I make no secret of it: I was not happy about D&D 5 being developed in the first place. I was not happy, but it did not particularly concern me either. The problem was that they wanted to reach every former and current D&D player, and I could see that at least Pathfinder fans would be hard to reach. It was also difficult to imagine easily luring back someone who had switched entirely to Call of Cthulhu in the mid-1990s. Yet every new edition brings people who swallow the marketing, believe it is good for everything and everything else besides, and try to explain that it will suit even those who moved in another direction for a reason. Twenty years before D&D 5, it was already perfectly obvious that no system suited everyone. Nor was there one that suited every former D&D and AD&D player.
So here was a system about as relevant to me as a randomly selected title among a thousand other publications I had no interest in. But I knew recruitment spam was coming, along with the arguments, abuse, and trouble it would cause in many groups. I needed D&D 5 like a hole in the head. And predictably, many people would simply ignore the markets for Pathfinder, OSR, and much else, and decide the right way to support the claim that it was “good for everyone” was to expect me to play it. To play a system that plainly did not serve my needs. D&D 5 could still have been good. But it was not, and this problem is difficult to explain without mentioning rainbow colors.
D&D really wants to be inclusive, and “every former, current, and perhaps potential D&D player” included LGBTQIA+ players too. They have not yet added P for pedophilic, N for necrophilic, or Z for zoophilic orientations. Yet if we are being progressive: they are born that way too, and being unable to live authentically with it could frustrate them too. Under the principles supposedly binding on everyone, it was difficult to hear an explanation of why they stopped there. A “barely adult” person around 19 or 20 running away with and endangering their lover is fine because they are lesbians too, but the same age difference among heterosexuals means prison. For some time, the promise has been that every official adventure, campaign, and so forth will feature the subject, an NPC of this kind, and so on.
Because D&D is about truly being anyone you can imagine. Except, for example...
Well, I need to begin the list of exceptions from three directions. Some things are not forbidden by the rules, but are not represented in adventures either, and there is certainly no intention of introducing those themes, so it is best not to try. Some things are rejected by the group and players. Some are forbidden by the rules. And some are made impossible by the rules. Let us start with the last category.
The Case of the Impossible Dwarf
When people were looking for what was iconic about D&D and AD&D, many immediately answered: our old adventures. The characters in them. In AD&D second edition, dwarves cannot be wizards for good reason, but our dwarf vowed that if Mystra healed his best friend, he would finish wizard school. They threw him out the door; he climbed back through the window. Stubborn as a dwarf. When he succeeded, he became an exceptional character, legendary in quite a wide circle. Restrictions attentive to the world and racial backgrounds can be inspiring, and often produce our best stories.
That possibility is gone. You can say the GM can be flexible, but a character will no longer be special for a reason like this. Many unusual combinations would come about because the GM allows them, rather than because the character achieves them. This route is closed. Unless we bring out good old second edition.
Dungeons & Dragonborns
Play with enough people, and you will have friends obsessed with dragons and all sorts of other things. AD&D second edition had Council of Wyrms, and D&D 3 offered many races too, albeit with ECL running wild. Among the best computer adaptations is Planescape: Torment, full of characters of decidedly unusual races. We lost these iconic things so the system could be “balanced.” We get Dragonborn instead. Admittedly, even compared with the bred drake playable under certain conditions in Shadowrun, or the half-dragons found in many places, it is a pale imitation. And suddenly the enthusiasm for handling things flexibly was not so conspicuous either.
If Draco wants to play a dragon, it will not be 5E. Good old 2E. Or 3E, perhaps Pathfinder.
Likewise, the possibility of my having a character whose Dexterity can be a little higher than the human maximum is not entertained. Like a forbidden class, that would support racial stereotypes, discrimination, and racism. Let us give up the elves' iconic Dexterity. The supposedly final rules in the last playtest were even worse. Thanks, but when I want to play such a character and bring out some version of (A)D&D for that reason, I will give up using 5E rather than my basic concept.
How I Ended Up Without a Fighter
Good old commie leveling in the name of balance and diversity. A fundamental principle. Although, if you roll your scores... if you do not choose the standard array and distribute them differently... Well, we could list plenty of cases where the balance is not so good. I thought of a fighter: a strategist and leader, not a defender-of-the-faith type, but someone who chose a military career and understood that work. Intelligence and Charisma would have been my high ability scores. Until the group began pulling faces. My primary stat would be low, my hp would be low, and I would hold the party back.
