I wondered whether this article was worth writing. The platforms' positions changed day by day, week by week, month by month. For a long time, business users could be told that malware did not really thrive on Windows Mobile versions, while Windows Phone 8.x excluded it. But that was not an important consideration for gamers or roleplayers. I would also find it hard to share this article in a programming group. Meanwhile, groups devoted to the operating system are already drowning in this subject. Then a question occurred to me: what do I say about Xbox? Kinect? Or, if the person asking is not a gamer, what will I say about Azure? Fact: if you use a Windows phone, switching is only a matter of time. Almost inevitable. Another fact: the question of switching has arisen in areas beyond phones. That last point requires an explanation.

The deciding factor is not that the platform is ending. Not long before this, many developers were still being persuaded to work with it. Plenty of development projects do not pay for themselves in two days. Then came an announcement whose message was not that products would be phased out gradually, allowing projects built on them to recoup their investment, after which the platform would reach a planned end of life, like many OS versions and other platforms. Instead, it takes effect practically immediately. A development with a five-year payback period, say, will have no devices available in years three, four and five.

Behind halting platform development lies a simplistic question: why do we need a third mobile platform? I do not know. Honestly, I do not know. I would say one was enough for me. The platform I used. Had Android, iOS or even both disappeared, it would merely have brought another Eternal September. But why do we need a fifth car manufacturer? In much the same way, I would often say there is no general need for an nth band, an nth computer game or an nth tabletop RPG system. We need the ones we use. Because they have many of the features for which we chose them.

And allow me to observe that users of these phones are not the first or only user group Microsoft is abandoning, nor would Andromeda OS be solely about this. Let us not forget traditional PDAs, or industrial applications of PDA- and phone-sized devices. Optimising for this size matters. So would being able to use the same code as on other systems without Xamarin's separate solutions or anything similar. This currently matters for business and industry, but the Internet of Things and increasingly integrated, automated smart homes will also contain devices of this size, and GSM-based communication will need support there too. Microsoft's opportunity was that, in one respect, it was not third or fourth. It had a system that worked at every relevant size and was used in enterprise environments, ATMs and many other embedded systems.

If the system serves this size well, phones follow naturally. If phones exist because of an ecosystem covering the entire spectrum and a UWP concept important at other sizes too, that completely unified ecosystem can easily be first in new areas, helping overcome UWP's app deficit. But this requires not abandoning the concept, individual areas within it, and with them the advantage of unity. Until now, Windows was present everywhere from phones through workstations and servers to many areas of industrial computing and embedded systems, and that unity enabled its move towards IoT.

The smartphone project had been running since 2003. Microsoft has now abandoned its partners. There is no guarantee that, say, ten years from now, the same will not happen to home-automation systems that people do not buy merely for ten years, and whose manufacturers would not choose Windows for only ten or fifteen years. By withdrawing from one area, Microsoft creates problems not only for Windows phone users, PDAs and similarly sized embedded systems, but also for people open to Windows 10 IoT, Windows-based home automation and a Windows-based home ecosystem. The message is also harsh and ill-considered for many connected small-business ecosystems.

We need smart tables, on which gaming is easy too, smart kitchens and smart living rooms. But if Microsoft thinks it can abandon markets after others have invested in its ecosystem, buying a Microsoft smart table for my smart home will not even cross my mind. Moreover, if Windows Mobile hobby development has burned me, I will not develop for Microsoft's smart-device platform either as a hobby or commercially. If many others burned now do the same, Microsoft has just carried its app-deficit problem into the next big thing in computing. It has shot itself in the balls in fields that have not even begun.

Which operating system I choose or do not choose is irrelevant. Generally, though, people who chose Windows 10 Mobile chose it for a reason: some feature or advantage. They then invested money and perhaps work through hobby or in-house development. They had a fundamental interest in their chosen system surviving. The other two did not matter. They did not need a second or third platform; they needed the one they chose, for the reasons they chose it. Their preferences could have been understood.

