It is the season for remastering legendary RTS games. Many people say a game like this will always be criticized, because someone will think it has been changed too much, or not enough. Once again, it is damned if it does and damned if it doesn't. All these dissatisfied, stubborn fans say of Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition that it is a remaster of a remaster—there was the HD version, after all—with the usual problems, and that is only worth 8.6 points. Because the game is expensive if you do not subscribe to one of Microsoft's services. Then came Warcraft III, not even from the hated Microsoft, with better preparation and no intermediate HD version, so it ought to be better value. Besides, the original was a truly legendary game. The result? When its user rating on Metacritic was around 2.1, I did not dare write about it, because surely it would go up from there. Then someone mentioned the average at the time, around 1.9, and an article pointing to the dissatisfaction. By the time I checked, it was 1.6. And the plunge did not look likely to stop. 

I started writing in the evening: 1.3. Checked a little later: 1.2. When a 2/10 review saying "the worst remake I've ever seen" actually pulls the average up. We heard that every map had to be altered. Where does this problem begin? One of the first complaints came straight from an acquaintance who had not even bought the game. We have now reached the point where even a 1/10 rating can be celebrated for improving the current average of 0.8. I know angry users tend to tank games' ratings after release. True, but 0.8 is so low that we rarely see anything like it even for EA's worst games, given that EA's most hated game stands at 0.9. There are currently two—yes, two—PC games at 0.8. And by the time this review is finished tomorrow or the next day, that rating could still move in either direction. The problem is that if someone asked me why Warcraft 3: Reforged is a worse game than, say, FIFA 20, which belongs to an entirely different genre but sits close to it in score, I would have plenty to say. 

For one thing, when FIFA 20 came out, most people's FIFA 19, FIFA 18, and FIFA 17 did not break. Neither did FIFA 98. Remasters and enhanced editions likewise do not usually ruin the old base game. One of Warcraft 3: Reforged's greatest offenses is that, whether you bought it or not, its release broke a game that had previously worked well. The old client was discontinued and disappeared from many places; you are forced to update to the new one. And that is thirty gigabytes. Great: many people's main computer is a desktop, while their laptop has a smaller drive. But they take the laptop with them, keep a few old favorites on it, and play something when time permits. Warcraft 3 used to fit comfortably; now it needs roughly an order of magnitude more space. So this is the first case in which a reworked edition has ruined a legendary game that many people played for good reason. No one else has produced a problem like this.

The larger client is only one new development. The other is the custom game policy, about which Leonard French made an excellent video. 

Custom games, which gave birth to DOTA and many other genres, revealed that Warcraft 3 Reforged's current policy takes opportunities and rights away from precisely the creators who helped make the original game legendary. We can discuss when, how, and in what details that process took place, but this is very far from the situation in which many legendary additions were originally created. I think that is a second difference. The client's size also points to poor optimization. Obviously, with everything turned up to maximum it looks nice, but it is not a dramatic leap. Yet the game stutters at higher settings, and character animations also have few frames per second. These are objective matters, as is the fact that a hell of a lot of promises about the game remained on Blizzard's website until the last day, and then did not come true. 

Blizzard had responded to some of this, but many people encountered the fresh advertising afterward, so that seemed current. With good reason. Anyone saying that this degree of deception is alien even to EA has a legitimate complaint. But think through the situation: in many cases, the solution to the stuttering is to switch to the classic visuals. Since we get practically nothing apart from the visuals, and many people have to turn those off because of the stuttering, they received nothing for their money, while the game eats more disk space and the custom-game development scene has been killed off. After other remasters that actually delivered value, what they experience here looks pretty damn bad. They paid, got nothing for it, and even their previous game is now worse in many respects and does not work where it should.

  • Custom campaigns are missing from the old features.
  • Not only new but also old multiplayer features are missing or difficult to access.
  • Word-censor problems affect custom game names.

I repeat: these new problems have affected every Warcraft III player since Reforged's release. Someone who developed or played custom campaigns, now runs into the complete failure of that feature, and sees that the old client has been killed off too, has good reason for record-breaking outrage. And so far we are mostly talking about faults that have never occurred with any game from any major publisher before. Unique problems of record severity. What else would they justify but a record-low rating? 

So people can point fingers about the terrible trend of one zero rating after another, but I think a zero from a substantial proportion of the players affected by the above is more than justified. A great deal was never really reworked. In place of the previous graphics, which were aging well, we got something new about which even the game's supporters say only that it works, although there are new bugs and problems. That is true, as is the fact that nobody is saying how amazingly beautiful it is or how much better. In other words, the copy we previously had installed has been replaced by a larger, buggier, worse one, and even positive opinions do not describe the visual changes as a worthwhile improvement.

