I have often heard that it does not matter if the monsters and contents of a dungeon have no explanation: that just adds to the wonder, makes it more fantastical, more, more, more... And we can list the advantages, as quite respected experts do. Certainly, if you are playing a dungeon crawl and would love to tell everyone what else you slaughtered, then the D&D 3.x approach is perfect: it has so many half-something templates that we know an enemy NPC probably has at least eighteen mothers and nineteen fathers. But when we also want to know when a character notices that something is wrong, when they begin to grow suspicious, we can either play a dice-rolling game built around the d20, or say that at some point the roleplaying wargame became a roleplaying game, so perhaps it is time for some roleplaying.
For the latter to work, though, it helps to have some idea of what is normal and belongs in the world, and what does not. I can report that we managed to fit a great many things into the adventure during play. Mostly things that could be there magically, rather than plausibly. I have seen more than one YouTube video in which someone respected, perhaps even for their own games, explains how magical this is and how wonderful. So yes, I know: when the world of D&D is completely illogical and the concept contradicts itself, that is magic, wonder, a virtue. If it happens in another game, it is a flaw and the game is shit. I know, why play with a group whose expectations differ so much? You can play something other than a dungeon crawl in D&D 5 too.
The trouble is that this kind of maaagic did not come up over how an ogre lives deep in a dungeon when it cannot even fit through the passage leading there and there is no food. The problem arose because, as in many good examples, a blocked trade route came up. Clear it, save the village: hardly a world-saving adventure. Of course, this immediately gives rise to two attitudes. One is "adventurer goes killing, gets XP and loads of trezhur", and trades the chant of letsplayalready, letsplayalready for rattling dice. The other asks: what actually came along this trade route, and might there be a detour as a precaution? Because a solution will still be needed if the expendable low-level adventurer does not come back.
We know how it goes: awe, wonder and maaagic work, anything can turn up, and who the hell would start worrying about boring things like economic geography or history instead of solving the adventure and doing the job? It is understandable that the book gaining almost core status focuses on the Sword Coast, and that providing varied adventure locations takes priority over making questions like these easy to answer. A book focused on such a small area has advantages, of course. After all, when I complain about how much lore and depth some computer RPG codices contain compared with a published campaign or many modules, 160 pages on such a small area looks like a supplement made just for me. Right up to the moment I open the book.
What a shame that some of it is about classes, backgrounds and all sorts of other things. Where there is lore, it is often sketchier too. Back in the day, when discussing a priestess of Eilistraee, we understood which two gods the goddess was the daughter of, why she had a relatively large portfolio, and how her worshippers lived. Here in this book, a substantial part of those portfolios has disappeared. The old lore is still there, of course, and plenty of content can be converted to 5E. The only problem was that our poor DM was not familiar with 2E lore. Never mind. We agreed that I would play 5E with him, we would compare it with Pathfinder 2, and then the group would play AD&D 2nd edition with me.
Although my character would ask questions and look for solutions, I let the subject go. I might not mind pushing the issue further, but it would also spoil the game for the others. We set off. We make plans. Because my character thinks the answer is not charge in and slaughter everything; we need to discuss tactics. And what matters here is not only what the character can do, but what the character believes their options are. What they learned, where and why, and many similar questions about the backstory. No explanation is needed; the character is more magical and wondrous too, even if roleplaying does not work on this point. When they levelled up, the greater balancing spell and maaagic gave them this or that ability.
I let it go. The others will think it through by next time; we will give it some thought. Even if many builds are strange, even if this is unfamiliar, something will work out, and until then there is no point spoiling the game. Let us move on. I am no prophet; I do not know that before long I will walk away from a game in another system. And even then, what bothers me will not simply be that an option official sources describe as legal and mandatory is too specific for the supposedly anything-goes game master, while he offers a character that runs into two or three explicit prohibitions and does not belong in the setting, all for a serious, roleplaying-focused game that requires a backstory. These things happen. Just because a system offers possibilities that interest me does not mean most people's expectations resemble mine. Better to let it go.
