The GM can change the game system and the game world, and it is bad form to question that decision. No, not because they are sitting there in a T-shirt saying “The GM is always right,” but because they usually know what they are doing, while the player does not know the GM's secrets. At least, that is the situation in the better cases. In worse ones, the player does not understand the world itself. I know, I know: you have a horror story where the GM said something incredibly stupid. But remember, that does not mean this stupidity is not part of “objective reality” in their world and their adventure. Ergo, the GM is always right. In their own world. That does not mean the GM can change the rules or the world without consequences, however. Every tiny change can have consequences, and the GM alone is responsible for them. A decision with unwanted consequences deserves to be called a bad decision, and a GM who makes a series of bad decisions is not always right... They are not right when they put their own bad idea ahead of everyone's enjoyment and the game suffers for it.
This is particularly conspicuous in forum and Facebook debates. Someone fond of a bad idea invokes the GM's freedom and says everyone understands them except a few nitpickers. That attitude is problematic for three reasons. The first is simple: why ask for help, advice or opinions if you then refuse to accept them because you are the GM? The other two are hardly more complicated. In a forum conversation, nobody is present in their capacity as game master. This is not a situation where the players cannot yet see the GM's secrets and an argument would halt the game, making it foolish to interrupt. The discussion itself is the reason for being there. If someone does not want to discuss things because they are the GM at home, why visit such sites? The third problem is simple: it is easy to understand the basics of an idea and think, “If this works, I might like it; it could be interesting in your game,” and so on. But the occasional nitpicker who has also thought through the pitfalls has put more work into evaluating the idea. If you handle a flaw with “I'm the GM, so shut up,” that flaw and its consequences remain in the system.
Make no mistake: I am not talking about one particular person, but about a situation many GMs find attractive: hiding behind the Game Master T-shirt and declaring that the game master is always right, so shut up. But this rule was not invented for people to hide behind in discussion forums and arguments. It was invented, for example, to prevent an entire session from being spent on a player insisting that “I certainly catch up with the stagecoach.” Again, if the player feels they should have caught the stagecoach, it can be discussed after the adventure. At that point it does not bother me if someone ignores the breastcollar harness, or the fact that changing horses is an innovation that speeds up a stagecoach's progress, so changing horses certainly does not make it slower. I do not even mind if another player points out that changing horses would not take hours, and that even they could unhitch them faster than the argumentative player considers realistic. Feedback from players and discussing things are valuable and interesting, but there is a place and time for them: strictly after the adventure.
Especially if it quickly becomes clear that the other players do imagine the stagecoach as fast. Then it also becomes clear that on one side stand the structure of the adventure and the reality the other players imagine as a logical whole... And on the other stands the arbitrary declaration of one player who will not accept it even as an unusual case. I know, I know: in this instance the player was wrong from the start and talking nonsense. Fortunately, however, it is rare for someone to be right and still make continuing the adventure impossible through argument. For two reasons. If they are right, most worthwhile GMs either admit it or indicate that there is a reason for the apparently illogical solution. The second reason is even simpler: people who are right generally also see that unnecessary argument only harms the game. If the GM's concept really does not fit the player's view of the world and would therefore ruin the character's life story, the player can decide to treat the adventure as a nightmare—and tell the GM so—get up and leave, or simply “sit it out.” The GM must respect that decision too.
Before or after the adventure, or on a discussion forum, however, the situation is completely different. The question is not whether we are arguing when we ought to be playing, sometimes already stealing precious time from a second session. It is what the GM or player might need to change to make the game work better. If the GM invokes “I'm the GM” on the grounds of “why shouldn't there be technology?” or “why shouldn't my world have a Dark Ages setting?”, they immediately demonstrate their unsuitability for the GM's duties. They cannot or will not establish the basic conditions for roleplaying, and they do not care about the group. That is a serious problem. The illogical things the GM needlessly forces upon the game make it harder to immerse ourselves in the character and feel that the world is alive, while also undermining the GM's authority. If trust is gone, if we no longer believe a good adventure is coming, and ever more serious inconsistencies obstruct immersion, then the game is up. Fooling around may still be possible; real roleplaying is not. The GM has failed. The adventure is gone, meaningful play is gone, and the role of game master has lost all substance. Crying “I'm the GM, and the GM is always right” is useless then. The failed GM was not right.
There may even have been a logical explanation for what the player found illogical; M.A.G.U.S. has more than one apparent inconsistency. I know perfectly well that many players ask how Krán and Pyarron became allies only a few years after the Dúlás. And I know that “shut up, I'm the GM” is just as bad an answer as “I don't know, that's what the books say,” or the explanation that Csanád Novák posted it on the forum with the label * * * * * O F F I C I A L * * * * *. A worthwhile GM can explain the reasons and create the conditions for the player to understand and imagine what is involved. You can say, “During the Cold War, France and West Germany were allies too,” and it becomes clear that Ynev can also have many reasons for a forced alliance. And Ynev had considerably more time for it.
We simply have to accept that neither temporarily held rights and slapping an * * * * * O F F I C I A L * * * * * label on a forum post, nor the GM's role, make anyone infallible. If what we create is illogical and we cannot defend it, the game suffers. Leaving part of the explanation until after play, a break and so on, or presenting it on a forum, is a good solution. Hiding behind titles is not. Nor does “Csanád agreed in Rúna” make an idea work on its own. Often, an ingenious, seemingly good answer to a real or perceived flaw creates problems elsewhere. People commonly tinker with many parts of the M.A.G.U.S. system, damage for instance. But the original system contains numerous compromises—carefully considered, thoroughly designed compromises. A solution that intervenes with a “good idea” is usually not so well thought through, and does more harm than good. That is the difference between an idea and a sound, defensible rule that has passed playtesting. A GM who alters the system ought to understand that difference too.
Changing things is not merely the GM's right, however, but their duty. The M.A.G.U.S. development team has changed many times, and many worldviews have appeared. Despite being official, some are problematic, unfinished, or deliberately incompatible with other authors' work. A GM who adopts everything “without criticism” and hides behind official material can easily end up with an illogical worldview and kill their own game. The GM's job is therefore to portray a logical world that fits the style of stories the players enjoy. That may, of course, require recommending a different system—or, God forbid, a different world. The GM has to adapt, and in turn forces the system to “adapt”....