Some questions about a game are settled by objective facts. One such fact is that the Shadowrun core book states that the game master adjusts Availability according to the situation and campaign. Full stop; a statement of fact. An absolute limit then applies to that modified Availability, which a starting character cannot exceed. But in what situation we adjust a weapon's Availability as GMs, by how much, and why, is highly subjective. No two GMs would say exactly the same thing. Nor will they ever. Starting equipment rests on numerous experiences and subjective decisions. You could say this is a subject on which everyone is right and nobody is right.
Because we have all gained different experiences in different circumstances and groups.
Honestly, About the White Raven
One standard does come to mind, though: if you present something as decisive, stick to it. Someone who fails to do so but immediately throws a fit when another person answers their question by explaining why their equipment differs is a problem. Not because their equipment list is bad, or because their opinion contains nothing that counts, at least when they GM, but because they behave antisocially. There was a minor conflict over this, but the most important considerations never came up: what produces the experience on which I base my weapon choices? And what can you learn from that experience?
This article is subjective. I will begin by saying that calling something as rare as a pigeon-gray pigeon would be meaningless. If I argue that something is rare, I must at least compare it to a white raven. If you then start saying how unsuitable that is, I will go beyond subjective experience and anecdotal argument and describe every possibility under which a white raven really does fit. Yet white ravens remain rare. A character who acquires weapons and equipment that way is rare too: a special snowflake. This cherry-picks characters for whom the weapon fits rather than describing the overall picture. You can tell the truth in a way that makes the overall picture false in someone else's eyes.
In a subjective opinion piece, however, I can begin my argument by mentioning an even rarer weapon.
More Than a Custom Weapon Story
When I speak of an even rarer weapon and a decisive consideration, I think of the Ares Thunderer. Not because it ever appeared in our game, but because it overturned our game without ever appearing. Neither a player character nor an NPC owned one, yet it was decisive. It appeared in Cannon Companion as an example demonstrating the weapon design rules. It showed that a weapon designed by a player or GM could have a manufacturer, brand name, history, and place in the world's history just like one on the weapon list.
The weapon list and the rules permitting design are equally valid official rules. By the time we switched from second to third edition after weighing things up, Cannon Companion already existed. Many weapons that had been favorites in second edition immediately fell out of favor. The Colt Manhunter was not about lots of bonuses for little money. Many people could give it a smartgun link too, at which point it would be less attractive financially. But a hell of a lot of characters insisted on the magazine holding one extra round, and preferred it to the Ares Predator for that reason. Once players can design weapons, however, even larger magazines become available.
Eventually we had a nice long list of brand names. We noted that in this campaign, Dragon had appeared in the Colt Dragon III tactical shotgun, while in another we had used the brand for the S-K Dragon assault cannon. The character does not and cannot know what was described where. They choose independently of that, and only a small fraction of the world's countless possibilities appear in the books. Many things can justify choosing the most common weapon, the mandatory one, the currently hyped model, or the top model sold in the branded store you visit. Fewer justify the battered gun that merely adds variety to the range.
For exactly the same reason, copying a sample equipment list I write would be unjustified.
A Checklist Instead of a Template to Copy?
There are reasons to discuss the book treating a SIN as essential, or needing to communicate even after throwing away your phone as advised. Those are matters of experience. Plenty of coherent equipment packages can be described, but basic loadouts including weapons merely kill the characters' individuality and will not necessarily fit the campaign. Someone violating in their next article the Availability 8 limit they shouted about is not only a problem because the GM might notice that 8 has become 10, 12, or 14. There is a much bigger problem.
The restriction still applies to modified Availability. If the GM runs a game in Chicago's sealed-off areas, most of the lovely basic equipment is out: the entire IPE grenade section, C4, stun grenades, and so on. And there are circumstances where the limit of 8 falls to 6. Good luck fitting inside it.
If you just want a quick game at a club or camp, a sample character is enough. If your equipment is a little sketchy, the GM will not obsess about your missing second phone or SIN card. And if a player character drops out of the adventure with a deadly wound, nobody will shed tears over a disposable character; it is far from certain anyone would take risks to pull them out of the shit.
If you have your own character, a party concept, a longer-term campaign, and individual ideas, you need a small checklist to avoid omitting essentials more than someone telling you which weapon is most overpowered. You need a list of considerations to weigh when choosing a weapon, not a weapon's name. One of the first entries should be to pay attention to the campaign concept, party concept, setting, and limits modified accordingly, and talk to the game master.
When Does the White Raven of Weapons Appear?
A subjective, anecdotal opinion piece may even have room for discussing when a weapon as emblematic of rarity as the white raven appears. I think three of my characters started with a Ruger Thunderbolt. For one, the biggest power boost was not the gun but the rank of lieutenant. The character worked in Lone Star's Tactical Division/SWAT unit. Let us just say that although they too were issued the standard police pistol, a handgun was not their default tool when trouble arrived.
