When I talk about why I prefer Shadowrun's third edition to the newer, later editions, I often point to the Shadowrun Companion and the campaign types it describes that are not about shadowrunners. These existed for second edition too, but in many respects the concept really came into its own in third edition. And not long ago there was an online campaign in which the characters were police officers. That is good in many ways, but it does not help everyone escape their everyday problems.
For an African American player, interactions with police and the question of racism are hot topics, and with police characters, at least some of the NPCs will be racist, which will show up in play too. Of course, this time he could see the problem from the other side as well. Indeed, he had signed up precisely because some of us had mentioned looking at problems from another perspective as a benefit of roleplaying, and he was looking for this kind of campaign. Meeting that player's needs required presenting potentially triggering subjects from another side, rather than simply flagging them with trigger warnings. Naturally, subjects such as "walking while black" and its variant, "driving while black," came up. We are familiar with those, right?
How players react to different descriptions is an interesting question. The first preconception is simple enough: if the game master describes someone, then, like a gun onstage, that NPC must have a role in the adventure, so let's stop them. The reality is that there are plenty of NPC generators that give a fairly good picture of a character. There are setting-neutral options, such as Chaotic Shiny's modern character generator, available at http://chaoticshiny.com/modernchargen.php, but there are other possibilities too.
If New Seattle or the Seattle Sourcebook tells us something about a neighborhood, for example, we can easily build on it. We know how wealthy the locals are on average, and it is easy to estimate what someone might be like who stands out from the neighborhood in a particular direction by a certain amount. We can see the area's racial breakdown, and for skin color we can draw on a similar present-day distribution, just as we can for age. We can generate names, hair colors, skin colors, and any number of other things too.
Once we have that information, any scripting language, or Visual Basic—even as a Word macro—can help put together a short description. In other words, as a GM you can generate an NPC with exactly zero effort whose role in the adventure serves just four purposes:
- The characters have to decide whether to stop them.
- Generated rumors can also start new cases: if the group bites on something, there is the next adventure.
- An investigation is hardly a challenge when the GM tells you who matters to the investigation simply by describing only those people...
- They also add color to the world.
After we addressed not needing to stop everyone, we soon reached a situation in which it was the Black player who started stopping Black NPCs—and trolls—more often, because that is what cops do, right? Surely that would make the roleplaying better. This is just as much a preconception as assuming that an NPC must be important if the game master describes them... Let's try setting that aside too. The aim is to play normal characters, not stereotypes that many people find offensive. Not only for SJW reasons, but for more believable characters and for the roleplaying itself.
From there, some descriptions were limited to outward appearance, some also mentioned that the person matched a suspect's description, and others noted that the person had been caught before and had been a suspect in several other cases. As you might guess, that last point mattered, as did a few other details. And those details appeared across every ethnicity, race, and skin color. He had also seen white "trailer trash" victims in real news reports about police brutality.
Where locals are hostile to the police, cases are harder to solve. Offenders can commit more crimes before being caught. More people believe they will get away with it, and doing some time is considered normal locally, so the deterrent effect of the law and law enforcement is weaker too. Despite a lower clearance rate, more people may serve longer sentences. But officers—even player characters—frustrated by constant failure are also more likely to consider breaking the rules. Usually in the interests of the victims. Or because they have had enough of a particular criminal... Or because they need results and can find little other way to make progress.
Where crime drives many people away, leaving far fewer opportunities to get ahead legally, locals readily cite the resulting situation, and social pressure no longer acts as a safeguard against crime that has become accepted. After an observation along the lines of if my character weren't so afraid of being accused of racism, things would be much uglier, it was time for a few Willpower tests. How long can a character who fears that kind of risk keep the tension under control...
His character then had good reason to look for ways to release that tension before it turned into police brutality, but those outlets can be taken away one by one, since opposition to them and the associated social pressure remain. He could not shout at a match, and joining a Matrix game left no room for anything either. Somehow, the picture sketched in simple strokes described reality quite well. And of course there were NPCs who tried to behave differently, only to have their own communities slap a few labels on them for it.
Just as today there are labels such as "oreo," "too white," "not black enough," "speaks white," and "acts white," coupled with the label of traitor, which make it harder to break out locally. And there are political forces and plenty of others that support this because they profit from it. Of course, there were also the many opportunities for off-duty officers to earn something on the side, from security work to "you know about investigations; take a look into this prospective tenant for me." In the latter cases, it often turned out that a tenant had more than a race and a skin color: they also had finances, political opinions, and a past, and those influenced decisions.
Yes, the possibility of violent protests, or a comment expressing no sympathy when someone "privileged" suffered damage and siding with the person who caused it, and so on, all appear as risks that can then be weighed. That pushes many people back into worse circumstances. So do situations in which an officer is watching a white human thief somewhere, but both the thief and an innocent troll of color nearby assume the officer is watching the latter out of racism, and the troll's reaction comes up during a background check and costs them a job.
Watching someone because of their clothing, paying attention to every unfamiliar face, and many other things can lead to similar remarks and, later, similar situations. Here it is decisions, deeds, and words, rather than color or ancestry, that exclude someone, yet we still see that different skin colors and races mean different chances.
The environment affects who is willing to teach there and how children grow up, but it can also make many police officers want to leave the area, while many worse officers may end up there. These processes were easy to portray. The music, the role models, the problems of families falling apart in places like these, and much else could paint a pretty dark picture.
The campaign ended after a little over a year and a half. The main boss was an investor who profited handsomely from the conflict and whose money partly came from local crime. We were about to start a new campaign when this player asked whether he could bring a new friend. I asked what sort of friend... A mixed-race woman—Black and Asian—whom he had met at the local police academy, and who had heard a lot of good things about Shadowrun when the question came up of why he, a Black man from a bad neighborhood, had suddenly wanted to become a police officer.