An unofficial, fan-made rulebook has appeared. Let me congratulate its creators here as well: that is a considerable achievement even if I do not like the resulting system, or many of its details. I do not like it because M.A.G.U.S. remains the most popular Hungarian roleplaying game to this day, so any system, homemade or otherwise, serves a decidedly heterogeneous group of fans. Pleasing every fan would not be easy. Anyone who started out saying “let's develop it as a community” stumbled over this. Even when plenty of people say they would join a community development project, those projects inevitably fall apart. Yet precisely this led many people to play a patchwork system with several notebooks' worth of house rules under the name M.A.G.U.S. Hulla can now play and GM in his own system instead of relying on similar spiral notebooks. Those who liked his work can switch too. This book is for them. 

Since they are not trying to sell it to me, there is no point demanding to know why, when assigning spells to skill ranks, their ordering roughly follows perceived power rather than a cumulative learning process. That serves their game; the opposite decision serves mine. This is one respect in which M.A.G.U.S. is difficult territory: I can readily point to an article in Rúna about life-path campaigns and say characters should be built up from childhood, and that many supposedly freer character creation systems fail to reflect the requirements of their orders, while someone else wants a little “action RPG” adventuring in the world of the M.A.G.U.S. novels they love.

The truth, though, is that my distrust of such “homebrew M.A.G.U.S. systems” does not even originate in these PDFs. It comes from several similar projects reaching the same conclusion: if you want to accommodate creators who can contradict you at any time, wiping out countries after a debatable supplement, then trying to do it unofficially, without them, while creating competition for them, is pointless. If you do not want to accommodate them, you can break away from the M.A.G.U.S. brand and say outright that you are creating a game that fulfills many of M.A.G.U.S.'s promises: the promises that so many official people claim were never part of the game and that run contrary to their numerous present-day ideas. 

That latter approach is, let us say, the “not-MAGUS” roleplaying game, versions of which plenty of people have started developing. Great; we can talk about those sometime. 

Hulla's system, however, soon drew a response. You can guess the kind. Promises, a few hints about the state of the official project. Great. Except I find it much harder to be pleased about this upcoming project than about Hulla's system, which otherwise does not appeal to me much. Partly because of the timing of the announcement. And partly because when people wrote over established material after certain disputes, it was not primarily the previous creator's work they damaged. I do not think it hurt those creators much. They did, however, manage to damage a consistent world and system that worked well for a GM.

Does it matter whether we are talking about the aquir being able to express anything in a sentence and have it happen, only for the capabilities of four languages to be introduced in a concept that contradicts itself within such a short span? Or whether it is credible to say a priestess of Ellana never really learns to fight when she receives better combat values than a city guard or many soldiers, and has weapon proficiency beyond the priestly baseline? Or whether a question about consistently following through on an event in play can be answered by whatever András Gáspár currently says his original idea was? That last answer tells us nothing about the continuation or the system, but apparently the past changes in this matter.

So most people have not seen a single line of the new system, and some commentators say complaining in advance is pointless. The problem is that the complaints are not about the system. They are much more about this process. And about how it will only end if people first recognize why it is bad, admit their mistakes, make peace with everyone involved—including people I would not happily sit down with either—and do everything they can to serve the community better.

Because M.A.G.U.S.'s biggest problem is not its system, but a community divided by these battles, in which many people adopt that harmful example. It is easy to see that this does not depend on exactly what the new core book contains, but does relate to how that book comes into existence. And that process has already begun. 

Another story also caused quite a stir online.

People immediately pointed out that trademark protection was involved. Fine. The lawyer commenting there and the one I consulted disagree. Let us put it this way: after seeing the situation, mine immediately asked a simple question. If using someone else's trademark on any product were prohibited, why would the law specify which products it is prohibited on? It applies to particular product types, and the situation probably differs between trademarks. That a trademark does not cover every product category under the applicable rules is almost self-evident. Apple is a trademark, after all. Yet a greengrocer does not break the law by displaying “apple” alongside the Hungarian word “alma.”

