I have not gone mad, but I do not think the city many consider excessively large is too big. Given how much the novels, Summarium and many supplements rework the world, Erion deserves a facelift too. It is no secret that another website is now starting to pour every idea into the city, trying to build a "shared" Erion while forgetting the need for a consistent world. But something that fails precisely to provide a consistently playable world would not be shared for many of us. Many numbers originally pulled out of thin air would remain holy writ. And with the style unchanged, the negative opinions would remain: that Erion is too large. Yet if we increase rather than decrease its size, we can still reach a point where the city is no longer "too large", and instead say: now we have reached an acceptable size. The explanation must begin far away in both space and time.

Every GM has their own Ynev, and my Ynev contains my Erion. Its wall is not a mile tall, but there is a reason people call it mile-high. Erion was already important during Kyria's golden age. At that time, many other races lived in Kyria alongside Kyrs and humans. If the Kyrs tolerated more than their own kind, it was natural not merely to tolerate other races native to Kyria alongside humans, but to recognise them as citizens. Just as Erion is now the centre of the great portal network, it was a logistical and commercial centre then, and every race and major group in Kyria needed representation there. I would not be surprised if dwarves were among its citizens. The area's outer wall is not merely a wall. It was carved from mountains, and where a mountain became a wall, a wall closed the valley too, with actual cities inside those walls. 

The work did not stop there. The largest ships naturally anchored in the bay, and there was a conventional harbour too, but even then dwarves did not build upward. They cut navigable canals into the rocky shoreline. There are sewers and plenty of other things too, of course, but the navigable canals matter, because they opened into enormous underground harbours. Warehouses, dwarven workshops. Erion as a city-state also includes many islands large and small: a harbour, particularly one this large, needs shipping routes and lighthouses to ease navigation along them. 

Some people farmed between the outer and an inner wall, but citizens with pointier ears than average also needed a district. So did their similarly pointy-eared trading partners from beyond the borders. I am not pleased that forest sprites were made playable characters, but I would point out that if they live here or in parks inside the inner walls, their settlements would form "tiny cities" within the city. The inner city wall erected by so many descriptions also matters. Here the underground warehouses connected to surface roads, and even to viaducts carrying traffic above ground. The wider roads needed for this required a wall much wider than the Great Wall of China. 

Within the familiar large districts, we know there are ethnic neighbourhoods based on "like attracts like". Many districts are partly autonomous, with guilds, streets and so on, and there are service providers too. Someone shopping on "Bladesmiths' Street", managed by the "Deservedly Distinguished Guild of Gorvikian-Erionian Smiths", may want to rest locally, because even the nearest point in the city's portal network is far away. I would certainly assume inns, taverns and other services would arise to meet that need. Someone else, however, would point out that this is not the inn district. But we should immediately clarify how the inn district functions. "Going to an inn several hours from the nearest city portal merely to sleep" would not be wise. So the question arises: what else is available there?

I am quoting my own Facebook comment. What matters, though, is that today every culture and ethnic group would be represented in Erion, alongside people who see themselves primarily as Erionian. These ethnic neighbourhoods also try to offer almost everything a major city provides. Traditional marketplaces alternate with markets functioning somewhat like "early commodity exchanges". A building may contain no apartments, only tiny rooms rented by visiting merchants, while their employees get merely a patch of straw-covered floor in a communal dormitory, because people trading cheaper goods can afford no more. Population density there will be appalling. 

There were once many parks; now more and more space inside the inner wall has been built over. The crowding includes not only surface buildings but the city extending underground. Transport is varied too. Ferries on the underground navigable canals, horse-drawn trams, heavier carriages carrying more passengers, stagecoaches, hired carriages, riding and so on supplement the city's portal network. Drinking water also arrives underground from the mountains. 

Most humans did not want to use the districts built inside either the outer or inner walls, or many underground districts. Lack of sunlight was a problem, and these places were not always safe for them. So the legends about the wall may have some foundation. What we get is not an Undermountain-scale superdungeon beneath the city, but an adventure location nevertheless. I have given no dimensions. Only described what is there, why it is there and roughly how it can be there. I have not mentioned that roof gardens on many houses can supply herbs for food, or that the harbour accommodated a substantial fishing fleet and whalers alongside merchant and naval vessels. 

Erion as a city-state is enormous. What everyone talks about is its capital, without its surrounding urban area. I could call it the "city centre", which is necessarily crowded. Since even this needs no enormous warehouses above ground, it can support a much higher population density.

The inn district brings to mind more than the inns familiar to adventurers. There is a reason legal associations are called inns in many places. Many inns were gathering places for people sharing a profession, so the inn district's functions include administration, many intellectual professions and, naturally, education alongside its chambers and guilds. Its separation from the travellers' district now makes sense. Many industries also occupy the poor district, not every part of which is equally miserable. The people operating the underground canals and warehouses live there too.

A city that seems unrealistic because of omissions and redundant, apparently unnecessary districts becomes more believable through even this small detail. 

Omit water, education, administration, industry and so much else, and you get a megalomaniacal, unbelievable Erion. Add them along the lines described above, and the city becomes larger, not smaller. Yet we move towards plausibility.