Many people were surprised that Delta Vision did not speak of profit when discussing publishing the roleplaying game. Yet they were wise to do so. An old marketing saying goes: if you get something for free, you are the product. When every fan site—even the “hostile” ones, even those many looked down on—received the opportunity to produce free, noncommercial supplements, the rights holders were buying content that often kept the brand alive. Good and bad mixed together. Deliberately so. Because what is good content? Or, more importantly, what is bad content? I would say an ill-considered, overpowered new class is an example of the latter. Others would say an insufficiently structured article I wrote.

But the new class has its target audience too. If it were not made for M.A.G.U.S., they would play something else. And some of my readers agree with me that the article is not “insufficiently structured” by accident. The average person can keep little more than seven or eight facts or considerations in their head, and even that takes effort. When I argue that idea magic must necessarily exist on Ynev, I examine not one or two arguments and perspectives, but at least thirty.

Some arguments are quite obvious. Spellcasting is tied to ancient languages. We affect everything through spoken words and the concepts they describe. Like it or not, that is idea magic. Even if many wanted to reject it because it was Nyul's idea and they did not want it that way. If I developed only that argument, nicely as we were taught, strictly following introduction, discussion, and conclusion, everyone could take in the article. It would be readable, concise, and enjoyable.

I would merely be spitting in the reader's face.

Because as a game master, the reader needs to weigh many arguments and counterarguments. If I quietly leave some out despite having considered them, I deprive the reader of a great deal of information. They could find them just as I did, of course. But they came here precisely so that they would not have to find them themselves: I would collect those arguments and considerations for them. So I write down the second consideration.

Of course it is broken into paragraphs. A new paragraph marks a new thought. But this second consideration may be a conclusion. It may be another independent argument. Or it may refute an opposing concept. Some will appreciate the jump between perspectives, because this thoroughness is why they come here. Plenty of others will find it hard to follow, feel their heads buzzing, and see no chain of logic in an article listing so many considerations. How could they? In a set of largely independent arguments that could be listed in random order, the only connection is that they point in the same direction.

It gets worse. The largely independent arguments are not entirely independent. Suppose each is connected in some way to three “randomly chosen” others. That too reinforces them; that too is what makes the system a system. But those connections also form a tangled collection. And I can only describe them where they occur and matter. Statistics tells us the average reader's head buzzes from all the tangle. But someone who comes here because I explore these considerations simply keeps tallying mentally: one more thing pointing the same way. 37:0, a really well-founded opinion—that is why I come here. 

I do not deny it, of course. Considering so much data has a serious curse: keeping it all up to date would be damned difficult. If a playtest version describes something as final, I may not have the time, inclination, or enthusiasm to check it again against the final version. I take a claim by the publisher or creators at face value, and assume that what they called final will remain that way in the finished system. Even if it is monumental nonsense and they must see that too. They do. And sometimes it turns out they fixed it for the final release.

That is why comments are enabled. And why I phrase things so damn elaborately. Saying “In D&D 5, modifier X works like this, so it is no good” is not the same as explaining over several sentences: when I tried it, I gave up on the system because modifier X worked this way. They said it would remain this way in the final system. That is sufficient reason for anyone bothered by it to put the system aside at that point. The two statements apparently say the same thing about D&D. One is ten words; the other is more than thirty. I even know someone who says at least twenty words must therefore be unnecessary.

But in mathematics class I learned that a function or proposition has a domain of validity. Where it matters, you need to specify it. And that is not the only difference. The ten-word statement says the system is bad, that the whole thing is about modifiers. If the modifiers were wrong, changing them with a house rule would take less than a minute. An important part of a public beta is A/B testing, where we often see nonsense that deserves rejection. Sometimes that turns out to apply to a solution intended for the final version. Even if it were not corrected, it would still be a flaw fixable in a minute.

But follow the context and the statement is about something entirely different. People who did not even move from AD&D 2nd Edition to 3rd Edition are, in all probability, not playing D&D. Their own favorite game either has a living current edition, or the player does not need one. There is no urgent reason to switch to D&D 5. There is no serious reason to invest in supplements for yet another system. And what is offered as a compromise for lovers of many editions is a compromise for us too, not an ideal edition. Here, a single minor flaw that anyone could fix in a minute—and that may since have been fixed—can be the last straw, or the one after it...

And not because the rule itself is so bad. It is easily fixed. Oh, and I can still change racial maximums or anything else. The DM is omnipotent in that respect there too. It simply sent the message that there are iconic spells: those are D&D's trademarks. Making races sufficiently distinctive, with many qualities iconic in their own way, is a distant secondary concern. Supplements may be the same. However much they fix the racial modifiers, that message can no longer be taken back.

And yes, I know fanboys. The Hungarian Roleplaying Community is full of them. They expect me to buy their favorite, with lots of important supplements, and spend hundreds of thousands of forints on them. The truth, however, is that they do not buy my favorites either. The world does not work that way. It is the publisher's job to sell me something, to persuade me to invest time and money in the system they want to sell. Fanboy arrogance will not do it.

But the marketer says negative publicity is good publicity too. Because it spreads. Because it makes you believe you are the target audience, which may be enough to make you buy after weighing the flaws. D&D 5 received a single page in our article on D&D's history. The forthcoming new M.A.G.U.S.? Several articles. We discuss it, it matters, and we may be its target audience. There are article topics prepared for the AD&D and D&D category. Still about 2nd Edition. Or about the links between D&D's many editions and computer games.

With that one beta-version approach, they communicated what did not really matter to the developers: something fundamental to me and, I believe, to this site's target audience. That made D&D 5 irrelevant. M.A.G.U.S. is not our favorite; we criticize it, but it is relevant. 

Delta Vision does not want to generate profit from the new M.A.G.U.S. I do not even think it wants most people to like it or wants it to be a popular success. Delta Vision knows that M.A.G.U.S. is relevant in many places: if there is news, we write about it. If we write about it, more people visit them at Book Week, and more become curious about the books we reject, wanting to form their own opinion. For Delta Vision, that already generates a benefit, even if the direct revenues from publishing M.A.G.U.S. fall short of its publishing costs.

In many respects, a voice inside me whispers that when the publisher's head says he raised the possibility in many places that they would consider a fan-made solution if one appeared, perhaps he did not really mean it. But what I learned about marketing tells me he absolutely did. Is he putting in free work to assess communities' solutions? Or reaching communities with a little work and minimal cost, remaining relevant on many websites for longer? “As if he would take me seriously...” I think, remembering the bad relationships in many quarters. But please: that very bad relationship may be why, if I put a publishable idea on the table, many people would engage with it. If many dislike me, many would pay attention.

And I have a practically finished system in a drawer built on precisely this concept. It does not want to sell a core rulebook; it would “buy a fan base” and build a brand. Back during Yardain and company's project, I suggested a solution where the basic system was at most thirty pages and fitted at the end of a novel. One notes that Tuan has since had a similar idea. Increasingly minimalist rulebooks have since become fashionable. Of course, that system can be applied to several settings and, importantly, supports several styles of play. How it can generate revenue through several optional channels has also been worked out.