This article will not be entirely fair. It would be much fairer if I put it only in the traditional M.A.G.U.S. system category, since the creators of the New Rulebook "put a system on the table" that works, even if we do not always agree with it and can therefore run into pitfalls and questions even while compiling a collection of NPCs. Yet I dare to take a swipe at all of today's official authorities at once, because the creators of that system no longer hold any rights either: they are not official, whereas András Gáspár and his associates are. So when I explain why I would treat an official source with reservations, arguments can arise very quickly.
Of course I will mention unofficial supplements as well as official ones, including the work known as Fejvadászok könyve, the Book of Assassins, even though my piece "Supplements from the Internet" has already given it a substantive answer. In D&D, Hasbro's current publications are official, but it would still never occur to me to use a supplement for fifth-edition D&D with the second or third edition, especially not as an official source. An official source is only official within the edition for which it was written. Mixing it with another edition amounts, at most, to a house rule. If András Gáspár says today that he thought of something that way from the beginning, but it contradicts official sources and the explanations their creators gave at the time, something else needs to be added:
In early M.A.G.U.S., literary Ynev and the roleplaying world were separate. Indeed, several writers deliberately had different literary Ynevs. In that case, we can say the particular claim is official partly within András Gáspár's literary Ynev, but not within the early roleplaying Ynev. And also within the new "M.A.G.U.S.: I Will Believe It When I See It" edition that, according to the promises of recent times, might perhaps be finished one day. That subtitle, which I have arbitrarily attached, reflects the fact that people talk about its carefully thought-out vision of the world, but hardly anyone has seen it. Either it exists or it does not, but the person insisting that it does has proved unreliable in many of his claims.
I know: curse my dear mother, how dare I talk that way about András Gáspár and his current associates? Frankly, though, that is only a small part of my opinion. With M.A.G.U.S., the usual question is ETK or ÚTK. Sometimes d20 gets a mention too. The trouble is that far more substantially different concepts have appeared than just those. Let us see how many changes of concept we can actually identify:
- In the days of the "Big Green Book", the world was a little sketchy, but never mind: the game master would fill it with content. Perhaps by recognising connections, too. One small but perhaps important point about player characters was the aim that the heroes of a continuing campaign should resemble the heroes of the novels. The world could thus be filled out in many ways, and the game really was about the PCs. This also fitted with the fact that not only warriors but even first-level thieves were better than many soldiers. The mechanical portions of magic theory and the skill system likewise offered only a possible path to follow, not a finished solution.
- Another part of the creative team began fleshing out a great many things. With the numerous warrior subclasses appearing in Harcosok, Barbárok, Gladiátorok—Warriors, Barbarians, Gladiators—we reached the point of "oh, sorry, there are lots of high-level NPCs here too", making it unclear why anyone would look specifically to adventurers for salvation.
- The many new races, critical injuries and so on in the Second Rulebook built on ideas gathered from here and there. Some fitted the picture; others produced radical changes. And many could be incorporated but brought a more "overpowered" foundation from the Internet into the system. Further power increases could then be built on that foundation, and those too could later become part of the system. The beauty of the amund is a frequently cited example of the problem...
- After Nyul left, the Summarium represented a radical, deliberate change of direction... But for various reasons it remained unfinished and impossible to finish. Its vision of the world can be atmospheric, and some people find it enchanting, but the inconsistency is still there.
- The ETK stirred things up a little. I recall that the assassin, "capable of killing with many weapons in any situation", now knows less about weapons than the martial artist. Arel's spheres change because she apparently developed a liking for boundaries set in stone. Oh, no: that consideration simply did not matter. Many of the witch's spells filled important gaps, but somehow nobody noticed that a witch who can magically gain Master level in a skill within hours is not going to struggle along at Basic level. The height of thoughtlessness, though, is the assumption that a witch will seek an animal body for herself, when only magic resistance stands in the way of stealing a human body. The trouble is that psionics and meaningful magic resistance are not very common among peasant girls... Mandatory HP loss dismantled the concept of deliberately long combats; in many cases a large FP pool thus became fairly pointless, and the spellcasters you have to catch became even more overpowered.
- The New Scrolls, Új Tekercsek, did not bring much of a new vision of the world, unless introducing new training paths and new forms of magic counts. Oh, and the basic premise of "how powerful and how much of a chosen one is an adventurer?" changed yet again. Beyond that, though, this is essentially a "system only" book...