And I am not the only roleplayer who remembers first reading about some people or culture in a fantasy world. Sometimes the creator registers a trademark so another game's creator cannot steal it. Fine. A few years or decades pass, and despite the trademark still being registered, the name turns up on a yogurt bottle or another product. We share it in the group and laugh. Familiar situation? The food multinational's lawyer is not an idiot, and they are not infringing. The trademark simply does not cover every product category. Electronics, the automotive industry, and plenty of others have accidentally produced examples that make a fantasy fan or a well-read person smile. 

It is also true, though, that damaging a brand or unfairly exploiting it is generally prohibited. Whether a handmade creation like this unfairly exploits the brand is debatable, and there is no widely established case law on comparable craft use. To put it mildly, there have not been that many cases, because very few people sue craft makers when they do not compete with official products. There is an important distinction regarding copyright protection too. 

Just as Index or The New York Times can use trademarks without permission or royalties, for example in criticism, your website can do so too. And if a roleplaying game trademarks the name of a fantasy country, that does not mean the same trademark automatically constitutes infringement if it later appears on yogurt packaging. There is no competition between those products, nor any unfair exploitation, and so on. 

If your creation merely alludes to another work or offers criticism, it can be fair use even if you make money from it. Even if your critical artwork is a poster just like official merchandise. Nor does the brand-damaging effect of legitimate criticism make that use unlawful. So it is not true that you cannot use a trademark without permission or royalties, and even make money from it. Alongside criticism, critical artworks, caricature, and parody can fall into that category. An illegal substitute product cannot.  

If people buy yours as a Christmas present instead of official products bearing the D&D logo because they want something nice related to D&D, part of that is lost profit. But it is also more than that. D&D has fan-designed merchandise too, through an official licensed platform. A fan designer on that platform is just as much an ordinary person, a simple creator, as the operator of a web shop like this. They too would like to be paid for their work and afford Christmas presents, without someone undermining them with unlawful pirate products.

Because it is easy to be cheaper and offer “better value for money” when a website unlawfully uses without permission something others have to buy. Incidentally, you can read the Criminal Code about this case and ask NAV, Hungary's tax and customs authority, or plenty of other competent authorities for their position. “Infringement of industrial property rights” and “infringement of copyright or rights related to copyright” are both criminal offenses. You can believe you are too small to get caught, that this is a small country and Blizzard, Wizards, and the rest do not pay attention here. 

Using a design without even naming or asking many of the original creators, and presenting the whole thing as your own, is particularly ugly. 

That remains true even though I use purchased models and such for my own pictures. In that case the license says I do not have to name their creators. Indeed, doing so might be unwise, because their names are trademarks, and if I point to them and someone thinks their work is rubbish because I have bungled an ugly picture... Well, that would be prohibited too. Some of my own creations are available on DeviantArt and can be purchased. Staying properly licensed costs me money, and a work featuring someone's favorite monster or something similar might make a good gift too. But the pirate has no such costs, and can therefore be cheaper and offer better value than any creator in Hungary or the surrounding countries. 

That includes me, my favorite DeviantArt artists, and my friends. It is sad to dismiss this by saying they will take it down if trouble arises. 

Only two things in the story are sadder. 

One is that M.A.G.U.S. lacks comparable products for its fans. It is not just endless promises about the core book, or having to wait for novels. You cannot even order a large, print-on-demand copy of an existing M.A.G.U.S. picture to hang on your wall. The rights holder does not give a shit about fans' wishes even where minimal investment could earn money. Not one official M.A.G.U.S. item will end up under the Christmas tree. Fans are left at the mercy of pirates who are dishonest in many respects. 

The other is that I had believed for a very long time that I had no illusions left. I have experienced the worst the Hungarian roleplaying community has to offer for years, and I essentially associated it with many of M.A.G.U.S.'s official figures. I was wrong. Simply because leaving someone misinformed about a legal issue through the actions of an asshole who does not even respect his own rules can be dangerous. Those involved can suffer serious losses. If I consider continually contradicting earlier material to be deceiving the consumer—who expects a continuation of what they know, and of the values previously promised and upheld—and consider that immoral and destructive of the value of the money and work we invested, then I must consider a deception threatening even more serious harm worse still.  

