Why do we need a deliberately bad poll? And why will we need a good questionnaire on the subject? Which question could have the greatest effect on M.A.G.U.S.'s future? I would say settling the relationship between literary Ynev and roleplaying Ynev. Why must the poll be deliberately bad? Why did I decide a bad poll was the goal? Because there is a small problem. The first conspicuous thing is the qualification if you can only choose from the following; the other is leaving spelling mistakes in a poll on a platform that underlines them for me too. Why? Because even if I did everything right, someone would want to pick a fight. Either because they do not understand the group within which an average is calculated, or because they would give the game away. In that case, the lesser evil is to argue about why a Facebook poll, part of informal communication, is a different genre from a commercial enterprise's questionnaire backed by an editorial team and publisher. 

It is quite entertaining to see people who immediately defended the publisher over numerous similar mistakes now grumbling, as I hear from three or four places, that if an unedited, informal Facebook poll has the same flaws, I should never have criticised the official questionnaire's quality. Behind my back, very honourably, of course. Somehow, though, it occurs to me that when we buy something from a publisher, we are not requesting unedited fan fiction from someone who considers themselves neither a writer nor suited to writing. My criticism also mentioned that our expert editor criticises my serious questionnaires too. I correct them. An informal Facebook poll is a different genre. Surely there will be no abusive row with those grumbling behind my back if I say it is interesting to offer criticism while failing to notice these distinctions.

But the poll's greatest problem was not the typos and other things mentioned there. It was a bigger flaw that I needed to ensure was harder to spot: the poll left little real choice. The dilemma presented was a false dilemma: 

  • I should be able to play what happens in the novels, with similar characters and similar things!
  • What happens in the novels happens, so PCs cannot play through it again. A PC is only an ordinary adventurer, but can meet Ynev's heroes.
  • For an ongoing character-development campaign, the first option; for small adventures, the second.
  • There should be no connection between literary and roleplaying Ynev! The novels' stories and heroes should not affect the game!

There, you can be pleased: I have corrected the punctuation, and even included a few "so"s and other little things omitted from the poll's answers because of length constraints. All things many people commented on, forgetting the distinction above. But one thing attracted very few complaints: I had left no meaningful choice. The trick in these options is that, when looking for a good system or edition, we do not yet need to choose between them. If the system already supports characters resembling the novels' heroes and stories resembling the novels, we can decide whether the PCs play those roles, NPCs play them and can be encountered, or they do not affect the campaign. That question is for the GM and players to decide before the particular game.

What is the other alternative? Making even the littlest little aquir, which was not so extreme in the setting, impossibly powerful to GM, because encounters with such beings are reserved for novel heroes. But ordinary adventurers should not casually meet those heroes either, because that is not why the writers created them. Besides, the author has decided privately where and when they are, without making room for mere PCs. Some grumble behind my back about spelling; let them. Some do not understand that the concept of an average can apply to any group—unlike a median, which requires a criterion for ordering—and that we know whom we consider "average" within it, and can connect this with standard deviation. They can even respond with "fuck your mother", as someone did. But nobody missed one thing.

The elitist attitude that some things should appear only in the creators' works, not even as NPCs in ordinary little players' games, while the great heroes' deeds nevertheless constrain those games because the great writers say so. Everyone, even the person hurling abuse, can decide: if the familiar approach being missing from the poll did not matter even when nitpicking, is that familiar approach really good? If it mattered less than a deliberately retained spelling error because this direction is unimportant to you, while others care about the other directions, does M.A.G.U.S.'s future lie here?

I have no further questions. For now, at least, because before a good questionnaire we need a few proposed solutions people can decide between.