People tend to believe their preconceptions. If I think someone will be a bad roleplayer for many reasons, and a few people confirm it, I believe them. It becomes one more piece of evidence confirming what I already suspect, know, or think—for example, about Zsolt Gajdán's roleplaying performance. That lasted until it emerged that the harsh criticism came from someone who apparently thought arguments could have academic qualifications, since, in his view, demanding those qualifications meant addressing the arguments rather than the person making them. I swear I am going to play a living, walking, university-student argument in some humorous roleplaying game. I will call him Gruber. In any case, I now had my first few doubts about the criticism appearing in the groups. 

Of course, you can cite one more, or any number of, incidents that should have told me what kind of person he is, both intellectually and in terms of backbone. I also know the disputes, not free of personal attacks, surrounding the two moderators replaced in record time, and one of them centers on precisely the same Zsolt Gajdán about whom this man expressed a bad opinion. Up to a point, one assumes his opinion is fair and sincere. Until we encounter him first declaring that remaining in group X means there is no serious problem there, then accusing those who leave in response of cowardice and spinelessness for leaving. That latter behavior paints a picture of a vile, dishonorable person. And if he says we cannot know for sure who you are, and that describing the worst of someone on that basis is fair and also yields a roughly correct conclusion, then we cannot know for sure that he is not a pedophile or a murderous "angel of death" either. What we do know is that he does not really take responsibility for his mistakes. 

At that point I began wondering how well he could know what sort of roleplayer Zsolt is. What had led to the problem? 

So it was thoughtless of me to dismiss reports that Zsolt Gajdán was a bad roleplayer with "what else did we expect; plenty of faults were predictable." It was a mistake. Even if my underlying argument still stands. After all, nothing about him has changed. The problem I pointed to is still there. Apparently, nothing has changed. I based my opinion on three problems.

The first is simple. Consider a short combat scene. The fighter is hit. If the player and GM are paying attention to the description rather than HP, the player or players need some cue that justifies healing. If you describe the impact of the hit in a way that warrants bandaging or magical healing, that treatment remains justified even after using any ability—such as Second Wind—that restores HP without removing the described effect. So the group wastes resources. But if you do not describe it that way, the fighter enters the next battle with low HP.

The person who fails to notice this flaw is playing from the HP written on the character sheet rather than from the descriptions and the imagined scene. Bad roleplaying? Metagaming? Yes. But most D&D players do it too. I will go further: D&D became this kind of system because the D&D fifth-edition design team works on the same basis. Zsolt, however, pays more attention than they do to characters' backgrounds and customizes the adventure to some extent, producing a more sensible story instead of herding people along with "the adventure is over there." So even with this issue, he is a better player than the masses who work from modules and oppose every addition. Or at least a less bad one. And that justifies his experience of being a roleplayer, since he roleplays more than the others and likes social solutions. 

A request along the lines of "Zsolti, try GMing once with the character sheets in your possession, so everyone else can rely only on descriptions and roleplaying" would quickly make him recognize the problem. Let's say more quickly than his chief critic would recognize that countless critiques use trademarks without permission, even for profit, and even harm the trademark owner. If this makes Zsolt the smarter and more straightforward person in many respects, then the story circulating about him deserves another look. It is a fact that several people's consistent accounts describe the same thing.

He was supposed to play a bigoted Imperial in Warhammer. He could not get himself out of a situation—the devil in the dice—and could not get his companion out so the companion could help him—the dice again. He was left in a situation where, after failing a roll, he was expected to narrate the action as an automatic success. Yet although bigoted and fanatical are related words, they do not mean the same thing. A bigoted but quieter character would not typically open his mouth all of a sudden under the adventure's pressure and reel off clichéd motivational speeches. All this in response to out-of-character prodding, without receiving any meaningful in-character motivation. So was he the dick who alone could not perform in an atmospheric story, or, when he sulked, was he actually roleplaying and trying to remain fair, while an unfair person expected the opposite from him?

Those present brushed this problem aside by saying that the GM in question was good at creating atmosphere, wasn't he? The problem is that roleplaying is not only about that. The GM entertains not only through atmosphere, but also through fairness and by handling the problem above. It hardly seems unreasonable to expect the description of a situation to include what past experiences the character associates with it, and what they therefore consider their surest chance. If recognizing and applying that is also an automatic success, were the two rolls that led to failure necessary at all? My feeling is that part of the expected behavior was left out when the characters were discussed and agreed on. Here too, there was too little in-character information. 

