Why might tabletop roleplaying interest a forum roleplayer? Honestly, the answer is primarily it depends. I know two basic extremes. One pitch would begin: you can play with people you do not want to play with, in ways you do not want to play. The other explanation concerns tools. Why mention the first explanation in an introduction meant to whet your appetite? Because so many forum roleplayers have experienced it that it is worth distancing ourselves from that approach. The second matters because even if you never end up around a table, this introduction can be useful for forum roleplaying too. I will not preach about which variety of roleplaying is the real thing, nor put down LARP—quite the opposite.
Tabletop roleplaying can easily start at a disadvantage. You enter Facebook's Hungarian Roleplayers' Community, ask for advice or look for a group, and a few screaming idiots tell you off: “This group is NOT about that kind of roleplaying.” Someone subsequently saying yes, it is about that too, whether forum RPGs, heavy-RP MMORPG guilds, or LARP, does little good. Later, they quote someone claiming young people today cannot read. Oddly, three paragraphs are already too much reading for him, while a young forum roleplayer enjoys reading replies longer than that. And plenty of books, of course. Then a few loudmouths appear in forum-roleplaying groups too, proclaiming tabletop systems the real thing. Besides, you need adventure; all that romance merely substitutes for it. You glance at a tabletop game and see miniatures tossed around a board, accompanied by statements on the level of “I hit him, from slightly behind, at +2.” They play a five-minute fight in five hours and a five-hour sightseeing tour in five minutes. Characters' relationships and personalities seem faint, and you say, no thanks.
These same clever people say that if someone involved in tabletop roleplaying notices, for example, how often sex is central to forum games, how kinky characters exist and there is demand for them, and wants to offer something to players who enjoy this, then instead of constructive criticism the response is “ugh, that is sexist, it will drive them away”—without any interest in what happens on a forum RPG site focusing, for example, on the lives of Las Vegas prostitutes. For recruiting you, they offer fellow tabletop players the infallible recipe: “You were young once too,” referring to recreating in roleplaying the mindless slaughter seen in Z-grade action films on yellow Vico videotapes. Meanwhile, concerning Call of Cthulhu's world, we thought today's young people were not there in the 1990s, so articles about Hungary then or technological development could help, and forcing Vico tapes into things belongs, at most, in such a description.
Roleplaying is entertainment. Everyone wants to enjoy themselves, and one of the simplest solutions is to step into someone else's skin for a while and be satisfied with that. Some would enjoy being an action hero from a Vico tape because it is impressive, provides a sense of success, and is cool... Others prefer being a high-class whore working in Dubai or Las Vegas, and therefore play prostitute-themed forum RPGs. In the latter case, “from behind” is not a combat position illustrated with miniatures on a dungeon map, promising more efficient slaughter. Even if some people find the situations in such games difficult to imagine. The next stage is feeling good not in the skin you put on, but in your own. Partly because of friends, partly because most people appreciate your play and think what you do is good. You are a respected member of a community.
One route to this is writing well. A forum roleplayer may even become a writer, often better than the person with a few published short stories who speaks up in the tabletop community to sneer at everyone. Another route is taking care with your roleplaying, creating increasingly interesting, detailed, better characters. A detailed world description helps, as does letting events and stories shape the character. Eventually you may wonder what your character would have done if you had responded in real time, prompting the other's response in turn. A lovely long reply, slowly delivered, is not always ideal. No matter. There is chat, whether on the site, Facebook, or Skype. In-character conversations, actions, and so on can happen in chat too; you have seen examples. You can write the forum reply from that afterward.
If eventually you decide that an agreed time and real-time play for a many-character adventure work better than uncertain waiting, choosing chat or a Skype call, you are already very close to tabletop roleplaying. Especially if it is a run adventure with a GM or game master. Or if the site already has a point system. Or if the game continues around a table at a forum meetup. The rules are not overly complicated? Irrelevant. You do not move miniatures? Also irrelevant. “From behind” does not mean a big attack bonus to your character? You are still close to tabletop play.
If every character is somewhere different, that is easier to manage on a forum. Waiting is less unpleasant than when a GM deals with one of six players while the rest can do nothing but wait. You can do something else, then write a reply once you receive one. But if everyone would have to wait on everyone else in multiple directions, making things so sluggish the game nearly stops? Bringing the group together, using chat, or speaking live helps.
Tabletop roleplaying has another trick. You can usually read its world description in a book. It is more detailed, often describes a world designed from the outset for good, substantial play, and fits on your bookshelf just like so many novels. Over time, a simple game and excuse to meet friends can become a serious hobby. Many then want to create their own world descriptions and rules defining characters' abilities. If a hobby-created solution interests enough people, it may even be published as a book. The difficulty is precisely that what gets published matters: taboos and perceived or real social expectations determine many things.
But I feel that a good game and its world should consider that we are no longer in the year D&D first appeared. Since then, the internet has arrived; many people play on forums, others on MMORPG servers. A publication for roleplayers would be unwise to forget that and make no attempt to reach roleplayers using certain media. But difficulties immediately arise. Sexuality is one such subject: natural in forum play, it feels alien to many people in tabletop games. In a game alternating between scenes suitable for forums and scenes played as tabletop roleplaying, the question immediately becomes more complex. Tabletop history includes many races, classes, and so forth built on sexuality. Succubi in D&D and AD&D, a possibility also raised with erinyes in second edition, and witches in M.A.G.U.S., to name just a few examples.
Or take Shadowrun's third edition, which I particularly like: pornography and prostitution both appear repeatedly, though often tied to organized crime, gangs, and the environments they influence. Mentioning the subject is hardly unprecedented. Yet many tabletop roleplayers remind me that it is different on forums, in chat, and in spoken conversation. The same girl who plays a sadistic dominatrix on a forum and smiles happily when a “kinkier executioner” appears in medieval fantasy may call an illustration in a book or on a website sexist. I think it is possible. But overlap between forum roleplayers focusing on sexuality and militant feminists reflexively crying sexism at similar subjects is very rare. Indeed, I have met several anti-feminists among female roleplayers.
But I also know a girl who runs games both on forums and at the table. In one extended game, she showed precisely how feminism that liberated women became an oppressive value system dictating that women should not be feminine because that would “objectify them,” and how it became exclusionary. Sex and politics were both subjects in her game. A tenth of it would have blown the fuses of tabletop-playing men staging mindless massacres recalling Vico-tape action heroes: sexist, indeed pornographic. Many female players create characters this way when beginning tabletop roleplaying. Once, since people hold meaningless tabletop roleplaying competitions, we attended as four girls and two boys. But all six characters were witches with different attitudes. Yes, the class that uses seduction and sexuality as tools. And yes, a witch is always female. The girls kept suggesting ways to make each character more colorful. Sexuality's role in the story could be prominent, and they often viewed kinky characters positively too. Because it was part of the story and character, rather than gratuitous pornography treating the participants as objects.
The roles of sexuality, combat, and politics, many details, and the proportion of time devoted to action and dialogue are all preferences potentially independent of whether you play around a table, over Skype, in chat, or on a forum. A game not matching your taste in these respects is not the medium's fault. But when trying a new medium, whether tabletop or chat, or a new world or rules, always try to explain what you want and what would bother you. If your group agrees on these things, the game will probably work. The boundaries between most forms of roleplaying will no longer seem sharp...