor does the second box containing soap, since we are talking about a witch, plus small cosmetic pots and bottles. A third pencil-case-sized container holds little jars of tea and spices. We understand that these three boxes and their thirty or forty equipment entries would disappear at the bottom of a schoolbag-sized backpack, because they are tiny. But the human reaction comes: wow, so much, surely she cannot carry it. Since this witch likes cleanliness, she even has spare underwear, fifty to a hundred grams of bandages and other similarly dreadful burdens.

Twenty metres of hemp rope, on the other hand, is tiny, compact and practically weightless. Someone with so many equipment lines must want everything but the kitchen sink, and those little boxes are unrealistic, because someone else managed with six lines. How well supplied that person is: twenty metres of rope was insufficient last time, so now they carry forty metres and fifteen torches, but adventure naked. Fine, not naked. They wear fifteen layers of dirt, and even a badger flees their smell. No washing supplies, but carrying barely movable objects makes them a macho adventurer. Someone who also found room for soap, with such a long list, can only be a powergamer. 

In short, in many groups the chorus of "overpowered, powergaming, overpowered" is guaranteed to start over even the overpowered soap. 

Overpowered soap. In a sense, yes. Even the finest magic weapon adds less to a heroic warrior's combat values than a little grooming adds to a witch's chances of seduction. Her principal weapon may work twenty or thirty times better than her previous hopeless odds. I am not talking about a runic comb and magical soap combination. Rest assured, it matters just as much to a bard's womanising and many other activities. And as the familiar suggestion says, the clouds give an unstylish bard a hard time, so even mana depends on it. A duellist does not appreciate being considered a base, primitive nobody by their own peers because of filth either. 

Picture that witch's "study", or laboratory. Got it? That is equipment too, with a decilitre each of some thirty alchemical reagents. Here comes the multi-page list. It also needs every item she once made but no longer has reason to use: she has better, stronger versions, and the old one mattered only for passing an examination. Measured by lines, this is overpowered too. Surely it is unsurprising when I say an amulet weaker than the one currently used, lying on a shelf, changes nothing? Inheriting a magic sword slightly better than anything the whole party could buy by pooling its resources takes just one line, so its owner says, "I'm not powergaming; I don't have thirty lines of equipment." Not even soap. Now that sword is what I consider excessive. 

Yet the problem immediately appears: however worthless that long-unused amulet on the shelf, which the character would never take along, look how many magic items she has. That is why I recommend preparing at least four lists for the game master. The first contains things such as the Potion of Power, healing potions the character can brew at any time, and the indispensable Amulet of Power. Next are items the character can make one way or another and would hardly leave without. The next list covers things she certainly has realistic access to. After that comes what she would acquire against particular dangers and other considerations. You explicitly do not request everything on that last list. If you wish, a fifth can contain extra items plausibly found with the character because she might have them and someone might give them to her. 

I often say anyone can publish a supplement online, so that alone is no authority. But any supplement can also be written. Yes, we have supplements featuring the insect-repelling rune occasionally appearing in novels, manufactured by a craftsman practising applied magic. An innkeeper might buy fifty for a silver piece, protecting guests in every room for up to three days after activation. After agreeing with the game master that the supplement on such items applied, a first-level duellist had two silver pieces' worth. One hundred magic items, at first level, on a character in the warrior class group. Since Ynev's year exceeds six hundred days, this merely protected the character from most bites during the travel portions of the first few adventures in insect season. 

A player once asked: if magic, spells and magic items have so thoroughly replaced ordinary technology on Ynev, where is the wonder, the magical atmosphere? Right at the first item that cannot be reproduced or manufactured. Some reflect lost knowledge; others might be portal items. Ooh, a djinn is terribly overpowered... Well, I have a high-level character who carries something like that. She rescued a Huri, learned about the three free wishes, and replied that this still did not make the Huri a servant. If the Huri wanted to thank her, all three wishes could simply ask for mutual respect and, perhaps, a chance at friendship. Since then the character and Huri are effectively best friends forever. 

Naturally, my character invites the Huri shopping. The Huri knows she will receive many gifts, so asking anything of a good friend would be particularly inappropriate. But the proper order remains summoning, bargaining, then everything else. So she bargains hard. Sometimes the price begins at two hugs, sometimes three kisses, a dance together, or "all right, but only if I can buy you something too", before we even get to her other creative ideas. Behold the wonder: an irreproducible item, rare, valuable, irreplaceable, requiring great care, magical... The adjectives could continue. I would add unique. That Huri has a name, character and past. Stories involve her, allowing both the item and its resident Huri to underpin many relationships.

I have introduced an item with no bonus at all. It was a magic weapon because it was an aquir soul trap containing a soul. By the time the party understood... They learned to communicate with the soul, planned to free it and restore the imprisoned person to life, discover something from them and continue the story based on that soul's past. We understand that even with zero additional combat value, this is a special item, not a reproducible runed one.

Yes, we have shown that a rolled starting sum of one gold piece can suffice. But we must also recognise that characters can often have far more extensive and richer equipment. Yes, including magic items.