If the situation around the table becomes one where out-of-character pressure is placed on the player and they are personally attacked, there is a problem. It is not only that the cues were missing, not only that the proposed solution and the logical order of events raise questions, and not only a matter of what happens out of character. There is something else too. Instead of focusing on an easily solved problem—an in-character reference to the character's past, experiences, or training would have worked—the person who set events in motion attacks the player personally and then declares that Zsolt is crap. Especially when, compared with most players focused on solving the adventure, what we see is him trying to portray his character's limitations after failure.

His character gave it everything, and the test failed. Trying afterward to explain that some trivial solution was not included in the test is a problem when the GM's description is followed by out-of-character pressure but no in-character information. We ought to distinguish people from actions here, and in-character from out-of-character matters, and that is primarily the GM's job. If there were shortcomings in that, was the fault really the player's stubborn sulking and insistence on what he considered the fair approach?

If various statistics model the character's knowledge, is it right to assume they leave out the basics? Is it right to keep the player in the dark on that point, then, after out-of-character pressure from the group—since everyone will report it the same way, and Zsolt may sulk at other times too—decide how bad he is? From a distance, those who say Zsolt did not cooperate, stalled the game, and that the story was interesting and atmospheric and they enjoyed it, and that the person who put it together is a fucking good GM, have a point. But so does anyone saying the GM was unfair here, that many of his solutions are logically questionable, and that the source of the conflict lies in his mistakes.

When it comes to personal unfairness, we should also remember that declaring a great many tricks means building on the character's knowledge. That is defined jointly by the character sheet, background, and previous adventures. The sheet contains a statistic for how the character can resist something, and the most basic method arising from their training was included in it. If the game master sometimes allows that as an extra after the roll, but in other cases rightly forbids it, we abandon consistency as well as fairness. Some abilities become replaceable—with automatic success—while others do not. The player cannot predict that subjective decision either, which harms immersion. It may fit an atmospheric tale, but it does not fit fair, good GMing. 

Recognizing that it takes two to tango, I have never begun dealing with even my worst players by writing a main post in groups, as an admin, about how crap they are. And if they missed something, I include what they missed and why. 

At this point, the story is no longer black and white. Further criticism, however, concerns how hard it is to judge when a description will be too much for him and when too little, and how very little feedback comes back beyond "it was good" or "it wasn't good." Interestingly, Zsolt said more than that about this incident too. Another nuance is that Zsolt is willing to try quite a lot of games, so he knows these games less well. Unkind tongues say that although he likes social characters, he only uses them tactically and rarely plays them out. And a description can easily be too much for him—almost putting him to sleep—and too little at the same time. Fair criticisms?

Here too, the truth is not entirely black and white. I would say he is not very accustomed to deeper immersion, and may not currently want it either. He would solve problems well with social characters too. But when it comes to communication, the GM can readily refer back to such a character's previous experiences. Recognizing a good way to approach something is part of the character's knowledge and impressions. If the description includes that information as one of the most relevant things at that moment, it is straightforward. 

If you deliver an amount of information at once that the player can retain in working memory, your description will not be unnecessarily long: it will not be forgotten, and they can extract the important information. Nor will it be too short, since that most important piece of information will be there. The most important element can also be repeated, perhaps in a different form. If such information comes up on several occasions and the player's mind works with it, they will remember it and be able to apply it later.

I do not consider myself an exceptionally good GM, precisely because I can see where I could do more and do better. But breaking information up and using several shorter descriptions is a very simple technique. Basic consistency, meanwhile, is a basic requirement of a good GM. I think most of us are capable of applying some simple technique to a foreseeable problem. But if we fail at the basic techniques and that produces a conflict attacking the player personally, even the most brilliant atmosphere cannot redeem it. During character creation, we can suggest writing many characteristic sentences and turns of phrase on a sheet alongside the character sheet, giving the player a support to lean on. We can also recognize that a player whose strength is usually solving adventures rather than immersion will certainly need some attention here.

Given how many conflicts he had as a former inspector, and how quickly he had to be removed from a moderator position over similar incidents, it is natural that he finds many things harder to communicate. That is why he feels that when the rolls, the basic declared actions, the GM's descriptions, and much else lead to success, he enjoys himself more and can contribute to the adventure in more ways, and that is good. And unlike a hell of a lot of other players I know, Zsolt can improve. 

