I have often mentioned, for many reasons, the simple fact that a game's rules shape the community around it. They partly determine who is more likely to enjoy the game—selection—partly suggest certain values, and partly teach players by providing reference points. In Call of Cthulhu, the likelihood that characters fail even in the very short term, the rulebook's forgetting that not every story was horror, and so on determine many little things. We have talked a great deal about Sanity, and plenty of house rules exist for it. What is strange is that, within this site's team, experience did not ultimately decide the matter. In one respect that is good news: experience and player preparation are not everything. Still, an odd situation can arise when a player is a little more familiar than the game master with Lovecraft's and his followers' work, or the information underlying it. What should be done then?

There is no universal advice, because the more experienced player may know it too, suspect it, and thereby prevent it from offering any way to surprise them. We nevertheless have options. The best opportunity to surprise a player is to find some phenomenon where we have a free hand. The Dreamlands are one such area: the question is often whose or what dreams are appearing, and whether those dreams can affect the world in return.

We also have a free hand when running a mundane investigative adventure, or trying to frighten the player with worldly dangers. These things happen. But one small problem needs consideration. What if the player, precisely because of experience and a suspicion that you will turn in this direction, assembles the solution very quickly? Once again there is no surprise, and once again information requires little effort. The problem simply arises because, while the game master normally has a substantial information advantage, here the player does. The situation is reversed from what is ideal for play and running a game.

What else can be done? The solution is very simple: distract the player with false clues. There can be plenty of explanations for everything, perhaps true of one region of the Dreamlands because that part of the plane is influenced by the dreams of someone who thinks that way, but certainly not generally true. Which partial truths really affect the adventure's events matters, though. It helps if several people dream in a story, and several people's dreams and nightmares appear.

In that case, even if one more obvious source of “dreams coming to life” is identified and can therefore be dealt with, someone else may still be “dreaming a little too vividly.” Why is entirely beside the point. Whether it is their profession, whether as a young lad they dream about certain girls, or “just imagine a girl as a lesbian” because that fires their imagination, dreams can affect the world to some degree and create a corner of it about which only you have information.

The situation is then restored: the person running the game is usually right because of their information advantage. Only they know what they are doing and why. An unusual decision can still pull the ground from beneath the player character's feet and suddenly turn the world upside down, but with one small difference: a GM mistake is not breaking fidelity to the world and immersion. There is a real in-character reason for the break, adding something to the game rather than taking away from it. I think that is more advantageous than otherwise.

Yes, this article was already waiting in the wings; I simply did not want to give away the idea during an adventure. We have now reached a point where the information can be shared. So go ahead, everyone: use dreams and nightmares coming to life yourselves. It fits the Mythos and remedies a weakness of the game beautifully: it primarily attracts people who are already hard to surprise because they know the world so well. Living nightmares are only one possibility, of course.

If you are ill-informed as a game master, an enthusiastic amateur cultist trying to call dark forces into being can be ill-informed too. Mix many things this way, and someone trying to navigate by the known Mythos, bringing out-of-character information into play, can easily go down the wrong track. There is ample opportunity for you to come out of the situation well despite all the problems.

The uninformed beginner's mindset is an unknown territory you fill with content, just like many mundane crimes or investigations unrelated to the Mythos the player knows so well. If you have made relying on the Mythos unprofitable in nine adventures out of ten, the player will not cause trouble with their extra information and knowledge in the tenth either.

A player's extra knowledge, a frightening problem for many GMs, may therefore prove easily remedied. That can also keep even the fans most familiar with the world from always being forced into the GM's role on the grounds that a player knowing more than the GM is undesirable. “You know the world best, so you run it” sounds persuasive and can be supported, but is terribly unfair because it excludes someone from the opportunity to play.

Knowing that people fear the unknown most, making even the player confident in their knowledge confront the unknown can certainly benefit the game. Do you think this direction is worth exploring?