We know the opinion: we barely know anything about the new M.A.G.U.S. in development, yet many are already slagging it off. Why make anything for a community like this? The trouble is that "we barely know anything" is not necessarily true. I have a terrible habit in arguments: I examine statements with every small detail and every consequence included. So I often react to a detail the other person did not intend to express. Since I consider the same thing from several angles, often producing very similar arguments, the dreaded wall of text of doom follows. This makes me negative: if a statement has a consequence making its direction unacceptable, I highlight that. I then mention no positive consequences alongside it, because unacceptable means unacceptable. Full stop. Meanwhile, you support that side hoping for some real or imagined positive consequence, and find it difficult even to understand why I criticise you for a distant, yet in many respects certain, consequence of your proposal.

Similarly, if you call certain things in a game time-wasting, I will point out why many people may desperately need that kind of situation. Of course, a game may contain nothing else and bore you. But instead of focusing on the absence of elements engaging you, you complain about the presence of elements entertaining someone else. Addressing the complaint you actually made would not necessarily add what you want or stop your boredom. It would, however, bore the other person. Perhaps it is unsurprising that I also like details falling into place in games. I even like being able to rely on the consequences of consequences, with the world functioning plausibly in that respect. That, the associated freedom and the available level of detail are why I enjoy roleplaying.

But I must admit that details important to me may bore someone else at the table. We can do what often happens in Shadowrun: GM several threads in parallel. That is difficult around a table, but easy through chat, many virtual tabletops and other online media. While even a smartphone may distract at the table, in this situation I do not mind multiple OneNote notebooks, numerous Word documents of notes and who knows what else being open. Small details often need recording, in case they matter later. Perhaps beggars behaving differently another time will lead to a good horror storyline. Players should be active, but I like characters' in-character arguments and plans built on details. 

Others seek something different, and often phrase it in ways inviting an argument. Ugly conflicts can follow, and neither of us liked the other's play style even long ago. Yet we ended up on the same side in the debate around the forthcoming M.A.G.U.S. We were discussing whether it is good for a writer to intervene in world design, or a world designer to start writing. We both agreed these require different aptitudes. Naturally, we approached it from opposite sides: he from the bad-writer/good-world-designer angle, with a simple example; I through analysis, concentrating on the risks of entrusting world design to a writer. Exceptionally, though, we had a good conversation, and much advance negativity annoys us both. Because some players cling to bad mechanical solutions rather than good objectives. The new M.A.G.U.S. has already made peace between incompatible sides.

Somehow, though, I do not believe it will unite the M.A.G.U.S. community. Not merely because some cling to bad solutions, their flaws, the contradictions they create and the reasons many reject an edition. Rather, because we do not know so little about the new M.A.G.U.S. We know it promises no mosaic magic. One reason I like M.A.G.U.S. is that a game may include both a wizard and another magic user who also conducts research. Rúna's writing on spell research made the obvious clear: practitioners of experiential magic can research new spells too, only more slowly, with greater difficulty and risk. A wizard, however, invents no new mosaic element, merely builds with existing ones. Becoming a mage and creating mosaic elements is harder still. A martial artist or someone else can also become a mage by perfecting themselves, researching and reaching the necessary level of understanding.

Imagine a witch devoted to Arel. She became a witch rather than a wizard because, although the mosaic principle eases progress and is the best widely available tool for designing spells, other serious aids require considerable experience too. And she considers Arel's follower the desirable woman, rather than, say, Ellana's. Power is not what Dreina talks about, but freedom and the ability to change the world. Like many witches, she belongs to a religious order and might even be ordained a priest, although mechanically she is not a priest and knows no priestly magic. Yet she is clergy. Sometimes the way she and the party's wizard wind each other up is more exciting than the adventure's intrigue! We still progress, even if this "free, but difficult and risky" approach occasionally means extinguishing the laboratory after a failed experiment instead of adventuring. 

Remove mosaic magic, and the foundation of all this disappears. That single promise, perhaps half a sentence or a whole one, means that if I want this experience and this duality of development paths, I can still find it only in the old system. So I will keep playing the old one. The new can join it, at most, rather than replace it. It is naïve to say this is the only important thing. It also matters to me that a wizard summons fire from the surroundings, leaving its effect absent elsewhere in the zone and making those places cooler. Another class's fire magic works differently. That can become a clue in an investigative adventure. Here again, classes differ in small details you often would not even consider. There is the mental eye too, and the concepts through which the M.A.G.U.S. monastery describes them.

Some things important to me will certainly disappear, others very probably. If I still want them, I must stay with the old system, not because I refuse change. But I am not alone in having expectations. If the new comes alongside the old, plenty of other games also deserve trying, and the new M.A.G.U.S. has no advantage in that competition. If it does what makes me play the current edition and is even slightly better, I should switch immediately. If it does not, it must compete with every other RPG. There are formidable competitors. Well-read people who speak English, an advantage in GMing, can choose from a hell of a lot of systems. They can explain them to players who do not speak English. 