If a company has a leader who allows himself to think not in terms of such customer considerations but in terms of why a third platform is needed, and under his self-confessed incomprehension the system deteriorates and then disappears, abandoning customers, and the company does not fire that leader, we must ask: why do we need a third cloud platform? Oh, in general, without considering features or satisfied customer needs, we do not. On that basis Azure can go down the drain too, and anyone who built on it can suffer. This time it is not Azure, only Windows Mobile. But there is no guarantee Azure will not be next tomorrow. If this and some loss of trust cause anything to decline, anything could follow. That makes seriously building on any Microsoft product pointless, because you may depend on it. Depend on it while some idiot asks why we need an nth product of this kind. 

Only a small proportion of people used Windows Mobile phones, and many are dissatisfied as the system deteriorated under this kind of leadership. But the reasoning behind its discontinuation, and the handling of the whole situation, are alarming. On this question, Martin Niemöller's words come to mind:

When the Nazis took the Communists,
I remained silent,
for I was not a Communist.

When they took the trade unionists,
I remained silent,
for I was not a trade unionist.

When they imprisoned the Socialists,
I remained silent,
for I was not a Socialist.

When they imprisoned the Jews,
I remained silent,
for I was not a Jew.

When they took me,
there was nobody left
who could protest.

And this is not merely a distant danger. Market share may be around 1%, say. But that 1% was certain to be reachable on Skype. Now they will no longer be automatically available through the OS, and many must consider how many similar applications fit on their phones, while Skype's market strength faces mounting attacks. If Skype does not matter to me, it also becomes less important to people around me with cheaper phones, for whom avoiding too much software matters even more. If we start migrating away from Skype, its gravitational pull will eventually draw fewer people towards it. Making chatbots available even to small groups is a new development. 

We are a roleplaying website, so playing with people who cannot sit around the same table is hardly surprising. Our editorial team includes people in Hungary, England and Germany. Skype is an excellent tool. But lately Messenger, Viber, Discord and who knows what else have been taking off. When will some smart alec in Redmond ask, "Why do we need an nth chat application?" In that case Skype would go in the bin too, along with its contact lists, saved chat histories and everything else. It can be unstable, after all, and its market position is less clear-cut now. If I switch, however, I no longer need its bot API. Azure ceases to be the obvious choice too. A bot would be useful when we use a chat system for gaming, but given these questions, trust in Skype may no longer be unshaken. 

If Skype becomes less of an obvious choice, and we will not build things for it or use its API, and Azure therefore becomes less obvious too, I will be less likely to choose it for my hobby. If I choose it less for my hobby, work projects will also lose the little extra advantage that I already know it.

Initially I wanted to list many advantages. One that occurred to me was simple. We have already seen compatibility problems that were either deliberate or merely looked that way. Indeed, there have been cases where Google's actions broke logins or synchronisation. Everything else worked, just not the rival they were trying to squeeze out. Of course, surely these were only accidents that looked deliberate. What prevents Google from introducing a similar problem after an update, making OneDrive or the calendars and email included in business Office 365 subscriptions work badly on Android? If even a backup device capable of maintaining business continuity is unavailable in that situation, the risk can already influence our choice of cloud storage, office suite and so on.

We managed the risk of such compatibility problems ourselves when at least one of our phones was made by Microsoft. At least one: work, personal, spare. The risk was also reduced by Google knowing that, if such a fault appeared, switching between office solutions, mail systems and so on would cost more than replacing one phone with a Microsoft device that would certainly work. This possibility influenced Google too, while giving you a plan B if something accidentally or deliberately broke for weeks or months. This mattered even if you did not own a Microsoft phone but subscribed to these services. And here you expect things to work well over five or ten years.

If someone does not think users must continue receiving the things for which they chose you, but instead treats every mobile OS as identical and asks why a third is needed, we can say that person is unfit to decide such matters. But if Microsoft decides on that basis and the decision passes through its decision-making process, that is damn alarming. And it is by no means only about Windows 10 Mobile.