The pages of the Új Tekercsek stated that the SUMMARIUM began as a more adult worldview, but its second and third volumes were never completed. Nothing came of that more adult worldview. It would be easy to point to the tediously familiar facts, list the many contradictions in the setting, and announce that “these were the flaws in the concept,” but the situation is not that simple. Partly because the first volume did appear, and partly because successful games exist with even more numerous and conspicuous contradictions and errors. Although these can justify rejecting the SUMMARIUM's use, they would not by themselves make the system a failure. I must mention more serious flaws than these.
We can argue for pages about where an idea creates historical contradictions and how details fall apart, but most players shrug: “I'll rise above it.” Creating a truly living character may be a little harder when the world is disjointed, but most people do not do that anyway and would not even notice the flaw. Vampire: The Masquerade is no different, with a problem involving precisely the tradition named in its title: the society described would require too many vampires for them to remain unnoticed. If Vampire is successful and popular despite this, who would dare say the SUMMARIUM must fail because of Od and historical contradictions? I do not think so.
I have to admit that although I too enjoy castigating the SUMMARIUM for these flaws, I know they were not what caused its failure. Even with them, the SUMMARIUM could have been a successful system with a successful worldview, however different from what so many of us came to love about M.A.G.U.S. The trouble is that even the foundations of the supposedly more adult worldview did not work and could not have worked. Simply because, when devising that allegedly more adult worldview, they overlooked one small thing: many of the “horror” games considered more adult do not work well. Even if many players proudly beat their chests about playing a game with a more adult, more grown-up worldview. It is time to grow up. A child yearns to spend time on more adult, more grown-up things; an adult seeks interesting, meaningful recreation.
Pursuing a more adult worldview in this way is therefore not very wise. Especially when the cautionary example is right in front of us. One of the most famous adventure modules in roleplaying history was I-6 Ravenloft, an excellent little horror story for AD&D parties. Horror works, so let us create a horror game, a wonderful horror world... The TSR team began the project with great enthusiasm. Many of us embraced the game eagerly; I myself carried more than one Ravenloft module to clubs. Sometimes they contained genuinely good advice on creating a horror atmosphere. Yet it still was not quite right.
When I ran the same adventure in the Forgotten Realms or any other world for a group aiming at a life-path campaign, they were afraid. If it was a Ravenloft adventure, however, even a succession of Fear and Horror checks designed to force fear could not help... Those checks had been introduced, after all, because without a roll the player was unwilling to be afraid. The horror was commonplace, and the player character, certain to be short-lived, was an undeveloped template, a disposable resource. The “more adult” horror setting did not work. As the editions “developed,” things grew steadily worse. They had been best at the beginning, without any checks, as an adventure module not so closely bound to a setting. Because the group had something to fear.
A horror is frightening only when you have something to lose and the creature is not an everyday occurrence. Once these things become commonplace, few people feel fear during a horror game. Simply because they expect monsters from a horror game and expect their characters to be disposable. So many games try to meet that expectation. Whether we think of Ravenloft's thousand kinds of checks or Call of Cthulhu's Sanity points, which make characters even more disposable, makes no difference. Again, we see a roll used for something that ought to be handled through roleplaying. Ought to be. But the system's creators did not introduce that roll out of stupidity; they did so because the player would not be afraid without it either. Their character was disposable and the threat commonplace. After all, what does someone expect when they sit down to play Ravenloft, Call of Cthulhu and so on?
Saying a game should be darker and draw on many horror devices because that will make it more adult is the wrong direction. It may lose depth, for example, and the character may become disposable, which makes the game anything but more adult. The change will also be unpopular with many people. But this flaw is still quite survivable.
It is easy to argue, “It is more adult because you cannot be a munchkin or powergame here.” Why—is that mandatory in classic fantasy or M.A.G.U.S.? If not, why does it bother you that powergaming is possible when your own group may choose not to do it? Reducing a character to a disposable resource makes nobody more adult or a better roleplayer. Nor does the feeling of “nyah-nyah, my GM's monster is bigger and scarier” make anyone more mature. It does not replace roleplaying or the character's fear either. Besides, it means the player is still preoccupied with power levels rather than who the character actually is. So much for anti-powergaming efforts.
Od and the worldview of big monsters and little adventurers would not have made M.A.G.U.S. the slightest bit more adult, and that is where the concept failed. The “more adult Ynev” followed a familiar path and failed for a tediously familiar reason. An aquir did not become scarier because Od wrecked the world. Indeed, the greater focus on monsters made them more commonplace, and they ceased to be frightening. That would not itself have been a problem if Od had not also found its way into the munchkins' toolkit... And when a patchwork like this, riddled with errors, tries to present itself as more adult than the work of so many game masters who also attend to the game's depth, it is fundamentally off-putting.
Yet a rarely seen goblin, well described and unfamiliar to the players, can be more frightening than an aquir mentioned constantly. That simply requires roleplaying. And for that, it helps if the world has depth: hidden connections the GM can build on and the players can discover. Overwriting and destroying those connections does anything but lead toward a more adult game. The creators forgot that they were not merely damaging and overwriting Zsolt Nyulászi's work, but also the work of countless GMs who had built on those connections. That made the SUMMARIUM a failure. Alongside its flaws, it made clear that its creators did not particularly care about the work players had invested in the world.
But however much the next two volumes failed to appear—the Új Tekercsek could even have been called SUMMARIUM II—the failure was not total. Those who began playing after the Summarium appeared were not affected by this attitude. What they saw was a book describing parts of Ynev absent from many other books. And they began using what they could. If their games leaned a little toward powergaming, a few Od points could certainly make them happy.