Some things are better let go, whether in D&D, AD&D, Shadowrun, M.A.G.U.S., Earthdawn, L5R, Star Wars, Game of Thrones, Rolemaster, GURPS or something else. But the very big problem here is that with a grown-up player or GM you can shake hands: not every game suits everyone, and our preferences differ. With a few systems, though, the players and GMs seem to be rationalising, as if trying to convince themselves too that their system—D&D 5, Vampire and so on—is good for everyone. And if your approach is to force it into uses it will not serve, refusing to let it go, the result is usually a bad game.
The truth is that you can let something go on several levels. First I let a great many issues go. Then something happened by the next session. There was something to discuss about Second Wind, the ability a fighter has from first level, which restores 1d10 + fighter level hit points. For example, if the hits described earlier involved actual wounds, what happens now, and why does someone else still want to heal the character even at maximum HP? Some things are harder to explain. Even something as simple as how our dwarf would acquire wizard training on levelling up during an adventure, when other people spend at least a decade studying to become wizards.
So the game continued, as it should in modern D&D. We won, next adventure, we won, another adventure. And I could be grateful that this was not Pathfinder 2. There is nothing wrong with becoming a member of a particular race during play. Shadowrun had SURGE and renewed goblinisation, and that even worked there. But in a fantasy RPG, being unable to play an elf while being allowed to play a character with elven heritage who slowly turns into an elf during the game was irritating in Pathfinder 2. We could be happy that 5E was so much better than that. And this was its direct competitor. Great: in the comparison, D&D 5 was clearly better. We put PF2 down and carried on with D&D 5.
Towards the end, I almost let a few more things go. Except that I remember why dance and song mattered to Eilistraee's faith, yet apparently Performance is not an available skill choice for either a worshipper or a priestess, because someone of that class cannot learn to dance and sing in accordance with their faith without a house rule. Why? Because maaagic, wooonder or whatever you like: of all the epic developer spells, they cast ruin roleplaying... Anyone who has played D&D knows feats are an optional rule, and I had good reason to raise many questions about multiclassing, so very few options remained for customising the character. But the places where a race truly stood out from humans by having a higher maximum had disappeared too. When the developers' idea of character customisation does not even allow a cleric to start with a skill appropriate to their faith, and one-dimensionality reigns, there is a serious problem.
All right, this is what the DM is for: saying that the rules as written, "RAW", are not what matters. And although people internationally often like to play RAW, our GM was not taking that approach here. He changed it without a problem. The skill could be taken, but that is not the issue when I judge the system and its creator. And the player was flexible too, already thinking about abilities outside the core package that could be better justified in character. The problems with these particular characters diminished, either because I let go of certain expectations, or because we let go of parts of the system by introducing house rules.
And of course we talked. If there is no levelling up during an adventure or a campaign covering a few weeks or months, and instead there is time to spend years studying between levels; if we swap a few abilities; if we change a few modifiers and maximums; if we bring back details from older editions; if... then of course this will be quite good. But after a while, the volume containing the changes would be thicker than the system itself. This is the point where, with M.A.G.U.S. too, I ask why you do not simply replace the system. I believe there are people who get enough extra from it to make even that worthwhile, and who will show me. Someone is preparing to do just that, and I do not want to discourage all that lengthy preparation, because why not? But with this group, we ultimately had to let 5E go.
Even though, while discussing the characters' backgrounds in character, I smiled when the experienced D&D 5 player remarked that this was almost like an RP server in a certain MMORPG: almost as much lore and background, almost as much room to focus on roleplaying. Great, we are making progress and improving. And there really were things it did better than Pathfinder 2. But the limited options for character customisation meant that after a while I was no longer the only one who felt the system prevented my character from being quite right. As the group became more in tune with one another, the others increasingly understood what I was missing too.
We understood the flaw and saw the limitation, but that did not get us very far. After all, I saw areas in which D&D 5 had improved, while they recognised many of the hard-to-fix elements as cumbersome and bad, so they could still reasonably consider their favourite system and edition the least bad of a not particularly good bunch. And the truth is that, however much I say which edition I reach for when I miss AD&D or D&D, I prefer Shadowrun, for example. So I had to convince them with an old system burdened by a thousand flaws, one that was not necessarily my favourite.