- Then came the Priests and Paladins series, Papok, Paplovagok. Several gods' attitudes change again. Never mind. Nor does it matter that the author loudly argues on a forum why Ellana's priestesses would be no good in combat, while giving them a weapon skill on top of what other priests receive. That is what someone who has never learned to fight looks like. On the other hand, tying many things previously treated as "assumed knowledge" to skills means that far fewer KP remain for things that would have added colour to a character. We did not just gain new options: something that worked one way yesterday now works differently. Skill incompatibilities remove many of the Second Rulebook's innovations, and not just for priests. Yet after the ETK and ÚT weakened adventurers, this drastically increases their power in many areas.
- Then András Gáspár and his associates suddenly began overseeing roleplaying Ynev too, and we got d20 and the Geoframia. How well these fit together is debatable... But anyone can point out the many places where they contradict what came before.
- We got the New Rulebook, Új Törvénykönyv, with many consolidations and changes.
- And 2.0 is supposedly in the works...
Ten concepts, ten underlying visions. The first was only a change from "let us play AD&D on Ynev", so we see nine real changes. Everyone can count for themselves how many supplements appeared along the way that did not touch the foundations of the concept or stir up numerous fundamentals. It therefore becomes very difficult to imagine anyone who "does not contradict" the official version, or one of the official versions. Take an example: the question of when the Maremite branch of Darton's paladins was founded. According to the Geoframia, this happened after the Dúlás, the Devastation. Priests and Paladins, however, discusses the tattoos these paladins used during the Dúlás.
Earlier there was no unambiguous date, but we did know a few things: the religious conflict was not really present at the start of the construction of New Pyarron, and before the Dúlás there was certainly something holding the church together. The founders' natural lifespans are finite too... And it takes a fairly long time for a knightly order to spread. A schism within the church raises an interesting question: "What did it split from?" After all, the Dúlás was itself accompanied by a schism in the church: see the distinction between the Pyarronite and Selmovite branches. The question of what split from where, however, indicates that the separation of this Dartonite branch, its becoming a distinct movement in substance, must belong to the period after the Dúlás.
So let us ask what the "original official position" would be, which the other source merely contradicted. Priests and Paladins, published before the Geoframia, gives a date for the first time, but plainly contradicts the earlier vision of the world; the author is plainly talking nonsense. Or does the date deducible from early sources and confirmed by the Geoframia win? Finding an answer is far from simple. What is easy to see, though, is that people already have different needs: some want to play the "finished", available version, accepting it as it is because that requires no work, while others want to follow a particular vision of the world, whether the newest or the oldest. Heaven forbid someone says they are willing to add to that vision as long as it causes no problems, but will reject any change that threatens to do so.
The above also shows us that the official position is not necessarily truer or better than the player's own position. We must ask: who matters more, the player or game master whose enjoyment you are playing for, or the people who produced such contradictory hackwork? Whom do you trust more: a player who always strives for the best for everyone's enjoyment, almost to the point of excessive perfectionism, or the "official authorities" who created the contradictions above? I need not answer the rhetorical question. But if you answer it yourself, I am not the bastard destroying the great men's authority.
You could say that consistency is not their strong suit, but at least they have ideas. Yet it never occurred to them that, just as the dervish is something of a "paladin", many other paladins need not use a knightly fighting style either. "Knightly training" would be odd coming from Arel, whose priests are versed in many underworld matters. But it would be just as odd if a country where Arel's faith is the state religion had no commander "acting on Arel's behalf". I know: their assassin clan has a "priest/assassin" path, developed in an unofficial supplement, the Book of Assassins... But that still is not someone versed in commanding armies, not a general, not a leader. Among the clan's leadership and the appointed leaders of individual units, an earned or inherited title could come with the possibility of a status similar to that of paladins. In other words, those holding rank—meridian—could be created as equivalents of other cultures' "knights" and "paladins". And that would be more useful than the situation of "never learns to fight, but fights better than veteran soldiers".
Unfortunately, the creative team lacks sufficient creativity for that. A rather implausible arrow machine gun as a surprise is nowhere near as valuable as a player drawing inferences from what has already been written, consciously building on it and, within those boundaries, surprising us with a backstory, a concept and play that surprise the game master and fellow players. If there are few examples of that latter kind of surprise, but plenty of slightly clichéd, slightly implausible characters from official sources, and their work frequently strips M.A.G.U.S. of precisely what made us buy it and start playing it alongside other games in the first place, then we must decide for ourselves what we expect compatibility with.