Another was a detective. The police pistol was mandatory, but in many cases so was waiting for backup, including SWAT if needed, instead of shooting it out alone. Needless to say, that gun mostly spoke on the firing range too. I like characters with plenty of contacts, and there was a connection to SWAT that bypassed the boss. Again, this was mandatory for a police character. Both characters were required to use the standard-issue weapon, and specific rules for a police group modify the general rules for shadowrunners.
Lone Star! Search! We have a warrant.
The third character? An odd one. Their parents were police too. The standard corporate promise to take care of the child if trouble struck actually amounted to something, largely because the character belonged to the company's elite team in a recruiting/training game, and—thanks to the Friends in High Places edge—had a good friend in Lone Star's senior management. Mostly, a water pistol or paintball gun is still the most appropriate weapon for this character. When the corporate VIP team received the new wonder weapon, and the otaku tribe connected to it acquired one, this character got one too, producing tears because the pretty pistol hurt their hand. But in the game, something like that is Golden-Legendary!
The professional “water pistol,” suitable for almost any active substance, is dangerous in their hands, though. It has held everything from cheap perfume substitutes to Auntie Nyau's ultra-strong homemade chili sauce. Awareness of danger is not a strong point yet, so there has been an occasion when a genuinely dangerous enemy was sprayed in the face with about ten servings of the strongest sauce. Riding a motorcycle without a helmet is not a good idea at times like that.
Experience Sometimes Says More Than Numbers
The lesson is that it is damned easy to create a backstory and circumstances in which an otherwise rare weapon's Availability drops drastically enough to make it permissible. Yet I have never chosen the Ruger Thunderbolt for any perceived or actual mechanical advantage. Having to change magazines every four shots, when you can carry only a finite number, is a brutal drawback I try to avoid. When choosing your character's weapon, dazzled by impressive numbers, you need to know the experiences that might talk you out of it. Experiences reminding you that many weapons are more than their numbers.
The rules in State of the Art cover combat clothing with many pockets, load-bearing harnesses, and the pockets and pouches attached to them, including the number of spare magazines you can carry. This restriction is more than enough to turn a weapon some consider enormously overpowered, and therefore ruthlessly ban, into a pointless piece of junk. In better groups, the question of precisely what the character carries, how much, and where arose and limited powergaming even before the official rule.
Notice, though, that the characters above share more than a connection to Lone Star. Far more important is the presence of a campaign and party concept. If you play a police campaign where every character is an officer, the police pistol is a given that affects every player character equally, and the GM accounts for it when designing adventures. If one character's gun permits sixteen shots per magazine rather than four, that can upset balance just as much as a higher-than-average Damage Code.
Lessons
When designing a weapon, we can choose to increase a heavy pistol's base Damage Code to 10M, enable BF—three-round burst fire—and use many options to reduce recoil. Its magazine is larger than the police pistol's too, making it much more flexible. Availability is even more subjective for custom weapons in anyone's imagined inventory, but plenty can be squeezed in here too. Some special ammunition would make its damage still more serious. There is one small problem: this weapon is also large and conspicuous, with every resulting drawback. You might as well carry an even larger weapon with even better damage.
You could carry an Aztechnology Destroyer II automatic shotgun. Base damage 10S, burst fire available, and you can switch between shot and slugs. Give it a sawed-off barrel and it looks cool. Weapons are more than their statistics, however. The Ares Predator family remains common in our games; weapon design rules did not kill it off, while the cheap and powerful Colt Manhunter fell away. Why? One of the Ares Predator's most important traits is being the most common gun in the shadows. Replacing the barrel, or even the gun, is trivial. That makes a character harder to track through ballistics reports.
The sound of the police pistol brings every cop in the neighborhood running. A precise weapon made of plastic and ceramics, embodying “one shot, one kill” in pistol size, can symbolize a character's professionalism. In an environment where a light pistol is more than enough—and there are many—someone seen with a heavier weapon arouses suspicion. According to the core book, recoil does no damage, but an otaku, necessarily a child, would certainly struggle with a serious weapon's recoil. You must be able to imagine the scene and what your character is doing and why.
Weapons and equipment can say a great deal about a character. When selecting them, remember that what your character takes where, and why, is part of roleplaying. The system rewards roleplaying with Karma, and that is how your character develops. If you know why you chose the weapon, and it is not just about dealing damage, then what weapon you have and why becomes part of roleplaying. You may sometimes even build on how certain NPCs are likely to react to it.
Knowing where the character bought the weapon, why they chose it, and why it was available there is a bonus. The story is what matters. Through that, you will know where and how the character carries magazines and remain within various hard limits. A sensible GM, where Availability must be modified, will remember whether you are buying a gun of a less popular and locally rarer brand stocked by few people on the street, or in that brand's own store. We portray worlds and characters, not misinterpreted statistics.