Young people these days... Nothing but MMOs and forum RPGs, no tabletop roleplaying. I decided to ask a few people why not. For some of those conversations I had to talk within the MMORPG in question, to people of several nationalities. Frankly, there were a few unexpected difficulties. The first player would rather have told me, in fluent Mando'a, what games his character played in casinos and why than talk about his own roleplaying habits. There are two problems with this. We have to pool money for the player's game card because he is under eighteen and his parents will not pay, but his character is over thirty. The other is that the player is occasionally a grammar Nazi—not about his native English, but plenty of players speak broken Mando'a.

But we got past that, and he explained his habits in fluent English. He told me that he plays freely there, goes where he wants, and his character enjoys drinks in the cantina... Tabletop roleplaying, meanwhile, is like a flashpoint. You have to run through a prewritten adventure with some stereotypical party because the GM worked on it and the others want their characters to advance. And for most characters he knows how their appearance, according to the player's description, differs from what the graphics engine shows. You say that is rare? I say that more than one game distinguishes between different sorts of RP guild. He belongs to a "medium RP" guild that is not exclusively about roleplaying. There are some impressively large heavy RP guilds too, with plenty of young people in them. 

And I found a second, third and fourth MMO where it takes ten minutes to find a heavy RP guild. At least Mando'a was absent there. But when people call you out for half a sentence of OOC, I very much doubt they would sit around the table discussing crisps and pizza. When RPG developers decide, in the name of streamlining, that reaching the adventure should be easier and that we should "focus on the essentials", they drive away a whole lot of players like these too. Because their first few attempts at tabletop roleplaying will not offer enough roleplaying.

You visit a forum roleplaying site. If we took even slightly seriously the opinions claiming that this age group cannot read, its written nature would seem strange. But if we know that some of them grew up devouring certain young-adult novels—Harry Potter, Szent Johanna Gimi and so on—then the use of writing is no surprise at all. And what else is unsurprising? On a forum, roleplaying is not replaced by moving miniatures around on the principle that "five hours' travel through varied scenery takes five minutes to narrate; five minutes of combat takes five hours". The only problem is that almost every supporting character may need a player behind them, because no GM could watch every scene in parallel and have something to add everywhere.

But for goodness' sake: it is no use promising that there is a game master who will handle all this through NPCs, since tabletop roleplaying has only four or five people, if the forum roleplayer who ventures down that path steps into a veritable minefield. No, not because there is a rulebook. Reading that takes, say, a day. No. The problem is that many girls play in the forum RPG community, sometimes with male characters. I see nothing wrong with that, since as game masters we certainly do it regularly. But the new player has a substantial chance of at least one party member objecting. Let us go a little further. How deeply will the game master delve into the story of someone crucial to the player's story? Many would not bother, on the principle that players should not invent NPCs. 

Besides, they may not want to go along with the party and solve a typical adventure module at all. Making time for roleplaying would matter more. Whether alone with particular contacts or with many characters meeting at a location, the event played out there is an excellent adventure too. It need not be a party of five or six adventurers going off to solve something: it could be a fine mystery, in which something happens at an event and roleplaying is the main tool of investigation. 

If this is the kind of game they enjoy, why would they play one where precisely this is pushed into the background, with lots of combat and mechanical manoeuvring, and a small party efficiently running through a prewritten adventure on a fixed track, stripped of as much incidental detail as possible in the name of streamlining? 

There is a good response to both situations: a somewhat sandbox style of GMing, paying attention to the characters. In both cases, the main offer is that many things can happen to the characters over a continuing campaign. We can explain that, like an MMO or a forum RPG, this too is a compromise. But as long as so many people loudly proclaim that this age group supposedly cannot read and does not rely on its own imagination, while powergamers offer them even more opportunities for powergaming without roleplaying under the slogan "we were young once too", winning these young people over will be bloody difficult.

Oh, and plenty of forum RPG players write better than quite a few M.A.G.U.S. authors. There are authors whose reading comprehension is weaker than that of an average secondary-school-age forum roleplayer too.