It seems to be game-design season. Although the Káosz Roleplaying Game 2.0 project started before this wave of enthusiasm appeared, everybody knows what sparked the sudden trend, and yet so many people ask: why that particular one? Some turn to a familiar setting because they have no ideas. Others do it because they have ideas. Perhaps several, some of which fit that particular setting, and once they have put work into them, they should not just sit in a drawer. Their own concepts will get a different approach. Some do it because they do not trust themselves to get there with their own concept. Others even believe they can successfully continue a project that has been cursed a thousand times over. And some point out that the project gives the rights holder publicity, but can also give you publicity. On this subject, though, I have repeatedly raised an interesting qualification: if you want to work with something that already exists, Chaosium's systems are there, and a limited license covers quite a respectable amount of revenue... But the OGL and plenty of other options also allow you to use a system commercially. For an adventure, a supplement, or a roleplaying game for your own setting. There are, however, ten questions you need to ask about any such project.

What is this game?

“A roleplaying game” is not a good answer, nor even “a tabletop roleplaying game.” That includes both the narrative-focused Vampire and early D&D, initially labeled a “roleplaying wargame,” which provided a transition somewhere between tabletop strategy games and modern roleplaying games, creating a kind of cooperative play. Of course, that could later move in an increasingly roleplaying-oriented direction, as with AD&D 2nd Edition and Planescape. It helps if your answer distinguishes this game from other similar games. Four or five characteristics certainly will not hurt.

What is the game about?

Above, you described a way of playing. During the development of D&D 3rd Edition, one of its leads said D&D was about killing monsters and taking their treasure. That is a completely different kind of answer from one you could give to “What is this game?” But both kinds of answer are needed. Looking at it this way also establishes a task and a reward proportionate to that task. Elsewhere, by contrast, the goal might be a well-played character who entertains other people too. Or it might be to let you feel a little as cool as the protagonist. Ideal game balance means something completely different in a challenge-oriented game than it does when the goal is to let you feel like a hero on the order of Raistlin, Drizzt, or Alyr Arkhon. In some games, characters can be heroes; in others, the aim is to spend a little time in the bad guys' shoes...

How do I plan to achieve this?

One tool for achieving the goal we saw in D&D was a system that attempted to maintain the ratio between challenge and reward, including things such as Challenge Rating. Although it failed to establish game balance, and therefore fair challenges, largely for objective reasons, you could still see that the goal was being considered when the rules were created. If you read the articles describing the Second Chance (Második Esély) project, you can likewise see that many of our system's solutions are underpinned by the particular game's goal. Do the same. 

Why will this be fun?

That is one way of putting it. But you can also ask: why will people buy your game? Why will they play it? It is easy to talk about varied challenges, varied characters, and numerous possibilities, but here too it is worth distinguishing the system you are designing from the rest.

What does ... mean to you?

Many people are not developing a new roleplaying game but a new M.A.G.U.S. Or designing a roleplaying game around the Cthulhu Mythos. Or perhaps another literary work. It is useful to articulate what the thing you are trying to adapt—whether a setting, a character type, or something else—means to you. It can be a very important support during development. 

What does roleplaying mean to you?

You need to articulate this for yourself too, and communicate it as well.

What do you see as the greatest risk?

That people do not like reading? The personalities of the writers behind the setting you have chosen? A lack of literary background? Many such risks need to be identified, and I often recommend SWOT analysis too. For now, though, focus only on the most important risks that you absolutely must address during development. 

What am I doing about this risk?

This may be the hardest question to answer. Since we do not know much about the risk, we cannot offer good examples either. But perhaps something like this comes to mind: an unusual combat system is hard to explain, which is a risk. A good example of play, however, perhaps a YouTube video accessible through a QR code in the book, and so on, can help players understand it. We already have a risk paired with a plan to address it.

What kind of setting do I plan to support?

Simply giving its name is not necessarily enough, because most settings have many interpretations. Cover those details when you answer the question too. 

How does all this relate to the literary background?

For example, do you want the associated events to be events that have already happened in your world? Or do you want the characters to have a chance to play through the same things, so those roles cannot be occupied by the familiar characters of novels and short stories? Does the fiction establish the constraints of a canonical world, or does it open up possibilities through potential stories and examples built on the basic setting?