2017 08 20 2If I had to name the three gravest problems responsible for M.A.G.U.S.'s present situation, I would think of three that have far less to do with the system or setting than with the publisher and creators. We probably know the story of the not-exactly-lawfully-published Enoszuke supplement, and how several literary works subsequently destroyed Enoszuke. It is easy to call that petty, vicious revenge that also seriously screwed over players, GMs, and fans publishing their own work who liked the setting. But it is no accident that Summarium and Kornya's Krán contradict Nyul's conception of magic and his Krán either. 

Something else belongs alongside the overpowered priestess of Ellana in Papok, Paplovagok: Ellana is the goddess of infidelity and frivolity, so vowing eternal fidelity before her is foolish. The Hungarian word for frivolity, léhaság, also relates to empty, barren ears of grain. Asking a goddess of infertility for fertility while ignoring the force behind Mother Nature and her fertility is illogical and disregards the earlier situation. It just happens that the creators behind PPL did not have a particularly positive relationship with Mogorva Chei's creator. The problem is that every change driven by such personal feelings primarily screws over players, GMs, and fans. 

But behind these contradictions we can suspect more than revenge: the current official creators may also fear a world someone else understands better. If someone else lays foundations allowing anyone to understand the world better and create better work within it, that creates uncomfortable competitive conditions for them. Conditions that would require courage to face. Quite a lot of courage. In truth, though, the problem is larger and deeper.

Ellana's blessing rests on many M.A.G.U.S. creators: lately they have been utterly unproductive, unfaithful to the world, the fans, and their readers. They keep promising and stringing people along, but write little. The situation behind this does not look like Game of Thrones, where the author has plenty of related work; it looks more like barrenness. More like Ynev does not live within them strongly enough to tell a new, interesting story every day or greet a group with a new adventure every weekend.

If they do not feel they have a million and one good stories within them, a little compensation comes easily. An arrow machine gun, say, or another device intended to be cool but actually rather empty. We feel they do not trust their story to stand on its own without such tricks, and compulsively reach for something. That betrays a lack of courage and confidence just as much as unproductiveness, contradicting earlier material, and destruction do. 

Invoking a constantly changing original position instead of real arguments, hoping nobody remembers what was written in old Rúna magazines, and backing it with power also shows that the problem is not merely a shortage of arguments. The creators do not trust their vision of Ynev to be convincing either. 

Some creators left, believed in themselves, and produced new worlds and works at least as interesting as the old ones. Others stayed, but are not particularly productive in either Ynev or the world of the Hálózat novels, once described as its sibling. They lack the courage and confidence to publish extensively within the setting and compete on equal terms, without destruction. They also lack the courage to create a world in which they would feel at home and could be productive. 

If they had the courage for the latter, and we saw successful new worlds from András Gáspár, Zsolt Kornya, and the others, they could more readily give M.A.G.U.S. projects that appeal only to fans room to exist. There would be less need to contradict and destroy.