In a closed group not focused on M.A.G.U.S., I read a surprising opinion as part of a comment: “Incidentally, I think ammund is so unbelievably terrible for M.A.G.U.S. in every respect it's ridiculous, as a player, GM, but above all as a supplement or module writer—he does terrible damage..” Fine, that is an opinion. So is what I have to put alongside it. No author without rights or official opportunities can single-handedly do serious damage to a game. If players apply reasonable source criticism to material downloaded from the internet, rubbish will not spread, and even the worst author will cause no harm. If the community cannot do that, it cannot do it without Amund either, so once again the problem is largely independent of him.
He, at least, is trying. He works, and he and his companions—the Krónikák team—put quite a lot together. In many respects, these events help the community. Nor is Amund responsible for all the problems of this kind that appeared long before his work. He is not responsible for the way so many official creative teams, including Yardain's people and some of those involved with Új Tekercsek, have spat on their predecessors. It is not his fault that private conversations keep returning to how M.A.G.U.S. was often an unpleasant experience as early as the second half of the 1990s, even when the official core book was almost lost among piles of spiral notebooks full of house rules.
When I saw a bunch of sensible people suddenly say they were putting down the M.A.G.U.S. roleplaying game but sticking with the M.A.G.U.S. card game because they liked Ynev, they had had enough. Amund and his controversial work were not a defining presence in the 1990s. Amund is not the cause of the problem, but at most a symptom. And if we look for causes, Summarium quickly comes to mind. A hell of a lot of good people put down the book because of it. Most players clutching a softcover ETK know the post-Summarium M.A.G.U.S., and that is where the tons of spiral notebooks came from too.
Summarium is the book that first states that anything can be expressed in any aquir language, then introduces a rule under which one can only break a finger, while another can break a leg too. That is how hard it tried to remain consistent with itself. But it rewrote the world's atmosphere. Elves changed from their earlier description in Rúna, as did the aquir, dwarves, Krán, and countless other things. We soon reached the point where the writing team decided what its original thinking had been back when Ynev was a world in which a few GMs at PeCsa ran different adventures.
Ooh, and aah, and wow, Summarium's elves are not such generic fantasy elves as... And out comes the AD&D reference. Well, Tolkien's elves tended toward order; many AD&D elves did so rather less. I think of the former relationship between the chief elven god and the chief dark-elven goddess, the story surrounding their daughter, and so on, and how during the story revolution you could actually explore that. The simplification and world rewriting of “D&D is about killing monsters and taking their treasure” came later, with D&D 3. At the time, racial maximums mattered in AD&D too, and much of the reasoning behind which classes were available to each race was properly supported.
Summarium's elves, by contrast, were about somehow explaining how elves forget their own language. How they can have less ancient blood than a Kránian headhunter with 1% ancient blood. The official big boys get to powergame; everyone else does not. Several concepts were neatly spat in the face. Off the top of my head, without claiming an exhaustive list, there is Rúna's article about life-path campaigns: we were supposed to be the ones who brought our characters up to the level of heroes in novels. Or the idea that, under the adventurers' Red Banner, the relatively few true adventurers—ordinary fortune-seekers do not count—are a force that shapes history, and that this banner's armies should roughly balance the power behind Ediomad's Black Banner.
But they became a nature people while remaining distant from nature. Their talent for hunting lost its rationale, and apparently they would struggle to identify with a predator even as a family member. Hunting for the good of the forest would be difficult to make work too. So they became different by force. Not good. The list goes on. The Summarium project and the “more mature” worldview intended for it were shelved. Other games introduced nonstandard elves in the meantime—Earthdawn comes to mind, for example—but did so thoughtfully.
A new edition arrived: Első Törvénykönyv. Let the martial artist who avoids weapons be trained in more weapons than the headhunter who can skillfully wield and kill with almost any implement. And never mind if, in witch magic, the book presents an ordinary person's TME of 0 as a bloody enormous obstacle. A core book does not need to be thought through.
At this point, players had five paths:
- Move over to the card game.
- Move over to another system—and many also bad-mouth M*.
- Accept this standard and operate at it.
- Try to cobble something together to fix the problems with ever more house rules and patches.
- Reject changes like these and try to remain consistent.
Since many people are enthusiastic about Summarium's atmosphere and about quite a few M.A.G.U.S. novels that everyone except their fans considers dreadful, Amund and his team serve this audience. In that context, he is entirely right that it makes no difference whether he surprises us with some idiocy or an official creator supplies the arrow machine gun or magical aircraft carrier. And unlike many authors, he leaves no doubt about the level at which he operates.
If this community swallows obvious self-contradiction and glaring stupidity from András Gáspár, Zsolt Kornya, and many other creators, there is nothing surprising about its treating online material to the same standard. Indeed, unimaginable stupidity becomes surprise and wonder here too. It is a great shame that one of the big names in Hungary's D&D community has explained why “any bullshit can become a wonder” is the right approach for a D&D dungeon, because that really leaves no reason to contrast the two systems. Incidentally, D&D does this better.
Amund's many ideas that seem forced, wild, or even destructive of the world adapt to this expectation of wonders. As I said, it makes no difference whether they come from him, András Gáspár, or Zsolt Kornya. Honestly following the third path is far better than believing, and convincing others, that the contradictions accumulating through patchwork will ever produce a good solution. It is better than simultaneously complaining that something bothers you and declaring everyone who is not bothered by it rubbish. There are plenty of examples of that too.
As for the fifth path, I think we understand why it will never become official. Why that path always requires saying: practice source criticism. Material brought in from elsewhere is no more than something you propose yourself as a player, and ideally the game master gives YOUR ideas more room, because it is you they need to satisfy, not some distant website. Others can offer at most advice and ideas. But it would be far harder to build a website that large around this approach...
Not impossible, of course. You simply have to let go of Ynev and every connection to the M.A.G.U.S. brand.