Of course. You can handle it flexibly and find an open-minded group. We did manage to try it once through Adventure League, and not just me but the other party members too. The TPK was a foregone conclusion. And many campaigns predict similar outcomes even for stronger parties, so someone saying the weaker character holds them back would be right.
Why the character is weaker, and by how much, is mathematics. Some people, of course, believe trying 5E overrides that. We can adapt, giving up plenty of available content. Earlier editions were no better balanced, of course; quite the reverse. And 3E relied more heavily on nonexistent balance, making the overall picture worse. But 2E treated balance more loosely, so I did not face this pressure as a player either.
Dilemmas and Questions of Character
What is truly good in roleplaying is being able to realize the character you imagine. We are not selecting from offered options, but bringing our ideas to life, preferably accurately. LGBTQIA+ characters belong in the world. There is no need to invoke a bogus medieval atmosphere and immediately cast the subject in a negative light. The main problem is that inclusivity has several sides. There could be a latent homosexual character who is proud of their children and has found happiness in many other things. What? That should not be included because it might offend someone's sensitivities? Interesting. Apparently some are equal and others more equal.
Back when Pillars of Eternity came out, an epitaph requested by someone who had preordered also alluded to an interesting question. What happens if, during a sexual encounter, the transgender partner conceals being transgender and says nothing about their biological sex? We know the response: even raising the question is not PC; anyone who dares ask such things should disappear. In many communities serving players and on related sites, including official channels, questions like these bring moderation and bans. The problem is that the side protecting transgender people and preaching diversity and inclusivity forgets that the other side has a right to sexual self-determination too. And that what someone can accept in such a matter touches on freedom of conscience and, where religious principles are involved, freedom of religion.
Roleplaying games can often be good precisely because they show both sides. When mantras about safe spaces and inclusivity allow some people to be offended, disregard some people's rights, fail to show everyone equal respect, and use that as the basis for erasing this subject from play, that is a serious problem.
D&D simplifies, and has various traditions of doing so. We represent characters, especially NPCs, with relatively few traits. Many values receive no representation. Again, of course, some are more equal: not everyone's dignity, rights, or values are worth the same. When it comes to the omitted subjects deemed less valuable, the feeling is not particularly pleasant. If we started saying this was not right, that too would bring moderation, because it offends the sensitivities of the more equal, while the other side's very rights are treated as shit.
People pestered me about it a lot, so I tried it without buying. But I certainly do not particularly want to play it long-term. I do not want to create content for it either, even just tokens or maps. I boycotted EA for years over unfair market conduct, but even then I did not start attacking every aspect of images one could assemble in The Sims, or its possibilities. I simply added that even if it were the world's best tool, I would not want it. And I was pleased that several much more expensive tools, some now free, were worth the extra cost.
I would not bad-mouth D&D on principle, but a hell of a lot of dilemmas and other details are missing, leaving the game with less depth. And, heaven forbid, if any developer decides the rainbow flag is indispensable, representing many other values should matter too.
Diverse & Dumb...
In the previous section I mentioned simplification in many areas at the expense of detail, depth, and content. Many people get more out of it only relative to themselves and the system, and even that is not necessarily much. Inclusivity and the demand for simplification even at the expense of quality naturally go together. Let the game be a pleasant, safe space even for people of below-average intelligence and those who are functionally illiterate. Well, content designed for that level will not hold everyone's attention.
Diversity is a business interest here. But anyone who accepts this simplification on commercial grounds must accept the rainbow flag too. D&D attempts one-sided representation in the name of diversity, rather than provoking thought. There are no multiple perspectives or dilemmas, because the people we want to reach would not understand why they matter; they remain in the safe space. The bigger problem is that surprisingly few members of D&D's development team understand the mathematics behind the system either, but they fit the diversity quota.
Well, they are in a safe space from me with 5E, and I can be safe from them by staying away from that environment when I can. The discrimination bothers me. But it is also true that there is hardly a story I am interested in that works in 5E but would not work in another system or edition with problems of a similar magnitude. In that situation, 5E would not be a rational choice even without the many limits on freedom mentioned above, even if I had no other problems with the system and could not argue against many of its solutions mathematically.
Feminism can be a subject in my favorite AD&D setting, incidentally. Admittedly, it focuses on the late nineteenth century. Although society was not inclusive, the presence of many sexual minorities can be a subject too. But there, it appears alongside many other subjects, examined from several sides, without having to show only positives in every situation. We can discuss the possibility of choice too, including the happy latent homosexual. And many other perspectives as well.