We noticed it was Christmas too. We noticed there were no M*-related gift items. We also noticed that having some would be nice. But obviously, in a situation like this, if you can ask a lawyer for help—or a judge or another legal professional—you ask for advice first. Well, we were told this was not a matter of their inviting homebrew systems, supporting fan material, and so forth: this definitely required permission. And some people might even have a duty to act regarding the trademarks. Ask permission!

We decided not to get into it after all. I do not think receiving permission is impossible. Nor do I think they could not say merchandise is a great idea, thank me for mentioning it, and make it themselves too, leaving no market for a mug, folder, or other item with my rendered pictures, even with the logo. That would obviously not be a business opportunity for me, but I would still have considered it positive. The problem is that I administer a related fan group. There have been, are, and will be plenty of arguments within the community. 

It matters that the group be a home for fans of both Tuan and DV, and for those who reject both sides. And whenever Delta Vision asked for something, we naturally arranged it even if it meant extra work and difficulty. I do not suppose they would be any less supportive of a worthwhile good idea, so the only price would be that we could much less readily remain ordinary fans on our own site. That was the situation until the possibility arose of, for example, putting a holy symbol on a priest's clothing. 

The answer came immediately: that might not be so simple. Sure, the copyright status of certain texts is clear. It is also true that there is nothing to dispute about the final court ruling on many trademarks. But after all the confusion, is the legal status of every such symbol clear? They have been depicted multiple times, some for print and others for the web, so besides the rights to the basic design, individual versions may raise questions too. In the best case, for each symbol we must ask whether they can authorize it; they have to investigate, and we wait for an answer... That means time and money. It is not an “oh, why not?” proposition.

In the worst case, the symbol might have a creator behind it who feels aggrieved over previous conflicts, dislikes this or another use, and wants to sue, whether or not they are right. M.A.G.U.S. is a child of the Wild East period after which even novels had to be put on a legal footing, when many drawings looked suspiciously like catalog photographs. If a design is even partly copied, and we use that detail because it makes the symbol look right, the original creator can object too. Today they have the means to do that, and they would “not be pursuing a company that died long ago.” 

At that point, a lawyer will not be helping as a favor either.  Reaching sound agreements, negotiating terms, and checking the facts is difficult for them in that situation too. All of it costs money, and it is expensive. 

The fact is that the copyright situation of many texts and images is more complicated. Without serious efforts to bridge the divides, reprinting earlier editions for collectors for the 25th anniversary would face obstacles, just as an official ebook version or a Roll20 or Fantasy Grounds ruleset containing the books' material would. Even if 99.9% of the rights needed for a functioning M.A.G.U.S. edition are definitely in one place, the remaining 0.1% can still spring a nasty surprise at any time, even on the holder of the other rights.

The “let the other man's cow die too” mentality, instead of reaching agreement, would be unrealistic in many settings—money talks—but given the conflicts here, it would not be surprising. If a group wanting to hurt DV can sue a business partner over a product like this, there will be legal costs regardless. Even if you eventually win costs, with the other party required to pay all your lawyers' fees too, you still have to cover them in the meantime, 

And if we generally think it is a good thing when a hobby can bring in supplementary income, and regard pictures sold on DeviantArt or monetized YouTube videos as worthwhile avenues while a little money can be earned tax-free and without extra administrative burdens, then it matters to point out that this should be done lawfully.

More and more people are using the latter option. And yes, many people use other people's trademarks for profit in critical videos or videos examining a subject, such as reviews. They show games in which copyrighted visuals, sound, and so on appear. That can be lawful without separately requesting permission or paying royalties. Royalties are not required, for example, under an open license, or for logos licensed for use on systems meeting the conditions, such as d20 System. But using another person's trademark or intellectual work—where copyright matters—often requires permission. Unlawful use can have consequences under both civil and criminal law. The latter is not something to play with, even when a discussion shaped by rudeness, abuse of power, and sheer volume does not necessarily reach a legally sound conclusion.