The truly dissatisfied customer is always the loudest. And thanks to the Internet, complaints can reach many people, including some who then feel they need to complain too. This happened with many roleplaying publications and utility programs, and it happened with Warcraft III: Reforged as well. This time, however, a new phenomenon appeared. A previously—and justifiably—hated game, Day One: Garry's Incident, has received quite a few 10/10 ratings over the last few days, and Metacritic's staff can barely keep up with weeding out the odd reviews. 10/10: not Warcraft III. It did not ruin every custom campaign, did not break all those games, did not kill an old classic, did not get innocent and in many respects good players banned from a host of other games too—because of chargeback incidents—and did not take away many players' familiar, legendary game. Arguments like these are flying around. So anything that is not Warcraft III gets 10/10. And anything better than that could even get 11/10, including FIFA 20 with its Ultimate Team rip-offs.

I was asked to join the chorus. I did not hand out a 10/10... I did, however, give it 5/10. That takes into account the fact that they did not deceive players or customers and did not cause damage. They did not break my game. It also reflects an honest attempt by an amateur who got in over their head; anyone buying something like this from a beginner cannot expect otherwise. The same is true of many tabletop roleplaying games sold as PDFs by independent developers. In that respect, this is not a unique situation, except that the tabletop roleplaying market does not have a Warcraft III Reforged. 

The problem is more that many of the 0/10 ratings we see are ridiculous. We have, however, grown used to reading about numerous subjects in one-sided articles that either condemn something or praise it. Political articles are like that too. Balanced, fair reporting is rare. The exceptions really are product tests and reviews, but even there we see little about objective advantages and disadvantages. And if many opinions are already one-sided, it is hard to write something worse. Among the emotionally charged articles comes a teacher's opinion: "I will not teach a fascist writer!" One article out of three includes a tiny fraction of the counterarguments, with isolated sentence fragments in place of reasoning.

I could say that children need to encounter bad things too, and understand why they are bad. They also need to learn how to recognize similar problems. How to distinguish good from better, and bad from worse. These would be important questions. This would mean that discussion of a generally popular game—whether we are talking about StarCraft or D&D—would not be a catfight between fanboys defending every flaw and opponents attacking even the good things. This kind of weighing-up is a skill many people ought to learn.

When you buy a game, a film, or something similar, this does not matter much. But with a car, there are differences, aren't there? And what if we approach politics this way, and the battles built on it gradually make the country unlivable? I am not thinking only of Hungary, but also of the current debate about whether Trump acted in his own interests, or whether pressing for proceedings in a corruption case primarily served the political goals for which he was elected and which he is supposed to pursue... Meanwhile, for example, many products are becoming harder to repair, more waste is being generated, and related imports from China are increasing, because the "Right to Repair" is being lost. 

The story is precisely that, for a hell of a lot of people, for a while everything is good. They blindly defend Blizzard or their favorite political party; then, once a tipping point is crossed, everything is bad. They are prepared to deceive themselves in support of either opinion, and the middle ground is missing. While the legend, and people's rationalization of their purchase, made it acceptable that Blizzard still owed players several promised features years after Starcraft 1 Remastered and had in many respects deceived the community, the company had good reason to expect the same to hold true for Warcraft III Remastered. 

Once that tipping point is crossed, though, things are different. Sacrificing the old game for shared play, wiping out years of work and the associated opportunities for the developers of many custom campaigns and other projects, is of course a historic disgrace with no previous parallel among major publishers. Personally, I waited a few days before asking for a refund, but when it became clear that some fixes were not among the things planned for the next six months, I too took the refund route. Even though Warcraft III Reforged may be an unprecedented problem in the history of major publishers, that picture can be nuanced and counterarguments can be recognized.

Just as criticism of D&D 4, Shadowrun 6, and many other games is about having crossed a tipping point. The good question is where the way back from that point lies, and how far a return is possible. D&D 5 is an obvious good example, because they managed to find the right way back through public testing and conspicuously different gameplay that offered something to everyone. But when the picture is more nuanced, some people will say they have found something else, something better, so it is no longer the automatic choice. Blizzard is not in such a comfortable position, because Diablo 4 cannot set itself against Diablo Immortal or the many things botched in Warcraft III Reforged in the same way.

A player who is not enthusiastic because of the hype but endlessly critical because of repeated disappointments, and who remembers that even the best World of Warcraft expansions have glaring faults, will readily find faults in Diablo 4 too. Confirmation bias filters out the good things and emphasizes the flaws at such times. Players share their negative experiences with one another, and this echo chamber reinforces the strongly negative mood. Now we say Blizzard's many other games were finished and polished to perfection at release, and what a shock our present experience is.

Here are a few stories, without claiming to be exhaustive, that I think we all know:

  • Some features promised for Starcraft 1 Remastered are still unavailable today, but we have already been able to buy new "cartoon" skins for it.
  • Most people thought Diablo 3's loot system was horribly botched; the expansion's release turned it into something better.
  • There was some confusion around installation keys for World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade. Many people, however, learned later than they should have what they would need to send back and how.
  • In the days of Diablo 1, bugs in the installer led many people to recommend copying an already installed copy. 

We can talk about balance, about how the precursors of many World of Warcraft problems are visible in Classic too, and about a million other problems. Fundamentally, though, as long as there are frequent pleasant impressions and people reinforce one another in their opinion bubble, building a legend around Blizzard, all these faults get overlooked. Just as many World of Warcraft fans often praise the game and call it good while they are playing, but the moment they stop playing, the old, previously denied faults come to light. 

And then came the one-sided assessment with precisely the opposite sign. 

In debates over Roll20 versus Fantasy Grounds versus the many other VTT applications, people readily say I don't care about Roll20's many scandals, adding what they themselves have not bought. Perhaps they even say that an adventure module they created would never go onto such a platform: they just throw in things they have found, so in their opinion Roll20 is great. The main problem is that other people do spend, create, and so on. You are therefore overlooking a fundamental flaw because it does not currently affect you. Except that you will not be playing with the people who avoid the platform for that reason, and when you defend Roll20 to them, you will fall out with them. It does not deserve zero points or a negative score, and we are not trashing it, but this is a huge flaw in its own right.

Just as it is a flaw that, on the other platform, another person cannot GM for free, or that you do not like installing something. It is also a flaw that the DM has to open a port, and that there is no dedicated server that can be hosted somewhere securely. And somewhere among the deciding factors will be the fact that I already have the paid ruleset, lots of adventures, and work invested in product X or product Y, and the other system's many advantages are not worth switching for. 

There is no need to switch roleplaying systems either, because the other one is not that much better and this one is not bad enough to justify switching. Fine, perhaps the other one—the system the fanboys praise to the skies—is actually worse. Perhaps there is not even a need to choose between two games. Often the rating is neither zero nor ten, but one of many similar scores somewhere in between, and sometimes tenths or hundredths of a point decide it. Because that is, in a way, what life is like.