I have raised this problem often. The most interesting answer said that things promised as certain were not certain after all: perhaps, like Lunír's system, it would never be published. That made me smile and gave me enough motivation to write this article. But it would mean no M.A.G.U.S. for either the twentieth or twenty-fifth anniversary.

It is no secret that I consider the Summarium project one of the greatest sins in M.A.G.U.S.'s history. It bears the logo. It is set on Ynev. It has atmosphere, and many love it. But a popular M.A.G.U.S. existed then, and many wanted a core rulebook for it. Something appeared with an entirely different worldview, shifting from adventurer-centred, human-centred heroic fantasy towards darker supernatural horror built around powerful monsters. Someone seeking a core book for the M.A.G.U.S. they currently enjoyed ended up putting one fragment of an unfinished project on their shelf: incompatible in setting and rules, and troubled by internal contradictions more severe than ever before. People were deceived.

The situation has remained familiar. Promised sequels arrive. We read one published volume today and the newly appearing volume tomorrow, and see that in theory the character has not aged. In practice, the character, world and much of the concept have changed, because too many years passed and the author changed too. Either it fits the picture we came to love, or we feel thoroughly deceived and resent the creators who misled us yet again. Knowing many details, and therefore what we will certainly or probably lose, means one thing: Delta Vision is being honest this time. The creators are fair enough to let us decide before buying or even before publication. Thinking through the statements' meanings and consequences, I must say we can learn quite a lot. That is certainly good.

And I admit my expectations are extreme.

I remember someone refusing to try CODEX because "there is no Bestiary", no animals or birds described, making its world barren and dead. Presumably you could not buy chicken in his Erion because M.A.G.U.S.'s Bestiary lacked a chicken, and he could not find it under hen either. Stupid? Yes. But he also considered it a flaw that, without a class, he could not describe exactly what his character was. That was long ago. If anyone still thinks that way, the absence of classes may bother them. And the Bestiary will not immediately contain hens, ducks, geese and so on. Though they may now be online thanks to large collection sites serving this play style excellently. New monster! Veérszunnyog. Appearing tomorrow. Written by István Veér, edited by the collection site's editor and chief Ynevologist, werebelly. 

This is far from my approach. But I know perfectly well that without classes, the site I am calling vérpisti.hu cannot publish "yet another class", the aquir battle-shrew. But please! Much of the player base does not create distinctive characters through backstories, other fancy nonsense or even behaviour. For them, trying a new class from vérpisti.hu makes things fresh, new and "not boring". Without classes, satisfying their needs will be damn hard. The system is unfinished, but if the things called certain are certain, it will contain no classes. It is skill-based. They can also give up the memorable 00 and many other iconic things they cling to, the things that kept them with M.A.G.U.S. instead of switching to, say, D&D 5. Those same reasons may keep them with the old M.A.G.U.S. instead of the new. Some reasons for choosing an edition can be called nonsense, others are personal taste, and others concern genuinely important possibilities.

You need not see the new core book to know that someone valuing the competition between the pseudonymous vérpisti.hu and vérovi.hu over which publishes more new classes with magical automatic mortars at first level will dislike this. They must discard their collection of new classes, and with no new classes there can be no new collection. I know: new magical mortars can still exist. But the problem is clear. Someone bored with an overpowered character, seeking "something different" and a new class, will not be won over by a weapon their current character could find. We can laugh at them! The two websites' teams can even take offence at this article. There is only one problem: we are talking about many players and many buyers. People who kept M.A.G.U.S. alive through camps and events.

We can laugh about whether the Bestiary needs a hen or whether mongrel-dragon deathbreather must be a new class. But a system that fails to win these people will lack support on many familiar sites, have fewer players, and cost us something again. Something may not matter to us, yet matter to the friend or fellow player we love, flaws included, and therefore want to play with. 

We are talking about mass preferences now. In many places, this problem contributed more to rejection of Új Törvénykönyv than the openly stated flaws. Because flaws can be corrected. And these rejecting groups make many other mistakes themselves, such as building bugs involving od into their systems. They already use house rules for character creation in the old system and could have done so here too. 

I know too. A class system is an outdated fossil with a thousand disadvantages, and "a little better than current M.A.G.U.S." will not attract many new people. But I have a story about a computer RPG. Everyone discussing Mass Effect: Andromeda talks about its lousy facial expressions and animation. The game practically failed because everyone talked about that. Suppose an early conversation explained that the SAM implant and many other things interfere with perception, how your brain assembles images and movement and what it filters out, making everything strange, but you will get used to it in time. Most people would no longer complain that the animation was shit. Instead they would talk about actually getting used to it! About never having considered that detail before. About its absence from early-version videos. How it might improve immersion, motivate people to write about the phenomenon and discuss it neurologically and otherwise. How it would be good publicity. How brilliant it all was, making the graphics brilliant too. 