If you are also interested in competitive play and want maximum FPS, you will choose the classic visuals that you use if you do not buy Reforged. In that case, Reforged offers practically nothing while taking many things away from you as a player because of the problems above. Someone encountering Warcraft 3 for the first time, meanwhile, will be annoyed that zoom is still limited, that too little of the landscape is visible, that many restrictions still feel like old games, and so on. The game's optimization is not perfect either. So this is hardly unalloyed joy in that case either. After a moment of nostalgic celebration, the faults remain, while the fixes must wait. And trust in Blizzard has run out.

You can say many things about the old graphics, and debate how attractive they are or are not. But it is a fact that the models remain exaggerated and stylized in many places, and that basically looks good with the classic presentation. There is a coherent whole. The changes in the remastered graphics are not always of equal quality, and much of that unified style has been lost. That gives little basis for a positive overall impression. Even someone who did not own the original but is interested in the story and would like to try it faces technical problems, an unjustified price premium over the previous situation, and a multitude of false promises. 

The somewhat buggy state shown in the picture, where the map loads before much of the loading screen does, and the other glaring, revealing faults create an interesting situation. On one hand, patches may fix them. On the other, we do not know how long that will take. But I have an interesting question: the game stutters, and even the revamped graphics are not that good by today's standards, so why is this supposed to be good? 

2020 02 02

That does not mean the game cannot be played. If we say it is almost as good as the legendary original apart from stability, size, and hardware requirements, it is easy to say this is not a bad game, even if a truly good game would not be like this. When Warcraft III was released, it really was brilliant in many respects and advanced the RTS genre. The problem is that the genre has developed in the eighteen years since. If we assessed the gameplay today, without nostalgia, I would quickly think of how few units we can move around. And of how, for esports and competitive gameplay, two sides are often not enough, because one side can easily become dominant; three or more factions are good. 

In many cases we can mention more varied units too. But it is also true that the Warcraft series appeared in a very interesting period. Many people thought a game's story was almost superfluous. Apart from a few serious RPGs, there was often little story, and it was uninteresting. Warcraft III, however, told a story. Today, lore and story are taken for granted, even in a racing game. So yes, Warcraft III was legendary, but the intervening years have brought us to a point where we expect more. In storytelling too. The original Warcraft III would therefore not be a bad game among today's competition, but neither would it be truly outstanding. Reforged's bugs, stuttering, and other problems would lower its rating from there to below the level of mediocre games. As an expensive rehash with little new to offer, it once again cannot expect a good rating. 

The game's defenders often say this: many people asked for the campaign to stay the same, and now there are all these complaints about it. There are several problems with that argument. The first that immediately comes to mind is that the people complaining about the campaign now are not necessarily the same people who requested that then. The second is that there was an opportunity to create additional content alongside the unchanged campaign. Blizzard did not take it. We, meanwhile, have not found enough value to justify the game's price as it stands. 

We did, however, find a problem that unquestionably justifies a zero rating all by itself. That is ban-gate. What happened is easy to understand: after the false advertising, too many people wanted their money back. Many refund options are difficult to find, and Blizzard rejects many refund requests. False advertising and several other factors, however, are sufficient grounds for reversing a transaction through PayPal, a bank, and so forth because of deception. This already costs Blizzard money, but neither PayPal nor card companies like such situations. When a merchant's fraud or false advertising causes many reversed transactions, that also costs their own support teams money and can lead to termination of the contract or a sharp increase in transaction fees.

When things reach that point, two things basically happen. One is that chargebacks and similar actions trigger practically automatic account bans, because Blizzard traditionally suspects fraud when money is taken back. The thinking is someone must have paid with a stolen card, in which case stopping every subscription really is sensible. On the other hand, if mass chargebacks cause certain payment services to become unavailable, even temporarily, that also means enormous lost revenue, lost players, and new problems for the World of Warcraft cash cow. 

This is a pretty bad situation, because if they disable bans for chargebacks, plenty of people will abuse it. But if they do not disable them, the affected players have every right to swear about sanctions affecting their entire Battle.net account, especially if they read about the solution on the official forum. If posts describing this approach are then deleted and the people sharing it are banned, what we see is accounts belonging to people helping others get refunds disappearing practically automatically, with the stated reason also connected to refunds. 

We can understand a publisher's reluctance to refund after a certain amount of play, but after deception on this scale, recovering the money is justified, since numerous false advertisements remained up at release and even afterward. Blizzard acted in bad faith, so a refund is justified even if Blizzard itself refuses one. It is very difficult to assess the value represented by World of Warcraft accounts on Battle.net accounts banned after money was recovered in this way, or the damage Blizzard's conduct therefore causes. 

And that is only the smaller problem. If such bans affect a few members of a group, friends may readily join the boycott. Thus even with relatively new World of Warcraft content, some people will leave, and neither Classic nor Shadowlands will bring some of them back. Even if the bans are lifted later, this could seriously undermine the success of future games too. 

We have now reached the point where Warcraft III Reforged refunds are automatic. They will probably review chargeback-related bans too, and publicizing the new automatic refund will stop the chargeback approach spreading, and so on. So they have addressed the problem, are addressing it, and want to address it. But that is shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted.