Rolling dice is an interesting business. Many people say that when you roll for the value of starting equipment, how “awful” it is that a bard might have just 1 gold piece. Some even add that they think the bard is a noble. Most bards, however, certainly are not nobles. The main problem is the weapon. Under the feudal system, the nobility's duty is to provide soldiers in exchange for their estates, but weapons have always been very expensive throughout history. A bard, meanwhile, has never understood either managing money or saving it, so they have surely been throwing it around. It would be highly unlikely for that to produce a substantial fortune. For similar reasons, a thief's wealth is questionable too: the guardians of the law occasionally relieve them of their painstakingly stolen possessions. There is no other class whose starting wealth could be 1 gold piece. And someone who does not decide that their Strength of 8 should become 18 because they imagined a strong character will not call that 1 gold piece 8 either.

Make no mistake: you can say that the character you rolled is not the one you imagined, and roll a new one. It is just sufficiently unlikely that the result will be an overpowered specimen. The probabilities do not change. Someone who does not want to reroll, who does not say they imagined something different, but immediately wants extra points without deductions and extra wealth without restrictions, duties or debt, deserves suspicion. The probability that they did not roll higher than they imagined in a single attribute, and cannot think of a single duty or debt to accompany their wealth—or indeed a single disadvantage—is very small. Tough luck.

As for that 1 gold piece, it helps to know that the core rulebook's prices are for buying an average-quality product at an average market. A favorable market could have let our character buy a slightly lower-quality item at a substantially lower price. So we are saying that we need to imagine the equipment of the most penniless bard, who also gets their instrument for free, and that we could spend the 1 gold piece on relatively good bargains. But what does belonging to the poorest possible adventurers as a bard mean? Say they traveled from cheap inn to cheap inn with their master. Making a living was never a problem, but because they could not afford to miss many performances, they always stayed somewhere appropriate. They do not need serious hiking equipment. They have two changes of traveling clothes, which the innkeeper is kind enough to wash, plus their performance outfit.

They need neither a horse nor a donkey. And since there was never any money for a “real weapon,” their armament consists of a knife and a walking staff. The knife would normally cost 50 copper pieces, but when all the cutlers at the fair are offering ever cheaper merchandise, a bard whose very presence brings in customers can certainly get one for 25 copper. It could be more, it could be less, but let us settle on that. The walking staff is free. A backpack can be obtained for another 45 copper, bringing us to 70. Neither a lot nor a little. A metal mirror is another 5 copper. They still need a sewing needle to mend clothes, a hook in case some daytime fishing would be nice, cards, and some sort of cooking pot. Some cloth for costumes, and soap. A few copper pieces can go on these little things, and by the time we are done, we may have spent 3 silver out of the 10. But it would be wise to leave 1 as spending money.

Can the remaining 6 silver cover a few changes of clothes that, while no match for a noble's, are still nicer than a peasant's? Easily. And the extra cloth can liven them up. Their modest magical power does not amount to much, of course; it is no formidable weapon. But like every adventurer, they resist fear relatively well, so when an opponent freezes with fear, they can still use their abilities. And in disreputable inns their knowledge of tavern brawling helps them too. Thus, according to malicious tongues, they can take on two guards. Things have been going well for them lately, too. Although they spend every bit they earn, they can often travel with caravans that even pay them for protection.

And it is still better that they learned swordplay from caravan guards than if sailors had taught them to wield a harpoon. They may have more clothes and equipment than a “whore turned bard girl from Enoszuke or Toron.” Bards like these, recently released thieves, and martial artists who care nothing for material things are the poorest characters in M.A.G.U.S. Some martial artists have never accumulated gold and do not consider it important, so 1 gold piece of starting wealth is perfectly realistic for them. And even that is only 1 gold if their starting weapon is worthless. In practice, that almost never happens.

We would certainly be surprised if a bard like the one in our example did not want to muscle their way into an adventuring party out of a thirst for adventure, or for the sake of a good story and future contacts. And they can hold their own as much as they need to. Obviously they have little equipment for surviving in the wilderness or facing the challenges encountered on adventures, but that is natural. Their richer companions can easily help them out, too. So 1 gold piece will not be too little for an adventurer to get started.

In principle, besides the thief and bard, a martial artist, sword artist, head-hunter, priest or paladin can also have 1 gold piece. But we have already discussed the poverty of martial artists. For the other classes, that 1 gold piece of starting wealth is supplemented by equipment they receive for free. Weapons, religious objects and so on relieve the character of precisely the burden of acquiring the most expensive items. Where there is no such table and you do not receive much equipment, you have to buy these things too, so much more starting money is justified. Classic M.A.G.U.S., however, gives you this equipment for free.

And a mail shirt, a good sword and so on already represent far greater starting wealth. Let us say that equipping a soldier to that standard would consume most of a minor noble's starting wealth. Buying the armor of a fully armored knight would consume a minor noble's entire income for 5–10 years. Shall we add a shield, armor and so on? And account for other family members, the starting cash already provided and so forth? We quickly reach the point where, for a knight or paladin, the noble family has already stretched beyond its means. Where are we supposed to find dozens more gold pieces? Things are quite different when everything has to be bought with money and nothing is included. There, this noble character may well have more money to spend because of their background yet still have to settle for cheaper armor. Because they cannot afford anything better.

I do not feel that the paladin's wealth is too little. Likewise, a head-hunter receives substantial weaponry, and unless they are a deserter and utterly penniless, they do not rely solely on their personal wealth on a mission: their order equips them. Against that background, 1d6 gold is not bad at all, especially since a 1 here also means the poorest possible head-hunter. A sword artist's swords are worth a considerable amount too. And a priest's wealth extends well beyond 1 gold, since besides religious objects and a holy symbol they may have weapons and armor.

The gladiator's minimum of 2 gold is again not their entire wealth. A warlock or witch, meanwhile, has no need for expensive weapons. And most witches, with due respect to the exceptions, are not spending their own money. But even this has only a 1-in-36 chance, so a total fortune of 2 gold is rare for them. A total fortune of 3 gold brings us to the warrior, fire wizard and wizard. But that requires a relatively unlucky roll: its probability is only 1 in 216. It is not very likely, and you can live much better on 3 gold than on the 1 mentioned earlier.

But in all fairness, it is worth looking at the table from the other end too. A martial artist's wealth rarely reaches the lofty heights of 5–6 gold, but that is acceptable. We also understand the thief's maximum of 10 gold. Anyone richer than that seldom needs to steal. The head-hunter's maximum wealth of 6 gold plus weaponry is understandable too. Nor are we talking about poverty in the case of priests. A bard who, despite throwing money around, can show another 10 gold's worth of odds and ends and spending money alongside a more expensive instrument worthy of being called a masterpiece must have an income fit for a noble.

The warlock's maximum wealth of 12 gold is understandable. Many of us may feel that 12 gold is too little for a witch, since witches can even include members of the high nobility. For them, that is merely a few months' or weeks' income. But such a witch does not yet control the family fortune, so her wealth consists primarily of the clothes and jewelry she is still willing to wear, has not given away, and does not find embarrassing. That can fit within this amount too.

In other words, if we rolled well for money, financial circumstances and origin, nothing prevents our character's equipment from making their noble birth believable. Even without debt—although many noble families, and sometimes rulers too, have temporarily gone into debt after a war, castle construction or the like. At such times an adventuring member of the family will hardly possess vast wealth without debts. And although many GMs would call extra equipment acquired through debt powergaming, I do not think they would say that if the money were needed for noble clothing, jewelry and so on. That could fit a witch, a bard, or plenty of other classes.

What does not fit is real estate. Ships. Carriages. Staff. Lots of vehicles. And, of course, countless little things that do not even appear on the book's equipment list. But a character like that is no longer an adventurer, partly because of their home. One of M.A.G.U.S.'s basic premises is that we play adventurers. Starting wealth is built around that, rather than a home, a private galley or savings to live off. 

But suppose someone is “half” an adventurer. A settled member of a school, with family wealth, the school's wealth, and personal wealth they can take along on adventures. The rolled starting equipment determines this last category, not the entire magical equipment of a wizard school's laboratory. You can play a richer person. But saying that what you receive is unrealistic, without even trying to fit within it, is not a nice thing to do. Especially if you are wrong and have argued with the GM about it too.