If SAM also reported graphics-related patches in the game, explaining which algorithm had improved to reduce the disturbance, and explaining this at the start of a new game... Discussion of this might have interested people who would never consider buying even a Mass Effect with good graphics and none of the known flaws. It would surprise players, offer unusual innovation and show creativity. Instead, since it is absent and you must imagine it yourself, you will say BioWare did a shit job. Some blame the graphics; others blame the missed open goal.

A class system can be a major disadvantage in the modern RPG market. But explanation, creativity and ingenuity can reverse the story. Instead of news that the class system is crap and went out of fashion twenty years ago, you can say someone has neutralised its disadvantages through unusual solutions and new ideas, creating something new and interesting worth examining even if you do not play M.A.G.U.S. or switch to its new system. 

Collecting supposedly modern solutions and presenting an entirely different system, with a world changed in many ways after a hundred-year jump, a very different worldview, quality matching the market average for release-ready products but an uncertain future and a different feel in many respects, thanks to dice deliberately influencing the game's character, is also a task. It too can produce a release even if it does not fit the previous worldview. Naturally, the M.A.G.U.S. logo can be stamped on it, alienating many players while motivating others to buy through the logo. Finally! But it is very different from thinking through how to turn current disadvantages into advantages, simplify the system and modernise it. Making the new M.A.G.U.S. relate to the old as D&D 5 relates to original D&D would be an interesting task.

It is a great shame Delta Vision did not choose that path. Only one M.A.G.U.S. rulebook has appeared with foundations so incompatible that little could be borrowed by people staying with the old system, making their disappointment potentially greater than with the other four reforms. Yes, d20. Other editions allowed discussion of useful elements to adopt, revealing many advantages and providing publicity. If total incompatibility prevents borrowing much, that publicity disappears too, and rejection becomes louder. 

The flaws of d100, classes and many other things can be improved enormously. A modern solution can readily be reached that still allows elements to be adapted to the old system, feels familiar to many and perhaps faces less rejection. I may or may not believe someone is professional and exacting enough to overcome every pitfall because their system, worldview, creation and bundled support and product are so good, and that after the standard suggested by the current developer blog, they will effortlessly sustain this miraculous system through many supplements. Belief is not easy when they scarcely attempt to assemble a marketable, average-quality system satisfying the needs behind people's existing choice, because that seems impossible to them. 

Of course, if the system really is that perfect, I will buy and recommend it, and include that alongside these considerations in the review. Things already known will be prepared, but a very positive conclusion would be wonderful. More than wonderful! Yet pessimism has a small cause. The system has been used for some time for science fiction. That is what its geniuses designed it for, so it must surely be good at it. Several DV authors were not especially fond of Ynev; a little science-fiction/horror direction could give them a comfortable home, a superb brand built by superb world designers and system developers while pleasing the existing writers. Yet for some mysterious reason, those at DV who know and have played this superb product do not consider it good and strong enough to burst into the science-fiction RPG market. 

This is where a little devil pipes up: "The M.A.G.U.S. logo will sell it." Even with a different world in many respects, a different atmosphere and worldview, and a system with an alien concept, as I have described at length. Quietly I think that, if this were the case, I would say I am thoroughly sick of it. But life is not black and white. One of my favourite characters arose when I set out to play AD&D. We had agreed beforehand: AD&D, Planescape. By the time I arrived, it had become "let's play M.A.G.U.S. instead", and that was the compromise. I had no M.A.G.U.S. idea ready, but the GM and group pointed out the many methods of adapting AD&D characters. A Planescape character could certainly find their way to Ynev. They randomly chose one of my backstory outlines.

Based on what has been said, the new M.A.G.U.S. does not provide what makes me play the old one. That is a definite promise. I have no reason to believe quality and brilliant worldbuilding will immediately convince me. But in many situations it may be a barely acceptable compromise for playing together. If creativity lets me turn Mass Effect: Andromeda's worst flaws into advantages, and I have a damn interesting character concept for World of Darkness, which I expressly dislike, then after reluctantly accepting "let's play the new M.A.G.U.S." as a bad compromise, I may still have ideas that make me grow fond of it, start fixing it and write articles here. I may want to play it too. Demand can gradually develop, and once it exists, even a barely average system can satisfy it. 

On that basis I have no serious reason for categorical rejection, unlike the pseudonymous vérovi.hu at times. Until something emerges that I firmly and categorically reject, while DV's representatives appear honest and fair, I have little reason to boycott the project and basic cooperation continues, this possibility belongs beside the harsh criticism. Even if the system initially meets rejection, releasing supplements on time, seeking new selling points and offering quality novels can gradually win people over. Gradually make them willing to settle for it, develop a good idea and grow fond of it through that idea. The project may then lose money in the short term but profit in the long term. Twenty-five years from now, as grey-haired, grey-bearded old men, we will not still be arguing about inheriting features from a fifty-year-old system that was poorly thought out even when new. 

Still, I would prefer a system trying to meet the same needs the old one met, the reasons we play it: many different needs of many people. That would require some resemblance to the old system.