Obviously the HP issue is one problem where he struggles to accept something simple, precisely because of the lack of immersion. Similarly, he struggles to understand the difference between one system in which it is hard to create a character who fits the world, and another in which it is hard to create one alien to the concept and the world. If he stopped looking for the D&D bard in M.A.G.U.S. and we played a few sessions, I think his opinion of that game would change too. And if you ask about particular solutions rather than the entire session, even "it was good" and "it was crap" give more information. If he is treated as a partner, his attitude can change a great deal too. That is why he takes part in other people's games that are enjoyable overall, with him included. 

Even if part of the GM's work sometimes involves providing him with support. He is certainly not at the level of someone who assumes that taking on a megacorporation is fine, while obtaining publicly available information about a person is the great achievement. You do not discover with him that a Call of Cthulhu character has a high Size characteristic but is physically small—a smaller target, harder to hit—and that this was achieved by simply writing it down instead of making the required rolls. Nor that, during the investigation adventure everyone agreed on, he finally wanted a break from investigating and thinking. Nor that the background promised but never given to the GM crosses over with three other worlds, and that the character could not survive five minutes with that background and behavior. 

Why? Because that latter example, even if it was unfair and bad there and dragged the group down to its level, could form the basis of a story enjoyable to both player and GM in its own crossover world, where a few less than realistic possibilities are allowed. I learned that a character must not be admitted under such conditions, and that trusting him was a mistake. In that place and at that time, both his character and the way he played it were unacceptable. Perhaps it should not emerge halfway through an adventure that, according to a background never previously disclosed, half the world is hunting him, yet for emotional reasons he has given himself a distinctive identifying mark and shown it to every networked surveillance camera and advertising system in the world. Without an appropriate Hunted disadvantage...

When someone sits down to play with you, you cannot see at a glance that they are a munchkin. And their Shadowrun character will not tell you in advance what will happen with that Size characteristic next time, with someone else, in another system. If many people have since said the same thing about them, along with other derogatory descriptions, that now concerns the person. What they delivered on one occasion, however, concerns only their foolishness on that occasion. If someone does not want constant mental work during play, we can ask whether they refuse to recognize even the basics, or simply do not want to do the thinking for three people, and whether the deteriorating situation should already have been stopped. 

Although Péter also mentions many faults, I still see Zsolt as fundamentally manageable; I have seen many worse players. I will go further: it is true that getting either a good or an average result with him takes work, and he can be considered bad for that reason. Yet he may be better than the median D&D player or the median Hungarian roleplayer. Whether he reaches the average among people I would play with—an average raised by a few sensational players and the initial selection of whom I would consider—is another question. But I think that, since he is willing to change where he recognizes a fault, if he recognizes many faults after trying an experiment or two and prepares accordingly, he could become a much better player. 

Combat is slow, and many GMs do not describe injuries or movements because more dynamic, chaotic combat would not match the situation shown on the battle mat anyway. That also leads most players to play from HP, FP, or status markers rather than from the described wound. But he adds content appropriate to the characters even to a published module. He tries when needed. And the lesson is not primarily that the GM in this particular case was crap. If you can live with his personal and GMing faults, many people find him very entertaining, even if he is not for everyone. Many people also expect players to compensate for some of the faults above, perhaps rightly.

Part of the lesson is not to decide after a test that the character must reapply the very basics they already used as part of the test. That is unfair. At the same time, be willing to refer to the character's past in your descriptions, discuss associations and memories, and thereby give the character something to go on. When your character sees a woman, you know a few details about her appearance, and your character wants to speak to her, you as the player know far less about the situation than your character does. If you explain what the woman seems like according to the character's experience—their understanding of people, and so on—and what style and approach would work when speaking to her, you come closer to that knowledge. 

You can likewise give a thief a clue about how to enter a building, while a fighter, assassin, or priest receives different kinds of in-character information. The player cannot make that association without information the GM has not provided. Giving every detail needed would be too long and sleep-inducing for the group, while the association is quick. Nor would a full description capture the details the character notices only subconsciously, since for them the conclusion itself is already the basic piece of information occupying part of their working memory.

It is no secret that I have a fairly extreme opinion about M.A.G.U.S.: the warlock is inherently a black magician for many reasons, while the fire mage, priest, bard, and so on are only half-fledged magic-users. A wizard requires harmony between GM and player. That often makes the witch the best option for a magic-user. And when dealing with the character's memories and associations, it is easy to refer to things such as the character having dreamed something a few days, or even years, earlier. 

In online play, however, we can use private messages to convey such associations. If played-out flashbacks are part of the system, with rewards or something else attached, so much the better. In any case, playing out flashbacks can be used in other games too. Nor is it a sin if, depending on the results shown in them, the characters happen to get lucky somewhere: after all, as GMs we control the world ourselves.