It is not good to take arguments out of a closed Facebook group. But a question raised there can be answered outside the group too, especially when the person asking is no longer a member of that roleplaying group. Answering is easy for me, since I have already given the same answer elsewhere, and now it can be linked in non-roleplaying groups too. Admittedly, their question began with a girl beaten for carrying a rainbow bag, while my answer will begin with Jews sent to the gas chambers. That was the point after which everyone ought to recognize where it leads when we set human rights aside, support extremist politics on emotional grounds, and stop thinking and weighing things up. Much of that is not open to dispute.
But the Girl Was Beaten...
However many counterarguments begin this way, there are problems, large and small. One is that we have only guesses about the motive for the beating and do not know what preceded it, so all we can do is prejudge. In such a debate, without precise information, every side can start only from its own assumptions and prejudices. Besides, my immediate response is a question: what exactly bothers you about this?
- That some people believe she was beaten because of the rainbow flag, rather than, say, a FIDESZ logo? Or a Magyar Gárda logo?
- That a woman was beaten?
- That someone was beaten for any reason at all?
From here, it is much harder to come out well. If the last thing bothers you, you know it is not about rainbows: drunken, aggressive people will beat anyone over the flimsiest pretext, the old joke about not wearing a filter-tipped hat all over again. If the first thing bothers you, you have already declared that not everyone's human dignity has equal value.
And that discrimination on your part, violating human rights, already goes hand in hand with violence and arbitrary power. When you speak of the defenseless, morality, and privilege, it probably does not occur to you that the Nazis talked about exactly these things. Jews did not follow the universal principles of the New Testament, their wealth gave them advantages in many places, and all kinds of other arguments could be listed for why they were privileged. The truth is that even if every sweeping and false accusation, including the blood libels, had been true, they could not have approached the evil committed against them. That was essentially a repudiation of universal human rights, by people who otherwise proclaimed their importance too, calling the same thing Christian values, humanism, or something else.
So when cisgender, white, heterosexual, male, or other people take the Jews' place in this kind of evil politics, someone expressing comparable hatred is not a progressive, decent activist, but merely another kind of Nazi. Only this new kind became a Nazi already knowing where such behavior leads, which makes their sins all the more serious.
In this situation, we do not know whether the trouble over the bag began with the other person striking back after the woman had been hitting them from within her own safe space, whether it was ordinary drunken aggression colored by the person's prejudices, or whether she really was beaten over the bag. Nor do we know how often, or in what way, the person who struck her had been attacked from under a rainbow flag. In that latter case, victims of extremism beating the bearer of the symbol would be just like the left beating Nazis. Many possibilities besides homophobia are in play. But arguing on the basis of prejudice would not be compatible with human rights either.
I Have a Theory...
When things are simply inserted and hammered home, the content is not trying to provoke thought. Context and depth disappear, making the whole thing less valuable and more primitive in many respects. Of course, that also makes it easier to digest. From the other direction, if easily digestible content is the goal, and you do not want the harder work of reading, thinking through, understanding, and filling things out, then thought-provoking material falls away. Alongside one-sided messages, you can beat the enemy. One small problem: this is not about human rights, tolerance, or humanism, but extremism organized around the most primitive, divisive logic of power. It makes no difference whether you stick a rainbow or a swastika on it.
But for someone whose priority is getting that message across, hammering it home instead of provoking thought, long live maximum simplicity. Dishonest but simple works on Netflix and in cinemas, often similar articles in the press, and of course simple rainbow messages. In any case, even those who practice this hammering home instead of encouraging thought invoke Nazi propaganda when discussing it.
This hammering home leaves no room for the possibility of a latent homosexual who is happy because of their family, success in hobbies and work, and many other things. There can be no other path, only the simple, hammered-in, one-dimensional one, and anyone joining the uniformed mass gets to beat the rest. It makes no difference whether we are talking about Coca-Cola's rainbow poster or new D&D adventures that always contain similar propaganda.
Yet if Coca-Cola's simplistic “love is love” slogan were invoked as a general truth in the context of love between a pedophile and a minor, or in many other situations, it would become clear that this universal “truth” was actually a lie, that such simplification is harmful, and that excluding people who reject it is dangerous extremism too.
In any case, proclaiming the universality of “love is love” is highly triggering. When an adult lesbian takes a minor away, endangers them, and things go wrong, the parents cannot accept that, even if such a child abuser could only be the star of Pride for a year. Yet apparently these people's sensitivities and human dignity do not count in this matter. One-sided campaigns are never solely about acceptance in such cases; discrimination and the grievances of people excluded from human rights are always at least as prominent.
Anyone who embraces this and disrespects another person's dignity because their extremist opinion is sacred should not complain afterward when someone else, for whom abuse replaces opinions and arguments, attacks their dignity in a similar context.
You Brought It to the Table Yourself
So there are things I would point out if you came to play bearing such a symbol. You know it can trigger someone else, that they will no longer have a safe space, and so on. By bringing the symbol, you have shown what their sensitivities are worth to you; equality means yours are worth no more. You want to hammer your message home aggressively; perhaps someone else does too. A third person says the hobby is about dilemmas, that art should depict these too, and that you will see several outcomes and perspectives, with the aim of making you think. If any of that triggers you, if it leads to harshness, hurt, or violence, then you brought the provocation and conflict into the company and to the table, and the responsibility is primarily yours. Nobody is going to protect you or suffer in your place or for your sake over this.
If you were interested, I would give quite a few examples of rights violations committed under the rainbow flag. If you needed somewhere safe to keep the symbol because you wanted to retain it without disturbing others, I would help find one. If you realized why extremism that does not give a shit about other people's sensitivities and rights is wrong on every side, and wanted to get rid of the symbol, I would recommend a safe trash can and help find a replacement product. Otherwise, the person could choose: leave, or accept being merely equal rather than more equal, with no safe space for them either in our shared entertainment.
At first, while the impression lasts, there will not be much sympathy either. Such aggressive propaganda will make many people angry, not only at the aggressive rainbow group, but also, through harmful and dreadful generalization, at gay men and lesbians who wear no such symbols. Even our friends in those groups may suffer because of other people's aggression.
The picture can be made more nuanced and changed; we are not condemning you in advance either. But the action you display, perhaps merely through carelessness or human error, means you start with a substantial mark against you. You are still welcome, because our inclusion comes with no asterisk and half a page of fine print listing exceptions.
If Mr. or Ms. Rainbow cannot stay and have fun with us on those terms, that is their decision, and it says something about their tolerance or lack of it.