And there is no denying it: the rules chaos characteristic of the end of AD&D 2nd edition was also hard to master with people who had never played 2nd edition before. So in terms of the initial experience, 5th edition was good. We needed a kit as well as a class, sometimes for good reason; several nonweapon proficiencies required calculations; we talked about backstories and teachers; and in the end the character sheet became more complicated too.
Then came the 2nd-edition adventure. There were no out-of-place monsters added for variety, awe, wooonder and maaagic. The boss in the first adventure was human, in the second adventure human, in the third adventure human, and in the fourth and fifth adventures human too. And since the players somehow refuse to let go of their brand-new 2E characters, I suspect the main enemy will be human in quite a few more adventures in the near future.
Is that not boring? No. In a dungeon where we explain everything by saying it is there just because, because this is fantasy, because maaagic and wooonder, and stop asking questions, repeating the same word over and over would be boring. But when we chose a setting here, they asked which was my favourite. I thought about it. I showed them the HR series of books: Earth, but with magic and lots of (A)D&D elements. I showed them a book that sets the technological range from prehistory to distant science fiction. I showed them that, according to Chronomancer, the Ravenloft: Masque of the Red Death boxed set could serve as a reference for this world too—obviously with fantasy elements rather than referring to Ravenloft-style horror—and the answers addressing that. So we had a world very different from the familiar Forgotten Realms, and they tried it.
In this context, a human enemy offers at least as many possibilities as in historical or adventure novels, crime fiction, or Westerns for younger readers. In one adventure, a maid exploited the fact that almost nobody notices servants, much less notices that the person present is not the one who should be there. She was a poisoner exploiting this social invisibility. A Marxist. Someone enraged that successful people's advantages are reinforced by access to better education. And that, as a woman from the lower classes, she not only lacked rights but was often almost invisible. It was not even about voting rights.
It was about how, when the head of the household also votes on his wife's behalf, but representatives are allocated according to the total population, a wife's voice can still reach politics, while some people remain invisible. I could connect that invisibility with the fact that there was no witness who had seen her and identified her as the murderer. The ex-soldier character could identify the poison, and the player figured things out and solved the adventure with his fighter. On recognition checks he could receive a bonus for having served in the right place: the background I had nagged them about mattered.
There was a somewhat nastier murderer whose family had once made its living from the African slave trade. After the fortune had gone on cards and many other things, he tried invoking the plight of poor slaves to collect money for black people from wealthy philanthropists, but the circle of beneficiaries was not exactly large. When he risked exposure, he dealt with it with sufficient brutality, smashing several people's heads apart with an axe and trying to pin it on others. He had to be fought; the d20 rolled. There was an armed robber, a con artist fleecing people with fake treasure maps who would also have lured the party into a nasty trap so that there could be a dungeon crawl, and plenty of others.
The unnecessarily varied mechanics, which had initially caused the game to stumble, improved in the group's eyes not because we had to introduce house rules, but because they got used to them. They became routine, so it no longer bothered anyone that many things worked differently. They did not have to keep hunting for what a feat said and where it introduced a situation applying to characters without that feat; they did not have to cobble things together from a thousand places, and so on. After a while it stopped being a problem. But they noticed that freedom here meant more than making each of a handful of narrow stereotypes playable. Even if you start from a story and a character living in the world, instead of a class and a few written templates, you have a better chance of creating that character.
The truth is, though, that we did not have to let go of 5E completely, because the advantage/disadvantage rule could be copied to some extent and inserted as a house rule into earlier editions. If a setting description already suggests that the DM should create kits based on players' ideas, then an ability or two can be copied. We can also see here that my preferred approach does require preparation. But when there is no time to prepare and we would otherwise turn to a board game or collectible cards, the question might be whether I would rather spend money on a D&D 5 campaign than on Magic: The Gathering cards, and so on. The context is different then. D&D 5 has also produced a better competitor to the perennial classic Ki nevet a végén?, a Ludo-style board game. And of course a D&D 5 cleric is a more interesting character than Monopoly's iron token, even if the cleric cannot take the skill most important to their faith.
Before lots of board game geeks take offence that board games moved beyond Monopoly, Ki nevet a végén? and the like long ago: I know that too. But there is a reason I compared it with the "classics" everybody knows, rather than the favourites of the community that takes the hobby seriously.