One of Call of Cthulhu's basic premises is that player characters are investigators. More than one book calls them that. Supernatural cases often arise, but at other times they become involved in mundane cases, since Lovecraft did not write only supernatural horror. This time we will discuss that situation: ideally it is relatively common, and occult knowledge does not solve the adventure here. The question immediately arises, though: how should we handle such investigative adventures? I have to say the answer depends largely on the setting and era. Compare the 1920s with the 2000s and the differences are already apparent. The 2000s offer well-equipped laboratories, computers, and databases. In the 1920s, the “Leica frame” and so-called 135 film could be novelties. Kodachrome, however, would have to wait until 1936. Even using photographs as evidence is not self-evident.
Psychology is developing, but there are no profiling units yet. Laboratories may exist, but the era of well-equipped forensic labs is still far away. Cars exist but are not yet widespread in most places. Airmail and the first airlines have appeared; the world has begun to change. And yes, if our interests extend beyond Lovecraft, it is worth knowing that Agatha Christie was active then too. Most of her works were set in this period as well. It was one of detective fiction's golden ages. If investigation matters in Lovecraft and detective fiction's golden age fell between the world wars, we can say that investigation, drawing heightened public interest, was part of the era.
The press, not particularly accurate then, sought sensation just as it does today. People enjoyed chewing over the details of crimes and mysterious stories, and the period had many amateur and professional investigators. If we seek that atmosphere, plenty of good investigative adventures are essential. It is worth considering how to run a good detective story. We could say we see enough crime dramas on television and they make good sources of inspiration. But I have to say that in many cases this is a serious mistake.
Most modern series not only take place in another era with investigators using different methods, but do not necessarily focus on investigation at all, preferring the investigators' lives and style. Even looking a little further back, we see Columbo intuit what happened “at the first moment” for no reason, then keep pestering the killer until he extracts a confession. There was not much investigation in that either. What would an adventure be like if we began, “You know who the killer is; keep after them”? Surely nobody would call that an investigative adventure.
Return to Agatha Christie's stories and a very different picture appears. There we find substantive investigation. We can examine the writer's methods: we always receive one or two clues or pieces of information more than the reader can keep track of, but following every fact would let us reach the correct conclusion ourselves. If the picture can be assembled from fewer facts, the adventure is almost linear and self-evident. If information must be organized, questions remembered, and every detail considered, the investigative work becomes a little more complex.
If players do not try to record and think through the evidence, forgetting a question or two because another direction is available, they can very easily go astray as important evidence is left out. Their role then becomes rather like Captain Hastings in the Poirot stories or Watson alongside Sherlock Holmes. They cannot discover the truth, but somebody beside them may solve the mystery.
A good investigator has to take notes, often forcing the player to collect and repeatedly analyze information too. In this era, the notebook is still the characters' main tool. Searching files is relatively difficult. What if we choose another era? Many things would work similarly even in the 1850s, except power cuts would not threaten the gaslights. There would be no cars, of course, and fewer trains. Things change little until computers become widespread. Indeed, since notes still need taking, the notebook remains until suitable laptops become widespread.
Clothes change, cars become more numerous and modern, laboratories and much forensic work develop. Yet paper and pencil remain important for collecting and organizing information. Until computers become genuinely user-friendly, they rarely provide investigators with answers. This begins to change in 1990s investigations. The IBM Simon, presented in 1992 and sold in 1993, brings the first smartphone. With a two-year contract, an investigator could carry their first smartphone. At least that was the situation in many US cities.
From then on, an investigator could easily access numerous information sources at any time. We gradually reached the modern age, where organizing information is much easier because databases join notebooks. We could now draw from modern series, but that would still be too linear. So it is a good idea to say that if a player can attend to seven facts at once, the solution ought to require the eighth too. Let the group pursue many directions if it wants, analyze information to understand the case, and leave room for teamwork.
Improving methods only appear to make investigators' work easier: they must analyze more and more data, and solving a case requires more evidence. Investigators are not the only ones learning; the other side's knowledge grows too. They can research investigative methods, communicate, and learn from one another's mistakes. They even share methods that can confuse investigators.
It remains true that if we want something beyond a linear adventure and care about somewhat realistic investigation, we should provide more clues rather than too few. Requiring too many difficult rolls for every clue, or making every clue immediately point to the same place, is not good. It is better for characters to face several possibilities while investigating. If the story can be assembled in several ways, and even a wrong conclusion can take them a long way, it becomes more interesting.
Wrong conclusions will come to light sooner or later, however. That can make the adventure harder.
Consider another small point: Call of Cthulhu should be frightening; characters should be scared. All we need do is build the criminals' network of connections. If questions such as “Who served time with whom?” repeatedly bring up names like the Vampire of Bucharest, we can make characters believe the cases are connected and “these people are involved in everything.” If the investigation then also leads to cultists, it becomes easy to make the average PC see horrors behind every bush.
The story can be built so Sanity loss appears not only in rolls, but in the player seeing how their character goes mad and why. When the character suspects things everywhere and begins mentioning all kinds of horrors, many people merely respond to that. The character will then surely begin believing the supernatural threat is everywhere, since everyone can say something about it. And as the character plunges into analyzing the Mythos... We know this road well.
The substantial surplus of information almost mandatory in an investigative adventure, an expanding network of connections, and many explanations and opinions can easily lead to Mythos elements that might occur anywhere. This is precisely the process that carries an ordinary mundane investigation into a horror story. As GM, it is worth paying attention to it too.